"Dallas was Succession before Succession"

James from London

International Treasure

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I disagree though, if done well and marketed right, we could get back there with tshirts and all. We certainly are living in a time where business is king and villains are being justified and conspiracy theories are running a muck. Writers and actors just need to dive into the deep end and rip these stories from the news around us, a Koch Bothers, an Oracle of Omaha, a Walton’s (and I don’t mean the mountain). Sleeping around is no longer limited to sheets pulled over naked heterosexuals. And the money of the very rich is at s level not seen since before the Great Depression Robber Barons. And literally with the right legal team a villain can get away with murder and treason at the highest levels. JR could look like a Girl Scout.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
JR could look like a Girl Scout.

Or, more likely, J.R. would be even badder today. Thanks to all the societal changes you mentioned, characters like him can be written with less restrictions than they could be back in 70's and 80's. I've mentioned before how one of the lines J.R. never crossed was directly killing someone (although he had no problem taking actions that could potentially lead to others deaths, nor felt any guilt when people committed or attempted to commit suicide because of things he did to them), but if written today he probably would, similar to how Frank Underwood and Lucious Lyon, both characters very much in the tradition of J.R. Ewing, were shown to occasionally kill people. Even on Succession, one of the son's accidentally kills somone in a drunk driving incident and his father and stepmother cover it up (and use it to blackmail him ).
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
Dynasty was Succession before Succession.

Dallas was trash. Not in a bad way, but trash.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I've mentioned before how one of the lines J.R. never crossed was directly killing someone
This is why I loved the character. He didn't have to kill anyone but his manipulations were responsible for the deaths of a few characters on Dallas; including his own brother...before Pam had that horrid dream. The pleasure in watching Dallas was the skill of the writers orchestrating another dastardly deed for JR to carry out, sitting back and witnessing how one character can mess with so many peoples lives.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
I *think* I've seen a little bit of Succession when I tried an alternative streaming service. And since I didn't watch all of it I assume it wasn't to my liking.
And I always confuse it with BILLIONS, although I've only seen the trailer of it (and therefore, not in a hurry to check it out).
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I *think* I've seen a little bit of Succession when I tried an alternative streaming service. And since I didn't watch all of it I assume it wasn't to my liking.
And I always confuse it with BILLIONS, although I've only seen the trailer of it (and therefore, not in a hurry to check it out).

Yes they seen like something I’d like to watch, much like other 80’s soaps seemed that way, but I never was able to get into them. I watched Dallas and Falcon Crest (and Knots Landing occasionally) but never got into Dynasty. I watched it for a bit taking notes for my grandma when she was in the hospital, but it just wasn’t my thing to stick around for, even though I found it interesting (I did recently watch the first 2 seasons and really got into them but then I just stopped). So I’m not sure I can figure out the difference for me between Dallas and Falcon Crest (where I held out to the end and would still keep going) and these others back in the day, let alone nowadays and the fact that I don’t go beyond thinking the commercials look interesting. Though I did throughly get into House Of Cards until my interest faded after he got to be president. Could making an interesting thread.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
I watched it for a bit taking notes for my grandma when she was in the hospital
The sterling stenographer! Yes you're Dynasty fan you just don't know it yet.

But what you see in these modern family-power-struggle dramas is that it builds its entire premise on a storyline taken from a soap opera.
So, I guess Succession (and Filthy Rich) is a bit like the post-Jock battle for Ewing Oil.
Personally, I think it's more effective when it's derived from previous soap storylines and character history, and it's also possible to have it intertwine with other storylines happening at that time.
A show like Succession needs to stay on topic, which (inadvertently) creates a shorter shelf life. Mad Men was much more successful in that regard, and I was still hungry for more when it ended.

NuDynasty had the opportunity to cherry-pick the best of the classic soap, and combined with modern techniques and room for bigger shock value (which they do, occasionally) it could have been awesome.
 

Emelee

Telly Talk Warrior
Don't trashtalk Succession!! It's one of the best series in the 21st century. The acting, the writing, well, everything really are miles better than most series. Original Dallas or Dynasty cannot compare. The only thing they have in common is who will succeed the mogul father once he dies. But many series have that element, including a series like Game of Thrones.

The siblings on Succession don't like each other. They don't like anyone except themself. They don't like their father and the father doesn't like them. There are few redeeming qualities in Succession's characters. They are selfish brats, through and through. Nasty for a either a good laugh or to feel good about themselves. They love to put others down to feel superior. And still you kind of like them.

Even JR loved and respected his parents. And Bobby. Succession is very much rawer. No melodrama. No whirlwind romances. Just raw. And I am loving it!
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
And still you kind of like them
Why wouldn't you, if they bring you so much entertainment?
I didn't say that Succession wasn't good enough, it just didn't click with me. I felt the same about Bloodline, another series I had expected to like.
It happens sometimes and it's no big deal, really.

Kelsey Grammer's BOSS is also about wicked selfish people and I loved it (still need to watch the second season, thanks for the reminder).
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Why wouldn't you, if they bring you so much entertainment?
I didn't say that Succession wasn't good enough, it just didn't click with me. I felt the same about Bloodline, another series I had expected to like.
It happens sometimes and it's no big deal, really.

Kelsey Grammer's BOSS is also about wicked selfish people and I loved it (still need to watch the second season, thanks for the reminder).
It’s that “click” I don’t get. Why it happens and why it doesn’t.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
The siblings on Succession don't like each other. They don't like anyone except themself. They don't like their father and the father doesn't like them. There are few redeeming qualities in Succession's characters. They are selfish brats, through and through. Nasty for a either a good laugh or to feel good about themselves. They love to put others down to feel superior. And still you kind of like them.
I shouldn't judge it until I've seen it but from your synopsis I cannot imagine liking it. I think this is why Dallas succeeded so well with the broader community because the writers were not forcing the Ewing millions down our throat but despite that wealth the Ewing and Barnes family dealt with problems like many of us do. This is why we could relate.
Succession (like Empire) sounds like I might tire of it pretty quickly. If Succession is just a bunch of rich snobs bickering and constantly putting everyone down I'd be thinking, "Why am I watching this?" I need that connection to characters.
 

Emelee

Telly Talk Warrior
I shouldn't judge it until I've seen it but from your synopsis I cannot imagine liking it. I think this is why Dallas succeeded so well with the broader community because the writers were not forcing the Ewing millions down our throat but despite that wealth the Ewing and Barnes family dealt with problems like many of us do. This is why we could relate.
Succession (like Empire) sounds like I might tire of it pretty quickly. If Succession is just a bunch of rich snobs bickering and constantly putting everyone down I'd be thinking, "Why am I watching this?" I need that connection to characters.

Considering it's a big Emmy-winner (plus other awards), you can at least be sure it's of excellent quality. It can be quite funny and you can absolutely root for some characters. I find it easy to see their POVs. Especially knowing their backstories.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
This is why I loved the character. He didn't have to kill anyone but his manipulations were responsible for the deaths of a few characters on Dallas; including his own brother...before Pam had that horrid dream. The pleasure in watching Dallas was the skill of the writers orchestrating another dastardly deed for JR to carry out, sitting back and witnessing how one character can mess with so many peoples lives.

I agree. I'm just pointing out the ways societal changes have affected entertainment. At the time of Dallas, it was still unusual to have a "bad guy" as the lead protagonist of an ongoing TV series (before that, the closet thing was probably Archie Bunker on All In The Family), which we know wasn't even the original plan of the series. So there were certain limits to how far they'd want to push him, I think that's what likely held the writers back from ever having J.R. directly cross that line. Now we've had shows with literal mobsters and serial killers as the lead, so it's different. So when I look at something like House of Cards, with another lead character who was initially very J.R.-like in the way he manipulated people, and a couple of times they had him directly kill people but that was always as more of a last resort for him, I could definitely see J.R. also being written that way and it being accepted, if it were written today.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
I *think* I've seen a little bit of Succession when I tried an alternative streaming service. And since I didn't watch all of it I assume it wasn't to my liking. And I always confuse it with BILLIONS, although I've only seen the trailer of it (and therefore, not in a hurry to check it out).

The first 3 seasons of BILLIONS were great, in my opinion. The lead character of Bobby Axelrod also gave off a vibe of a modern-day J.R. to me. And the other lead of Chuck Rhodes is similar to how Cliff was originally written, before they made him a perenial loser, and I loved the ongoing battles between them. It started going downhille in its 4th season, and at this point I've continued watching mostly out of habit, with some small hope that it will return to its high point eventually.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
I could definitely see J.R. also being written that way and it being accepted, if it were written today.
Jeb Hollister (Chuck Connors) in the short-lived western soap THE YELLOW ROSE was the "TNT Cliff Barnes" of the 1980s. Pure and murderous villainy.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
I shouldn't judge it until I've seen it but from your synopsis I cannot imagine liking it. I think this is why Dallas succeeded so well with the broader community because the writers were not forcing the Ewing millions down our throat but despite that wealth the Ewing and Barnes family dealt with problems like many of us do. This is why we could relate.

Yes, although I also love SUCCESSION so far, I've also said before that the core of DALLAS is how it was so relatable despite their wealth. It's why I've said unlike the fans here who prefer the "Romeo and Juliet" romance of Bobby and Pam as what drove them to the show, to me it's the "Caine vs. Abel" sibling rivalry of J.R. and Bobby that is the real draw. Rich, poor, White, Black, southern, northern, etc, it didn't really matter, if you grew up with siblings, you could relate to the idea of loving, sometimes hating, sometimes competing with, them.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
It’s that “click” I don’t get. Why it happens and why it doesn’t.

Nobody does. If it was that easy to figure out exactly why certain shows click with an audience then TV and movie studioes would have nothing but hits. But they try it all the time, one show because a breakout, and then there's a bunch of copycats by other networks trying to cash in, and most of them bomb.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
Considering it's a big Emmy-winner (plus other awards), you can at least be sure it's of excellent quality.

Again, I'm a fellow fan of SUCCESSION, but I just have to disagree on principle with the general idea that "winning big awards = excellent quality". Nah, not necessarily. I mean, obviously "quality" is a subjective term, but winning a bunch of awards just means award show voters and producers like it. Plenty of failed shows over the years have won Emmys.
 
Top