Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Were The Barnes/Wentworths Mentality Stable?
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Karin" data-source="post: 150223" data-attributes="member: 57167"><p>Well I think you need to look at what has caused the characters to act the way that they did.</p><p></p><p>Like for instance, the reason why <em>Rebecca</em> started hating the Ewings and got involved with the fued was because JR pushed her son so far that he tried to commit suicide. So instead of laying blame on herself and wondering if her abandoning Cliff as a small child had caused this, she found a scapegoat JR Ewing and then decided to side with Cliff in the Barnes-Ewing fued. I don't think Rebecca was mentally unstable. There is nothing on the show that suggest that she was anything but a strong woman, a survivor. I guess in some ways she was a cold woman, considering that she was able to abandon her two young children for so many years. Yet she did love all her children. So she was not without emotions.</p><p></p><p><em>Cliff'</em>s biggest weakness was when he attempted suicide. I doubt he wanted to die though. It was merely a cry for help since he wanted his mother and Sue Ellen and everyone else who had turned their backs on him to release how badly they had hurt him.Then as for the fued with JR that wasn't one sided as JR went after Cliff too.</p><p></p><p><em>Pam</em> sometimes had depressions. I think what set it off was not knowing her true identity and feeling like she'd been lied to her whole life. The man who she thought was her father wasn't her biological father and that shook her to the core of her being. I think most adults would react badly to that kind of news. The most crazy thing Pam ever did was standing on that rooftop threatening to commit suicide. That was brought on by her feeling inadequete as a woman and wanting to have a child really badly. She needed to be a mother and the psychologist explained it with that Pam wanted to give a baby everything she had lacked as a child. She wanted her child to have the stable upbringing she was denied. So she needed to have a baby. Of course when she adopted Christopher Pam got well.</p><p></p><p><em>Katherine </em>well she was driven by jealousy. After having been her mother's only child for so many years she suddenly had two siblings to compete with for her mother's love. She didn't like that. Also when her mother died she blamed Cliff for her death and began to hate her brother. She also wanted Bobby and when she couldn't have him she tried to kill him since she didn't want anyone else to have him. I'd say out of them Katherine was the one who had the biggest mental issues. Maybe you could say she was temporary insane when she tried to kill Bobby. At the end of the day (since the dream season never happened) she backed off when she saw that Bobby and Pam had reconciled. She just disappeared and didn't reappear until Pam's accident. Then Pam disappears from the hospital and Bobby receives a letter. Considering that Katherine's faked one letter to Bobby before from Pam that ought to have been a warning flag but it wasn't...</p><p></p><p>We are getting off topic here and although it can be argued that yes the Barnes/Wentworth clan all had some issues that could mean that they were mentally unstable. I don't think it's that black and white since there were reasons that explains why they felt that way and acted the way they did. I think this proves once again how well fleshed out the characters on the show were. They were complex just like people in real life are.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Karin, post: 150223, member: 57167"] Well I think you need to look at what has caused the characters to act the way that they did. Like for instance, the reason why [I]Rebecca[/I] started hating the Ewings and got involved with the fued was because JR pushed her son so far that he tried to commit suicide. So instead of laying blame on herself and wondering if her abandoning Cliff as a small child had caused this, she found a scapegoat JR Ewing and then decided to side with Cliff in the Barnes-Ewing fued. I don't think Rebecca was mentally unstable. There is nothing on the show that suggest that she was anything but a strong woman, a survivor. I guess in some ways she was a cold woman, considering that she was able to abandon her two young children for so many years. Yet she did love all her children. So she was not without emotions. [I]Cliff'[/I]s biggest weakness was when he attempted suicide. I doubt he wanted to die though. It was merely a cry for help since he wanted his mother and Sue Ellen and everyone else who had turned their backs on him to release how badly they had hurt him.Then as for the fued with JR that wasn't one sided as JR went after Cliff too. [I]Pam[/I] sometimes had depressions. I think what set it off was not knowing her true identity and feeling like she'd been lied to her whole life. The man who she thought was her father wasn't her biological father and that shook her to the core of her being. I think most adults would react badly to that kind of news. The most crazy thing Pam ever did was standing on that rooftop threatening to commit suicide. That was brought on by her feeling inadequete as a woman and wanting to have a child really badly. She needed to be a mother and the psychologist explained it with that Pam wanted to give a baby everything she had lacked as a child. She wanted her child to have the stable upbringing she was denied. So she needed to have a baby. Of course when she adopted Christopher Pam got well. [I]Katherine [/I]well she was driven by jealousy. After having been her mother's only child for so many years she suddenly had two siblings to compete with for her mother's love. She didn't like that. Also when her mother died she blamed Cliff for her death and began to hate her brother. She also wanted Bobby and when she couldn't have him she tried to kill him since she didn't want anyone else to have him. I'd say out of them Katherine was the one who had the biggest mental issues. Maybe you could say she was temporary insane when she tried to kill Bobby. At the end of the day (since the dream season never happened) she backed off when she saw that Bobby and Pam had reconciled. She just disappeared and didn't reappear until Pam's accident. Then Pam disappears from the hospital and Bobby receives a letter. Considering that Katherine's faked one letter to Bobby before from Pam that ought to have been a warning flag but it wasn't... We are getting off topic here and although it can be argued that yes the Barnes/Wentworth clan all had some issues that could mean that they were mentally unstable. I don't think it's that black and white since there were reasons that explains why they felt that way and acted the way they did. I think this proves once again how well fleshed out the characters on the show were. They were complex just like people in real life are. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
6 + 4 =
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Were The Barnes/Wentworths Mentality Stable?
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top