until brenda bland appeared
if Bobby had to end up with anyone, Id take Jenna 1st love (and so wrong with Ray!) or Holly who he did have chemistry with and they worked well together in S5/6
I agree with you about Jenna. I'd rather have Bobby with Jenna on Dallas TNT with their son Lucas than Bobby with Ann. As much as I tried to like Bobby and Ann I never could root for them.
Bobby and Phyllis actually sounds okay. Phyllis seemed a lot more normal and down to earth than most of the women in the Bobby Ewing Fan Club. I couldn't see her getting agonizingly weepy or whiny over a break-up or problem with Bobby. Too many women who liked Bobby acted like he was the ONLY guy in the world who was decent, or that it was the end of the world if he didn't want them or broke up with them. That was seriously irritating.I mean even Bobby with Phyllis could have worked after Pam? She was sweet and a nice person and genuine. They wrecked bobby once Pam left. His taste in women rapidly deteriorated :-( and the lack of pining and grieving was terrible :-( Pam certainly grieved after he 'died'

Thinking a little more on this thread. Perhaps having Holly return after Pam's death could have been an interesting idea however I would have taken the story down a different path. Months after Pam's disappearance, Bobby finally succumbs to the realization that Pam will never return. He wanders into the Oil Baron's Club for lunch and bumps into Holly Harwood. They strike up a conversation which lasts well into the night - however they go their separate ways. A few weeks pass and Bobby contacts Holly to get her thoughts on a business deal. They meet for lunch which again goes late into the evening however once again they go to their separate homes.
There is no mistaking Holly's fondness for Bobby but she dares not push anything. Bobby meanwhile begins to enjoy her company and her knowledge about the oil industry - a common interest - so to speak. Over time (this has to be organic) Bobby develops feelings for Holly until he falls in love with her and asks her to marry him. Though she says yes she is reluctant to move to Southfork until she is Mrs. Ewing. They race off to Vegas and marry.
While this romance had been developing no one in the Ewing family is suspicious since Bobby keeps his blossoming relationship with Holly a secret, a secret she also shares. The last thing Holly needs is unwarranted attention from JR.
Bobby phones ahead to Southfork and informs Miss Ellie he wants her to arrange the family to gather. As the family wait patiently JR is doing his usual pre-dinner wisecracks, aimed at Clayton or that half Ewing Ray.
In walks Bobby with Holly. JR just about chokes on his bourbon and branch. Sue Ellen begins walking towards the bar. When Miss Ellie pushes Bobby on why he wanted the family there he introduces Holly to the family as his bride. JR's grasp on his glass is so tight it shatters. Sue Ellen begins pouring.
Later in the evening Holly awakens and wanders down to the living room where she interrupts a slightly drunk JR. He informs Holly he'll destroy the relationship. She retaliates by informing JR there was no mistake about her return to Dallas. It was her intent to get Bobby to fall in love with her just so she could get inside the family.
Holly stands her ground. "I didn't marry Bobby because I love him JR. I married him because I knew how much it would anger you. But I'm no fool, I know how you operate. I'm here for only thing one, to get you out of Ewing Oil!"
![]()
Freeze Frame.Cue end credits.
Bobby with any woman that JR had had "sexual relations" with is simply a "no go"! :bang:
And Holly is no exception!![]()
What is cool about this is that for once, a woman wouldn't want to marry Bobby because of his evil powers over women that make them believe he is the ONLY decent man in the world. That was seriously getting old!Thinking a little more on this thread. Perhaps having Holly return after Pam's death could have been an interesting idea however I would have taken the story down a different path. Months after Pam's disappearance, Bobby finally succumbs to the realization that Pam will never return. He wanders into the Oil Baron's Club for lunch and bumps into Holly Harwood. They strike up a conversation which lasts well into the night - however they go their separate ways. A few weeks pass and Bobby contacts Holly to get her thoughts on a business deal. They meet for lunch which again goes late into the evening however once again they go to their separate homes.
There is no mistaking Holly's fondness for Bobby but she dares not push anything. Bobby meanwhile begins to enjoy her company and her knowledge about the oil industry - a common interest - so to speak. Over time (this has to be organic) Bobby develops feelings for Holly until he falls in love with her and asks her to marry him. Though she says yes she is reluctant to move to Southfork until she is Mrs. Ewing. They race off to Vegas and marry.
While this romance had been developing no one in the Ewing family is suspicious since Bobby keeps his blossoming relationship with Holly a secret, a secret she also shares. The last thing Holly needs is unwarranted attention from JR.
Bobby phones ahead to Southfork and informs Miss Ellie he wants her to arrange the family to gather. As the family wait patiently JR is doing his usual pre-dinner wisecracks, aimed at Clayton or that half Ewing Ray.
In walks Bobby with Holly. JR just about chokes on his bourbon and branch. Sue Ellen begins walking towards the bar. When Miss Ellie pushes Bobby on why he wanted the family there he introduces Holly to the family as his bride. JR's grasp on his glass is so tight it shatters. Sue Ellen begins pouring.
Later in the evening Holly awakens and wanders down to the living room where she interrupts a slightly drunk JR. He informs Holly he'll destroy the relationship. She retaliates by informing JR there was no mistake about her return to Dallas. It was her intent to get Bobby to fall in love with her just so she could get inside the family.
Holly stands her ground. "I didn't marry Bobby because I love him JR. I married him because I knew how much it would anger you. But I'm no fool, I know how you operate. I'm here for only thing one, to get you out of Ewing Oil!"
![]()
Freeze Frame.Cue end credits.
As long as a woman has moved on from doing anything with JR and actually loves Bobby, how is it wrong for Bobby to be with them? Sure, Bobby was a hypocrite for marrying April after pretending to be a saint with that rule, but I don't understand how being with someone your sibling had a sexual relationship with is bad.Bobby with any woman that JR had had "sexual relations" with is simply a "no go"! :bang:
And Holly is no exception!![]()
You often seem to refer to Bobby as a saint, which really puzzles me.As long as a woman has moved on from doing anything with JR and actually loves Bobby, how is it wrong for Bobby to be with them? Sure, Bobby was a hypocrite for marrying April after pretending to be a saint with that rule, but I don't understand how being with someone your sibling had a sexual relationship with is bad.

don't date or marry the ex-partners of their close family members. It's just a "no go" in the civilized world. It's not a "rule" that's said out loud (like Bobby did on Dallas). Instead, it's one of those "silent" cultural things that we just grow up and learn to live by.
It sounds like you've been doing some genealogy studying regarding your own family, which is not quite the same as anthropology. However, I do agree that when we go back approx. 125-150 years ago or more, sister-in-laws or cousins often took the place of a deseased relative. Something that would be looked at oddly today! :eck:I shall counter that argument by suggesting this is a recent phenomenon in society. In my spare time I research my family history and have come across several instances where in-laws have married. There was nothing ever "no go" about it. It had more to do with survival I imagine. One gentleman and his wife had several children only for his wife to die during childbirth. In steps his sister-in-law to take care of the children while the grieved widower continued working the farm. About a year later they married and went on to have children themselves. And this is not the only isolated case I've come across.
I will argue that today's civilized world is the one which puts the "icky" factor on this type of relationship.

And let's not forget Bobby did go on and marry his half-brother's former girlfriend. I'm talking about Ray and Pam. Ok, to be fair Bobby didn't know at the time Ray was his half-brother but once that realization was discovered he should have kicked Pam off Southfork.
Now, can we get back to discussing why Ray and Lucy never sought therapy after they discovered the uncle had been having his wicked way with his niece![]()
Rove....I agree. Hated Bobby with gold digger April....tramp Tammy....big gob Tracey....bland Annie.....Kay was the only one I sort of liked. When VP left, that was it for me.....
:loveit: