Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Is there 'an announcement' imminent..?
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="stevew" data-source="post: 208310" data-attributes="member: 130"><p>Thank you for your break down. I did not mean for Bobby to walk around in a dress and be called momma. I mean in the Miss Ellie role in a broad sense. And yes this is who Bobby was, not the man TNT showed us. Like his mother her loved the land over the money of oil. Like his mother he loved his family and tried hard to keep them together. Like his mother he was a moral compass for the family. It’s this broad concept not making him mom of the family. It seems to me both of you are way over sensitive about some sort of liberal gender identity issue. That’s not the case at all in my writing, though I suppose it could be. But if my two choices were Bobby and Sue Ellen, and you asked me who should be the moral compass who fights to keep the family together and who should be the business focused parent pushing their son to succeed even if they have to skate the moral line - I’d say Bobby for the first and Sue Ellen for the later. This isn’t some sort of liberal conspiracy to change the world as you know it or the world as you knew it. </p><p></p><p>As to Sue Ellen verses Jock, good guess. I’m not sure you’re right, certainly not all these decades later (aside from the crap CC gave us). She’s had plenty of time to learn, but more than that, she had the ability to build up a network of allies that would make someone like Jock not as big of a threat as you assume. Jock knew, as evident through his interaction with the cartel, the value to his success was beyond the hard work in oil field (Diggers domain). He knew it was his network and Sue Ellen, at this age, I wouldn’t put it past her to be more than capable. Ironically this was JR’s failure in business, he tore apart networks. If she learned from JR to horde information and from Lockwood to build allies - today she might truly give an old 1st generation roughneck like Jock a run for his money. </p><p></p><p>No where did I say Sue Ellen inherits Miss Ellie’s money. I said it goes to a foundation which Sue Ellen controls. Would I be surprised a foundation which included Clayton’s money included Sue Ellen? No. Would I be surprised that Sue Ellen figures out a way to control said foundation for her benefit? Again no. What people hated about what Dallas become was a joke. Sue Ellen developing into a strong and capable leader of a multi billion dollar foundation is not a joke. Which Ford controls the Ford Foundation today? None. In fact until recently not one Ford served on that foundation’s board. You don’t seem to understand how such work. Is Sue Ellen in the role as leader of an international NGO believable? Yes. </p><p></p><p>Again you read what wasn’t there. I did NOT say Afton married Wendell. I said she gave birth to his son. I’d even make it clear he raped her and scared the hell out of her to give up her son. But no where do I say they married. It’s hard to defend my ideas when you read into it what you want, things which are NOT there.</p><p></p><p>The Wendell side of things was a great missed opportunity in the original Dallas and with the right actor, the Wendell Ewing feud could replace the worn out Barnes Ewing feud. The idea with Afton was merely to tie Pamela and Jeremy’s son in a way similar to Pam and Cliff. No I’m not saying copy word for word to replicate these relationships. I’m saying broad concepts. Like Pam defending her brother, even when he’s wrong. </p><p></p><p>JR could have had many, many children. Just because it was CC’s idea doesn’t mean it was a bad idea. Frankly they could ignore it and use Cally’s child in this role. Though frankly I’d like to see a woman in the role. I always liked Abby Ewing and Angela Channing in similar roles and see no reason why doing such in Dallas makes the show no longer Dallas. </p><p></p><p>Bobby dabbled in politics, ranching and business. This is NOT uncommon of second and subsequent generations of a wealthy family. But at the heart of the story I suggested as one possible idea is a business called EWING INDUSTRIES, of which Ewing Oil is a subsidiary and is based on Koch Industries - primarily an oil business at its core, much like EO was based on Hunt Oil. Bobby and Sue Ellen are retired from the business, much like Jock was, and the next generation, found with many third generation business families, aren’t involved in the day to day running of the company they inherit but instead delegate to employees. So John Ross could be chairman and ceo, much like when Bobby was running the company. And his sister could play a behind the scenes manipulative role much like when JR was pushed aside for Bobby. That was when Dallas was great. But most of this third generation would not be day to day operatives, if the family had been as successful as it seemed. So yes they’d run the business but use other people to do it for them. Certainly not go into an office everyday to punch a time card and work on the grind stone - that pushes the concept of believability. </p><p></p><p>Finally there’s no oil man in JR. There was a businessman who happened to be in the business of oil. JR and Bobby and eventually Sue Ellen cultivated money and power, that’s not a dilettante. Maybe Sue Ellen was to start but her character grew into a very capable women. Certainly Bobby’s venture into politics is included here, a move which would make him more powerful. Cattle ranching was a side business and like his father, Bobby retired to ranching and yes that makes sense. </p><p></p><p>I’m just putting my ideas out there. I’d like to see it continued in some form. I think it can again be as good as it was in its original run in the first 1/2 half anyway, I think it can focus on the family and business dynamics from the original with a new generation and I think it can again be relevant to current events and realistic. If you don’t like my ideas, that’s fine, but to speak for anyone but yourself and to read into what I write what isn’t there is tedious. You most certainly have your opinion and you most certainly are not a neutral party because of it. But then neither am I.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="stevew, post: 208310, member: 130"] Thank you for your break down. I did not mean for Bobby to walk around in a dress and be called momma. I mean in the Miss Ellie role in a broad sense. And yes this is who Bobby was, not the man TNT showed us. Like his mother her loved the land over the money of oil. Like his mother he loved his family and tried hard to keep them together. Like his mother he was a moral compass for the family. It’s this broad concept not making him mom of the family. It seems to me both of you are way over sensitive about some sort of liberal gender identity issue. That’s not the case at all in my writing, though I suppose it could be. But if my two choices were Bobby and Sue Ellen, and you asked me who should be the moral compass who fights to keep the family together and who should be the business focused parent pushing their son to succeed even if they have to skate the moral line - I’d say Bobby for the first and Sue Ellen for the later. This isn’t some sort of liberal conspiracy to change the world as you know it or the world as you knew it. As to Sue Ellen verses Jock, good guess. I’m not sure you’re right, certainly not all these decades later (aside from the crap CC gave us). She’s had plenty of time to learn, but more than that, she had the ability to build up a network of allies that would make someone like Jock not as big of a threat as you assume. Jock knew, as evident through his interaction with the cartel, the value to his success was beyond the hard work in oil field (Diggers domain). He knew it was his network and Sue Ellen, at this age, I wouldn’t put it past her to be more than capable. Ironically this was JR’s failure in business, he tore apart networks. If she learned from JR to horde information and from Lockwood to build allies - today she might truly give an old 1st generation roughneck like Jock a run for his money. No where did I say Sue Ellen inherits Miss Ellie’s money. I said it goes to a foundation which Sue Ellen controls. Would I be surprised a foundation which included Clayton’s money included Sue Ellen? No. Would I be surprised that Sue Ellen figures out a way to control said foundation for her benefit? Again no. What people hated about what Dallas become was a joke. Sue Ellen developing into a strong and capable leader of a multi billion dollar foundation is not a joke. Which Ford controls the Ford Foundation today? None. In fact until recently not one Ford served on that foundation’s board. You don’t seem to understand how such work. Is Sue Ellen in the role as leader of an international NGO believable? Yes. Again you read what wasn’t there. I did NOT say Afton married Wendell. I said she gave birth to his son. I’d even make it clear he raped her and scared the hell out of her to give up her son. But no where do I say they married. It’s hard to defend my ideas when you read into it what you want, things which are NOT there. The Wendell side of things was a great missed opportunity in the original Dallas and with the right actor, the Wendell Ewing feud could replace the worn out Barnes Ewing feud. The idea with Afton was merely to tie Pamela and Jeremy’s son in a way similar to Pam and Cliff. No I’m not saying copy word for word to replicate these relationships. I’m saying broad concepts. Like Pam defending her brother, even when he’s wrong. JR could have had many, many children. Just because it was CC’s idea doesn’t mean it was a bad idea. Frankly they could ignore it and use Cally’s child in this role. Though frankly I’d like to see a woman in the role. I always liked Abby Ewing and Angela Channing in similar roles and see no reason why doing such in Dallas makes the show no longer Dallas. Bobby dabbled in politics, ranching and business. This is NOT uncommon of second and subsequent generations of a wealthy family. But at the heart of the story I suggested as one possible idea is a business called EWING INDUSTRIES, of which Ewing Oil is a subsidiary and is based on Koch Industries - primarily an oil business at its core, much like EO was based on Hunt Oil. Bobby and Sue Ellen are retired from the business, much like Jock was, and the next generation, found with many third generation business families, aren’t involved in the day to day running of the company they inherit but instead delegate to employees. So John Ross could be chairman and ceo, much like when Bobby was running the company. And his sister could play a behind the scenes manipulative role much like when JR was pushed aside for Bobby. That was when Dallas was great. But most of this third generation would not be day to day operatives, if the family had been as successful as it seemed. So yes they’d run the business but use other people to do it for them. Certainly not go into an office everyday to punch a time card and work on the grind stone - that pushes the concept of believability. Finally there’s no oil man in JR. There was a businessman who happened to be in the business of oil. JR and Bobby and eventually Sue Ellen cultivated money and power, that’s not a dilettante. Maybe Sue Ellen was to start but her character grew into a very capable women. Certainly Bobby’s venture into politics is included here, a move which would make him more powerful. Cattle ranching was a side business and like his father, Bobby retired to ranching and yes that makes sense. I’m just putting my ideas out there. I’d like to see it continued in some form. I think it can again be as good as it was in its original run in the first 1/2 half anyway, I think it can focus on the family and business dynamics from the original with a new generation and I think it can again be relevant to current events and realistic. If you don’t like my ideas, that’s fine, but to speak for anyone but yourself and to read into what I write what isn’t there is tedious. You most certainly have your opinion and you most certainly are not a neutral party because of it. But then neither am I. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
6 + 4 =
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Is there 'an announcement' imminent..?
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top