Instead Of Pam Having The Accident And Leaving

Who Would Pam Have Been Better Off With - Bobby Or Mark?


  • Total voters
    10
  • Poll closed .

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Pam and Bobby decide to take a second honeymoon after all the awfulness of the BD Calhoun situation, and to celebrate her newfound fertility. They rent a boat in Galveston. There’s a terrible storm / boating accident. Bobby survives, but Pam’s body is not found and she’s presumed dead. Bobby can mourn her loss and move on with his life, but the door is open if Victoria ever wants to come back.

Excellent.
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
Pam and Bobby decide to take a second honeymoon after all the awfulness of the BD Calhoun situation, and to celebrate her newfound fertility. They rent a boat in Galveston. There’s a terrible storm / boating accident. Bobby survives, but Pam’s body is not found and she’s presumed dead. Bobby can mourn her loss and move on with his life, but the door is open if Victoria ever wants to come back.
I'm not sure if that's a great deal better. Missing presumed dead is still something of a cliche and the viewer would still be left in the same kind of limbo.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I'm not sure if that's a great deal better. Missing presumed dead is still something of a cliche and the viewer would still be left in the same kind of limbo.
Agreed that it’s a cliche. But it’s better than “burned beyond recognition; then runs away; then comes down with fatal disease syndrome”. And it’s better than Pam abandoning her young son voluntarily and later deciding to die alone rather than give her family closure. And it’s better than the characters thinking Pam dumped them to marry her plastic surgeon.
 
Last edited:

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
All the decisions producers made after the dream season are because of the dream season, they simply didn't want credibility in the show to get any lower - Bobby returning from the dead was bad enough, but then we had Jock possibly returning from the dead too. Add that to Ellie changing faces TWICE and your audience begins to see the 4th wall and the show is becoming a parody of itself.

They were never going to kill Pam off because of what happened with Bobby. Everything looks and sounds good with hindsight, but for me they should have created a plot where Pam HAD to leave and basically write it like Gone Girl - but without the revenge setup - the viewers would have seen her plan but not the show's characters. SO, the viewers knew why she went, where she went etc but not the characters.

Pam could then have returned if VP agreed or they re-cast - everyone wins.
 

Bobby Southworth

Telly Talk Fan
Top Poster Of Month
At the very least, they should have written it that Bobby and Cliff looked for Pam after she disappeared. Bobby just accepting everything and being mad at her never set well with me. He would have understood that she was just badly injured, and not in her right state of mind. Perhaps a conversation between Pam and either Cliff or Bobby could have taken place off screen, where she refuses to come back, and they have no choice but to accept her wishes. Bobby still could have slowly, hesitantly began dating again by the end of the 11th season. The way it was written was just out of character for Bobby. It was out of character for Pam as well, but at least she had an excuse. She was traumatized.

As for Pam leaving to be with Mark, I say no. Mark to me was never a likable character, due to the way that he pursued her while she was still married to Bobby. I also don't think she would have left Bobby to be with Mark after they were married again.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Perhaps a conversation between Pam and either Cliff or Bobby could have taken place off screen, where she refuses to come back, and they have no choice but to accept her wishes.

Seeing Bobby look for Pam for several episodes and then finally find her would have been great for the fans if Victoria Principal had been willing to appear, but otherwise, the fans don't get any payoff - they don't get to see Bobby and Pam have that crucial conversation. I think that's the most likely reason they didn't have Bobby search for Pam. If Bobby can't find her, it's a letdown. If he does find her, but we don't get to see Pam and Bobby talking to each other, it's a letdown.

As for Pam leaving to be with Mark, I say no. Mark to me was never a likable character, due to the way that he pursued her while she was still married to Bobby. I also don't think she would have left Bobby to be with Mark after they were married again.

The poll we did that asked who Pam would have been better off with - Bobby or Mark - was dead even. I think John Beck got a bad deal as a result of wiping out season 9. He played his role very well and apparently there were fans who did find him likable - or they at least thought Pam would have been better off with Mark.

Mark did pursue Pam aggressively, but then Bobby had no problem taking Pam away from Ray, his own foreman. Pam was attracted to those aggressive, type A personality men. She said she wanted "an ordinary life" and then immediately goes for a man who also runs a huge company and is highly competitive. Pam was one of those women who claims she wants one thing, but her actions show she doesn't really want what she says she wants.

I don't think Pam would have left Bobby for Mark after remarrying either, so they would have had to have had to have Mark return and tell Pam he searched for a cure but couldn't find one and wants to be with her for as long as he has left, if she'll still marry him. To do that they would have had to have been getting ready for VP's leaving the shown advance and planned accordingly - something they didn't seem to do. If they wanted to give her a way to be able to leave and then possibly return, this is the only way I know of they could have done it well. If she doesn't return it's because Mark lived, and if not, it's because Mark died. Being with Mark in his final year or last few years is the only way I see Pam willingly leave despite the opportunity to remarry Bobby.
 
Last edited:

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I would've either had her die in the fireball incident OR just have her leave. Have her finally be fed up with the Ewings after JR does something far too dastardly, divorce Bobby and have her live off screen with shared custody of Christopher a la Sue Ellen. It's not ideal, but at least we wouldn't have the ridiculous Pam the Mummy storyline and her fate left hanging because they didn't want to kill her off due to the previous Bobby fiasco.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I would've either had her die in the fireball incident OR just have her leave. Have her finally be fed up with the Ewings after JR does something far too dastardly, divorce Bobby and have her live off screen with shared custody of Christopher a la Sue Ellen. It's not ideal, but at least we wouldn't have the ridiculous Pam the Mummy storyline and her fate left hanging because they didn't want to kill her off due to the previous Bobby fiasco.

I find it incredible that they wouldn't kill Pam off after what should have been an immediately fatal accident, because they didn't have the confidence in themselves to be able to say "no" if Victoria Principal asked to return. Pam's death should have been a monumentally important storyline, but they robbed themselves of the opportunity to do it because they couldn't commit to one vision for how the show should make the best use of the loss of Pam! When Jim Davis died, Dallas made the best use possible of losing Jock Ewing and the contest for Ewing Oil it caused was my favorite storyline they ever did.

I wouldn't have liked Pam leaving because of something dastardly JR did. Bobby and Pam were supposed to be the Romeo and Juliet of Dallas, so her love for Bobby should always have been stronger than her hate for JR, just as nothing Cliff did should have ever turned Bobby against Pam. I could see her saying they needed to move out of Southfork to have their own home because of JR, but not divorcing Bobby because of JR.
 

Bobby Southworth

Telly Talk Fan
Top Poster Of Month
I suggested the off screen conversation because, if it was on screen, it would have had to take place with her as the mummy or badly disfigured at that point. I'm not sure how that would have worked. I suppose the lighting could have been dim enough that we couldn't clearly make out her face?

In any case, I think the way her departure was written, and the way Bobby handled it could have done more damage, or at least as much as the dream season scenario. Pam was supposed to be the love of his life, and he just displayed self pity and wrote her off. That was a poor ending to the story of Bobby and Pam; The couple the show was supposed to originally revolve around.

As for Mark, I suppose if he somehow could have returned before Bobby and Pam were remarried, and asked for Pam to be with him during the end, that could have worked, and would have been better than what the writers ultimately came up with. On the other hand, it was such a big thing for Bobby and Pam to finally remarry.... It's just a shame it was so short lived, and handled the way it was with Victoria's departure. I agree, Kenny that it would have been better to just have her die, but yes, obviously they didn't want another Patrick Duffy scenario.
 
Last edited:

Toni

Maximum Member
If VP had come back to the show, I wonder how they would have used her. Suppose Pam came back and Bobby was with April then, and even if he hadn't married April, Pam divorced Bobby twice, so who would they put Pam with?

So easy! Throw the skunk off the train and take Pam back!!
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
So easy! Throw the skunk off the train and take Pam back!!

I know you're kidding, but April was the best wife Bobby ever had because she was the one who loved him and never underestimated him or ran away from him. Pam had underestimated him, thinking he couldn't handle the contest for Ewing Oil and that she had to go to court with Miss Ellie to try to take away from Bobby the opportunity to even participate in the contest. That was Bobby's decision - not Pam's or Miss Ellie's. You can't rewrite someone's will just because you don't like it. Ellie didn't believe Jock was mentally incompetent when he wrote that will and you could tell how that while she said that in court (so she could rewrite Jock's will) you could tell she didn't believe her own words. She only said Jock was incompetent because her lawyer said saying that was the only way she and Pam could win.

I find Pam going to court to try to take away Bobby's fathers' right to have his will carried out just because she didn't like it to be disgusting. I doubt Pam would have wanted someone else to rewrite her will. A will is literally someone's last request. Because of that, it's sacred. Ewing Oil was Jock's company and he had the right to say who inherited it and how. Pam tried to do everything she could to deny Bobby the opportunity Jock offered him and that's unforgivable. I was glad Bobby stood up for his right to participate in that contest and that he proved he had the wherewithal to win it!

Pam said to Bobby: "You're not the man I married"! What she was seeing at that time was Bobby in a stressful situation. When Bobby saw Pam in a stressful situation, when she was in the mental hospital after trying to jump of he roof of a building, Bobby was supportive. He didn't tell Pam that she was no longer the woman he had married because the Pam he married would never have tried to jump off a building just because she couldn't wait the two years to adopt just like any other couple who wants to adopt does. Bobby stayed supportive of Pam through everything but she refused to reciprocate.

Bobby was always there for Pam when she needed his support. The one time Bobby really need Pam's support, she turned against him and left him! A few weeks later she was in France with Mark Graison - not something I'd expect from a woman who would have been mourning the loss her marriage to supposedly "the love of her life." Wow, Pam must have been so distraught over her marriage to Bobby ending to be on the beach in France with Mark about a month later.

Marriage is a give and take relationship and that doesn't mean Bobby give and Pam just takes. Yet when it was her time to give back and be there for him in a difficult time for him, she ran!

I believe April was the best wife Bobby ever had. She didn't underestimate him, she didn't try to take away something away from Bobby that he valued highly, and she never ran when things got tough. Bobby deserved a wife who not only truly loved him but would also be there for him just as he would always be there for her. April was that woman.

In any case, I think the way her departure was written, and the way Bobby handled it could have done more damage, or at least as much as the dream season scenario. Pam was supposed to be the love of his life, and he just displayed self pity and wrote her off.

As you can see above, Pam ruined or at the least, badly damaged that "love of her life." I don't know how Bobby could have ever thought of her the same after her betrayal in season 6. After Pam once again ran out on him, Bobby reacted pretty much the same way I'd expect any man to react the third time his wife bails on him. Whatever anyone might think of Bobby, he never bailed on Pam.

As for Mark, I suppose if he somehow could have returned before Bobby and Pam were remarried, and asked for Pam to be with him during the end, that could have worked, and would have been better than what the writers ultimately came up with. On the other hand, it was such a big thing for Bobby and Pam to finally remarry.... It's just a shame it was so short lived, and handled the way it was with Victoria's departure. I agree, Kenny that it would have been better to just have her die, but yes, obviously they didn't want another Patrick Duffy scenario.

That hypothetical scenario with Mark was a way where they could have had VP leave the show and then provide a valid reason in the storyline for how she could return, if that's what they really wanted to do. I think it's a little convoluted and contrived.

Having Pam die would be cleaner, not so contrived as any of the other scenarios and would have provided great drama. I believe having Pam die in her car crash was the way to go, other people here seem to agree, and it's just a shame that the people running the show din't have the integrity to say: "This is the best possible way we can handle Victoria Principal leaving the show. It's the best way we can handle a bad situation. This is our vision for how the show needs to proceed and it's what we are sticking with.
 
Last edited:

Dallas Fanatic

Telly Talk Member
I'm new to this forum (although I used to be on it about 15 years ago or so). Anyway, the way that they wrote off Victoria Principal is probably the single worst thing they ever did to this show. I also was not a fan of how they desperately attempted to resolve it in the reboot. And though I do understand why VP didn't want to come back, I was truly hoping she would reconsider the reboot, at least for some guest appearances.

I have been watching the show again on IMDB (I have seen every episode at least a dozen times over the years), and clearly her character was key to the show. I just don't think the producers really believed she would wash her hands clean of the show, particularly after the regret that Patrick Duffy had for leaving.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I'm new to this forum (although I used to be on it about 15 years ago or so).

Welcome back!

Anyway, the way that they wrote off Victoria Principal is probably the single worst thing they ever did to this show.

It was certainly one of the bad things they did to the show, although in the last season she was in, season ten, they had already fallen a long way from when they were at their peak. That was reflected in how many of their fans they'd already lost in the previous six years. Their peak was season four - Jim Davis' last season in Dallas before he died. In season four they scored a 27.6 Nielsen rating. In contrast, season ten - Victoria Principal's last season - scored on an 18.6 Nielsen rating.

In season 11, they dropped to a 15.2 rating. That drop a 3.2 is the second biggest drop in a year that Dallas ever had and was largely caused by the departures of Victoria Principal, Susan Howard, and Deborah Shelton.

The biggest drop they ever had in one year was a drop of 4.4 points between season four and season five which was largely caused by the death of Jim Davis. When he died, they lost the man who played the role of Jock Ewing - the head of the family.

The way they handled losing those two vital characters was as different as night and day. Their reaction to losing Jim Davis was to make the most of a terrible situation by making Jock Ewing's death as meaningful as possible. They created some their most memorable work in their grieving over the loss of Jock and they utilized Jock's will to create the contest of Ewing Oil between JR and Bobby, which is my favorite Dallas storyline. They decided to utilize losing Jim Davis in the way that would create the best drama, the best stories and the most emotional reaction.

When they lost the character of Pam because Victoria Principal wanted to become a movie star, they did the opposite. They decided to handle the loss by reacting in the most indecisive way possible. They went in the most noncommittal direction possible, just so they would end up with a situation where they could bring back Victoria Principal just in case she changed her mind. They created a storyline to accommodate the possible return of the actress instead of using the situation to have Pam die in the crash and create the most powerful scenes they could have created. They refused to commit to the best artistic vision they could create, so instead they went half way with it and got poor results.

I just don't think the producers really believed she would wash her hands clean of the show, particularly after the regret that Patrick Duffy had for leaving.

She'd been telling them for a long time that she was leaving for good and wanted to be in movies. The way they handled it tells me they didn't trust themselves to be able to stick to their word if she asked to return and tell her "No, you can't return. We told you if you left, you were leaving for good." They weren't able to keep their word and stick to the artistic vision for the show they had chosen when Patrick Duffy asked to return and apparently they still didn't trust themselves to make a decision and stick to it.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The biggest drop they ever had in one year was a drop of 4.4 points between season four and season five which was largely caused by the death of Jim Davis. When he died, they lost the man who played the role of Jock Ewing - the head of the family.
The 1980-81 season average rating included the 52.1 rating for the episode that resolved the “Who Shot J.R.” cliffhanger. Without that episode, the average rating for that season would have been much closer to that of the following season. Attributing the 4.4 rating point drop to Jim Davis’ death isn’t accurate, since the Southfork swimming pool murder cliffhanger didn’t have nearly the same cultural impact.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The 1980-81 season average rating included the 52.1 rating for the episode that resolved the “Who Shot J.R.” cliffhanger.

I didn't deny that.

Without that episode, the average rating for that season would have been much closer to that of the following season.

How much closer?

Attributing the 4.4 rating point drop to Jim Davis’ death isn’t accurate, since the Southfork swimming pool murder cliffhanger didn’t have nearly the same cultural impact.

I said it was "largely caused by the death of Jim Davis." I don't attribute the entire drop to his death, but his absence was the single biggest change from season 4 to season 5 by far. The show wasn't the same without him and the ratings reflected that. Jock Ewing was, after all, the head of the family and the man who founded Ewing Oil. He was the man his sons looked up to and set the standard they tried to live up to. JR's biggest hope was to one day make Jock proud of him. Jim Davis had a background in westerns and helped bring a western feel and a grit to the show that faded in his absence. His influence in making Dallas what it was is undeniable.
 
Last edited:
Top