Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Was April Killed Off In Hope For Pam Return?
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Kenny Coyote" data-source="post: 135651" data-attributes="member: 102"><p>Remember on an earlier post of mine on this thread I wrote about how I agreed with someone (maybe it's Barbara Fan) who said that JR and Bobby alone couldn't carry the show? I replied to her post and here's an excerpt from my post: "JR and Bobby alone couldn't carry the show because they were both too likable. You need someone who is going to create the conflict that drives the story. Since people loved the Ewing family and Cliff was obsessed with destroying the Ewings, there was tremendous conflict and so the early and middle seasons were great. Cliff eventually learned his lesson - revenge is a waste of time. It was good for Cliff but bad for the show. Then they had to replace Cliff as the bad guy with Carter McKay and he couldn't do nearly as good of a job."</p><p></p><p>Sure, dramas often involve feuds and even very bitter feuds, but I think the above explains that just because a character is crucial to the show and he's very bitter doesn't mean I, or other people watching it will necessarily like someone who is bitter and crucial to the show. That character may be their most despised character on the show. You want people to feel strongly about the characters. If people love them, great. If they hate them, that's great too. If they feel indifferent about them, that's a problem.</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p>No, not even close. JR is going to defend Ewing Oil if somebody tries to bring harm to it and he'll defend his family if he senses a threat from the outside. Cliff was obsessed with hurting both, it's practically all Cliff thought about. As a result of his obsession, Cliff was almost always talking about the Ewings and often specifically JR Ewing. It got to the point where he had nothing else at all going on his life. Sure he married Jamie, but why? So he could get ahold of the share of Ewing Oil she was entitled to and that's how absolutely bitter and obsessed with trying to ruin the Ewings Cliff was. before Jamie he was going out with Mandy. What did he do with her? Used her as a sort of spy whose job was to pretend to befriend JR so that she could get information from him to give to Cliff. Of course Mandy got tired of being used "like a puppet" as she put it and how did Cliff handle it when she got so fed up with his obsession that she was going to leave him? Cliff said "Mandy, I really need you now. I need you more than ever." The audience could tell she needed to be told this - to know that Cliff loved her and needed her for much better reasons than getting information from JR. You could see she was considering changing her mind about leaving until Cliff added that the reason he needed her more than ever was to keep pumping JR for information! The man was absolutely clueless, oblivious. </p><p></p><p>It really doesn't take a lot of discernment to see how different J.R. was from Cliff. J.R. talked about Cliff as little as possible. Instead of spending his time obsessed with Cliff and letting the rest of his life go to hell as a result, J.R. spent his time doing what he enjoyed and you could tell. He'd always wanted to run Ewing Oil just like Jock had and JR was living out his life's dream in doing so. Cliff went to law school because he din't want to work in the oil business. So why did he end up in the oil business despite wanting to be a lawyer? To fight yet another losing battle against the Ewings. It would be comical if it weren't so sad. In sharp contrast with Cliff's bitterness and the misery it caused Cliff, J.R. was always smiling. J.R. was loving life and it showed. I think most people like a happy person. I know I do.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Kenny Coyote, post: 135651, member: 102"] Remember on an earlier post of mine on this thread I wrote about how I agreed with someone (maybe it's Barbara Fan) who said that JR and Bobby alone couldn't carry the show? I replied to her post and here's an excerpt from my post: "JR and Bobby alone couldn't carry the show because they were both too likable. You need someone who is going to create the conflict that drives the story. Since people loved the Ewing family and Cliff was obsessed with destroying the Ewings, there was tremendous conflict and so the early and middle seasons were great. Cliff eventually learned his lesson - revenge is a waste of time. It was good for Cliff but bad for the show. Then they had to replace Cliff as the bad guy with Carter McKay and he couldn't do nearly as good of a job." Sure, dramas often involve feuds and even very bitter feuds, but I think the above explains that just because a character is crucial to the show and he's very bitter doesn't mean I, or other people watching it will necessarily like someone who is bitter and crucial to the show. That character may be their most despised character on the show. You want people to feel strongly about the characters. If people love them, great. If they hate them, that's great too. If they feel indifferent about them, that's a problem. No, not even close. JR is going to defend Ewing Oil if somebody tries to bring harm to it and he'll defend his family if he senses a threat from the outside. Cliff was obsessed with hurting both, it's practically all Cliff thought about. As a result of his obsession, Cliff was almost always talking about the Ewings and often specifically JR Ewing. It got to the point where he had nothing else at all going on his life. Sure he married Jamie, but why? So he could get ahold of the share of Ewing Oil she was entitled to and that's how absolutely bitter and obsessed with trying to ruin the Ewings Cliff was. before Jamie he was going out with Mandy. What did he do with her? Used her as a sort of spy whose job was to pretend to befriend JR so that she could get information from him to give to Cliff. Of course Mandy got tired of being used "like a puppet" as she put it and how did Cliff handle it when she got so fed up with his obsession that she was going to leave him? Cliff said "Mandy, I really need you now. I need you more than ever." The audience could tell she needed to be told this - to know that Cliff loved her and needed her for much better reasons than getting information from JR. You could see she was considering changing her mind about leaving until Cliff added that the reason he needed her more than ever was to keep pumping JR for information! The man was absolutely clueless, oblivious. It really doesn't take a lot of discernment to see how different J.R. was from Cliff. J.R. talked about Cliff as little as possible. Instead of spending his time obsessed with Cliff and letting the rest of his life go to hell as a result, J.R. spent his time doing what he enjoyed and you could tell. He'd always wanted to run Ewing Oil just like Jock had and JR was living out his life's dream in doing so. Cliff went to law school because he din't want to work in the oil business. So why did he end up in the oil business despite wanting to be a lawyer? To fight yet another losing battle against the Ewings. It would be comical if it weren't so sad. In sharp contrast with Cliff's bitterness and the misery it caused Cliff, J.R. was always smiling. J.R. was loving life and it showed. I think most people like a happy person. I know I do. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
6 + 4 =
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Was April Killed Off In Hope For Pam Return?
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top