Why Lucy Was The Most Expendable Character Of The Main Cast

James from London

International Treasure
One of my favorite scenes is when Val and Karen are walking on the beach and Val mentions recently speaking to Lucy. Later in the conversation Karen asks her how long it has really been since she's spoken to her daughter. Val replies, "About eight
months "
Nothing else is said which is perfect, imho. All the tragic undercurrents of that relationship are there

Yeah, that was great. I felt I didn't really need to see Lucy on Knots after that.
 

James from London

International Treasure
Even to meet her baby brother and sister?

Well, I felt Val's line to Karen addressed the mother/daughter estrangement quite neatly and poignantly. To then bring Lucy back to Knots for another visit would have meant un-estranging them all over again (or ignoring the implications of the scene with Karen, which would have been a shame). I wouldn't necessarily have objected to it, but it just didn't feel necessary. Also, once you've got Lucy back and she's said hello to everybody, you're still left with the age-old question: what do you do with her? Knots doesn't really need her so she goes away again, but then we're left to wonder why she doesn't come back the next time someone dies or gets married. It just felt cleaner this way.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I did not like how after the writers did such a great job with that relationship, only for in the next season they had Lucy forget him and go chasing after Peter.

If Mickey had been able to see that only a few months after he died, that the next guy Lucy went after was Peter, as if he were any replacement for Mickey, I can't imagine the disgust Mickey would have felt.

It just goes to show that Lucy didn't have any particulate qualities she was looking for in a man. It would have been nice if after Mickey, she had learned what she wanted in a man, but instead she just went back to that same pattern of going out with whatever guy happened to be around.

It's hard for the audience to get too invested in whatever Lucy does because she doesn't even seem care what, or who, she does.
 
Last edited:

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Well, I felt Val's line to Karen addressed the mother/daughter estrangement quite neatly and poignantly. To then bring Lucy back to Knots for another visit would have meant un-estranging them all over again (or ignoring the implications of the scene with Karen, which would have been a shame). I wouldn't necessarily have objected to it, but it just didn't feel necessary. Also, once you've got Lucy back and she's said hello to everybody, you're still left with the age-old question: what do you do with her? Knots didn't really need her so she goes away again, but then we're left to wonder why she doesn't come back the next time someone dies or gets married. It just felt cleaner this way.

Well, that makes a lot of sense. Valene had a very dramatic life. The "Where's Lucy?" question would have beem raised so often it would have been a running joke. Let's see. Where's Lucy when
1. Ben went missing.
2. Val's brother Joshua, Lucy's uncle, went over that roof.
3. Her grandmother Liliane ran over Chip and was put in a mental institution.
4. Val had a supposed miscarriage and disappeared.
5. Gary "died" in season 5.
6. Val "attempted suicide" via Jill.
7. Val had a brain virus.
8. Gary went to jail for "killing" Jill.
9. Gary was hospitalized after a race car driving accident.
10. Val "died." Although, if I recall correctly, Mack did call her about coming to the funeral.
11. Val returns from the dead.

Lucy had more reasons to be at Seaview Circle than to be at Southfork. If she needed a purpose in life she would certainly have found one there. Those suburbanites would have kept her hopping!
 

James from London

International Treasure
If Mickey had been able to see that only a few months after he died, that the next guy Lucy went after was Peter, as if he were any replacement for Mickey, I can't imagine the disgust Mickey would have felt.

It just goes to show that Lucy didn't have any particulate qualities she was looking for in a man. It would have been nice if after Mickey, she had learned what she wanted in a man, but instead she just went back to that same pattern of going out with whatever guy happened to be around.

Maybe Mickey would have thought Lucy was grieving and looking for a way to rebuild her life by making a new friendship. Yeah, Peter did just "happen to be around", but he was nice and sincere. A little weird maybe, but nice. And it's not as if she was ripping his clothes off, she just wanted to start dating again. And even if she had been ripping his clothes off, so what? Whatever gets you through.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
When someone mentions the tv series DALLAS, Lucy is the first character that springs to mind. I don't know why that is.
Lucy had more reasons to be at Seaview Circle than to be at Southfork
But let's also consider the thing that made her such a unique and interesting character in the first place: the unusual upbringing at Southfork without her parents.
I honestly don't know how they should/could have capitalized on that since that whole storyline was already in the past when Dallas began.

But I don't think that soaps should be written just to give characters something to do.
The characters react to and deal with the events, and what happened on Dallas that affected Lucy? Not much.
Of course it's very easy to give her all sorts of unrelated storylines, and that's what they often did, but unrelated always feels like unrelated, so not much to gain in that regard.

And yet, despite all of this, the image of Lucy Ewing was just as iconic as Southfork itself. Whatever she was going to do or whomever she was going to marry, it had to happen there.
If she couldn't be part of Ewing Oil then why not give that part to her husband? Imagine the unexpected and treacherous alliances, the constant bitchery between Lucy and Sue Ellen.
I think that would have been more interesting than Lucy as a model or doctor's wife.
Alternatively, give her a hip club in downtown Dallas (ooh, how very La Mirage).
 

James from London

International Treasure
When someone mentions the tv series DALLAS, Lucy is the first character that springs to mind. I don't know why that is.
And yet, despite all of this, the image of Lucy Ewing was just as iconic as Southfork itself.

Ah, maybe that's because Lucy is the one character one can't really imagine belonging anywhere but Southfork. She's unique to DALLAS, a rare, odd plant that grows solely in response to the three adult couples surrounding her when the series begins. She's the extra ingredient that only makes sense as part of that specific recipe and yet is also crucial to the taste of that recipe.

I don't think that soaps should be written just to give characters something to do.

I've never thought of it like that before, but that is so true! I think that's why the argument that the writers should have made Lucy a part of Ewing Oil on Dallas or the Sumner Group on Knots has always bothered me. Noooo! That would have tampered with the ecosystem of the Ewingverse, just to give her something to do. I think characters simply have a natural shelf life and Lucy's was what it was.

If she couldn't be part of Ewing Oil then why not give that part to her husband? Imagine the unexpected and treacherous alliances, the constant bitchery between Lucy and Sue Ellen.

I feel like I've personally exhausted all the coulda/shoulda/woulda possibilities of the '80s soaps, but the one idea I still have a soft spot for is swapping Mitch's storyline for Kit Mainwaring's so that Lucy has a one-episode fling with the poor kid in Season 1 and then marries the gay one in Season 3. She loves him and doesn't realise he's gay, but Jock and JR do but don't tell her cos they need the marriage to take place for business reasons. Lucy only finds out her granddaddy knew after his death which turns her into Connie Corleone from The Godfather II ... but all of that would probably screw with the Ewingverse ecosystem too, so forget I said anything.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
She's the extra ingredient that only makes sense as part of that specific recipe and yet is also crucial to the taste of that recipe.
I think that's the best way to describe it.
... but all of that would probably screw with the Ewingverse ecosystem too
That's true. Fans have posted many coulda/shouldas that would have worked really well for this or that character or storyline, but change one thing and you change everything.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Perhaps after this there could have been a scene where she is back in Dallas talking to Mickey's grave. I did not like how after the writers did such a great job with that relationship, only for in the next season they had Lucy forget him and go chasing after Peter.
This trait appeared to be a modus operandi for Dallas. They didn't wish to dwell on a characters death. They had great fun in the lead up to a death but didn't wish to expand on that character after their demise.

Take Kristin. Although the writers create an air of reflection surrounding her death and having Sue Ellen making note she wishes to accompany the body on the same flight, we never see her funeral.

Was there a funeral for Rebecca Barnes Wentworth?

The same can be said of Mickey. In this case the writers main focus was on Ray and the court proceedings. Again no funeral. The exception to the rule was Bobby. I suspect though as a major character the writers felt the need to establish closure for both characters and viewers. But you will note no funeral for Katherine. How disrespectful.

Why did the writers excuse themselves from creating funeral/burial scenes when these circumstances can create so much drama?
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The characters react to and deal with the events, and what happened on Dallas that affected Lucy? Not much.
Of course it's very easy to give her all sorts of unrelated storylines, and that's what they often did, but unrelated always feels like unrelated, so not much to gain in that regard.

Lucy does very little except react. Other characters react too but they're also proactive. They have goals.

You notice how Lucy always seemed to be lacking something on the inside, that she always seemed to be plagued by self-doubt? That she lacked self-esteem? That's a result of her not having goals, of not working to achieve those goals she needed. You might ask since she had inherited all the money she'd ever need, why did she need goals?

You look at someone, say a businessman, and yes, they do want to make money and that's fine and good, but at bottom, the purpose all goal achievement is to achieve a sense of mastery, of efficacy, to achieve a certain type of happiness that can only be had as a result of achieving goals.

A lot of people find that once they finally make the money they'd always dreamed of, they're not really any different inside. It's because they didn't take a philosophical approach. The idea is to gain a sense of mastery, a sense of self-esteem which can only be derived from achieving goals, but you have to have that stated explicitly at the outset. If you think you're going to end up having those things only as a result of having the money and you don't work on developing other aspects of your life along with it, like your philosophy, then you're just going to have a big bank account and be bereft of the rest.

We all know people who have made a good amount of money, but they're self-arrested intellectually. They're no further ahead at the age they are now, mentally, than they were when they started their career. They're still psychologically beset by the same conflicts, the same sense of insecurity and self-doubt. They gained the financial status they wanted, but they didn't get that sense of mastery. Self esteem can only be achieved by starting the whole process by stating explicitly: Not only do I want the money, but I want self-confidence. I can only get that by enjoying the process, gaining the knowledge, and recognizing that I am a more effective person.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
That is a very insightful post, and especially unique because it involves a character we just don't think about very often.

You notice how Lucy always seemed to be lacking something on the inside, that she always seemed to be plagued by self-doubt? That she lacked self-esteem?

I know it's funny to feel sorry for a rich girl who had everything handed to her, but I do feel sorry for Lucy. People judged her by her family name and (rightly or wrongly) people assumed she was a spoiled rich kid. One of my good buddies was very wealthy growing up, and there was always this second guessing of, "Are these people at my party because they like me, or are they at my party because I'm wealthy and they may need something some day?"

You look at someone, say a businessman, and yes, they do want to make money and that's fine and good, but at bottom, the purpose all goal achievement is to achieve a sense of mastery, of efficacy, to achieve a certain type of happiness that can only be had as a result of achieving goals.

And this is why the Lucy as a Waitress storyline was very realistic. Lucy found happiness in achieving goals and doing a good job on her own. She was finally happy when she was able to really do a job all by herself, where the Ewing name seemed a million miles away.

I wish they could have seized this opportunity to have a big blowout, and show off Charlene Tilton's acting skills. Imagine a scene where they find out at Southfork that Lucy has been working as a waitress. And Lucy finally gets her moment when she declares,

"At least at the Diner, they appreciate me for who I am, not for my name! And when somebody says, 'Good Job!' it's because I did a good job, not because they are trying to get on my good side.

And when I mess up, people aren't afraid to tell me I messed up. Then they jump in to try to help. I feel like I'm part of a team, like we are working together. When's the last time this family worked together for anything?

And last night, at the end of my shift, a cowboy came in for a late supper. And he saw me pour out the stale coffee and make a fresh pot. He said, 'You did that for me? Just for me? That really picked up my night, I appreciate that!' When's the last time anybody really appreciated anything around here?

And the other day, I left my purse in my car. I have credit cards with unlimited credit in that purse, but the people at the diner didn't know that. They took up a little collection for me for my bus fare. That two dollars means more to me than ten percent of Ewing Oil, I can tell you that!

The friends I made and the people I work with are more of a family to me then you have ever been. Here, I feel like an outsider but at the diner, I feel like I belong. Like I'm really contributing something. And I like it.

It shows me how my mom felt when she was working there."

.........

I think Charlene Tilton could have pulled this off. It would have been a good scene.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
That is a very insightful post, and especially unique because it involves a character we just don't think about very often.



I know it's funny to feel sorry for a rich girl who had everything handed to her, but I do feel sorry for Lucy. People judged her by her family name and (rightly or wrongly) people assumed she was a spoiled rich kid. One of my good buddies was very wealthy growing up, and there was always this second guessing of, "Are these people at my party because they like me, or are they at my party because I'm wealthy and they may need something some day?"



And this is why the Lucy as a Waitress storyline was very realistic. Lucy found happiness in achieving goals and doing a good job on her own. She was finally happy when she was able to really do a job all by herself, where the Ewing name seemed a million miles away.

I wish they could have seized this opportunity to have a big blowout, and show off Charlene Tilton's acting skills. Imagine a scene where they find out at Southfork that Lucy has been working as a waitress. And Lucy finally gets her moment when she declares,

"At least at the Diner, they appreciate me for who I am, not for my name! And when somebody says, 'Good Job!' it's because I did a good job, not because they are trying to get on my good side.

And when I mess up, people aren't afraid to tell me I messed up. Then they jump in to try to help. I feel like I'm part of a team, like we are working together. When's the last time this family worked together for anything?

And last night, at the end of my shift, a cowboy came in for a late supper. And he saw me pour out the stale coffee and make a fresh pot. He said, 'You did that for me? Just for me? That really picked up my night, I appreciate that!' When's the last time anybody really appreciated anything around here?

And the other day, I left my purse in my car. I have credit cards with unlimited credit in that purse, but the people at the diner didn't know that. They took up a little collection for me for my bus fare. That two dollars means more to me than ten percent of Ewing Oil, I can tell you that!

The friends I made and the people I work with are more of a family to me then you have ever been. Here, I feel like an outsider but at the diner, I feel like I belong. Like I'm really contributing something. And I like it.

It shows me how my mom felt when she was working there."

.........

I think Charlene Tilton could have pulled this off. It would have been a good scene.

That was nice creative take on a missed opportunity- they could have done more with that storyline. It's kind of funny that one of the very few things JR and Lucy had in common is neither worked because they needed the money. JR had already made all the money he could ever spend but it was the challenge of building Ewing Oil even bigger, of making a great deal or executing a great business plan that made it so important. Remember how he had his own company he was running but he chose to work for Bobby because Bobby had the Ewing Oil name? It was working to building Oil and the challenge it presented that he found meaning in. Even if he had to answer to Bobby.

The only problem was JR couldn't stand to not be allowed to dealing oil and it wasn't that he couldn't make a lot of money in real estate or something else, it's that to him the oil business had a special meaning.

Lucy made very little money at the diner, but it was an opportunity to see how she would do on her own without the benefit of the Ewing name, and she seemed to be doing well and enjoying it. Unfortunately, like all Lucy storylines, they never allow it to grow to the next level - they just cut it short, which made her look like a dilettante - someone who just goes from one thing to another because nothing in particular means much to them, or because they don't have the dedication to stick with one goal and see it through.

I could picture a situation where maybe after learning the business Lucy eventually opens her own diner. It wouldn't look like an impressive business in size compared to Ewing Oil, but as long as it was something she had a passion for, that would be all that matters. It just had to be something that she felt strongly about.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
but it was an opportunity to see how she would do on her own without the benefit of the Ewing name, and she seemed to be doing well and enjoying it
someone who just goes from one thing to another because nothing in particular means much to them, or because they don't have the dedication to stick with one goal and see it through.
You seem to forget that there isn't much at stake here. It's all good and well to mix with the ordinary people, but at the end of the day - whether she succeeds or not - she'll still have that precious Ewing name.
It was a project, and to make a point is not the same as to make a living.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You seem to forget that there isn't much at stake here. It's all good and well to mix with the ordinary people, but at the end of the day - whether she succeeds or not - she'll still have that precious Ewing name.
It was a project, and to make a point is not the same as to make a living.

As nice a compliment as that is, it's not my idea. It's the idea put forward by @Lastkidpicked. I can't take credit for his idea.
 
You notice how Lucy always seemed to be lacking something on the inside, that she always seemed to be plagued by self-doubt? That she lacked self-esteem? That's a result of her not having goals, of not working to achieve those goals she needed. You might ask since she had inherited all the money she'd ever need, why did she need goals?

I dont ask why she needs goals because I don't think characters necessarily need them in order to be important to a series. Their lack of goals can prove as fascinating, if not more so. Some of the more interesting characters in drama are plagued at times by self-doubt, lack self-esteem or have little in the way of goals or the ability to achieve them. Both Lucy's parents ticked a number of these boxes for several years of their onscreen journeys. Perhaps to a greater extent than Lucy.



We all know people who have made a good amount of money, but they're self-arrested intellectually. They're no further ahead at the age they are now, mentally, than they were when they started their career. They're still psychologically beset by the same conflicts, the same sense of insecurity and self-doubt. They gained the financial status they wanted, but they didn't get that sense of mastery. Self esteem can only be achieved by starting the whole process by stating explicitly: Not only do I want the money, but I want self-confidence. I can only get that by enjoying the process, gaining the knowledge, and recognizing that I am a more effective person.

There's truth in what you say, but then again, drama offers us the opportunity to get to know those self-arrested characters beset by conflicts, insecurity and self-doubt, as well as those who aren't. Their differences are what drive the drama. I wouldn't be interested in watching an ensemble of people who all shared my beliefs or value system, nor those of anyone else. Neither do I tune in to see self-actualised people showing me the path to mastery. That's not to say characters should necessarily fail at every turn. But over and above everything they need to remain interesting and watchable.

Characters in soap are dysfunctional to a man. Otherwise where's the drama?



I wish they could have seized this opportunity to have a big blowout, and show off Charlene Tilton's acting skills.

I suspect Charlene Tilton's acting skills are the very reason the powers that be didn't give us such a blowout.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
Like Mum Val, I can only say: "Poor, poor Lucy."

She was like the chorus in the Greek tragedies, always giving comments about what was happening, criticizing the "bad" and defending the "good". So underrated, so subtly played by The Charlene. Of course, at the end, she was devoured by the devil of audiences, who only wanted to see big shoulderpads, couples re-marrying and catfigths. But not even re-marrying Mitch could save poor, poor Lucy: she was marked with the U letter of "Useless" for any supersoap. And sent into the sunset, to use the Atlanta toilets (sic!) and waiting for big-time doctor at home. She was trapped in a loop of pride and prejudice...
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
And sent into the sunset, to use the Atlanta toilets

Is that a common idiom? If not, it should be!

(overheard in a popular watering hole for lawyers near the courthouse)

“Hey, is that Alan Beam guy still around Dallas? I haven’t seen him in a while.”

“Nah, he’s using Chicago toilets now, last I heard”

(in the checkout line at McGregor’s feed barn in Braddock)

“Say, what’s that Ray Krebbs been up to, Ernie?”

“Ol’ Ray’s using them fancy Austrian toilets now, the ones that spray the water up when you flush.”
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I dont ask why she needs goals because I don't think characters necessarily need them in order to be important to a series. Their lack of goals can prove as fascinating, if not more so.

I rarely find a character with a lack of goals fascinating or even interesting. I certainly don't find a lack of them to make a character more fascinating. I can think of a few examples of characters in TV dramas or dramatic movies that found a way to be fascinating despite an almost complete lack of goals, such as through the sheer force of their personaliy, but they're rare.

Some of the more interesting characters in drama are plagued at times by self-doubt, lack self-esteem or have little in the way of goals or the ability to achieve them.

I'd agree, but only with the caveat that at some point in the story, they have to begin to set goals, even one goal, and the story has to have a logical progression where we see that character overcome their insecurity and lack of self-esteem. The exception would be as in the above example where a character may have such a compelling personality or other attribute that is enough to make them interesting to watch, but again, they're rare. It takes quite an impressive actor to be able to pull that off and that may be why I find it rare that a character without goals is interesting.

I wouldn't be interested in watching an ensemble of people who all shared my beliefs or value system, nor those of anyone else.

Why not? I could definitely get interested in that! I wouldn't want to see it in every show or every movie because I like some variety, but I'd absolutely find that interesting as long as it also has a good story that's well executed.

If a TV drama has a cast full of characters with ether such a lack of values or such an either warped or irrational set of values that I find them repellent, I have no interest in what happens to them and stop watching. Not that they can't have bad qualities, but there has got to be some redeeming value to them that's enough to make me have any interest in seeing what happens to them.

Neither do I tune in to see self-actualised people showing me the path to mastery

I don't tune in expecting to see it, but if I were to find such a show, I'd be very pleasantly surprised! I'd be incredibly surprised. In today's competence-phobic society I'm not sure that any studio would allow a dramatic TV series fitting that description to be made.

Characters in soap are dysfunctional to a man. Otherwise where's the drama?

The drama is in the struggle against adversity to achieve one's goal. A character could be highly effective- fallible of course, but not nearly to the point of dysfunctional - and in a drama they're still inevitably going to have to confront adversity, whether it's in the form of extremely dysfunctional people, or in the form of formidable competitors, or adverse situations that unexpectedly arise, making it that much harder for them to do whatever it is they have set out to do.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
I'd agree, but only with the caveat that at some point in the story, they have to begin to set goals, even one goal, and the story has to have a logical progression where we see that character overcome their insecurity and lack of self-esteem
I think these things can happen without it being a goal, and it certainly applies to Gary and Valene. It's the story that decides for the characters what happens to them, not vice versa.
The drama is in the struggle against adversity to achieve one's goal.
That description reminds me of the popular rags-to-riches stories/mini-series from the 1970s and 80s.
But the prime time soaps, and especially Dallas and Dynasty, was sort of a reverse situation i.e. it starts with characters who are already living the American Dream, and the dysfunctional soap aspect shows how they manage to make such a big mess of everything.
It's not so much about getting bigger and better, but trying to keep what they already have and to prevent everything from falling apart.

And of course JR also wanted Ewing Oil to become the biggest and most powerful independent oil company, but personally I think the story focused on how he tried to achieve that - usually in the most despicable way possible, which is what made it so entertaining to watch - rather than the growth and success itself.
JR was not a "master", he was a schemer, a bully, a backstabber - probably the most intellectually self-arrested character in the Ewingverse, which is backed up by his suicide in the series finale. So much for that grand and carefully planned victory.
 
Top