Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
How should oldDALLAS have ended?
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Kenny Coyote" data-source="post: 162854" data-attributes="member: 102"><p>Giving the audience what they want is more logical than giving the audience something they don't want. Whether an ending is happy or sad doesn't necessarily have any bearing on how logical it is. You can have sad endings that make sense and sad ending that don't make sense. You can have happy endings that are logical and happy endings that aren't. Happiness and sadness are just emotions. There isn't anything inherently more logical about one as compared to the other. It's how you go about creating that emotion that makes it rational or irrational.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>I agree with that since JR and Sue Ellen together had been done to death. We know it doesn't work. I wish they hadn't kept JR and Sue Ellen together as long as they did. WE got so much of the same thing over and over again with that pairing. There would be happiness for a while and then it would fall apart. It always eventually fell apart. They were a nice couple when they were getting along but when they weren't it was painful to watch. Some of that is fine. It's a drama, after all. There are going to be painful times..,but being relentless with showing how dysfunctional of a couple they are is unnecessary as far as I'm concerned. I get the point - they don't stay happy together for very long because something always goes wrong. Once things go seriously wrong, a little bit of that goes a long away. Seeing episode after episode of the two of them treating each other terribly isn't my idea of fun. it gets very abrasive after awhile to see two people being so sarcastic to each other. I think Miss Ellie put it best in one episode where the women were complaining about their husbands not being there and Miss Ellie said words to the effect of: If the men aren't here, whose fault is it? Clayton and I are very happy together. If we weren't, I'd make changes. Don't spoil my day with your constant complaining!</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>I agree! Revealing Wes Parmalee actually was Jock would be wrong from several standpoints. I'd find it insulting to Jim Davis and his legacy to recast Jock. Telling the audience that a man who looks nothing like Jock, whose build is completely different from Jock's build, whose voice as well as his style of speaking is nothing like Jock's, is insulting to the intelligence of the audience. </p><p></p><p>Finally if Parmalee had been Jock, why would Miss Ellie deliberately endanger his life by saying Parmalee was an imposter? She was there when Clayton said if he turned out to be a fraud, he'd hunt him down and he'd kill him. Clayton was not joking when he said that. He was as serious as could be. Then as soon as Miss Ellie told Clayton the news, that Parmalee confessed he was an imposter, Clayton got a gun and went looking for him. Miss Ellie tried to stop Clayton but how could she? She's a small woman and Clayton is a great big guy. She couldn't physically stop him from going after Parmalee to shoot him. </p><p></p><p>At that point, does anyone think she wouldn't have told Clayton the truth - that Parmalee really was Jock but that he'd changed so much she no longer felt the same about him anymore - that the man she is in love with now is Clayton and not Jock? </p><p></p><p>Suppose that somehow Parmalee had been Jock but he'd left because Ellie was no longer in love with him, she was in love with and married to Clayton and that Jock staying around would have been hurtful to everyone involved. Well, if that's why he left and why she agreed that for him to leave was best for everyone, she'd have to tell Clayton the truth. She couldn't lie to Clayton, making Clayton believe Parmalee was a con man who had tried to destroy their family by claiming to be Jock. There would be far too much chance of a a disaster happening if Clayton did manage to track him down. Even though Ellie would say that Jock had changed so much that he was no longer the man she'd been in love with and that she no longer felt capable of feeling the way about him she used to, she'd still have all that history with him and naturally she'd care what happened to Jock even of she didn't love him the way she used to.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Kenny Coyote, post: 162854, member: 102"] Giving the audience what they want is more logical than giving the audience something they don't want. Whether an ending is happy or sad doesn't necessarily have any bearing on how logical it is. You can have sad endings that make sense and sad ending that don't make sense. You can have happy endings that are logical and happy endings that aren't. Happiness and sadness are just emotions. There isn't anything inherently more logical about one as compared to the other. It's how you go about creating that emotion that makes it rational or irrational. I agree with that since JR and Sue Ellen together had been done to death. We know it doesn't work. I wish they hadn't kept JR and Sue Ellen together as long as they did. WE got so much of the same thing over and over again with that pairing. There would be happiness for a while and then it would fall apart. It always eventually fell apart. They were a nice couple when they were getting along but when they weren't it was painful to watch. Some of that is fine. It's a drama, after all. There are going to be painful times..,but being relentless with showing how dysfunctional of a couple they are is unnecessary as far as I'm concerned. I get the point - they don't stay happy together for very long because something always goes wrong. Once things go seriously wrong, a little bit of that goes a long away. Seeing episode after episode of the two of them treating each other terribly isn't my idea of fun. it gets very abrasive after awhile to see two people being so sarcastic to each other. I think Miss Ellie put it best in one episode where the women were complaining about their husbands not being there and Miss Ellie said words to the effect of: If the men aren't here, whose fault is it? Clayton and I are very happy together. If we weren't, I'd make changes. Don't spoil my day with your constant complaining! I agree! Revealing Wes Parmalee actually was Jock would be wrong from several standpoints. I'd find it insulting to Jim Davis and his legacy to recast Jock. Telling the audience that a man who looks nothing like Jock, whose build is completely different from Jock's build, whose voice as well as his style of speaking is nothing like Jock's, is insulting to the intelligence of the audience. Finally if Parmalee had been Jock, why would Miss Ellie deliberately endanger his life by saying Parmalee was an imposter? She was there when Clayton said if he turned out to be a fraud, he'd hunt him down and he'd kill him. Clayton was not joking when he said that. He was as serious as could be. Then as soon as Miss Ellie told Clayton the news, that Parmalee confessed he was an imposter, Clayton got a gun and went looking for him. Miss Ellie tried to stop Clayton but how could she? She's a small woman and Clayton is a great big guy. She couldn't physically stop him from going after Parmalee to shoot him. At that point, does anyone think she wouldn't have told Clayton the truth - that Parmalee really was Jock but that he'd changed so much she no longer felt the same about him anymore - that the man she is in love with now is Clayton and not Jock? Suppose that somehow Parmalee had been Jock but he'd left because Ellie was no longer in love with him, she was in love with and married to Clayton and that Jock staying around would have been hurtful to everyone involved. Well, if that's why he left and why she agreed that for him to leave was best for everyone, she'd have to tell Clayton the truth. She couldn't lie to Clayton, making Clayton believe Parmalee was a con man who had tried to destroy their family by claiming to be Jock. There would be far too much chance of a a disaster happening if Clayton did manage to track him down. Even though Ellie would say that Jock had changed so much that he was no longer the man she'd been in love with and that she no longer felt capable of feeling the way about him she used to, she'd still have all that history with him and naturally she'd care what happened to Jock even of she didn't love him the way she used to. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Who played Sue Ellen in Dallas?
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
How should oldDALLAS have ended?
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top