Bobby: “I Will Not Let JR Take What’s Rightfully Christopher’s.”

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Rightfully Christopher’s? Lol Bobby actually uttered that line at the beginning of the fight for Ewing Oil. Was he serious? Did he really think his recently adopted child has more rights to his daddy’s company over his biological grandchild (John Ross)?

Normally I’m on Bobby’s side, but I think he was out of place with that one. If he knew his own Daddy and he did, no way would he accept an adopted child running his company over his own blood.
 
Last edited:

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
Just because Jock may have had a fucked up attitude regarding adopted children doesn't mean Bobby had to respect that. As someone with adopted relatives I'll tell you that family is in the heart, not just the blood. Christopher was Bobby's son, period. And therefore, yes, Christopher had absolutely as much right to a piece of Ewing Oil as Bobby, J.R., and John Ross did.
 
Last edited:

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Just because Jock may have had a fucked up attitude regarding adopted children doesn't mean Bobby had to respect that. As someone with adopted relatives I'll tell you that family is in the heart, not just the blood. Christopher was Bobby's son, period. And therefore, yes, Christopher had absolutely as much right to a piece of Ewing Oil as Bobby, J.R., and John Ross did.

Nothing against adopted members of a family lol, but I still don’t think he was in the family long enough for Bobby to make that type of claim, especially knowing his daddy.
 

Jabari Lamar

Telly Talk Fan
but I still don’t think he was in the family long enough for Bobby to make that type of claim, especially knowing his daddy.

Long enough?!? The minute Bobby legally adopted him, he was his son, and entitled to anything a biological child would be the instant they're born. It's only natural that he would want to pass down his part of the Ewing legacy to his son, same as J.R. wanted for John Ross. Therefore his statement made perfect sense.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Besides, Kristin was almost part of the family...
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Long enough?!? The minute Bobby legally adopted him, he was his son, and entitled to anything a biological child would be the instant they're born. It's only natural that he would want to pass down his part of the Ewing legacy to his son, same as J.R. wanted for John Ross. Therefore his statement made perfect sense.

And then there’s this thing called “birthright.” You’re telling me it was just as much Christopher’s birthright as it was JR’s, Bobby’s or John Ross’ to one day own Ewing Oil? If it was that easy for Christopher to get a piece of the pie, Gary, Lucy and Ray should have raised holy hell to get their piece.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
Uh, yeah. Bobby and Pam considered Christopher as theirs and therefore a legitimate heir to the Ewing empire (and whatever the Barneses could muster up I guess). That they'd fight for his right for that isn't odd; it'd be odder if they didn't. In fact, him being adopted might even make them fight harder because they'd want to prove that he's an equal part of the family.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Billy I definitely do see ur point. And adoption was looked at a lot differently back then so I do understand ur opinion. But technically, once Christopher was adopted he officially became a Ewing heir so Bobby was right to say what he said. If he was officially adopted by Bobby and Pam only 5 minutes before the battle for Ewing Oil began he’s still legally entitled to what’s his one day nonetheless
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Miss Ellie, who actually had a hand in raising Ray, once said, “Ray Krebbs is running my daddy’s ranch without an ounce of Southworth blood in him.” In her will, she left Southfork to Bobby and John Ross. Why did she leave Christopher out?

Technically, Bobby might have been right, but common sense wise, I don’t think so. No way would Jock had approved that.
 

J. R.'s Piece

Telly Talk Star
Miss Ellie, who actually had a hand in raising Ray, once said, “Ray Krebbs is running my daddy’s ranch without an ounce of Southworth blood in him.” In her will, she left Southfork to Bobby and John Ross. Why did she leave Christopher out?

Technically, Bobby might have been right, but common sense wise, I don’t think so. No way would Jock had approved that.
Jock said Bobby was the best of the lot, regarding his boys. Yes, he did once make a comment about “a real Ewing” in regard to the possibility of Bobby and Pam adopting. We don’t know exactly how Jock would have reacted. Miss Ellie brought up the subject of adopting to Sue Ellen in Black Market Baby. She didn’t have a problem with it.

It wasn’t leaving Christopher out. It bypassed JR. Christopher would inherit from Bobby.

Gary wasn’t that interested in things like that. Plus, Lucy is his daughter and he has three other children.

As for being adopted, time factor doesn’t matter. Christopher is legally Bobby’s son.
 
Last edited:

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
I think Bobby was right. Christopher was his son, period. He made no distinction about blood.

As far as birthright goes, it's funny that Lucy was never considered to have any right to Ewing Oil. Surely, it was HER birthright. Do you guys think Jock didn't think that because she was a female or because she was Gary's child?

Also, technically, Lucas had a "birthright" too. And Margaret. I know Ewing Oil wasn't around by the time they were old enough to learn the business...but still

BUT - that's why I don't think it was about "birthright" to Bobby. I think it was just about him and JR and their battle. If he was concerned about birthrights, he would have been concerned about Lucy too. There were other Ewing heirs, but Bobby only saw Christopher and John Ross. In Bobby's mind, those two boys were extensions of him and JR.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
I don’t think the problem for Lucy had anything to do with the fact that she was Gary’s daughter. I think it definitely had more to do with the fact that she was a woman and the world was still quite different back then in that respect. She had her voting shares and could do with them whatever she saw fit but being a woman in a male driven family of millionaires in that time frame definitely hindered her. She never would’ve been given a fair chance to run the company, for example. Margaret, when ready to claim her birthright, would’ve been much more accepted than Lucy due to it being many years later and now a much different society in terms of how women were viewed. Margaret may have had a chance to run the company by now or at least be on equal footing with the male heirs. Just my opinion
 

Laurie!

Telly Talk Fan
At that point in the show, Bobby only cared about himself winning and to hell with the consequences. I personally think in that particular scene, he was just trying to use Christopher to sway Pam's opinion. After all, Christopher was nearly two decades away from claiming his birthright.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Christopher is Bobby's son.

Just because he isn't biologically his son doesn't mean he hasn't got any less rights to the Ewing fortune & that includes Ewing Oil.

Christopher has just as much right to own a piece of the company as John Ross has.

And so have I, because I'm Lucas Krebbs & Bobby's my father. :)
 
Top