Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
It's Become Obvious Why Dallas Went Downhill
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Snarky Oracle!" data-source="post: 140175" data-attributes="member: 57984"><p>DALLAS' Season 6 and 7 (per DVD count) were arguably the most solid two-year period the series ever had, the show reaching its creative maturity circa 1983.</p><p></p><p>So say I.</p><p></p><p>Spiritually, the recasting of Miss Ellie (with Donna Reed or anybody) still seems to be the line in the sand, the crack in the veneer, the symptom that something was now wrong behind the camera. When we read during the Summer of 1984 that Miss Ellie was being re-cast, we couldn't believe it --- DALLAS wasn't just a hit, but already a legend in its own time. And they were recasting a core character, the Emmy-winning matriarch??</p><p></p><p>It was obviously going to be a disaster, so why didn't the executives know that at Lorimar? It's always so frustrating and perplexing when the brass understands their show less than the viewers do.</p><p></p><p>The short-term effect of Mis-Ellie Syndrome was that the otherwise competent Season 8 (per DVD count) had a pall over it, a feeling of depression, a sense that something had now been ruined -- and perhaps that sense of ruination made Bobby's death even more effective (although I wish they'd found a reason to leave poor doomed Donna Reed out of Bobby's hospital bed scene). And maybe the show should have indeed ended there, I'm not sure.</p><p></p><p>For the year Bobby was ostensibly dead, DALLAS' writing team changed (Katzman, Art Lewis, and Paulsen went elsewhere the same time Duffy did) and the KNOTS LANDING writers came in; at first, Season 9 (per DVD count) seemed like it was going to be a rawer, more experimental DALLAS, using techniques, even camera work, Katzman would never have permitted.... That <strong>could</strong> have been good, as Katzman had sometimes kept DALLAS on too tight a leash and a little rigid, but, alas, the new team began to show by mid-season that they didn't really know where they wanted to go with their new DALLAS stories --- they'd done great work on KNOTS, but on a somewhat less subtle and nuanced show like DALLAS, the narrative rambling and 'let's-fix-this-series' agenda just became a cluttered mess. It felt smug, and politically correct.</p><p></p><p>Then, when Katzman returned with Duffy for Season 10 (per DVD count) in 1986, Uncle Lenny's malice seemed most involved in his cutting out the previous year as a "dream" (then and now considered <strong>the</strong> pre-eminent 'jump-the-shark' moment in all of TV history, and not the minimal controversy the surviving cast tries to make it out to be in recent years) than necessity. There were other ways to do it, even in a single episode; and if they felt they <strong>had</strong> to use the dream, making it comatose Bobby's dream still seems the only logical way to do so, but instead they chose to push blame off onto his ex-wife, Pam, which just made the scenario feel five times dumber than it had to.</p><p></p><p>The only reason viewership didn't drop much from the previous year was that, aside from the "I just had a terrible 31-episode dream, Bobby!" opening most people hated, the rest of Season 10 -- Wes Parmalee and BD Calhoun -- was so snappily good, and the closest DALLAS ever came to self-parody which actually worked --- that it remains one of the most re-watchable years the series ever did (and the sole reason I'm happy DALLAS didn't conclude immediately after Bobby's demise).</p><p></p><p>But the next season, Pam's exit was bungled (in part because they lacked the usual spring hiatus planning time in 1987) and the series seemed to know Pam's exit was umbilically-tied to Bobby's much-despised method of resurrection, choosing to sweep her fiery crash almost under the rug to avoid complications, which just displayed contempt for the exiting actress, character, and the audience at home.</p><p></p><p>DALLAS was doing what all the decade's nighttime serial were doing after 1985: turning into daytime soaps. Even the new edited-on-video post-production style made everything look cheap, even KNOTS, which was the only show maintaining creative integrity into the late-'80s.</p><p></p><p>DALLAS began doing the same kinds of silly, shlocky things they used to criticize DYNASTY for... I can handle the range war, Cally as JR's mismatched wife, the timely oil spill, JR's burn-out, even Lady Jessica's murder spree.... but the pacing, tome and details were now <strong>all</strong> <strong>wrong</strong> (which is what happens when a Howard Lakin replaces a David Paulsen) and Katzman, long-cited as "the brains of DALLAS" happily signed-off on all of it, even though most of it was as bad or worse than anything Peter Dunne did to the show the year Duffy and Katzman were gone. </p><p></p><p>Many years later, Larry Hagman admitted that the last couple of seasons "weren't up to par" and Patrick Duffy conceded that they "lost objectivity" about what qualified as a good story.</p><p></p><p>It got to the point that DALLAS seemed determined to commit one major gaffe annually during the last half of its iconic run, but that self-debasing slide all seemed to start with what they did to Bel Geddes/Reed and the viewer in November of 1984.</p><p></p><p>That's when the karma changed.</p><p></p><p><img src="https://78.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m19l4c7ecx1r6js0mo1_500.png" alt="" class="fr-fic fr-dii fr-draggable " style="" /></p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Snarky Oracle!, post: 140175, member: 57984"] DALLAS' Season 6 and 7 (per DVD count) were arguably the most solid two-year period the series ever had, the show reaching its creative maturity circa 1983. So say I. Spiritually, the recasting of Miss Ellie (with Donna Reed or anybody) still seems to be the line in the sand, the crack in the veneer, the symptom that something was now wrong behind the camera. When we read during the Summer of 1984 that Miss Ellie was being re-cast, we couldn't believe it --- DALLAS wasn't just a hit, but already a legend in its own time. And they were recasting a core character, the Emmy-winning matriarch?? It was obviously going to be a disaster, so why didn't the executives know that at Lorimar? It's always so frustrating and perplexing when the brass understands their show less than the viewers do. The short-term effect of Mis-Ellie Syndrome was that the otherwise competent Season 8 (per DVD count) had a pall over it, a feeling of depression, a sense that something had now been ruined -- and perhaps that sense of ruination made Bobby's death even more effective (although I wish they'd found a reason to leave poor doomed Donna Reed out of Bobby's hospital bed scene). And maybe the show should have indeed ended there, I'm not sure. For the year Bobby was ostensibly dead, DALLAS' writing team changed (Katzman, Art Lewis, and Paulsen went elsewhere the same time Duffy did) and the KNOTS LANDING writers came in; at first, Season 9 (per DVD count) seemed like it was going to be a rawer, more experimental DALLAS, using techniques, even camera work, Katzman would never have permitted.... That [B]could[/B] have been good, as Katzman had sometimes kept DALLAS on too tight a leash and a little rigid, but, alas, the new team began to show by mid-season that they didn't really know where they wanted to go with their new DALLAS stories --- they'd done great work on KNOTS, but on a somewhat less subtle and nuanced show like DALLAS, the narrative rambling and 'let's-fix-this-series' agenda just became a cluttered mess. It felt smug, and politically correct. Then, when Katzman returned with Duffy for Season 10 (per DVD count) in 1986, Uncle Lenny's malice seemed most involved in his cutting out the previous year as a "dream" (then and now considered [B]the[/B] pre-eminent 'jump-the-shark' moment in all of TV history, and not the minimal controversy the surviving cast tries to make it out to be in recent years) than necessity. There were other ways to do it, even in a single episode; and if they felt they [B]had[/B] to use the dream, making it comatose Bobby's dream still seems the only logical way to do so, but instead they chose to push blame off onto his ex-wife, Pam, which just made the scenario feel five times dumber than it had to. The only reason viewership didn't drop much from the previous year was that, aside from the "I just had a terrible 31-episode dream, Bobby!" opening most people hated, the rest of Season 10 -- Wes Parmalee and BD Calhoun -- was so snappily good, and the closest DALLAS ever came to self-parody which actually worked --- that it remains one of the most re-watchable years the series ever did (and the sole reason I'm happy DALLAS didn't conclude immediately after Bobby's demise). But the next season, Pam's exit was bungled (in part because they lacked the usual spring hiatus planning time in 1987) and the series seemed to know Pam's exit was umbilically-tied to Bobby's much-despised method of resurrection, choosing to sweep her fiery crash almost under the rug to avoid complications, which just displayed contempt for the exiting actress, character, and the audience at home. DALLAS was doing what all the decade's nighttime serial were doing after 1985: turning into daytime soaps. Even the new edited-on-video post-production style made everything look cheap, even KNOTS, which was the only show maintaining creative integrity into the late-'80s. DALLAS began doing the same kinds of silly, shlocky things they used to criticize DYNASTY for... I can handle the range war, Cally as JR's mismatched wife, the timely oil spill, JR's burn-out, even Lady Jessica's murder spree.... but the pacing, tome and details were now [B]all[/B] [B]wrong[/B] (which is what happens when a Howard Lakin replaces a David Paulsen) and Katzman, long-cited as "the brains of DALLAS" happily signed-off on all of it, even though most of it was as bad or worse than anything Peter Dunne did to the show the year Duffy and Katzman were gone. Many years later, Larry Hagman admitted that the last couple of seasons "weren't up to par" and Patrick Duffy conceded that they "lost objectivity" about what qualified as a good story. It got to the point that DALLAS seemed determined to commit one major gaffe annually during the last half of its iconic run, but that self-debasing slide all seemed to start with what they did to Bel Geddes/Reed and the viewer in November of 1984. That's when the karma changed. [IMG]https://78.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m19l4c7ecx1r6js0mo1_500.png[/IMG] [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Who played Sue Ellen in Dallas?
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
It's Become Obvious Why Dallas Went Downhill
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top