Donna Reed, "She Just Wasn't Mama"

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I can't remember whether it was Larry Hagman or Patrick Duffy who said that in relation to Donna Reed taking over the role of Miss Ellie but I often wondered would they have had said the same thing had Mary Martin had been cast in that role?

When Barbara Bel Geddes decided to retire there was some speculation as to who would be the new Ellie and it was reported that Larry had suggested his mother, Mary Martin, for the role. Do you think the cast and the viewers would have accepted her as Miss Ellie? When Barbara decided to come out of retirement to go back to the role would that have dared to sack Larry's mother? It would have been interesting to see how the producers had handled that situation.
I don’t mind a role like Jenna Wade recast, but I say no to any recasting of a major character. I would have:

1) Miss Ellie and Clayton set up the Farlow Foundation and leave the land and oil to it “protected” - a while story waiting for JR to get his hands on it once out from Miss Ellie’s grip.

2) Give the house to John Ross - a potential for JR and Sue Ellen to later fight and a reason it became more home to Sue Ellen than just her husband’s family home. could be complicated trust story lines.

3) Give the ranch business to Bobby and $1 lease terms for the land, this way ranching remains party of the story as back ground and Bobby stays on the property - maybe have him teach the boys ranching for a good later story line.

4) Miss Ellie move to KL to be near Gary, along with traveling, maybe Clayton buys a yacht. Once there she wouldn’t need to show up on KL, always explain her traveling. That way if she wants to come back she’s around to return easy, or easy to add to KL if she wants a different story. But no new actress.

5) Clayton goes back into the oil business and travels between CA and TX to remain part of the story line if all agree. Part of the arrangement could even be he and Mis s Ellie keep a bedroom at South Fork.

So when Bobby gets hit by the car she’s not around to be at the hospital. And if she chooses to return next season it’s an easy fix.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I also felt sorry for Donna. Barbara Bel Geddes was a hard act to follow and of course she was, furthermore always will be Miss Ellie Southworth Ewing Farlow. Donna as an accomplished actor in her own right chose to portray the Ewing matriarch, in a way she perceived the character should be. However for millions the character was well known; as a down to earth, homely yet not to be messed with mother to J.R., Gary and Bobby.

As I said before Donna should have been given a new role, if TPTB wanted to fill the void left by Ellie e.g. Jason Ewing's wife or a relative to Sue Ellen or some other important character. If Mary Martin had been in Donna's shoes would things have worked out differently. Maybe, maybe not but I don't think Larry would have stood for it.


A furniture company's delivery van is at Southfork. Clayton has just parked his blue Rolls Royce Silver Spirit behind J.R.'s olive green Mercedes SEL. Ellie played by Donna Reed arrives to tell the furniture company's employee where to put her purchases, (a scene from season 7; DVD-8, 1984 - '85):

Ellie signs the delivery docket: "Thank you!"

Ellie to Clayton: "For us, it's a new set of bedroom furniture. Donna helped me choose it yesterday and I got them to deliver it today."

Clayton seems surprised: "Bedroom furniture."

Ellie: "I thought it was time for a change."

Ellie and Clayton kiss.

The Ewing matriarch then gives her orders to the delivery man: "Follow me and I'll show you where to put everything."

J.R. c/w trademark Stetson and briefcase in hand, appears on the patio: "Hey mama what's going on?"

Ellie smiling: "A new set of bedroom furniture for Clayton and me."

She walks off to get everything arranged.

J.R. squares up to Clayton: "Oh really! How about that."

J.R.: "Well I have to hand it to you. You're not here a week and you're changing things around already."

Clayton: "For your information it was mother's decision and since it's our bedroom and not yours, it is really none of your business. Is it?"

J.R. chuckles and in his best English accent, replies to his stepfather: "I suppose not!"

He goes to get into his Merc'. However he notices Clayton has him blocked in.

J.R. politely asks Clayton: "Could you arrange to have that blue thing moved out of the way, so I can get my car outta here?"

Clayton throws his Rolls Royce keys at him and replies: "Be my guest!"

J.R. is not amused.
I agree, Donna Reed could have been given another role to fill the void of the Miss Ellie character taken in a different direction but just not Miss Ellie.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Mary Martin would certainly have been harder to blast out, assuming that they had wanted to. But recasting was really the only call they could make. A new character simply wouldn't have had the authority that Miss Ellie did, whoever was in the role.
Miss Ellie’s cousin Donna Southworth with proof 1/2 the property belongs to her. “Aunt Donna” could her JR the oil he wants and Bobby could have great memories with her. Not the same authority as momma but still an interesting role.
 

Monzo

Telly Talk Star
honestly, I wouldn’t be surprised if the cancer was already setting in (before anyone knew) and that’s part of what led to the flat performance. Look at poor Jim Davis in his last season.
If Barbara didn't agree to come back and they would have sticked with Donna what would have happened after her death? I can't imagine they would have tried another Ellie recast.
 

ClassyCo

Telly Talk Warrior
I don’t mind a role like Jenna Wade recast, but I say no to any recasting of a major character.
We got three different incarnations of Jenna Wade, and that didn't really bother me. The only one I didn't like was Francine Tucker who played her between Morgan Fairchild and Priscilla Presley.

As much as I like Priscilla, I personally wished whatever needed to be worked out would've gotten worked out so Morgan could've returned to the role full-time in 1983.​
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
a relative of Miss Ellie, who has an equal compassion for Southfork and the land.
It still wouldn't be someone that JR would take seriously.
Better to have put Miss Ellie on ice for a while -- a hospitalization -- until things were worked out with BBG than to recast. A character who's needed to maintain the balance of a show structurally won't do so by being recast with someone else.
The problem with that is that BBG was not expected to return.
Not the same authority as momma but still an interesting role.
You've said it yourself: the authority would be lacking.
 

Crimson

Telly Talk Star
For some reason, Donna Reed on DALLAS has been showing up on my Youtube feed recently. I'll be blunt: she was bad. It's not just that she was miscast or even that she approached the role with an inherently bad concept, her acting was just terrible. She seemed to play every scene with a stuffy dignity and whispered all of her dialogue. Maybe that kind of stiff acting could cut it on other 80s soaps, but I wouldn't have wanted to see her on DALLAS even in a different role.

I believe it's been suggested before, but pity that if Donna on DALLAS had to occur that it didn't align with the "Dream Season" to be easier disregarded.
 

thomaswak

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Little question : was Donna paid more or less (or equally) than Barbara?

Actually, I want to say that my question wasn't just out of curiosity. It's just that he would have been horrible to pay Donna Reed more, after they refused Barbara a raise. That's why I was asking.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Actually, I want to say that my question wasn't just out of curiosity. It's just that he would have been horrible to pay Donna Reed more, after they refused Barbara a raise. That's why I was asking.

That definitely would have been terrible. However, since Ms. Reed sued and won, and they had to pay Ms. Bel Geddes, karma struck the producers.
I wonder how much they had to pay BBG to return.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
For some reason, Donna Reed on DALLAS has been showing up on my Youtube feed recently. I'll be blunt: she was bad. It's not just that she was miscast or even that she approached the role with an inherently bad concept, her acting was just terrible. She seemed to play every scene with a stuffy dignity and whispered all of her dialogue. Maybe that kind of stiff acting could cut it on other 80s soaps, but I wouldn't have wanted to see her on DALLAS even in a different role.

I believe it's been suggested before, but pity that if Donna on DALLAS had to occur that it didn't align with the "Dream Season" to be easier disregarded.
yep, I don’t know if people who disagree are just being nice, but I have to agree with the above.

Why on earth would adding her as some other character have added anything positive to the show? At that point, Martha Scott, Priscilla Pointer (not Presley, another I think people on here are wayyyy too 'charitable' to!) and Alexis Smith could all act rings around Donna.

As I said earlier in the thread, the simplest and most plausible explanation for such an accomplished actress giving such a flat performance is that she was already sick from the cancer and just didn’t have the energy to do more. I’m no Harlan Danvers, but I’m pretty sure terminal-stage pancreatic cancer doesn’t just leap up out of nowhere fully-formed.
 
Last edited:

ClassyCo

Telly Talk Warrior
I believe it's been suggested before, but pity that if Donna on DALLAS had to occur that it didn't align with the "Dream Season" to be easier disregarded.
I've heard this said so many times, and one wishes it would have worked out that way. Had Donna Reed been on the show that ninth season (per DVD count), then it would definitely be easier to erase her from the DALLAS canon. But she was there in one of the more pivotal seasons, and she was there when Bobby flatlined. It makes it less forgivable that we didn't get the real Miss Ellie (for the lack of better words) during those sadder, more poignant moments.​
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Do you know if BBG ended up getting paid more when they asked her back?

I tend to assume it, but I don't know the specifics. Of course, after BBG returned, a whole year had passed and she'd had time to recuperate, so she was able to work a full work load.

After having previously refused Bel Geddes' request for lightened workweek, one marvels at how short Donna Reed's workweek must have become when her scenes started getting cut back so dramatically --- which happened almost right away.

The whole Mis-Ellie mess should never have happened. It was executive arrogance and one could argue it ultimately undermined the entire series.... It cast a depressive pall over that season (even before Patrick announced he was leaving and that Bobby would die) and a sense that something great had now been ruined.

From that point forward, the series seemed to 'lose face' and annual gaffes like The Dream Resolution became a new, regrettable tradition. Or, as Susan Howard phrased it, "the audience abused again".

And, indeed, the DALLAS producers seemed to develop a contempt for its audience. (Just as DYNASTY's producers seem to resent their actors). And that sometimes also happens in real-life relationships: one person is enamored with another, and the less-emotionally invested partner comes to sneeringly look down on the other for dispensing that adoration. Even though they like the approval, they also disrespect the partner for giving it to them.

That's how DALLAS and its slide felt.

e8d441639284cee7b25f48593a2a59c6.jpg
f1d16c6bd019a1c55310c4312d6b96be.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
No disrespect to Donna Reed but I wish some talented person could utilize the technology that is deep fake and replace Donna Reed with Barbara Bel Geddes.
The whole Mis-Ellie mess should never have happened. It was executive arrogance and one could argue it ultimately undermined the entire series.... It cast a depressive pall over that season (even before Patrick announced he was leaving and that Bobby would die) and a sense that something great had now been ruined.
We spoken of this before but there is something "off" when Season 8 returns. This is when Afton discovers Bobby on the floor in the office. In my opinion I think there was a nasty, bitter war going on behind the scenes. Call it a clash of egos, creative control, whatever but the fallout from what occurred behind the scenes thrust itself onto the screen.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
No disrespect to Donna Reed but I wish some talented person could utilize the technology that is deep fake and replace Donna Reed with Barbara Bel Geddes.

Of course, that's how I feel about most of DYNASTY.

I guess there are union rules involved which would stop this kind of thing. But if they can conjure Marilyn or Audrey Hepburn decades after their deaths to sell tampons, why can't they switch Reed back to Bel Geddes?

Alas.

Hey, maybe they could switch Bel Geddes to Reed for the dream season?? :lol:
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Hey, maybe they could switch Bel Geddes to Reed for the dream season??
We may laugh about it now but with the advancements in software technology gaining speed who knows where this will lead. It's not so much the unions stopping this kind of thing but descendants of those who have passed.

In all seriousness could we ever imagine Barbara Bel Geddes's as Miss Ellie removing the painting of Jock from the Southfork living room? Barbara Bel would have given the scene her all and as a mark of respect to the late great Jim Davis.
 
Top