Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas Writers Room
Dallas in the 90's
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Miss Texas 1967" data-source="post: 55715" data-attributes="member: 36"><p>I started responding, had to stop to go to work and then I came home and Karin had responded and I think her response is about equal to what I had in mind. </p><p></p><p>I see what you're saying, but I don't think it's the same thing. Christopher essentially grew up thinking his mother had abandoned him (and she kind of had), whereas John Ross always had one or both of his parents around and he knew they both loved him, even if they didn't love each other or couldn't live with each other. Apart from when he was very young and she went to live at the Southern Cross, Sue Ellen took his opinion into consideration every time it came to moving and she always did what was best for him. She allowed him to live at Southfork when she had custody, she asked him to move to England with her and told him she wouldn't leave if he truly couldn't bear her to leave, and the minute he decided Dallas wasn't the right choice for him, she opened her arms and welcomed him back. JR was a bit more manipulative imo, he certainly used John Ross as a bargaining chip, most memorably when he and Sue Ellen were divorced the first time and he wanted him back on Southfork, and then later when he had him hidden away in a boarding school just to spite Sue Ellen. That's all in the show's history. </p><p></p><p>Regarding the fanfic, JR definitely could have made much more of an effort to visit or even just keep in contact with his son, that's a given, but I don't think his crappy communication is anywhere near the level of abandonment. The way he treated John Ross on the show when James was around kind of emphasised JR's emotional immaturity, James was the shiny new thing who was old enough to do everything JR treasured doing the most with his own father, but John Ross while animate and excitable was not quite old enough to be in the business and everything JR was involved in. It's no excuse to shaft one child for another, especially when prior to James' appearance he was a good father, so you'd think he'd have the desire to continue to build on their relationship, but I do kind of understand how it happened. Then afterwards, where we end the show and start the story, JR basically hit emotional rock bottom and had to rebuild his life; he was no "use" to anybody for a while there, he was ill and there was a period of time where he needed to recover. Pam had the same thing, I understand her staying away while recovering if that was what was genuinely the best option, but she didn't just stay away for a few months or years, she was literally gone for seven years. JR tried to kill himself, he disappeared for a while and had to come to terms with a lot of real and perceived loss in his life (real with Jimmy, Ewing Oil, Sue Ellen, Cally & her child etc, but perceived in the sense that he had "nothing" and no reason to live anymore), but he recovered and he returned to life, he also never completely disappeared. I'm sure part of his quietness was embarrassment too, the way he treated John Ross when James was around was probably embarrassing to think about when he realised James just upped and left without really considering him, but John Ross had always wanted to be his mini-me and had really been pushed away.</p><p></p><p>I feel like there is more I could say on this topic but I'm getting myself in a bit of a muddle with show history vs fanfic storylines, so I'll wrap up with a couple of quick comments. I think Pam, and JR and Sue Ellen's actions are different, quite different. Pam just disappeared without a trace from her husband and son's lives one day, she allowed them to think she had died/been kidnapped/whatever, that was deliberate, even if she thought it was what was best at the time. Then she gave birth to Rebecca, recovered, built a "normal" life, and didn't give any real empathetic thought to the people she had left behind, namely Bobby and Christopher, but everyone else too; she compensated for her selfishness when it came to other people's lives by padding her and Rebecca's lives with bits and pieces of the past, all while she could have had the real thing if she had wanted to. Then she pops back up one day without showing too much empathy for what she put everyone through, she was more concerned about how everyone would react to her being back. For me, the million dollar question that can't be answered but would give a good indication of Pam's true state of mind is how long would she have stayed away if Bobby hadn't found her? What was she waiting for? It wasn't physical healing or until Rebecca was mature enough to hear her history, those had already happened, so what was it?</p><p>Over to JR and Sue Ellen, I don't think there was ever any doubt that they loved their son, or that John Ross knew it. He was a pawn in their games and at times there were a lot of things that seemed to take priority over what would have ultimately been best for John Ross (a stable home), but at all times there was always at least one of his parents he knew loved him, and even in the hard times he did eventually receive reassurance. JR didn't visit or call as much as he should have, that wasn't nice, but it's not unforgivable or on the same level of questionably intentioned abandonment in my opinion. Plus, John Ross doesn't take it all very seriously at all now; he either covers his real feelings with jokes, or he knows his parents well and knows bickering is just what they do and it's not worth getting all stressed out over. Regarding Sue Ellen, I think she's always been more purely intentioned, she just had a lot of deep issues that got in her way of being a good mother, however she did seek help and I don't think she's anywhere near the level of Pam (or even JR) now.</p><p></p><p>Hopefully even some of that makes sense :shy:</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Miss Texas 1967, post: 55715, member: 36"] I started responding, had to stop to go to work and then I came home and Karin had responded and I think her response is about equal to what I had in mind. I see what you're saying, but I don't think it's the same thing. Christopher essentially grew up thinking his mother had abandoned him (and she kind of had), whereas John Ross always had one or both of his parents around and he knew they both loved him, even if they didn't love each other or couldn't live with each other. Apart from when he was very young and she went to live at the Southern Cross, Sue Ellen took his opinion into consideration every time it came to moving and she always did what was best for him. She allowed him to live at Southfork when she had custody, she asked him to move to England with her and told him she wouldn't leave if he truly couldn't bear her to leave, and the minute he decided Dallas wasn't the right choice for him, she opened her arms and welcomed him back. JR was a bit more manipulative imo, he certainly used John Ross as a bargaining chip, most memorably when he and Sue Ellen were divorced the first time and he wanted him back on Southfork, and then later when he had him hidden away in a boarding school just to spite Sue Ellen. That's all in the show's history. Regarding the fanfic, JR definitely could have made much more of an effort to visit or even just keep in contact with his son, that's a given, but I don't think his crappy communication is anywhere near the level of abandonment. The way he treated John Ross on the show when James was around kind of emphasised JR's emotional immaturity, James was the shiny new thing who was old enough to do everything JR treasured doing the most with his own father, but John Ross while animate and excitable was not quite old enough to be in the business and everything JR was involved in. It's no excuse to shaft one child for another, especially when prior to James' appearance he was a good father, so you'd think he'd have the desire to continue to build on their relationship, but I do kind of understand how it happened. Then afterwards, where we end the show and start the story, JR basically hit emotional rock bottom and had to rebuild his life; he was no "use" to anybody for a while there, he was ill and there was a period of time where he needed to recover. Pam had the same thing, I understand her staying away while recovering if that was what was genuinely the best option, but she didn't just stay away for a few months or years, she was literally gone for seven years. JR tried to kill himself, he disappeared for a while and had to come to terms with a lot of real and perceived loss in his life (real with Jimmy, Ewing Oil, Sue Ellen, Cally & her child etc, but perceived in the sense that he had "nothing" and no reason to live anymore), but he recovered and he returned to life, he also never completely disappeared. I'm sure part of his quietness was embarrassment too, the way he treated John Ross when James was around was probably embarrassing to think about when he realised James just upped and left without really considering him, but John Ross had always wanted to be his mini-me and had really been pushed away. I feel like there is more I could say on this topic but I'm getting myself in a bit of a muddle with show history vs fanfic storylines, so I'll wrap up with a couple of quick comments. I think Pam, and JR and Sue Ellen's actions are different, quite different. Pam just disappeared without a trace from her husband and son's lives one day, she allowed them to think she had died/been kidnapped/whatever, that was deliberate, even if she thought it was what was best at the time. Then she gave birth to Rebecca, recovered, built a "normal" life, and didn't give any real empathetic thought to the people she had left behind, namely Bobby and Christopher, but everyone else too; she compensated for her selfishness when it came to other people's lives by padding her and Rebecca's lives with bits and pieces of the past, all while she could have had the real thing if she had wanted to. Then she pops back up one day without showing too much empathy for what she put everyone through, she was more concerned about how everyone would react to her being back. For me, the million dollar question that can't be answered but would give a good indication of Pam's true state of mind is how long would she have stayed away if Bobby hadn't found her? What was she waiting for? It wasn't physical healing or until Rebecca was mature enough to hear her history, those had already happened, so what was it? Over to JR and Sue Ellen, I don't think there was ever any doubt that they loved their son, or that John Ross knew it. He was a pawn in their games and at times there were a lot of things that seemed to take priority over what would have ultimately been best for John Ross (a stable home), but at all times there was always at least one of his parents he knew loved him, and even in the hard times he did eventually receive reassurance. JR didn't visit or call as much as he should have, that wasn't nice, but it's not unforgivable or on the same level of questionably intentioned abandonment in my opinion. Plus, John Ross doesn't take it all very seriously at all now; he either covers his real feelings with jokes, or he knows his parents well and knows bickering is just what they do and it's not worth getting all stressed out over. Regarding Sue Ellen, I think she's always been more purely intentioned, she just had a lot of deep issues that got in her way of being a good mother, however she did seek help and I don't think she's anywhere near the level of Pam (or even JR) now. Hopefully even some of that makes sense :shy: [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Who played Sue Ellen in Dallas?
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas Writers Room
Dallas in the 90's
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top