Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Global Telly Talk
General TV
World Cup of Soaps
The World Cup of Dallas
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Kenny Coyote" data-source="post: 109802" data-attributes="member: 102"><p>I'm taking a different approach than I have seen some use to choose a character they would like to win. I'm not going to judge who should win by comparing each character's weakest moment or weakest season and then choosing the character whose worst time was less bad. I'm choosing based on criteria drawn from what I consider each character's best moments and best seasons.</p><p></p><p>Miss Ellie wins this because as good as Bobby was, Ellie edges out Bobby on the quality of her best performances. Some of her best scenes were with Jock. Shortly after the episode "Bypass" when Jock suffered a heart attack, there was an episode named "Survival" in which there was reason for Ellie to believe both J.R. and Bobby might have died in a plane crash. Ellie was amazing with the vigilance with which she protected Jock from suffering any extra strain on his recently operated upon heart, by keeping the news from him until she could find out a definitive answer as to the fate of Bobby and JR.</p><p></p><p>She tried her best to keep Jock from finding out two of his sons might bed dead. When a reporter trespassed on Southfork in order to try to capitalize upon a grief stricken mother by trying to interview her for his newspaper about the possibility that JR and Bobby might have died in a plane crash. he reaction was to tell Ray to get a shotgun.. She asked the, by now, humbled and terrified reporter: "Do you know what we do to vultures around here"? She went on to tell him if he didn't leave at once she'd fill him full of buckshot. This was the kind of passion with which she was capable of protecting Jock when he had just had open heart surgery, and the passion with which she would have protected any of her sons as well.</p><p></p><p>When Ellie herself was in a crisis she was extremely believable as, for example, a woman who had just had a mastectomy and felt as if she were now "deformed" as she put it. Bobby could certainly exude pain in times of a crisis but with Miss Ellie it seemed especially real, as if these types of things were really happening to Barbara Bel Geddes. </p><p></p><p>I also have to give Barbara Bel Geddes' portrayal of Miss Ellie the nod with respect to longevity and commitment to the show. Unlike some other characters, Ellie didn't die in Dallas or run away from her family never to be seen again. The actors behind those characters showed they didn't have the same loyalty to Dallas as Barbara Bel Geddes did in much the same way that Miss Ellie was fiercely loyal to her land - to Southfork. While Bobby "died" or at least sure seemed to die at the end of season 8 and Pam ran away from her family in early season 11 never to return home, just so the actors playing those characters could try to find roles to play that they apparently held in higher regard than their roles in Dallas (or why leave?), Barbara Bel Geddes showed the same loyalty towards Dallas that Miss Ellie showed towards Southfork. The only reason she missed season 8 was because of medical necessity. As soon as her health enabled her to return, she did!</p><p></p><p>Miss Ellie loved having her entire family live with her at Southfork, even though her sons Bobby and JR were adults and later on, her grandchild Lucy continued to live at Southfork after she had turned 18. In the society of The United States, it is quite unusual for three generations of a family to live together, but just imagine being in a family where everyone had plenty of money to move out on his own but instead chose to stay together because they loved each other so much that they preferred to stay together! </p><p></p><p>That's wonderful and I can't imagine how much drama the show would have lost if they had all lived separately instead of all together at Southfork. That was a vital part of Dallas, and that southern tradition of several generations all living together in a large house, reminiscent of Gone With The Wind's O'Hara family who were wealthy yet all loved together in a big house with its own name - Tara - made Dallas considerably better than it would have been had they all lived in different houses spread across the state of Texas, as so many families these days do tend to not just move out on their own but often move hundreds or even thousands of miles away from each other. Miss Ellie and Jock, but especially Miss Ellie made sure her family stayed together and we were all far better off because of the fascinating social dynamics created by the Ewings all living together.</p><p></p><p>Congratulations Miss Ellie!</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Kenny Coyote, post: 109802, member: 102"] I'm taking a different approach than I have seen some use to choose a character they would like to win. I'm not going to judge who should win by comparing each character's weakest moment or weakest season and then choosing the character whose worst time was less bad. I'm choosing based on criteria drawn from what I consider each character's best moments and best seasons. Miss Ellie wins this because as good as Bobby was, Ellie edges out Bobby on the quality of her best performances. Some of her best scenes were with Jock. Shortly after the episode "Bypass" when Jock suffered a heart attack, there was an episode named "Survival" in which there was reason for Ellie to believe both J.R. and Bobby might have died in a plane crash. Ellie was amazing with the vigilance with which she protected Jock from suffering any extra strain on his recently operated upon heart, by keeping the news from him until she could find out a definitive answer as to the fate of Bobby and JR. She tried her best to keep Jock from finding out two of his sons might bed dead. When a reporter trespassed on Southfork in order to try to capitalize upon a grief stricken mother by trying to interview her for his newspaper about the possibility that JR and Bobby might have died in a plane crash. he reaction was to tell Ray to get a shotgun.. She asked the, by now, humbled and terrified reporter: "Do you know what we do to vultures around here"? She went on to tell him if he didn't leave at once she'd fill him full of buckshot. This was the kind of passion with which she was capable of protecting Jock when he had just had open heart surgery, and the passion with which she would have protected any of her sons as well. When Ellie herself was in a crisis she was extremely believable as, for example, a woman who had just had a mastectomy and felt as if she were now "deformed" as she put it. Bobby could certainly exude pain in times of a crisis but with Miss Ellie it seemed especially real, as if these types of things were really happening to Barbara Bel Geddes. I also have to give Barbara Bel Geddes' portrayal of Miss Ellie the nod with respect to longevity and commitment to the show. Unlike some other characters, Ellie didn't die in Dallas or run away from her family never to be seen again. The actors behind those characters showed they didn't have the same loyalty to Dallas as Barbara Bel Geddes did in much the same way that Miss Ellie was fiercely loyal to her land - to Southfork. While Bobby "died" or at least sure seemed to die at the end of season 8 and Pam ran away from her family in early season 11 never to return home, just so the actors playing those characters could try to find roles to play that they apparently held in higher regard than their roles in Dallas (or why leave?), Barbara Bel Geddes showed the same loyalty towards Dallas that Miss Ellie showed towards Southfork. The only reason she missed season 8 was because of medical necessity. As soon as her health enabled her to return, she did! Miss Ellie loved having her entire family live with her at Southfork, even though her sons Bobby and JR were adults and later on, her grandchild Lucy continued to live at Southfork after she had turned 18. In the society of The United States, it is quite unusual for three generations of a family to live together, but just imagine being in a family where everyone had plenty of money to move out on his own but instead chose to stay together because they loved each other so much that they preferred to stay together! That's wonderful and I can't imagine how much drama the show would have lost if they had all lived separately instead of all together at Southfork. That was a vital part of Dallas, and that southern tradition of several generations all living together in a large house, reminiscent of Gone With The Wind's O'Hara family who were wealthy yet all loved together in a big house with its own name - Tara - made Dallas considerably better than it would have been had they all lived in different houses spread across the state of Texas, as so many families these days do tend to not just move out on their own but often move hundreds or even thousands of miles away from each other. Miss Ellie and Jock, but especially Miss Ellie made sure her family stayed together and we were all far better off because of the fascinating social dynamics created by the Ewings all living together. Congratulations Miss Ellie! [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
What month follows July?
Post reply
Forums
Global Telly Talk
General TV
World Cup of Soaps
The World Cup of Dallas
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top