Dallas: Canon, Fanon and Headcanon

within those things I view as canon there's still a hierarchy of those things that I view as true canon and those that are lower down the chain.

This hierarchy is informed by the series itself, and how truthful it feels at any given time.

The early self-contained episodes of the mini-series and Season One feel less canon to me than the episodes from John Ewing III onwards (some key episodes are exceptions in the first year or so. Not least Digger's Daughter). I suppose it also helps me make sense of the Gary and Kristin recasts (a rare case of the recast being the more authentic in my headcanon. Not that either is necessarily better. They're just the ones my head most strongly associates with them).

Likewise, post End Game, things start to feel less real to me. Not all the time, but there are areas that get somewhat airbrushed out of the big picture for me. Little details like character exits and recasts.

There's the dream season, of course. Impossible to view now without the underlying feeling that it's not canon. But for me, ironically, it's the episodes after Bobby's resurrection that my brain does some revisionist work on. Anything past that point is in the same area to me as most of the self-contained episodes. Which makes it easier to tweak facts in my headcanon. It's not concrete, but at the back of my mind is that Pam died in the tanker crash. And it's from Carousel onwards where everything starts feeling seriously non-canon for me. Anything after Sue Ellen shooting JR is so cherry-picked it’s practically an alternative universe to me.

So the only Dallas that I can truly say is canon for me is April 1979 to May 1984 (or Seasons Three to Six). Outside of that, things can get a little warpy.



You dreamt it. ;)

Ah. Thanks for confirming it. I think I was thinking of Lucy's name being mentioned in a later Knots episode.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
The recast of Pam seemed so bizarre (and unnecessary too, I suppose). Do we know for sure that it was her?
Oddly enough, the same happened to the Pam in Falcon Crest when she tried to kill Richard, "Katherine Wentworth" style.
 
The recast of Pam seemed so bizarre (and unnecessary too, I suppose). Do we know for sure that it was her?

All signs point to the Pam in Carousel being the real thing. But the most telling thing for me as a viewer is that by that point I didn't really care whether or not it was Pam. At least, not as much as I should have.
 

J. R.'s Piece

Telly Talk Star
I think it was written before it was revealed that Jock's mistress during the war was an army nurse named Margaret Hunter.
Ah! The affair which changed Ray Krebbs’ birthdate and made him about two years younger than his previous age in Triangle.

New Beginnings feels a more tangible part of Dallas canon to me than, say Community Spirit because it was a true crossover and because the story came directly out of something that happened on Dallas.*

Knots storylines being referenced on Dallas were pretty rare (Gary's big drunk got the Dallas stamp of approval, which perhaps makes it inarguably canonical).


* It could be argued that all of Knots came directly out of something that happened on Dallas, and so is canon.

Likewise, within those things I view as canon there's still a hierarchy of those things that I view as true canon and those that are lower down the chain. I just wish I was as
JR meeting Karen (from Community Spirit) gets mentioned on Dallas by JR in the same episode. Lucy mentions visiting her parents to Muriel and Alan Beam. And in Five Dollars A Barrel, JR asks Gary if he is still working at that used car lot. And when Gary comes to Bobby’s funeral, Miss Ellie tells Gary that he has been through a lot and she can sense a strength in him that wasn’t there before.

Oh yes. Pretty much everything a character says is only as reliable as their memory. Or motive.

Dallas has come to be less concrete for me, too, in my time on SoapChat. It might well be that I'd find it a bit too neat if I read it cover to cover. As it is, I tend to use the Van Wormer books for little details - especially the pre-history stuff. So that has a bearing on how I fill in certain gaps.

I was trying to think if there were other fantasy sequences during Dallas's run, and the only one that sprung immediately to mind was Kristin's version of Sue Ellen's visit the night JR was shot. I dare say there are other flashbacks told that way.
Didn’t Sue Ellen once have a dream sequence about JR hunting her down?

I like taking all the information. Like on Batman 1966 where The Green Hornet is revealed to be a tv show that Bruce Wayne enjoys and gets interrupted by The Joker. And The Green Hornet is later revealed to be a hero known to Batman and pops up for a window cameo. And The Green Hornet is afterwards also secretly a hero, unknown to Batman but also an old acquaintance of Bruce Wayne.

Oh yes. Pretty much everything a character says is only as reliable as their memory. Or motive.

When JR first starts talking to his painting of Daddy, he sees the words “Jock Ewing” on the office door. Yet, when he walks through, it says “J Ewing” on the door. I like to think that he is imagining at least one of them.
 
Top