my mom went and saw this and loved it, me i like Will Smith and i have enjoys his movies and his music going back to his Fresh Prince days in the really late 80's. but he was i'm sorry he was really miscast in this, also no one absolutely no one can replace Robin Williams he IS the Genie no matter how hard they try to replace him. personally the idea that they are remaking all these movies and making them live action is really stupid what it says it to me is they've run out of ideas so they are going to their own movies to remake them.
i think they need to hire some really great writers and do something different that they haven't done before even though that no doubt can be tough i'm sure. i haven't Seen John Carter but that movie is different i hear, on why that one flopped was cause the trailer makes the film look like it was a completely different film i hear i only mention that one cause that one was based off a book series and was different. and as for Aladdin really than why even make it huh? course i asked the same question anyways when they 1st announced it