What if Gary & Val stayed on Dallas for the series run?

ArchieLucasCarringtonEwing1989

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I'm not sure this has been discussed but what if instead of spinning Gary and Val off onto their own series, they were further integrated into the DALLAS framework?

You could almost achieve David Jacobs original aim at having scenes from a marriage scenario as well as a glossy family saga that DALLAS eventually became.

Before we carry on I understand that Gary and Val needed their own series as there was too much history between them that probably would've overspilled into the relationships of
Bobby and Pam & JR and Sue Ellen, and taken the action away from them.

Would Gary have started his own company in Dallas, and would a friendship blossom between Pam and Val? Plus Lucy having her parents around, disciplining her would be interesting.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I saw Gary as a weak character, certainly not in the same league as Jock and JR but it was this same reason which I found Gary intriguing. If Gary had remained at Southfork I would have liked the writers to explore alternative energies with Gary at the helm. Perhaps write him as somewhat of a nerd. He excelled at school/college with a keen interest in chemistry/science and engineering. He made not have had JR's natural scheming abilities to run Ewing Oil but Gary was smarter than JR intellectually, something which JR hated. Jock had no idea what the hell Gary was doing but quietly admired Gary's successful business as people/businesses and governments began to explore alternative energies, rather than rely on oil.

In the few scenes between Miss Ellie and Val there was a genuine warmth between the two. I see Val developing a strong relationship with Pam since they were both from the wrong side of the tracks. I do however see Val having a prickly relationship with Sue Ellen, which would have been great viewing.

I would not have had a problem with Gary and Val remaining in the series Dallas but....

....where the hell was that extra bedroom at Southfork to accommodate Gary and Val? :lolo:
 

ArchieLucasCarringtonEwing1989

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I saw Gary as a weak character, certainly not in the same league as Jock and JR but it was this same reason which I found Gary intriguing. If Gary had remained at Southfork I would have liked the writers to explore alternative energies with Gary at the helm. Perhaps write him as somewhat of a nerd. He excelled at school/college with a keen interest in chemistry/science and engineering. He made not have had JR's natural scheming abilities to run Ewing Oil but Gary was smarter than JR intellectually, something which JR hated. Jock had no idea what the hell Gary was doing but quietly admired Gary's successful business as people/businesses and governments began to explore alternative energies, rather than rely on oil.

In the few scenes between Miss Ellie and Val there was a genuine warmth between the two. I see Val developing a strong relationship with Pam since they were both from the wrong side of the tracks. I do however see Val having a prickly relationship with Sue Ellen, which would have been great viewing.

I would not have had a problem with Gary and Val remaining in the series Dallas but....

....where the hell was that extra bedroom at Southfork to accommodate Gary and Val? :lolo:

In the pilot JR mentioned that Gary and Val had their own cottage so perhaps they could've lived there perhaps, or maybe Gary and Val would buy their own ranch with Lucy which was near to Southfork, like Ray and Donna.

I also would've liked to have seen Gary set up his own company outside of oil, away from JR's playing field, or maybe he could turn his ranch into a business.

I would like to have seen what his relationship with Ray would've been like, as it was never really developed since Gary was away for most of Ray's life, they're also the closest in age out of the Ewing brothers, with JR being at least 8-10 years older than Gary and Bobby was about five years younger than Ray, I think they themselves, were only a year apart in age.

I would imagine Gary being slightly envious of Ray had he stayed, Ray being not only illegitimate but he also had Jock's love way before it was revealed he was his son, and also Ray had a close relationship with Miss Ellie, because he loved the land, Ray ironically was more Southworth than Ewing at times yet Jock still loved him over Gary, there was no real such rivalry between JR and Bobby on this front as they were both Jock's favourite sons for different reasons.

I would like there to be some sort of underlying bitterness between Gary and Ray, they go into business together but Gary and Ray would have an icy relationship, sort of the opposite of JR and Bobby who while they were rivals they still loved and respected one another and at times even trusted each other where it was needed
Bobby was JR's favourite brother after all despite everything bad that occurred, somehow I don't think it would be the same for Gary and Ray especially if it had come out that Ray slept with Lucy his own half-niece!

In the few times we did see Gary and Ray interact they did seem to like each other but being opposite ends of the country (and on different shows) there wasn't enough bonding time between these two, they're a less extreme version of DYNASTY'S Carrington sister's:
Fallon and Amanda.
 

Willywill316

Telly Talk Newbie
Gary to me as well was weak in comparison to everyone else, including Lucy his daughter. I think if he'd stayed it would've upset the balance of the show and they wouldn't have lasted as long as they did, or eventually Gary would've had to be killed off or "sent away"
 
Gary to me as well was weak in comparison to everyone else

Whenever Gary is mentioned on the Dallas forum there are invariably comments pegging him as terminally weak. I've never been able to get on board with that.

I can understand why Jock would write Gary off as weak - his view of the world being very parochial. But did he truly believe that - or did he get past it? He humbled himself in order to attend Gary's wedding after all. Family or not, Jock Ewing wouldn't do that for someone he didn't respect.

And I can understand why JR would say that he thought Gary was weak. Personally I never thought JR truly believed this either. He parroted Jock's criticism because it reinforced Jock's desire to have no contact with his middle son and kept Gary away. Give a dog a bad name, and all that. But pretty much every time they interacted it appeared to me that JR wanted to keep Gary away from Texas because he was afraid of him to the point of irrationality. And he feared Gary because he knew there was so much more to him than weakness.

Gary was weak at times, certainly. Even fifteen years down the line from his introduction. And I can throw in intermittently frustrating, dishonest and unlikeable. But weren't all the characters sometimes? He was also a speaker of truth, noble and willing to fight for what he believed in. He just happened not to believe in a great deal of what his family were about.

Admittedly my view is also based on having seen his growth on Knots Landing, something that's not so evident on Dallas.




it was this same reason which I found Gary intriguing.

That's it exactly.

If he'd been introduced as a self-actualised "strong" character, where would be the journey?
 
Last edited:

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I certainly think it would have been interesting in the earlier seasons to have Gary and Val present. I especially liked the rare scenes with Gary and Sue Ellen, who were equally black-sheep by way of their addiction. I also think maybe Val and Jenna could have struck more of a friendship than Val and Pam for two reasons (at least): 1. Val and Jenna were both childhood sweethearts of the Ewing brothers, which they could have bonded over; and 2. Val could have butt heads with Pam, who very early on in the show acted as a maternal figure for Lucy, which would have undoubtedly caused some envy had Val stuck around.
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Gary and Valene being on Dallas might have been interesting to see. I had hoped they would have been on Dallas TNT. That could have been good then I am reminded that the writers were not interested in the Ewing Family so they would not have added more Ewings.
 
Top