Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
JR and Miss Ellie
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="stevew" data-source="post: 220757" data-attributes="member: 130"><p>I found your declaration “Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge” to be a “bash.” You might have just been quoting someone else but you did not state such. Opinions can certainly be just feelings and gut reactions (as your statement seems to be aimed at) but they can also be based on evidence in a subjective case (like pointing out the good and the bad of a character). You seem to have a need to rank things, like stating something is “lowest“ when such is just subjective and being the one to do the subjective ranking gives me the impression you’re “full of yourself.” </p><p></p><p>It wasn’t hard to understand the analogy and I didn’t think it was hard to understand the word survival. Not having a business isn’t an issue of survival, though many use such a word. A business is a want not a need. A business is not a living being. Shady business dealings, no matter what’s going on around you doesn’t make me see a person as a good guy. As I’ve said over and over it’s all shades of grade. But I’m not going to see Jock as a good guy because he did what he had to do to get or keep what he wanted, regardless of Ray or Punks statements. </p><p></p><p>I in fact did NOT judge Jock to be bad. I clearly stated that Jock and JR are viewed as bad, which you you seem to confirm, but they were not only ones - that ALL the characters, even Miss Ellie (the point of the post) had “bad“ tendencies even if the majority don’t label them as such. Again the characters were shades of gray, a complexity I appreciate in the story telling. Thus means that yes Jock and even JR we’re also complex enough to be both good and bad. </p><p></p><p>It seems as if we agree on this shades of grade but in your post you don’t make mention of characteristics and behaviors you go on to weigh weigh such and justify the “bad” as survival. The sum of a man, to understand him and appreciate who he was isn’t to take a total account as if adding up numbers, it’s to recall the good and bad just as they are. I’m sure from what I recall of Jock he would be the first man to say to St. Peter, maybe the only character on Dallas to say, “I don’t need anyone to wash over or justify what I did. I own it all, the good and the bad. One doesn’t take away from the other. It’s all me” - that is the point I’m getting at. </p><p></p><p>Regarding Miss Ellie, not only is she not seen in the same harsh light, I did not get the impression she would take ownership of the bad. I get the impression she’d say “but” a lot when ask to account for the bad. But in the case of both I don’t know what was in their hearts, not even in JR’s heart so I don’t judge any of them as good or bad, just a lot of shades of gray and I don’t feel the need to weigh or rank them (except for the occasional poll for the fun of it, and I do believe I ranked Jock as my most likable). </p><p></p><p>Sometimes in a post it is difficult to be clear and sometimes statements can come off with an unintended tone. I do appreciate the challenges you make to my thinking. These challenges help me to better understand myself as a person and for that I thank you very much.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="stevew, post: 220757, member: 130"] I found your declaration “Opinion is the lowest form of human knowledge” to be a “bash.” You might have just been quoting someone else but you did not state such. Opinions can certainly be just feelings and gut reactions (as your statement seems to be aimed at) but they can also be based on evidence in a subjective case (like pointing out the good and the bad of a character). You seem to have a need to rank things, like stating something is “lowest“ when such is just subjective and being the one to do the subjective ranking gives me the impression you’re “full of yourself.” It wasn’t hard to understand the analogy and I didn’t think it was hard to understand the word survival. Not having a business isn’t an issue of survival, though many use such a word. A business is a want not a need. A business is not a living being. Shady business dealings, no matter what’s going on around you doesn’t make me see a person as a good guy. As I’ve said over and over it’s all shades of grade. But I’m not going to see Jock as a good guy because he did what he had to do to get or keep what he wanted, regardless of Ray or Punks statements. I in fact did NOT judge Jock to be bad. I clearly stated that Jock and JR are viewed as bad, which you you seem to confirm, but they were not only ones - that ALL the characters, even Miss Ellie (the point of the post) had “bad“ tendencies even if the majority don’t label them as such. Again the characters were shades of gray, a complexity I appreciate in the story telling. Thus means that yes Jock and even JR we’re also complex enough to be both good and bad. It seems as if we agree on this shades of grade but in your post you don’t make mention of characteristics and behaviors you go on to weigh weigh such and justify the “bad” as survival. The sum of a man, to understand him and appreciate who he was isn’t to take a total account as if adding up numbers, it’s to recall the good and bad just as they are. I’m sure from what I recall of Jock he would be the first man to say to St. Peter, maybe the only character on Dallas to say, “I don’t need anyone to wash over or justify what I did. I own it all, the good and the bad. One doesn’t take away from the other. It’s all me” - that is the point I’m getting at. Regarding Miss Ellie, not only is she not seen in the same harsh light, I did not get the impression she would take ownership of the bad. I get the impression she’d say “but” a lot when ask to account for the bad. But in the case of both I don’t know what was in their hearts, not even in JR’s heart so I don’t judge any of them as good or bad, just a lot of shades of gray and I don’t feel the need to weigh or rank them (except for the occasional poll for the fun of it, and I do believe I ranked Jock as my most likable). Sometimes in a post it is difficult to be clear and sometimes statements can come off with an unintended tone. I do appreciate the challenges you make to my thinking. These challenges help me to better understand myself as a person and for that I thank you very much. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Who played Sue Ellen in Dallas?
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
JR and Miss Ellie
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top