Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Dallas: What It Had And What It Lost
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Jimmy Todd" data-source="post: 181633" data-attributes="member: 3926"><p>Ok, [USER=102]@Kenny Coyote[/USER], these are some interesting points.</p><p> The hero having to be present to fight the villian makes sense. If the hero doesn't do anything, what good is he or she? I think it also depends on the goal or "quest" of the hero. Getting to see Lucy was her quest and she succeeded in that. It took her several years, but in addition to being poor and alone, it's important to remember how young Valene was when she had Lucy. I believe 15 or 16. She was a poor kid on her own up against the</p><p>Ewijg money and influence. Not easy.</p><p> If Valene's quest was to get Lucy away from the Ewings, well she failed at that, but it's debatable if that was her quest. JR called her out in this when he visited Knots Landing. He told her she can't blame him for her relationship with Lucy because she could visit Lucy any time she wanted and vice versa.</p><p> I still believe a hero is one who holds onto their core values when it would be easy to give in to the wickedness and cynicism of the world, which Valene always did.</p><p> This brings me to your point about being cutthroat in the oil business. I agree with that, but how cutthroat one has to become is debatable. It can be a rough game and one can play rough, but do they have to lose their core values? Maybe, but there are two philosophers whose ideas relate to this, imho: Hannah Atendt and Jean-Paul Sartre.</p><p> I'm sure your familiar with the phrase Arendt coined, :the banality of evil." Evil becomes an everyday thing, so it's accepted and not thought about too much. However, is it any less evil just because it has become a mundane part of life? Are we all subject to the "banality of evil"? For example, if I became an oil baron would I engage in corrupt practices such as blackmail and exploiting workers to the point where it became just part of the job and I never gave it much thought? I'd like to think I wouldn't, but if I was born into the same circumstances as Bobby and JR, I very well might.</p><p> Sartre brought up the idea of "bad faith." My understanding of it is people justify unethical or immoral behavior by saying, "it was the times," or "it was the culture" so no one really thought it was evil. Is this true or are people of that time period or culture just kidding themselves and deep down they know what they're doing is wrong?</p><p> My point is that if someone in such a situation takes an honest look at themselves and decides, despite the pressure to maintain their code of ethics, they are a hero. I could be completely naive in thinking that's possible in the oil business or politics, but I would like to believe somebody could do it.</p><p> Here's a thought: Aristotle said a classic tragic character must, among other things, be basically good but have gone wrong and have sone admirable qualities, even when they go down the dark path. They also have a fatal flaw. JR did many evil things, but he had admirable qualities: tenacity, the ability to take command of a situation, quick wit. Maybe he and several other characters aren't just villains, but have some elements of the tragic. I'm not saying they are all 100% classic tragic characters, but some aspects. JR was pretty much told by both parents that he was not their favorite. That has to be scarring for a little kid to hear. Returning to Atendt, would anyone be just as bad as JR if their parents sent them the same message?</p><p> Just throwing this out there because of the definitions you and I have for what constitutes a "villian," a "bad guy," and a"hero."</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Jimmy Todd, post: 181633, member: 3926"] Ok, [USER=102]@Kenny Coyote[/USER], these are some interesting points. The hero having to be present to fight the villian makes sense. If the hero doesn't do anything, what good is he or she? I think it also depends on the goal or "quest" of the hero. Getting to see Lucy was her quest and she succeeded in that. It took her several years, but in addition to being poor and alone, it's important to remember how young Valene was when she had Lucy. I believe 15 or 16. She was a poor kid on her own up against the Ewijg money and influence. Not easy. If Valene's quest was to get Lucy away from the Ewings, well she failed at that, but it's debatable if that was her quest. JR called her out in this when he visited Knots Landing. He told her she can't blame him for her relationship with Lucy because she could visit Lucy any time she wanted and vice versa. I still believe a hero is one who holds onto their core values when it would be easy to give in to the wickedness and cynicism of the world, which Valene always did. This brings me to your point about being cutthroat in the oil business. I agree with that, but how cutthroat one has to become is debatable. It can be a rough game and one can play rough, but do they have to lose their core values? Maybe, but there are two philosophers whose ideas relate to this, imho: Hannah Atendt and Jean-Paul Sartre. I'm sure your familiar with the phrase Arendt coined, :the banality of evil." Evil becomes an everyday thing, so it's accepted and not thought about too much. However, is it any less evil just because it has become a mundane part of life? Are we all subject to the "banality of evil"? For example, if I became an oil baron would I engage in corrupt practices such as blackmail and exploiting workers to the point where it became just part of the job and I never gave it much thought? I'd like to think I wouldn't, but if I was born into the same circumstances as Bobby and JR, I very well might. Sartre brought up the idea of "bad faith." My understanding of it is people justify unethical or immoral behavior by saying, "it was the times," or "it was the culture" so no one really thought it was evil. Is this true or are people of that time period or culture just kidding themselves and deep down they know what they're doing is wrong? My point is that if someone in such a situation takes an honest look at themselves and decides, despite the pressure to maintain their code of ethics, they are a hero. I could be completely naive in thinking that's possible in the oil business or politics, but I would like to believe somebody could do it. Here's a thought: Aristotle said a classic tragic character must, among other things, be basically good but have gone wrong and have sone admirable qualities, even when they go down the dark path. They also have a fatal flaw. JR did many evil things, but he had admirable qualities: tenacity, the ability to take command of a situation, quick wit. Maybe he and several other characters aren't just villains, but have some elements of the tragic. I'm not saying they are all 100% classic tragic characters, but some aspects. JR was pretty much told by both parents that he was not their favorite. That has to be scarring for a little kid to hear. Returning to Atendt, would anyone be just as bad as JR if their parents sent them the same message? Just throwing this out there because of the definitions you and I have for what constitutes a "villian," a "bad guy," and a"hero." [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Who played Sue Ellen in Dallas?
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Dallas: What It Had And What It Lost
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top