"Dallas" Politically Incorrect?

What Do You Think Would Ultimately Happen As A Result Of Dallas Debuting Now And Angering PC Groups


  • Total voters
    6
  • Poll closed .

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
In this age of such extreme levels of political correctness, I wonder how the people who belong to groups promoting that PC agenda would have reacted to Dallas if it debuted today instead of in 1978 but otherwise have been exactly the same regarding the content of the series.

I believe they would have been very much against "Dallas" (for this thread I'm talking about Dallas making its debut now and being exactly the same in content as it was then). There would likely have been movements to boycott CBS for airing Dallas and marches and rallies held to protest Dallas. I believe their biggest problem with Dallas would have been with J.R. and his inability to be politically correct even a little bit. Perhaps it wasn't "inability" to be PC as much as a complete lack of desire on J.R.'s part to be politically correct and the resulting lack of effort to even attempt trying to be more PC.

The last straw for the people promoting the extremist PC agenda of today would be that despite JR exuding qualities which would normally have caused him to be booed by the audience, he was cheered by the audience, or cheered by a large portion of the audience to be more precise.

That a network was airing a series that depicted such politically incorrect behavior and doing it in a way that it may have even seemed that Dallas was proud of being politically incorrect, would have truly angered these types of organizations. For me, that would have been very fun to see.

I don't think they could have succeeded in stopping the show from being aired or making CBS change Dallas to their liking, since it would (again for the purposes f this thread) be getting tremendous ratings which would have made it the most popular series on TV and tremendously profitable as a result! Still, the commotion that the friction between CBS and the members of these PC organizations would have caused in today's social climate would be interesting to say the least!
 
Last edited:

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
I think this idea is a bit extreme. I mean it's a work of fiction. CBS wouldn't be advocating the behaviour of the DALLAS characters. We don't only have sanitised TV characters on shows now. I don't see marches and the like to boycott a show because a character is a bit of a bastard. There have always, and will always be TV villains.
 

Herofan

Telly Talk Active Member
I’m always noticing politically incorrect t things from any show from that far back. It doesn’t matter to me, but I see things and hear comments made that I know would raise eyebrows in today’s climate.

One thing with Dallas that always gets my attention is that women still kinda have their traditional place in society, especially in the earlier seasons.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Dallas wasn't politically incorrect. It was sexist. Let's call a spade a spade. Granted, sexism was accepted more in the US at the time, but it was already changing in parts of the US. But it made sense that Dallas, Texas, would be behind the curve.
 

Richard Channing

Eternal Member
I've often wondered why in the mini-series all the help at Southfork were African American, and it was established that they had worked there for many years, yet at the beginning of season 1 they were gone and the staff were Hispanic instead. Was this a sign of changing times? That it was no longer seen as politically correct to portray black people as the servants of rich white folk, but it was however acceptable to show Hispanics in this role?
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I think this idea is a bit extreme. I mean it's a work of fiction. CBS wouldn't be advocating the behaviour of the DALLAS characters. We don't only have sanitised TV characters on shows now. I don't see marches and the like to boycott a show because a character is a bit of a bastard. There have always, and will always be TV villains.

It is a extreme idea and considering it's a work of fiction, there is no reason any of the things I mentioned should happen. I still think that if Dallas debuted today in exactly the same form as it originally did (no changes to content) it would cause a lot of commotion among pro PC organizations and I agree with you that CBS wouldn't be advocating the behavior of the Dallas characters. While I think your take on it is very rational and it's the same as the way I see it, I think what these extremist organizations would do is protest Dallas on the grounds that they would believe CBS would be socially irresponsible by having such a series run in their network.

Of course, JR, and then probably Jock would get the most criticism. You[re right that there have always been TV villains and always will be, but they'd probably argue that Dallas would be making it alright to like the villain. To a degree maybe Dallas did make it alright to like the villain because JR was actually antihero, and one of the first ones on a popular TV series. Vocabulary.com defines an antihero as:
"An antihero is the main character of a story, but one who doesn't act like a typical hero. Antiheroes are often a little villainous.

Traditionally, the protagonist — main character and focus — of a story has been a hero: someone good, noble, and brave. However, some stories change things up by having an antihero instead. An antihero may not be heroic at all. TV shows have featured antiheroes who are mobsters, drug dealers, crooked cops, and even serial killers. An antihero is kind of like a villain, or a mix of a hero and a villain. Antiheroes are complex characters, which is why they’re popular."

JR might not be the exact personification of an antihero the way it's defined here, but it would be hard to argue that JR isn't the central character of Dallas. Who in Dallas gets more onscreen time than JR? Who gets talked about by the other characters of the series as much as JR? JR has characteristics that make him a mix of a hero and villain and he's also a complex character.

I disagree with the last phrase in "Antiheroes are complex characters, which is why they're popular." JR is certainly complex, anti could be a contributing factor to why he's popular, but I never saw it as the main reason why he's popular. The main reason would have more to do with having that tremendous ability for getting what he wants, outsmarting the people who want to bring him down, winning much more often than he loses despite often being outnumbered and having to defend himself from gangs of enemies as opposed to just one enemy, having qualities people admire such as charm, having a way with words and being desired by lots of pretty ladies. To put it simply, JR has a high level of efficacy just as most heroes do. Since he lacks compassion and honesty too much tone considered a hero, he's an antihero.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I think this idea is a bit extreme. I mean it's a work of fiction. CBS wouldn't be advocating the behaviour of the DALLAS characters. We don't only have sanitised TV characters on shows now. I don't see marches and the like to boycott a show because a character is a bit of a bastard. There have always, and will always be TV villains.

Yup, if anything I think characters like JR, Jock etc would be even more extreme in todays tv climate.

Dallas would probably be criticized for their horrible writing of women, lack of minorities etc but that wouldn't exactly be wrong or unfair, would it?
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I don't really think Dallas was politically incorrect in any way, although I do agree those who go out of their way to both cause and take offence would probably find some reason to get it removed from the screens were it to be launched today.

The political correctness would have more of an effect on sitcoms, certainly here in the UK. So many of the truly great British sitcoms of the 70s and 80s would never get off the ground due to the gnashing of teeth and wailing of the PC mob.

Swami
 

James from London

International Treasure
One could argue that DALLAS is critiquing the behaviour it depicts, at least some of the time.

Julie Burchill in her introduction to the 2003 reissue of Valley of the Dolls: 'Like many mainstream entertainments, Valley Of The Dolls is far more critical of the American Dream than many avowedly "subversive" projects. As Dallas showed American big business to be corrupt and filthy through and through, so Dolls protractedly and minutely picks apart the "magic" of showbusiness.'
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Not for its time no. Even now, there is nothing that you could point to and say it's un-PC that I can think of, apart from sexist behaviour. There were no inappropriate references that I can think of, apart from maybe one which JR shouldn't have said about Kit....:eck:
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
One could argue that DALLAS is critiquing the behaviour it depicts, at least some of the time.

I don't see it with Dallas--granted, I have not seen the post-dream seasons). Early Dynasty clearly critiqued capitalism and sexism, and Blake and Cecil were representatives of a corrupt system. It wasn't that either of them or their companies was the problem by himself, it was what the ideology they supported and propagated that was the problem. This critique was gone by season two of course. In Dallas, on the other hand, I didn't see all business being portrayed as corrupt: we were led to believe that J.R. was the bad apple but that capitalism overall wasn't bad.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
In this age of such extreme levels of political correctness, I wonder how the people who belong to groups promoting that PC agenda would have reacted to Dallas if it debuted today instead of in 1978 but otherwise have been exactly the same regarding the content of the series.

I believe they would have been very much against "Dallas" (for this thread I'm talking about Dallas making its debut now and being exactly the same in content as it was then). There would likely have been movements to boycott CBS for airing Dallas and marches and rallies held to protest Dallas. I believe their biggest problem with Dallas would have been with J.R. and his inability to be politically correct even a little bit. Perhaps it wasn't "inability" to be PC as much as a complete lack of desire on J.R.'s part to be politically correct and the resulting lack of effort to even attempt trying to be more PC.

The last straw for the people promoting the extremist PC agenda of today would be that despite JR exuding qualities which would normally have caused him to be booed by the audience, he was cheered by the audience, or cheered by a large portion of the audience to be more precise.

That a network was airing a series that depicted such politically incorrect behavior and doing it in a way that it may have even seemed that Dallas was proud of being politically incorrect, would have truly angered these types of organizations. For me, that would have been very fun to see.

I don't think they could have succeeded in stopping the show from being aired or making CBS change Dallas to their liking, since it would (again for the purposes f this thread) be getting tremendous ratings which would have made it the most popular series on TV and tremendously profitable as a result! Still, the commotion that the friction between CBS and the members of these PC organizations would have caused in today's social climate would be interesting to say the least!
I don't even agree with the premise of this thread because I don't think we live in an "age of such extreme levels of political correctness" because there is nothing extreme about calling out sexism, racism and homophobia, the extremism is in holding those views. I don't understand who "PC groups" are, I guess you mean normal decent people who don't believe the world revolves around white, straight men.

Specifically about Dallas, if it was made today and set in present day, it would look completely ridiculous. For example, the idea of presenting Dallas as being a totally white environment, when in reality only about 50% is white, would look totally out of place. However, other themes of the show would still work. The abuse of women by men still exists in society and the corruption in big business and how the rich screw over the poor still happens today so all would be relevant to depict on a prime time show.

What specifically do you think the "angry PC groups" would object to that isn't currently depicted on other shows on TV?
​
 
Last edited:

James from London

International Treasure
I didn't see all business being portrayed as corrupt: we were led to believe that J.R. was the bad apple but that capitalism overall wasn't bad.

Well, the three bees -- booze, broads and booty -- were introduced in the very first episode as something all the Ewing men -- Jock, JR and Bobby -- routinely distributed to politicians and whatnot to keep them on side, so the family business was immediately established as corrupt and dirty. And I don't think Ewing Oil was depicted as any worse than any other oil company. (Certainly the original cartel members JR did business with were at least as dirty as he was.)

True, DALLAS itself didn't take a moral position and say "These people are bad", but dirty deals were shown to be a fact of life: something they were all aware of and had profited from and, at the very least, turned a blind eye to. I guess early DYNASTY did the same thing but more overtly -- nobody in the family challenged Jock over his business practices the way Steven did Blake because they were all in on it.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Specifically about Dallas, if it was made today and set in present day,

I said it would be debuting now - not set in present day. It wouldn't be set in present day. It would be set in the late 70s ad 80s. That's the only way the content could be the same. Different actors would be needed since most are elderly or dead now, but aside from that the content would remain identical.

I don't even agree with the premise of this thread because I don't think we live in an "age of such extreme levels of political correctness"

If you don't think this is "PC World" we're living in now, I can't imagine what you would think would be.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
I said it would be debuting now - not set in present day. It wouldn't be set in present day. It would be set in the late 70s ad 80s. That's the only way the content could be the same. Different actors would be needed since most are elderly or dead now, but aside from that the content would remain identical.
If it were still set in the 1970s and 1980s there wouldn't be any issue at all because many of the attitudes that where shown in Dallas were common place in that time and the audience would accept it on that basis.

If you don't think this is "PC World" we're living in now, I can't imagine what you would think would be.
I don't think there is anything politically correct about respecting the rights of all individuals to be represented and treated fairly, I think that's common decency. "PC" is a pejorative term often used by those who don't accept the need to respect those rights. No, we don't live in a "PC World" we live in a more enlightened one.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
In Dallas, on the other hand, I didn't see all business being portrayed as corrupt: we were led to believe that J.R. was the bad apple but that capitalism overall wasn't bad.
Do you remember that scene when Mrs Scotfield goes to Ewing Oil to let them know she was instrumental it bringing them down? "One of the little people fighting back" was how she described her actions. "You people up here in your ivory tower don't recognise the faces of the people you hurt" seemed to be a general and pretty damning critique of all big business.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Do you remember that scene when Mrs Scotfield goes to Ewing Oil to let them know she was instrumental it bringing them down? "One of the little people fighting back" was how she described her actions. "You people up here in your ivory tower don't recognise the faces of the people you hurt" seemed to be a general and pretty damning critique of all big business.

No, I don't, and I suspect it happened in episodes I have not seen. Was this after the dream season?
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Was this after the dream season?

Yes, it is in season 10 - the season in which they temporarily lost the right to use the Ewing Oil name and were fined roughly 667 million dollars by the government. Do you think any of that money went to the "little people" as Scotfield put it? I doubt it! It probably filled the corrupt politician's back pockets!

I loved the scene where some government worker tried to entrap JR and secretly film him while he did it. He picked the wrong guy to try to entrap, ha ha!

"You people up here in your ivory tower don't recognise the faces of the people you hurt" seemed to be a general and pretty damning critique of all big business.

She said that because she didn't have the education,the knowledge or the experience in running a big business to make an accurate analysis of the situation. That was during the oil crunch that hit the southwest around 1986-1988. That was a real phenomenon we've discussed here before. @Lastkidpicked knows all about that because he lived it. Tons of businesses were going under and not just little ones. Braniff Airlines went under. Oil companies of course went under. Major hotels went out of business. Touring rock and country bands stopped touring in the southwest because the economic situation was so bad that the entertainment dollar was gone!

So, if Ewing Oil said, OK, we'll keep everyone employed, even though they'd be operating at a loss, they'd be putting themselves in financial jeopardy. If Ewing Oil goes under, then it's not just a layoff - those jobs are gone. Permanently. Instead of just some Ewing oil employees being out of work, if Bobby kept everyone on the payroll until the company went bankrupt, then EVERY Ewing Oil employee would lose his job. It was a situation of lay some people off to cut costs and keep the majority of the employees working, or run the company into the ground which means every Ewing Oil employee is then out of work.
 
Last edited:
Top