With the utmost respect to David Jacobs for creating one the best television series ever would it be considered an injustice to place that much pressure on him? He may have given birth to Dallas but once his other creation - Knots Landing was greenlit - his involvement with Dallas diminished over the years.
Upon hearing the news Dallas had been resurrected I thought his concept making John Ross the good guy and Christopher the bad guy was interesting.
I don't know if "injustice" is the way to describe it, but based on his leaving Dallas to make Knots Landing, it's pretty clear that Knots Landing was where his passion was - not Dallas. I don't know how closely he followed Dallas after his departure for Knots Landing, or if he did, I don't know that he was necessarily a big fan of it. I haven't read much about him, so I'm sure there are people here who might have more insight into that - did he continue to follow Dallas closely and did he like it a lot?
That he was thinking of the continuation in terms of "good cousin" against "bad cousin" makes me wonder if he looked at original Dallas as "good brother" against "bad brother." That may have been his original view of it, but it certainly didn't stay that way.
Jacobs wanted to have the series primarily center around Pam and Bobby and have JR as more of a secondary character, which shows he doesn't have all the best ideas.
I don't think people would want to see such a simple, black and white division with JR and Christopher being the "bad team" and Bobby and John Ross being the "good team."
That would create a father vs. son dynamic. I don't believe Dallas would have had anywhere near the success it did if it had been built around it being father against son. That would have been a very ugly direction in which to take it. Family against family - the Barnes-Ewing feud - was a far more appealing way to build conflict, and it sure worked!