Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Times when you agreed with the villain.....
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Jabari Lamar" data-source="post: 171406" data-attributes="member: 2208"><p>Agreed, and yes this could mainly be an argument of semantics, but I think it's because antihero has the word "hero" in it, so it's hard to think of J.R. that way. He was my favorite character, and the reason I stuck with the show right throught to the end, even as his character got somewhat watered down by bad writing, but he was a clearly a <em>villain</em>. Sure he had his good moments, where he would occasionally be shown to care for others (including Bobby and Sue Ellen, whom he was often at odds with), but he was mostly a bad guy who did bad things. The fact that many of us liked J.R. didn't make him any less of a villain, any more so than fans of Star Wars who like Darth Vader, or Tony Soprano from The Sopranos.</p><p></p><p>When I think of an antihero, I think of someone who does bad things for good reasons. Putting this in a context of comic-books, Batman and The Punisher are both vigilantes and therefore technically criminals. But Batman beats up and captures bad guys and then turns them over to the proper authorities, thus he's considered a hero, while The Punisher muders bad guys, and thus he is an anti-hero. Going back to TV protagonists, I think Walter White from Breaking Bad could more accurately be called an antihero, as his villainous acts started from a desire to take care of his family after his impending death. While J.R. was simply greedy and selfish. And while some of his actions (Double-crossing, cheating, lying, etc.) could be attributed to simply trying to win in the cut-throat oil business, many of his other actions, including the adultery and rapes, had no justification beyond his own desires. And even the idea that he drew that line at murder, I look at that more as a sign of the times. That probably would have been considered a step too far for a TV show protagonist in the 80's, but not so now. I think if Dallas were created today, J.R. probably wouldn't be above an occasional murder, similar to Frank Underwood or Lucious Lyon.</p><p></p><p>And even then, while J.R. never directly killed anyone, he certainly was shown to not be above taking actions which would likely lead to people's death, such as hiring a mercenario to blow up Saudi Arabian oil wells, and financing a coup in a foreign country. Not to mention how he seemed to relish in the attempted suicides of Cliff Barnes and Edgar Randolph, both of which were caused by his actions.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Jabari Lamar, post: 171406, member: 2208"] Agreed, and yes this could mainly be an argument of semantics, but I think it's because antihero has the word "hero" in it, so it's hard to think of J.R. that way. He was my favorite character, and the reason I stuck with the show right throught to the end, even as his character got somewhat watered down by bad writing, but he was a clearly a [I]villain[/I]. Sure he had his good moments, where he would occasionally be shown to care for others (including Bobby and Sue Ellen, whom he was often at odds with), but he was mostly a bad guy who did bad things. The fact that many of us liked J.R. didn't make him any less of a villain, any more so than fans of Star Wars who like Darth Vader, or Tony Soprano from The Sopranos. When I think of an antihero, I think of someone who does bad things for good reasons. Putting this in a context of comic-books, Batman and The Punisher are both vigilantes and therefore technically criminals. But Batman beats up and captures bad guys and then turns them over to the proper authorities, thus he's considered a hero, while The Punisher muders bad guys, and thus he is an anti-hero. Going back to TV protagonists, I think Walter White from Breaking Bad could more accurately be called an antihero, as his villainous acts started from a desire to take care of his family after his impending death. While J.R. was simply greedy and selfish. And while some of his actions (Double-crossing, cheating, lying, etc.) could be attributed to simply trying to win in the cut-throat oil business, many of his other actions, including the adultery and rapes, had no justification beyond his own desires. And even the idea that he drew that line at murder, I look at that more as a sign of the times. That probably would have been considered a step too far for a TV show protagonist in the 80's, but not so now. I think if Dallas were created today, J.R. probably wouldn't be above an occasional murder, similar to Frank Underwood or Lucious Lyon. And even then, while J.R. never directly killed anyone, he certainly was shown to not be above taking actions which would likely lead to people's death, such as hiring a mercenario to blow up Saudi Arabian oil wells, and financing a coup in a foreign country. Not to mention how he seemed to relish in the attempted suicides of Cliff Barnes and Edgar Randolph, both of which were caused by his actions. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
What month follows July?
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Times when you agreed with the villain.....
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top