Dallas - Understanding The Phenomenon - The Third And Final Chapter

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Even in a show made up of a large ensemble there is bound to be a main star who breaks through out of that ensemble. J.R. Ewing was the one who did that in Dallas. J.R. Ewing wasn’t just the most featured, most talked about character in Dallas – he was an icon! I don’t believe you can plan to create an iconic character any more than you plan to create a TV series that will be a phenomenon.


You do your best to make the biggest star of your show an interesting, compelling character who is very entertaining but tons of people have tried to do that on the TV shows they make or used to make, and very, very few managed to create a character who truly became iconic. Having a very talented and charismatic actor portraying that role is crucial but by itself is no guarantee that an icon will be created. In Larry Hagman, Dallas had a very talented and charismatic actor and that made it possible for JR Ewing to become iconic but those things are incomplete by themselves.


I’ve talked about how the success of Dallas, to some degree came about accidentally in the sense that the show wasn’t originally planned to feature JR nearly as much as it ended up doing. I’ve talked about how the phenomenon grew organically. They listened to the fans and gave JR Ewing more TV time than he was originally planned to have. When you’re on the brink of having a phenomenon, you don’t hold back; you go with it!


They were very wise to give JR rivals and enemies who made him look good. He made them look good as well. That’s critical. It means when JR beat them, he looked great and when he occasionally lost to them, he at least lost to someone who was a formidable adversary.


What else was there to the tremendous appeal of the JR Ewing character? After all, he was very flawed. Never before in TV history had a character who had so many traits traditionally associated with those of a villain become so beloved by the fans. Well, that in itself is part of the answer. Society had changed from the 50s and 60s. Society was tired of and quite frankly, bored by the goody-goody traditional fan favorite type character.


By the late 70s, the audience was ready to root for an anti-hero like JR Ewing. He bent the rules when he wanted to. JR broke the rules when he wanted to. He made up some rules of his own that others had never even heard of before. There’s something very exciting, even seductive about being bad. We saw it in our rock and roll stars all the time. Like JR, they didn’t live by the normal conventions of society. They lived the way they wanted to live and so did JR Ewing. That was a huge contributor to his popularity, his notoriety, and ultimately in playing a huge part in creating the Dallas phenomenon.


You want your break-through star to be entertaining and JR was. You also want him to be able to make people feel strongly about him and what he did and JR accomplished that. He made people love him, he made people hate him, but with JR Ewing there was no in between. People were not indifferent to JR Ewing. That’s critical. You want to make people feel strong emotions. In fact, people becoming so passionate about JR Ewing and about Dallas in general is what led to it becoming the phenomenon it became.



What were some other things that made JR Ewing so compelling to the fans and led them to become so passionate about Dallas? One compelling attribute JR had is that whatever JR wanted badly, he went after 100 percent and usually got it. That’s an attribute that’s extremely appealing and it’s something that’s very inspiring. Having the tenacity and the skill to be able to go after something you want badly and get it! It’s something people could strive for in their own lives. In that respect, people wanted to be like JR Ewing!



People liked to live vicariously through JR. They didn’t necessarily want to be just like him but the things he had which they envied and wanted to live vicariously through were the money, the power, and the sex. Also, JR was a risk taker. That’s an exciting quality. People like that. It was also a necessary part of the character for the purposes of having exciting storylines. Being a risk taker meant sometimes his gambles didn’t pay off and he lost. He was still fallible. He didn’t win all the time. That would have made it predictable. He won most of the time – enough that he was clearly a winner. He lost just often enough that it kept things unpredictable and also realistic in the sense that nobody wins every single time.



JR Ewing was a man that men admired and who women desired. He was an extremely successful man. Above all, JR Ewing was a winner. People love winners. Winners are inspiring. People need inspiration in their lives – inspiration from someone who they might or might not dare to actually emulate, someone they may not even have the ability to emulate if they wanted to, but someone who they can live through vicariously.


We saw what happened to Dallas when for some reason they had JR stop being a winner. Dallas was never a top rated TV series again. That hurt Dallas more than any other single change that happened to the show.


The only other thing that hurt Dallas on a somewhat comparable level was that Dallas lost its believability in its later years. Believability is very important. The early days of Dallas were fairly well grounded in realism. In its later years the storylines became less realistic. They became more and more outlandish. That was unnecessary and it hurt the series badly. People stopped watching when Dallas lost the needed amount of believability to keep them watching. Can you imagine JR telling Jock that he decided to pay a mercenary to blow up oil wells in Saudi Arabia? Jock’s reaction would have been priceless; I’ll say that. The great years of Dallas told great stories without resorting to the absurd. Haleyville, the insane asylum, and the Angelica Nero storyline are just some examples of storylines that I can’t imagine even being considered in the days when Jock Ewing was still the man of the house at Southfork.


Credibility is crucial as well and Dallas managed to not just damage theirs, but actually kill their credibility. The infamous return of Patrick Duffy as Bobby by reason of declaring the entire previous season (and the ending of season 8) "just a dream" that Pam had, destroyed the credibility Dallas had built. When a show does something like that, the audience will never again give anything at all that happens in the show again the degree of credibility, and therefore importance, they previously would have. It diminishes the value of anything and everything else your show ever does when you kill your credibility.


In comparing the storylines of the glory days of Dallas to the storylines of the waning days of the series, you’ll see they eventually completely lost touch with realism. Dallas was never the most realistic series to begin with but when it was hot, it had enough realism to keep people hooked, watching it religiously week after week. Dallas in its peak years was realistic enough that the viewers could still get emotionally invested in it. In a serialized show like Dallas, an emotional investment on the part of the viewers is crucial to keep them coming back week after week, year after year and they did. Dallas didn’t stay on top forever but while it did it was one hell of a ride!
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Very interesting theories about Dallas, and specifically J.R. Ewing.
Kenny Coyote did a great job of explaining the phenomenon that was Dallas from a character driven point of view. As a person who was there for the original run, may I add to his post what was going on during the time Dallas was sweeping the world?
Even in a show made up of a large ensemble. . .
So let's start with the first few episodes, before the character of J.R. Ewing broke out. The world was in economic turmoil at the time. We were hearing terms we'd never heard before-- layoffs, downsizing, corporate bankruptcy. We even had a term called the misery index. Imagine waking up to the news each morning to check the misery index. God, we needed a distraction!

And along come the Ewings. This larger than life family with more wealth than they could ever spend. But there is something different about this family. Until now, most rich people were shown as living in mansions, surrounded by valets and chauffeurs, with gold plated everything. Not this family. They were ultra-wealthy but there was an interesting grittiness to them. They didn't live in a high rise penthouse-- they lived on a cattle ranch! This could get interesting.
I’ve talked about how the success of Dallas, to some degree came about accidentally in the sense that the show wasn’t originally planned to feature JR nearly as much as it ended up doing. I’ve talked about how the phenomenon grew organically
Things were changing fast in the 1970's and the traditional roles of men and women were blurred. Many people were in that confusing area between strong women in the workplace (think of Sly, who was much more than a secretary) and the "old school" thinking that still existed. (Think of Jock-- "A woman's place is in the bedroom, not the boardroom!").

Remember that in the early days, J.R. was a sympathetic character. Here he was, going into the office every day and grinding work out, while Bobby traveled the world, charming beautiful women and wining and dining clients. And yet, for all of J.R.'s hard work, Bobby was treated as the prodigal son.

And then, when we saw the dirty tricks that J.R. pulled, we actually started enjoying the scandals and rooting for him-- actively cheering him on as he rolled over his adversaries. Why? Because as of the following quote:

By the late 70s, the audience was ready to root for an anti-hero like JR Ewing. He bent the rules when he wanted to. JR broke the rules when he wanted to. He made up some rules of his own that others had never even heard of before. There’s something very exciting, even seductive about being bad.
Once again, let's place this in the backdrop of world events. Americans were being held hostage during the Iranian Hostage Crisis. World leaders, including the president of the United States, were powerless to free them. Every night, updates on the hostage crisis included all of the reasons why leaders of the free would were impotent on this matter.

So, along comes J.R. Ewing. Ole J.R. doesn't hold diplomatic pre-meetings to discuss the size and shape of the table for the upcoming diplomatic meeting. Oh, no! Good ole J.R. would get those hostages out, and it didn't matter what he would have to do in order to get it done. Lie, cheat and steal? Fine, just solve the problem. Bribe whoever needed bribing? Fine, just get it done! Blackmail those who could not be bribed? Whatever it takes, J.R.! We're rooting for you!

There’s something very exciting, even seductive about being bad.

I'll take that one step further and say that we NEEDED someone to be bad.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Very interesting theories about Dallas, and specifically J.R. Ewing.
Kenny Coyote did a great job of explaining the phenomenon that was Dallas from a character driven point of view. As a person who was there for the original run, may I add to his post what was going on during the time Dallas was sweeping the world?

So let's start with the first few episodes, before the character of J.R. Ewing broke out. The world was in economic turmoil at the time. We were hearing terms we'd never heard before-- layoffs, downsizing, corporate bankruptcy. We even had a term called the misery index. Imagine waking up to the news each morning to check the misery index. God, we needed a distraction!

And along come the Ewings. This larger than life family with more wealth than they could ever spend. But there is something different about this family. Until now, most rich people were shown as living in mansions, surrounded by valets and chauffeurs, with gold plated everything. Not this family. They were ultra-wealthy but there was an interesting grittiness to them. They didn't live in a high rise penthouse-- they lived on a cattle ranch! This could get interesting.

Things were changing fast in the 1970's and the traditional roles of men and women were blurred. Many people were in that confusing area between strong women in the workplace (think of Sly, who was much more than a secretary) and the "old school" thinking that still existed. (Think of Jock-- "A woman's place is in the bedroom, not the boardroom!").

Remember that in the early days, J.R. was a sympathetic character. Here he was, going into the office every day and grinding work out, while Bobby traveled the world, charming beautiful women and wining and dining clients. And yet, for all of J.R.'s hard work, Bobby was treated as the prodigal son.

And then, when we saw the dirty tricks that J.R. pulled, we actually started enjoying the scandals and rooting for him-- actively cheering him on as he rolled over his adversaries. Why? Because as of the following quote:


Once again, let's place this in the backdrop of world events. Americans were being held hostage during the Iranian Hostage Crisis. World leaders, including the president of the United States, were powerless to free them. Every night, updates on the hostage crisis included all of the reasons why leaders of the free would were impotent on this matter.

So, along comes J.R. Ewing. Ole J.R. doesn't hold diplomatic pre-meetings to discuss the size and shape of the table for the upcoming diplomatic meeting. Oh, no! Good ole J.R. would get those hostages out, and it didn't matter what he would have to do in order to get it done. Lie, cheat and steal? Fine, just solve the problem. Bribe whoever needed bribing? Fine, just get it done! Blackmail those who could not be bribed? Whatever it takes, J.R.! We're rooting for you!

There’s something very exciting, even seductive about being bad.

I'll take that one step further and say that we NEEDED someone to be bad.

Thanks, LastKid! I like the way you explained how our national and international economic and political climate of the late 70s contributed in a very significant way to Dallas becoming a phenomenon. You're very good at verbally painting a picture that describes exactly how a situation was at a certain time in a certain place. I did focus primarily in the character driven aspects of the Dallas phenomenon, primarily for two reasons. One reason is of the various contributing factors I believe it was the most significant. Second, taking a look at every single contributing factor would be better suited for a book than an internet forum! I didn't even cover every aspect of JR Ewing that made him such a successful and iconic character.

Maybe the most significant aspect I didn't write about that is how cheerful he was. He wasn't the typical grumbling, constantly angry and bitter type of guy which is so often associated with someone so ruthless. He was far from being that stereotype. He was truly unique. He had a tremendous enthusiasm for life and enjoying life to the utmost. I wonder how much of that cheerfulness was planned out for him - something that he was directed to do - as opposed to something he may have contributed on his own. I wouldn't be at all surprised to find out that it was Larry Hagman's idea to portray JR in that way. After all, we know he ad-libbed a lot of his lines to make them sound the way he believed JR ewing should sound. If I remember correctly Hagman stated he ad-libbed roughly fifty percent of the lines of his which made it to the final cut. So maybe he "ad-libbed" when it came to JR's personality being so upbeat as well.

I agree with the various points you made, such as the Americans taken hostage in Iran and the angry sentiment it caused which was directed primarily at the Iranians but also a substantial portion of that angry sentiment was aimed at our national leaders and their incompetence in dealing with the situation swiftly and effectively. Hence, your conclusion that "...we NEEDED someone to be bad."

I thought it was very interesting that the Iranians released the hostages on the very same day that Ronald Reagan took office. Remember that? I always wondered how much of that decision was based on their fear of what Reagan would do to them and how much of their decision was based on depriving Jimmy Carter of being able to make the announcement while still President, that the hostages had been freed. What's your opinion on that? I'd say it was roughly 50/50. They were scared of Reagan but they also wanted to screw Carter out of being able to make that announcement while still President

I'd forgotten "the misery index." I guess I was too young in the 70s to be able to remember as much of it as you did and in that detail. Or maybe we're the same age and you just have a better memory than I do! I'm sure you remember hearing about the massive layoffs that affected the U.S. steelworkers in the late 70s. In general there seemed to be a malaise in our country in the late 70s and Dallas was a great escape from feeling that malaise, if only for an hour a week. Very shortly after Reagan took office, that malaise not only ended but there was a surge of optimism that swept the nation and from then on, things were great during the 80s. As far as I'm concerned our quality of life in The United States peaked in the 1980s. It truly was an awesome decade. I love pretty much everything abut the 1980s - especially the music! Do you have a favorite decade?
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I thought it was very interesting that the Iranians released the hostages on the very same day that Ronald Reagan took office. Remember that?
And to compare this to Dallas-- President Carter was working through legal, diplomatic channels to negotiate freeing the hostages, much the way we could imagine Bobby Ewing negotiating a deal. But when Ronald Reagan was running for president, the American people made his instructions very clear-- "Get them out of there whatever it takes! Bomb them back to the stone age if you have to." This is exactly the position that J.R. would take.

To put a finer point on it-- If you were negotiating with Bobby and then J.R. was taking over, wouldn't you free those hostages before J.R had control?

I'd forgotten "the misery index. Dallas was a great escape from feeling that malaise, if only for an hour a week. "
Absolutely! Watching the wealthy Ewings was the perfect escape.
And there was enough alcohol at the Dallas parties to really make you forget things. "Get you a bourbon and branch?" As you hear the ice cubes clinking in the glass.
Maybe the most significant aspect I didn't write about that is how cheerful J.R. was.

Yes! The best part is, just when you expect J.R. to explode with Rage, he zigs when you expect him to zag. Remember the famous scene when Donna pushes him in the pool? He's treading water, with his Stetson hat and his briefcase floating beside him.

We expect him to be angry, but instead he cheerfully calls out, "Well, don't go away mad, Darlin!"
PEFECT!

And over on Knotts Landing, Gary actually stands up to J.R. for the first time. In fact, Gary kicks J.R. out of his hotel suite. A hotel suite that J.R. was paying for!

So, do we see J.R. explode with rage at this? No. The magnificent bastard puts on his hat, takes his leave, and chuckles.
"I wish my Daddy was still around to see this. Gary with guts. Finally."
 
Last edited:
Top