Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Telly Talk Soaps
UK Soaps Forum
Brookside
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="James from London" data-source="post: 410125" data-attributes="member: 22"><p>... and, of course, Paul Collins' Petrochem nemesis Nigel as an undertaker with three lines and Marie, Michelle and Petra's dad as a shifty chauffeur who comes to a horrible end.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>I was actually wondering what it might have been like had we seen the "pint of bitter beer" Gordon returning from France a few years older, but not necessarily any wiser, and walking into his first Liverpudlian gay bar.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>Yes, that's it exactly. It's as if the writers are as intimidated by Gordon's sexuality as Paul and Annabelle are so they daren't get under his skin in any real way. I guess they just couldn't find "a way in" to the character the way Jimmy McGovern would eight years later by creating a character who was not just gay, but also a Catholic priest. Hey bingo: instant inner conflict!</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>I guess coming out <em>is</em> a bit of a cliche in drama but it had never been done on a soap. It's interesting that when Colin first appears in <em>Enders</em>, he's half in and half out. The first time he talks about a previous relationship in the Vic, he self-consciously changes the pro-noun to "she". Aside from Dot's belated discovery, there isn't a grand moment of revelation for the locals. They just gradually twig as they go along and more or less accept him while continuing to make low level homophobic jibes behind his back. Even shortly before he leaves, the otherwise completely likeable Frank Butcher is casually referring to him as Clause 28.</p><p></p><p>Coming out's a bit like grief, in that it's an internal process which can be difficult to dramatise in the context of a soap. <em>Enders</em> (and other soaps) would find a way round this by co-opting the traditional love triangle as a way of externalising that inner conflict -- torn between two lovers, torn between two worlds. In '90s <em>Enders</em>, Kathy's nephew finds himself falling in love with his pregnant girlfriend's brother; in the '00s, a guy is having a secret relationship with another man while preparing for a marriage arranged by his devout Muslim family. The tug of war both experience with relation to the people around them mirror what's going on inside themselves. Then, about ten years ago, you finally get a scene as straightforward but strong as this:</p><p></p><p>[MEDIA=youtube]mNiZDQqzPBQ[/MEDIA]</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>On one hand, the awful straight-to-video <em>Brookside</em> thing in which Sheila acts as Jimmy Corkhill's getaway driver would suggest not. On the other, I think my favourite episode of <em>Coronation Street</em> is the one in '79 that takes place after a lorry crashes into the front of the Rover's and deals with how the characters respond in the immediate aftermath of a disaster. If (and it's a big if) the writing is truly committed to the characters and the characters are great as Bobby and Sheila, then in theory it shouldn't matter if it's a lorry or a helicopter that's just landed on them.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>Which I sometimes think is the best kind of acting -- so believable you don't even notice it. It's there to serve the story rather than call attention to itself. Of course, it's not the kind of "Look, Ma, I'm Acting!" acting that wins awards, but who cares about awards?</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>Oh yes, that was in relation to Michelle's affair with a married man. The man in question has just turned up as one of Terry and Pat's new housemates (the less slobby one).</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>I never particularly look forward to Kevin and Sally's appearances. I think it's because those initial scenes with Sally's daughter Jessica were a bit overwrought, but now you come to mention it, yes they always turn out to be really good!</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>Which means I was bit hasty in dismissing the whole video recorder thing as a non-event.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>Such an interesting comparison. Funny that Damon comes from the far more politically clued-up family yet was naively optimistic about his YTS scheme, whereas Tracy is savvy enough to know the whole thing's a con. Despite that, the real irony is that she'll end up benefitting from the scheme far more than Damon did. In the meantime, she's hilarious. Her scenes with Shelley are properly funny in a way that some other <em>Brookie</em> attempts at comedy (usually involving Ralph) just aren't. Maybe it's an accent thing, but Shelley could easily be Mo (off of Matty and Mo)'s comedy sister. You can imagine her driving Mo mad by offering her unsolicited advice about her complicated love life. "... that's what I always say."</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="James from London, post: 410125, member: 22"] ... and, of course, Paul Collins' Petrochem nemesis Nigel as an undertaker with three lines and Marie, Michelle and Petra's dad as a shifty chauffeur who comes to a horrible end. I was actually wondering what it might have been like had we seen the "pint of bitter beer" Gordon returning from France a few years older, but not necessarily any wiser, and walking into his first Liverpudlian gay bar. Yes, that's it exactly. It's as if the writers are as intimidated by Gordon's sexuality as Paul and Annabelle are so they daren't get under his skin in any real way. I guess they just couldn't find "a way in" to the character the way Jimmy McGovern would eight years later by creating a character who was not just gay, but also a Catholic priest. Hey bingo: instant inner conflict! I guess coming out [I]is[/I] a bit of a cliche in drama but it had never been done on a soap. It's interesting that when Colin first appears in [I]Enders[/I], he's half in and half out. The first time he talks about a previous relationship in the Vic, he self-consciously changes the pro-noun to "she". Aside from Dot's belated discovery, there isn't a grand moment of revelation for the locals. They just gradually twig as they go along and more or less accept him while continuing to make low level homophobic jibes behind his back. Even shortly before he leaves, the otherwise completely likeable Frank Butcher is casually referring to him as Clause 28. Coming out's a bit like grief, in that it's an internal process which can be difficult to dramatise in the context of a soap. [I]Enders[/I] (and other soaps) would find a way round this by co-opting the traditional love triangle as a way of externalising that inner conflict -- torn between two lovers, torn between two worlds. In '90s [I]Enders[/I], Kathy's nephew finds himself falling in love with his pregnant girlfriend's brother; in the '00s, a guy is having a secret relationship with another man while preparing for a marriage arranged by his devout Muslim family. The tug of war both experience with relation to the people around them mirror what's going on inside themselves. Then, about ten years ago, you finally get a scene as straightforward but strong as this: [MEDIA=youtube]mNiZDQqzPBQ[/MEDIA] On one hand, the awful straight-to-video [I]Brookside[/I] thing in which Sheila acts as Jimmy Corkhill's getaway driver would suggest not. On the other, I think my favourite episode of [I]Coronation Street[/I] is the one in '79 that takes place after a lorry crashes into the front of the Rover's and deals with how the characters respond in the immediate aftermath of a disaster. If (and it's a big if) the writing is truly committed to the characters and the characters are great as Bobby and Sheila, then in theory it shouldn't matter if it's a lorry or a helicopter that's just landed on them. Which I sometimes think is the best kind of acting -- so believable you don't even notice it. It's there to serve the story rather than call attention to itself. Of course, it's not the kind of "Look, Ma, I'm Acting!" acting that wins awards, but who cares about awards? Oh yes, that was in relation to Michelle's affair with a married man. The man in question has just turned up as one of Terry and Pat's new housemates (the less slobby one). I never particularly look forward to Kevin and Sally's appearances. I think it's because those initial scenes with Sally's daughter Jessica were a bit overwrought, but now you come to mention it, yes they always turn out to be really good! Which means I was bit hasty in dismissing the whole video recorder thing as a non-event. Such an interesting comparison. Funny that Damon comes from the far more politically clued-up family yet was naively optimistic about his YTS scheme, whereas Tracy is savvy enough to know the whole thing's a con. Despite that, the real irony is that she'll end up benefitting from the scheme far more than Damon did. In the meantime, she's hilarious. Her scenes with Shelley are properly funny in a way that some other [I]Brookie[/I] attempts at comedy (usually involving Ralph) just aren't. Maybe it's an accent thing, but Shelley could easily be Mo (off of Matty and Mo)'s comedy sister. You can imagine her driving Mo mad by offering her unsolicited advice about her complicated love life. "... that's what I always say." [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
What month follows July?
Post reply
Forums
Telly Talk Soaps
UK Soaps Forum
Brookside
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top