It's Become Obvious Why Dallas Went Downhill

Toni

Maximum Member
And, meanwhile, on "Knots", its vocal actors (ahem, actresses I´d say, though I would include here those who penned scripts once in awhile like Pleshette, Murray, Devane, or Houghton) relentlessly called at the producers´ or writers´ home to complain about their characters´ lines and suggest ways to improve them. But even so, some actors like Joan Van Ark, Julie Harris or Constance McCashin used to be underutilized during their latest seasons. Which didn´t stop the showrunners to act as a creative team with them and feature the best storylines of that era, prior to the Lechowicz´s arrival.

And if that happened in the most exquisite soap of the four major ones, go figure what didn´t happen behind the scenes in the Lorimar "products" or in the ever vacuous Spelling "junk TV". I still wish that someone could write a book about the secrets of those shows, maybe Ryan Murphy could add them to the "Feud" anthology.

Regarding the Capice vs. Katzman chapter, I see it as a power play (to use a title out of the "Dallas" episode titles) and a tale of greed that would make J.R.´s plots look like naughty children´s games. What is so ironic in hindsight is to remember that, back to mid-80´, the Lorimar execs did think they were getting bigger and bigger, producing movies for big screen and setting up takeovers. In their case, I also think that their merge with Telepictures, which I never knew if was a well-thought move or just that, a hostile T.O., partly was what began to hurt the series very badly.

The video editing has been mentioned already, and it´s tremendously ironic that a dream had a wonderful look and then, when the dreamer wakes up, reality is so blurry. I also think that Donna´s Reed suit damaged the company´s reputation, especially when she died so sadly. And after Duffy´s return, I read in a French magazine that the new Lorimar (-Telepictures now...) honcho stated that the demands of high rises from the actors would be ignored. Which led me to think, given that the date of that interview was 1986 or 1987, that was the reason VP and Susan Howard were let go.

Again, it was another power play, and the company seemed to need to say who was the boss then. Let's remember that "Knots Landing" was severely hurt those years too, when Harris and McCashin were axed. And "Falcon Crest" (coincidence, another L-T production...) got rid of Robert Foxworth, William R. Moses and Cesar Romero around that time too. At least they seemed to be more coherent than the producers of the two "Dynasties", who always were accusing their colleagues of whatever problems they had (to know more about it, read the "Dynasty" forum and their clever experts there).

Katzman´s moves after the dream solution seemed to be a desperate seek for control: he hired two of his sons for major jobs in the show, and as Barbara Curran´s book proves, Susan Howard was vocal in her disagreements with both producers (especially with Katzman, because she didn´t want Donna to have a lover while she was pregnant, and she still was angry with him for letting go the deaf boy adoption storyline, for obvious reasons...). Duffy allegedly got paid one million (of 80´s dollars!) just for coming back, and a big rise for episode too, as well as the promise to make Bobby stronger.

I wonder what Duffy thought about the latter when he saw that his character was playing James Bond and sharing the blame with J.R. about the B.D. Calhoun affair. From good ol´ Bobby he became stupid Bobby. Too bad. I only saw improvements for Bobby in his scenes with Christopher, but not searching for mummy Pam and sharing Ewing Oil with J.R. again (and Cliff!!) were bad moves from the writers (controlled by Katzman).

If I had to find a reason for that lack of insight, I´d blame those possible behind-the-scenes problems between Katzman and the new people at the helms of NuLorimar. I seriously doubt that someone who gave us seven brilliant seasons of urban, soapy drama could be so lack of imagination and good sense as the five last seasons seem to prove. Even the casting was less than memorable after the dream, look at some of the names of the acting "masters" he brought aboard: Sheree J. Wilson, the guy who played B.D. Calhoun, Hunter von Leer (who seemingly thought that B.D. was a true American hero who wanted revenge because J.R. "killed" his man, lol!), Karen Carlson, the very annoying Mrs. Scotfield, or the girls from the next season, including Miss Bonsai! We were lucky to have William Smithers for awhile!
 
Last edited:

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Spiritually, the recasting of Miss Ellie (with Donna Reed or anybody) still seems to be the line in the sand, the crack in the veneer, the symptom that something was now wrong behind the camera. When we read during the Summer of 1984 that Miss Ellie was being re-cast, we couldn't believe it --- DALLAS wasn't just a hit, but already a legend in its own time. And they were recasting a core character, the Emmy-winning matriarch??

It was obviously going to be a disaster, so why didn't the executives know that at Lorimar? It's always so frustrating and perplexing when the brass understands their show less than the viewers do.
The beginning of the end. A saying which can be so easily applied to the recasting of Miss Ellie. But I'll add the rot had set in much earlier than the introduction of Donna Reed. That rot had started the moment the opening credits rolled with "Killer At Large." Starring in alphabetical order, "Where was Barbara Bel Geddes?" Shafted by the hierarchy. Talk about lack of respect for an Emmy Award winning actress. By the end of this episode Afton was gone, followed shortly thereafter by Katherine Wentworth. There was the head turning introduction of Mandy Winger and Jamie Ewing.

Jesus. What happened between "End Game" and "Killer At Large?"
 

Toni

Maximum Member
The beginning of the end. A saying which can be so easily applied to the recasting of Miss Ellie. But I'll add the rot had set in much earlier than the introduction of Donna Reed. That rot had started the moment the opening credits rolled with "Killer At Large." Starring in alphabetical order, "Where was Barbara Bel Geddes?" Shafted by the hierarchy. Talk about lack of respect for an Emmy Award winning actress. By the end of this episode Afton was gone, followed shortly thereafter by Katherine Wentworth. There was the head turning introduction of Mandy Winger and Jamie Ewing.

Jesus. What happened between "End Game" and "Killer At Large?"

I dare to say that the change you point out actually happened in the middle of the scene of Miss Ellie and Clayton´s wedding (the one we did NOT see). Remember they did a fade out, just when she was walking down the aisle and out of the house? If a character like Miss Ellie gets married and you don´t see their vows and their performers´ acting, this already means that something is wrong.

Add to that that the Whodunit had little buildup because I have always suspected it was a last-minute addition (as was the first one, but a lot less successful, aside from the staging, which I did love, with the score and the shock of "Bobby´s been shot, not J.R.!"). Suddenly, we had a cliffhanger episode that didn´t really bring anything new at all. It was just the old formula, but reversed: the victim eventually isn´t who we think that would be. This was to "Dallas" what the Moldavia wedding was to "Dynasty": good execution but poor resolution. "Killer at Large" is a season premiere by-the-numbers, with a lot of people telling each other the same thing: "Bobby´s been shot." Lame. Katherine and Pam looked amazing in her Travilla dresses though.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
Not my area of expertise, but I thought Travilla was a much better designer than Nolan Miller, which is funny because he was brought to the show exactly because of Nolan Miller on DYNASTY.

I 100% agree. So does she:
upload_2018-11-11_0-49-54.jpeg​
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Travilla did lots and lots of grecian pleating. Sometimes too much.

But Miller's daywear for Krystle in the mid-to-later seasons was atrocious.
 

retrosonic

Telly Talk Member
You know...the writers never really developed the Ray character they way they could have. Rather than bringing in James and Jamie, the writers could have done more with Ray. Remember in the early episodes, Ray and JR and buddies that went out to bars together. Somehow, they could have had Ray and JR reconcile.
 

Julia's Gun

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I dare to say that the change you point out actually happened in the middle of the scene of Miss Ellie and Clayton´s wedding (the one we did NOT see). Remember they did a fade out, just when she was walking down the aisle and out of the house? If a character like Miss Ellie gets married and you don´t see their vows and their performers´ acting, this already means that something is wrong.

I remember thinking how weird it was we didn't see their wedding after all the build up. They are all dressed up and then it cuts away, what an anti-climax. I remember thinking my DVDs must had been cut when I rewatched that year, but if this was linked to Barbara's contract machinations, it's a real shame, she must have felt awful if she was actually being sidelined.

Was a wedding scene actually planned or ever filmed. Does it still exist somewhere? Was the cliffhanger going to involve Kathering trying to shoot Bobby at the wedding, and Miss Ellie gets hit instead? (like Karen that year in Knots). Or am I just getting carried away now....
 
I remember thinking how weird it was we didn't see their wedding after all the build up. They are all dressed up and then it cuts away, what an anti-climax. I remember thinking my DVDs must had been cut when I rewatched that year, but if this was linked to Barbara's contract machinations, it's a real shame, she must have felt awful if she was actually being sidelined.

Barbara was ill at that point and had made slow progress from her heart op

Once a soap can no longer afford its established characters and start replacing them with younger, cheaper talent, the end come soon.

Absolutely, if the cast from s12 and 13 were in the mini season and S1 I would not be sitting here typing and writing about Dallas as I wouldnt have watched it, Id have probably tuned out long ago despite Mr Duffy in it as it was C**P!

Agree @kenneth but the newbies were very lacking in talent ;)
 

Toni

Maximum Member
I remember thinking how weird it was we didn't see their wedding after all the build up. They are all dressed up and then it cuts away, what an anti-climax. I remember thinking my DVDs must had been cut when I rewatched that year, but if this was linked to Barbara's contract machinations, it's a real shame, she must have felt awful if she was actually being sidelined.

Was a wedding scene actually planned or ever filmed. Does it still exist somewhere? Was the cliffhanger going to involve Kathering trying to shoot Bobby at the wedding, and Miss Ellie gets hit instead? (like Karen that year in Knots). Or am I just getting carried away now....

The only info about this cliffhanger that was official is that it was a homage the "Who Shot JR?" plot, and that Sue Ellen and Holly were filmed shooting too. Oh and Morgan Brittany knew who "did it" all the time!

The rest of theories are just that, theories. Maybe Jessie could have kidnapped Miss Ellie and disappeared until the next season, maybe the shooting scenario was a last-minute decision, maybe BBG didn´t know the details of his agent´s negotiations until it was too late, or maybe it was the shock of see Ms. Dread playing her Ellie what made her want to return (who´s to blame her!).
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Bobby returning
JR weakening
Pamela leaving

Donna Reed thing never really bothered me as I never liked BBG. She never talked like a Texan.

It's odd how no one really complains about the death of bobby, but his absurd return as it titled the axis of the show.
I always felt bobby should have been murdered by Jeremy Wendell and JR spends the rest of the series proving it. There was no reason the show couldnt have continued without Bobby.
Knots Landing killed off Sid and thrived so there was no excuse for Dallas imploding other than bad planning. The first mistake was to make Bobbys death so final. Big no.
Make it vague.
Plane crash. Had Duffy said no to a return. The Ewings find his remains. Since he did return. They find a guy in an mental ward matching the description of bobby.
He returns. No big deal. No erased storylines. No weird dream stuff.
 
There was no reason the show couldnt have continued without Bobby.
Knots Landing killed off Sid and thrived so there was no excuse for Dallas imploding other than bad planning. The first mistake was to make Bobbys death so final. Big no.
Make it vague.
While I wholeheartedly agree with the first part of this, I'd also point out that Knots thrived in large part because Sid's death was final.

He died onscreen just as Bobby did and was unequivocally dead. The big difference with Knots is there was no question of Sid returning. Despite him being a lead character. Despite the series plummetting from #28 to #43 the following season. Despite the actor who played him being alive and having some regrets about his decision (as Don Murray has admitted). Sid stayed dead.

Characters dying offscreen always feels like a cheat. I don't believe Sid's death would have had any significant resonance if his death had been vague. All involved creatively in the storyline and its impact on the series put the integrity of the story ahead of everything else. Ultimately, those creating Dallas didn't.
 

DallasFanForever

Telly Talk Supreme
Bobby dying off camera would’ve made more sense in terms of them not having to do the dream resolution obviously but then I think I would’ve felt cheated cause Swan Song wouldn’t have been the same for me without him saving Pam’s life and then the subsequent hospital scene. If Bobby did die off camera I don’t like the idea of a plane crash because I felt like they had done too many of those already. Bobby and J.R. had been in a plane crash, Rebecca, Mark, Dusty, Jock’s helicopter, I was Aviation-ly worn out at this point.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
While I wholeheartedly agree with the first part of this, I'd also point out that Knots thrived in large part because Sid's death was final.

He died onscreen just as Bobby did and was unequivocally dead. The big difference with Knots is there was no question of Sid returning. Despite him being a lead character. Despite the series plummetting from #28 to #43 the following season. Despite the actor who played him being alive and having some regrets about his decision (as Don Murray has admitted). Sid stayed dead.

Characters dying offscreen always feels like a cheat. I don't believe Sid's death would have had any significant resonance if his death had been vague. All involved creatively in the storyline and its impact on the series put the integrity of the story ahead of everything else. Ultimately, those creating Dallas didn't.
True, but considering how attached the show was to Bobby, a lot less ensemble than the great KL, off-screen death was their best choice. We can only say this since we know outcome. no one had any idea that PD would return. He was offered $1 million bonus, plus a $30 grand an ep increase so we cant blame him for saying yes to the return. I say no to his death, that should have been a never. You want to leave, cool, but Bobby stays alive.
 
Last edited:

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
You know...the writers never really developed the Ray character they way they could have. Rather than bringing in James and Jamie, the writers could have done more with Ray. Remember in the early episodes, Ray and JR and buddies that went out to bars together. Somehow, they could have had Ray and JR reconcile.
JR only liked Ray for what he could get from him, when that stopped their friendship stopped. It grew worse when he was revealed a Ewing. I think they went to far in their hostility though, geez. He attempts to kill JR, nearly burns down SF....
 
Top