Dallas Was A Great Show, But Boy Could They Be Unrealistic.

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I know it’s TV, but under what jurisdiction could Katherine Wentworth attempt to kill Bobby TWICE and admit to it in front of a bunch of people (security guards, JR, her lawyer, Cliff) and be out the very next day?
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
That kind of thing, for me, really wasn't much of a problem. It was the stuff in the last few years, things like the Haleyville storyline, JR being committed to the sanatarium. Those kind of things were so far removed from Dallas at its peak, in my view that was more of a problem in being unrealistic.

Swami
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
That kind of thing, for me, really wasn't much of a problem. It was the stuff in the last few years, things like the Haleyville storyline, JR being committed to the sanatarium. Those kind of things were so far removed from Dallas at its peak, in my view that was more of a problem in being unrealistic.

Swami

I agree that those were bigger problems and they were definitely a couple of “jump the shark” moments, but they could have done the Katherine Wentworth storyline better.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
That kind of thing, for me, really wasn't much of a problem. It was the stuff in the last few years, things like the Haleyville storyline, JR being committed to the sanatarium. Those kind of things were so far removed from Dallas at its peak, in my view that was more of a problem in being unrealistic.

Swami

Yes, and if you take a look at when they started getting to these absurd, completely unrealistic storylines, it coincided with their ratings falling farther than ever before. They'd had some drops in the ratings int past but were still a relatively highly rated show. Top ten or top 15 until these absurd storylines began. trying to blow up oil fields in Saudi Arabia to get the price of oil higher, Haleyville. the sanitarium, these were things that would never have been even considered back in the time when the record breaking "Who Shot JR" storyline took place, or even in seasons 7 and 8. Season 10 with its resurrection of Bobby Ewing was the beginning of the attitude "We can do anything we want and the people will accept it." Except they didn't accept just anything they did! The more often they ran completely unrealistic storylines, the more sick the audience became of having its intelligence insulted and the more of them quit watching Dallas.

Compared to these types of things, something like Lucy becoming a model was relatively minor, especially when she was doing mainly head shots which we could see based on the photographs Roger took of her and placed in the "shrine." Most or maybe all of those pictures in the "shrine" were only of her face. For that specific type of modeling - head shots - height is irrelevant.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
She tried to kill Bobby in the hospital
And yet she screamed "let me go!" Seems like a solid case of harassment to me.

As for the confession, any crazy person can confess to this or that crime, surely that alone doesn't get that person convicted?
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Season 10 with its resurrection of Bobby Ewing was the beginning of the attitude "We can do anything we want and the people will accept it."

To complicate matters a bit: it's not that they really thought people would accept anything--it's that they thought people would be willing to accept anything as long as it brought Patrick Duffy back. So, why was the cult of personality around a beloved actor (two, if you also count Larry Hagman who lobbied hard for Duffy's return) deemed more important than the show's trust bond with the viewers?
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I know it’s TV, but under what jurisdiction could Katherine Wentworth attempt to kill Bobby TWICE and admit to it in front of a bunch of people (security guards, JR, her lawyer, Cliff) and be out the very next day?

How is it unrealistic? It was bail, and Katherine was a very rich woman, and as it turned out rich enough to skip her own bail too. I think we all know that the rich can get themselves special favours from the courts, whereas people without much money are doomed. Had Katherine been working class or even middle class, she would have been remanded for trying to kill somebody like Bobby Ewing. This is more real than you think. We often see Bobby throwing his weight, and wallet, around, when he wants to get something done.

Look at Sue Ellen after J.R. was shot, when she couldn't raise bail money. With money, out she comes. Without money, rot in jail.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
And yet she screamed "let me go!" Seems like a solid case of harassment to me.

As for the confession, any crazy person can confess to this or that crime, surely that alone doesn't get that person convicted?

Are you serious? She was caught red handed at the hospital and then told anyone who would listen how she tried to kill him in JR’s office.

Not only does releasing her puts Bobby’s life in eminent danger, but she’s a danger to society.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
How is it unrealistic? It was bail, and Katherine was a very rich woman, and as it turned out rich enough to skip her own bail too. I think we all know that the rich can get themselves special favours from the courts, whereas people without much money are doomed. Had Katherine been working class or even middle class, she would have been remanded for trying to kill somebody like Bobby Ewing. This is more real than you think. We often see Bobby throwing his weight, and wallet, around, when he wants to get something done.

Look at Sue Ellen after J.R. was shot, when she couldn't raise bail money. With money, out she comes. Without money, rot in jail.

Katherine was actually caught and then confessed. Big difference. And I’ll use your own point against you. Bobby Ewing and the Ewing family are pillars of the Dallas community and are wealthy. Heck, we’ve seen JR buy off just about everyone in Dallas. You really think they would have given her a bail?
 
Last edited:

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Katherine was actually caught and then confessed. Big difference.

Confessed to a few individuals before a lawyer had seen her and got her bail with the necessary funds, no doubt preparing a case for the defence. Although Katherine obviously had other ideas, i.e. skipping bail.

And I’ll use your own point against you. Bobby Ewing and the Ewing family are pillars of the Dallas community. You really think they would have given her a bail?

Barnes-Wentworth is a strong rival to Ewing by that time, and a lot of money. Enough of a financial security from the defendant, and a judge who is open-minded about bail, will mean bail. Katherine's criminal history was also very much in her favour. And it was attempted murder rather than actual murder that was the charge, which is something else in Katherine's favour.

Later that season, Jenna Wade in Laredo had big trouble getting bail after Renaldo was killed, because of a hostile judge, but if it isn't actually murder that's the charge, and the defendant has a lot of money then the chances are that they will get bail.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
and then told anyone who would listen how she tried to kill him in JR’s office
Well, some psycho killers have a big ego and want to take credit for everything bad that happened.
As for the murder weapon, the poisoned needle, she may or may not have intended to use it. But she didn't eventhough she said she did.
And Bobby's testimony, he was kinda blind-ish at that moment so...it's all very confusing.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Well, some psycho killers have a big ego and want to take credit for everything bad that happened.
As for the murder weapon, the poisoned needle, she may or may not have intended to use it. But she didn't eventhough she said she did.
And Bobby's testimony, he was kinda blind-ish at that moment so...it's all very confusing.

Confusing to who? JR, the nurses and the guards all rushed in while she was holding the needle. They had to wrestle the needle away from her.

And I hope you guys aren’t confusing making bail to actually having a bail set. I can’t see any judge giving her bail.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
And it was attempted murder rather than actual murder that was the charge, which is something else in Katherine's favour.

While that's true, I think that part of our legal system should be changed. Why is a person who attempts to kill someone but then because of blind luck, the victim survives, a better person than someone else who tries to kill someone and that victim not getting lucky, dies? To me both criminals are equally bad and deserve the same punishment. The victim being lucky enough to survive the murder attempt does not make the would be killer any better of a person than if the victim had died, does he?
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Katherine's criminal history was also very much in her favour. And it was attempted murder rather than actual murder that was the charge, which is something else in Katherine's favour.

Again, she tried to kill him not once (which is bad enough), but twice. The second time she was caught red handed. Is she a danger to society? Any judge would have to take that into consideration before giving her bail. There’s no way you can say that she isn’t a danger to society, regardless of her “clean record.”
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
To complicate matters a bit: it's not that they really thought people would accept anything--it's that they thought people would be willing to accept anything as long as it brought Patrick Duffy back. So, why was the cult of personality around a beloved actor (two, if you also count Larry Hagman who lobbied hard for Duffy's return) deemed more important than the show's trust bond with the viewers?
There's always a certain amount of 'suspension of disbelief' involved. It's just a matter of how far you can stretch it before it breaks. Patrick's return was eagerly awaited initially. It was only as the implications of the dream became apparent that the backlash set in.
 
Top