Season 2, Episode 14: "Home Again"...a lost opportunity

Bobby's the Best

Telly Talk Member
Just finished watching this episode, and I came away once again feeling like it was a lost opportunity to delve deeper into the character building that would have helped loyal viewers to better understand the early years of the Southworth/Ewing history.

During the episode, it is revealed that Miss Ellie's long lost brother, Garrison, has come back to the ranch, with a much younger woman at his side. After JR accuses her of wanting to latch on to a rich old man in the hopes of grabbing a piece of Southfork, she explains to Bobby, Pamela, and eventually the rest of the family, that an ailing Garrison has simply come home to die...to be near family in his final days. But sadly, that is where the story ends. The episode closes with Garrison and Miss Ellie taking a walk around the ranch. The next episode sees JR and Sue Ellen back at the forefront...while Garrison and his nurse, Cathy are noticeably absent...never to be mentioned again.

I feel like the writers missed a golden opportunity here. Gene Evans was a marvelous character actor, and I think the writers shortchanged both him and the viewers by not extending the Garrison story line for maybe three or four episodes, complete with what undoubtedly would have been a brilliantly acted death/goodbye scene involving Evans and BBG.

Thoughts?
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
The show was still episodic at that point.
 

Bobby's the Best

Telly Talk Member
I get that, but that just serves to prove my point. This was a wonderful chance to finally move the show beyond the weekly, episodic genre and really develop it into the night time soap that it eventually became. Instead it's just another useless footnote in "Dallas" history.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I feel like the writers missed a golden opportunity here. Gene Evans was a marvelous character actor, and I think the writers shortchanged both him and the viewers by not extending the Garrison story line for maybe three or four episodes, complete with what undoubtedly would have been a brilliantly acted death/goodbye scene involving Evans and BBG.

Interesting idea. And this would have provided a good opportunity to go deeper into the relationship between Ellie Southworth, Jock Ewing, and Southfork Ranch.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
The show was still episodic at that point.
sure, but certain events and storylines had spanned episodes by that point - Pam’s miscarriage, Cliff running for state Senate, Cliff and Sue Ellen’s affair, the red file and section 40, Ray and Lucy, etc.

Garrison Southworth didn’t have to be another Willie Gust or Rita Briggs (or, dare I say, Guzzler Bennett).
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
And what is wrong with Willie Gust and Rita Briggs, huh. Huh?

But Garrison was supposed to be dead and now he was going to die anyway. Sure, they could have stretched it a little bit but I feel the dilemma had already climaxed in that very episode.

Slightly underwhelmed that he wasn't an impostor who was secretly searching for Hitler's Hell Bell (it's collecting dust in the barn).
 

Toni

Maximum Member
Garrison was mentioned a lot of times (of course, not as often as Jock), most of them by Miss Ellie. He´s the unsung hero of "Dallas"... If I had been the showrunner, I´d have written in a secret daughter of his instead of the Ewing cousins. Though I´d have kept Dack Rambo as the pool cleaner... in his trunks.

1604700472572.png​
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Without the pivotal presence of those two early-season stalwarts, along with the dastardly Edison Faraday Haynes and the fearsome criminal gang who kidnapped Bobby, the ABC of Dallas thread would be 5, 10, possibly even 15 pages shorter!

Do any of you read @Taylor Bennett Jr. 's posts and think he might be the son of Richard Kelton?

It makes perfect sense.
 
I also think it was a mistake to not have him around for longer

I loved Home Again, for one BBG got a bigger and better script to sink her teeth into and i found it emotional at the end

next epiosde, nothing, no mention of Garrison, no update, funeral and that was disappointing

BUT!!

all these years we have been lied too! Miss Ellie and Garrison saw each other a few years earlier before he turned up on the SF doorstep as back from the dead!! 1976 infact and she never let on ;)

They were in as in episode called The Search of a US TV drama
Spencer's plane crashes in a bad storm, leaving it in pieces and he and his three passengers stranded with little water and a broken radio in the hot summer.
and they ended up in hospital together!!!

MTWDXb2.png
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
The problem with acting is there will always be a lot of missed opportunities - people age and you can't just go back and add something, like you could just add a chapter to a book. At best you can go forward and explain what we missed that was never filmed as if it happened just not on camera. I guess we have to use our imagination to fill in the pieces, but I agree with you, it would have been a great opportunity to get to know Miss Ellie and her family better or at least visit with them.
 

Brian Kinney

Telly Talk Addict
Matt Mulhern played Garrison Southworth in Dallas - The Early Years, so in 1986 he wasn't really forgotten as part of Ellie's family story. But yes of all the characters who appeared in the early episodic format seasons he was the one who should've appeared again. For a final farewell with Ellie or some family secret with consequences.

Upper row f.l.t.r.: Dale Midkiff (Jock), David Marshall Grant (Digger) and Matt Mulhern (Garrison); lower row: Molly Hagan (Ellie), Hoyt Axton (Aaron) and Marjie Rynearson (Barbara)

k7wga2uw.jpg


Photo Credit: WB TV
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Yeah, in one of the later seasons Miss Ellie and Clayton are visiting his grave. He was buried on Southfork.
He was my Great GrandFather, I want to pay tribute to him.

Rest In Peace Garrison Southworth, the true owner of Southfork. :(

Here's a rare pic of Garrison about to board the vessel he served on which Miss Ellie thought he subsequently died on. ;)


Gene Evans in Operation Petticoat (1959)  Garrison Southworth.jpg
 

TheDeadBobby

Telly Talk Active Member
They could have created a dream episode panning with Miss Ellie walking into the bathroom and Garrison stepping out of the shower saying 'Good Morning'! With that they could have gone another 3 to 4 episodes and dug in deeper if needed. :popcorn:
 
Top