Should JR Have Ever Been Forgiven For The BD Calhoun Fiasco?

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Of all the things JR did, this was by far the worst. Not only could he have gotten Sue Ellen, John Ross, himself or anybody at Southfork killed, but he did get his private investigator killed. He lost Ewing Oil/his daddy’s company because it was dissolved. Made the Ewing’s the laughing stock of the Dallas oil community. Could have landed himself and Bobby in prison. Not to mention the fight with Clayton that sent him to the hospital.

Re-watching Dallas, I might have to say that the family was enablers to JR. After all this, Bobby defended JR to Pam by saying “what’s done is done.” We’ve seen Bobby go after JR for far less. Sue Ellen was very quick to forgive him and even defended him after he put her son in danger. Even Miss Ellie is very tolerant of JR. The only people that seem to really go at JR and call him out on his BS is Pam, Clayton, Donna and to a certain degree, Ray. People JR ironically considers “outsiders.”
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Of all the things JR did, this was by far the worst. Not only could he have gotten Sue Ellen, John Ross, himself or anybody at Southfork killed, but he did get his private investigator killed. He lost Ewing Oil/his daddy’s company because it was dissolved. Made the Ewing’s the laughing stock of the Dallas oil community. Could have landed himself and Bobby in prison. Not to mention the fight with Clayton that sent him to the hospital.

Re-watching Dallas, I might have to say that the family was enablers to JR. After all this, Bobby defended JR to Pam by saying “what’s done is done.” We’ve seen Bobby go after JR for far less. Sue Ellen was very quick to forgive him and even defended him after he put her son in danger. Even Miss Ellie is very tolerant of JR. The only people that seem to really go at JR and call him out on his BS is Pam, Clayton, Donna and to a certain degree, Ray. People JR ironically considers “outsiders.”

The reason JR got in trouble is because he helped the CIA and then they didn't give him the protection the offered in return! They broke their word. How can they justify asking citizens to help them and then not return the favor? That sends an awful message: "Don't help law enforcement because they won't help you." Remember, the reason Calhoun went after JR is that he told the CIA about Calhoun's plans and Calhoun's men got killed the process.

Then the CIA was negligent about keeping their records secure, they fell into the wrong hands and despite their carelessness, they still refused to take any responsibility for their carelessness. I thought it was disgusting. Why would any citizen be motivated to help law enforcement if they knew that's what you get in return?

JR's idea to have Calhoun blow up oil fields was a bad one, but he rescinded his orders; he changed his mind. If you decide you want to murder someone, but then you change your mind and don't do it, should you be treated the same as if you actually carried out the murder? Should you never be forgiven because you thought about doing it?
 
Last edited:

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
JR's idea to have Calhoun blow up oil fields was a bad one, but he rescinded his orders; he changed his mind. If you decide you want to murder someone, but then you change your mind and don't do it, should you be treated the same as if you actually carried out the murder? Should you never be forgiven because you thought about doing it?

JR was warned multiple times about Calhoun. Heck, even Calhoun himself warned him. I believe he told him once it gets started, there’s no going back. This man was about as extreme as it gets. As smart as JR was supposed to be, what made him think that this was a good idea? He could have started WWIII according to Bobby.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
JR was warned multiple times about Calhoun. Heck, even Calhoun himself warned him. I believe he told him once it gets started, there’s no going back. This man was about as extreme as it gets. As smart as JR was supposed to be, what made him think that this was a good idea? He could have started WWIII according to Bobby.

Yeah, I thought it was out of character and they were creating drama for the sake of drama. This type of thing began with the Angelica Nero storyline in season 9. Dallas was at its best in the first 8 seasons when the stories were local in nature, about Southfork and the Texas oil industry and the Barnes-Ewing feud. That's when they were still believable. Getting involved in these unbelievable international stories was the beginning of the mentality of "How do we make the next storyline bigger, more shocking and more spectacular than the last"? That's a bad direction to go because eventually you get to where you can't top yourself anymore and there's no direction to go but backwards. They did things like bring Bobby back from the dead, said it was all a dream and those types of things killed the credibility of the show.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Don’t forget that ultimately it was Mrs Scottfield spilling the beans to Wendell that got JR caught. If Bobby had been more sympathetic to her then she wouldn’t have squealed to Wendell.

Swami
 
Top