Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Dallas Season Reviews
What went wrong -- and right -- with DALLAS?
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Snarky Oracle!" data-source="post: 27411" data-attributes="member: 57984"><p><strong>Season 12:</strong></p><p></p><p>This season finds a too-campy humor in full-flower as Sue Ellen secretly produces a theatrical motion picture about her life at Southfork (not a bad idea, in concept); J.R. marries a hillbilly girl, Cally (Cathy Podewell), less than half his age; a nearby rancher, Carter McKay (George Kennedy) begins sabotaging activities at Southfork, creating something akin to a modern-day range-war --- as a now-single Bobby is drawn to McKay's daughter in another potential Romeo & Juliet scenario (which they should have pursued); and the Ewing brothers go to Europe, then Moscow, to do big (if vague) business.</p><p></p><p>These plots were rather decent, actually, if only the show surrounding them still felt solid, but, regrettably, the cracks were becoming fully visible. Somehow, it all just wasn't holding together... everything felt rushed, out-of-pace... motivations were beginning to seem contrived... Wealthy oil baron J.R. held captive on a chain gang? Miss Ellie suggesting Bobby take in Cliff Barnes at Ewing Oil?? Okay, maybe, as a conciliatory gesture --- but to have the idea come up and be decided on in a 10 second exchange in the Southfork living room without any sense of dramatic pause as to the gravity of such a decision, or to the history involved?</p><p></p><p>Sue Ellen shelves her movie, quite illogically, threatening to release it if J.R. misbehaves or neglects his new bride, Cally, with no explanation as to how the financial backers of her picture might feel about this. But, no fool, Sue Ellen is out the door with no intention of returning. She's getting out just in time.</p><p></p><p><strong>Season 13 & 14:</strong></p><p></p><p>Beginning in 1989, the final two seasons of Dallas saw the once-giant series slide into the same pattern adopted by most bad soaps: stuff just happens...</p><p></p><p>Plots are clearly from boredom and are barely fleshed-out if not aborted altogether (why did Sue Ellen, after shelving her movie when she left town, never live up to the ultimatum she'd put to J.R. about when and why she might distribute it?? Just think about the dramatic potential <em>there</em>!). Other stories appear with little or no <em>raison d'etre</em> and then dissolve much the same; extraneous bit characters abide giving the impression that the producers might possibly have an idea in mind for them -- but to no avail; relationships seem forced (one never bought Bobby and April as a couple, let alone their doomed wedding in Paris), and the atmosphere of the Ewings residing at Southfork Ranch is no longer believable at all --- and the show doesn't even seem to be trying <em>to convince</em> us anymore!</p><p></p><p>Just as telling, the show has a "new" theme design beginning with the Fall of '89 --- only it utilizes the same shots of the city skyline as the previous design, yet now those shots are re-arranged and clumsily interspersed with head-shots of the cast matching every drum beat like something some kid might put on Youtube years later. But these opening titles now include the young, minor players, presumably in a transparent attempt to trick the fans (or satisfy the network) into thinking the series was still fresh or hip... It wasn't successful.</p><p></p><p>In fairness, the 1989-90 season started out with promise, the oil tanker spill (in the immediate wake of the factual Exxon Valdez disaster) almost coming off. Then, J.R. meets the grown son he never knew he had, James (Sasha Mitchell); Pam's look-alike (Margaret Michaels) haunts Bobby who thinks she may really be his ex-wife; and Cliff Barnes, now estranged from Ewing Oil, legally pursues J.R. for the latter's involvement in that huge oil-spill... Once again, these were good ideas, but somehow it all seemed for naught..</p><p></p><p>Perhaps the biggest bungle of the '89-90 season was the serial-killer storyline in which a menagerie of the Clayton's business associates are snuffed-out in a repetition of stupidly bizarre death scenes. The murderess? None other than Lady Jessica Montfort, Clayton's psycho sister fresh from the mental hospital! Jessica had been a terrific character and it was good to see the scenery-chewing Miss Smith reprise her creepy role (and it was quite appropriate that DALLAS turn macabre in its closing era, just as David Paulsen had done with DYNASTY when he tried to save <em>that</em> messed-up show in its final season) but, missing the tanker entirely, these DALLAS killings are played more for laughs and less for horror, the skeletons-from-the-closets possibilities completely lost; the Ewing Family Story, amazingly, is not furthered or in any way enhanced.</p><p></p><p>The final year, the 1990-91 season, was, to be frank, a bit pathetic -- the stories, the stunt casting (Susan Lucci, Barbara "I Dream of Jeannie" Eden)... Susan Lucci kills April, Michelle kills Susan Lucci. And who cares? By the time Joel Grey guest-starred as J.R.'s guardian devil in the show's May 1991 finale, one found oneself asking: "is this what the present bosses wanted to control DALLAS for --- these last few seasons ??"</p><p></p><p>The epic serial had become merely epically silly... only nobody was laughing (or, going by the ratings, watching anymore).</p><p></p><p>The brass believed that Bobby and J.R. were the only two characters that mattered to the show, the show's antipathy for strong women became far more pointed in its later years. They proved it by letting Miss Principal get away far-too easily in 1987, firing Susan Howard the same year, firing Linda Gray in 1989 (the P.R. statement was that she quit), firing Barbara Bel Geddes and firing Charlene Tilton <em>twice</em>!!</p><p></p><p>Apparently, the only 'strong' females allowed anymore were pistol-totin' babes.</p><p></p><p>Eventually, even the other guys weren't safe: Steven Kanaly, fired in 1989... Perhaps the show kept Ken Kercheval and Howard Keel around just so J.R. could occasionally snarl at somebody who was (or had been) <em>sort of</em> an in-law--- especially since brother Bobby, by series' end, was just about the only remaining true Ewing relation...</p><p></p><p>Of course, slipping ratings means decreasing profits which, in turn, means less money with which to produce the show, especially with Larry Hagman's salary still soaring; the more established supporting actors -- or those with biggish salaries yet deemed "disposable" by executives -- were being released.</p><p></p><p>That is, as they say, show business. Budgets change. But allowing the show to turn into an overt sitcom, as Katzman fully believed DALLAS should be a cartoon, meant that the series had now become a parody of something that was already a parody. Yes, a show like DALLAS can and must offer humor and satire, but, as DALLAS creator David Jacobs once observed, that humor has to be kept on the down-low, with the project played absolutely straight on the surface.</p><p></p><p>Obviously, Katzman didn't agree. And crashing ratings didn't seem to faze him. In fact, years after the series' dismal 1991 conclusion, Lenny Katzman stated that his 'biggest mistake ever' in DALLAS was killing off April, a secondary character who'd died in the final season when no one was even watching the show anymore.</p><p></p><p>In its concluding seasons, DALLAS should have turned dusty and dark (similar to the tone of the 2012 reboot, despite the new show's continuity issues), showing the Ewing empire, through scandal and corruption, crumble --- <em>really</em> crumble, thus allowing the saga to somehow come full-circle; instead, they let the show <em>itself </em>crumble, grasping apathetically in order to churn-out yet another episode, yet another season, yet another 19-year-old for the old-guys to sleep with for no particular reason.</p><p></p><p>The later reunion movies, J.R. RETURNS (1996) and the even lesser WAR OF THE EWINGS (1998) seemed much too much like the very last days of the weekly series, only even weaker. Everything was played overtly for laughs at the expense of anything else.</p><p></p><p>The brass, it would seem, were unrepentant.</p><p></p><p>True, DALLAS always had humor even in its peak years, but that was a wry, intelligent humor, the show cynical and wise.... and at a level far from the quasi-titillating, campy fate that would befall it at its sunset, the show having slipped into the state of perpetual and deliberate self-parody Katzman preferred even if the audience didn't.</p><p></p><p>Simply put, the Fat Lady dun sung --- but it seems nobody was listenin'...</p><p></p><p>Of course, who really listens when you're singing in the shower? And, for millions of fans around the world, that's just where DALLAS remains, even today: frozen in time, locked in 1986, forever awaiting a better explanation as to why Bobby is all lathered-up in his ex-wife's bathroom.</p><p></p><p><img src="http://media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/25/c7/a0/25c7a0f23aebacaff6682bee9e41c6db.jpg" alt="" class="fr-fic fr-dii fr-draggable " style="" /></p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Snarky Oracle!, post: 27411, member: 57984"] [B]Season 12:[/B] This season finds a too-campy humor in full-flower as Sue Ellen secretly produces a theatrical motion picture about her life at Southfork (not a bad idea, in concept); J.R. marries a hillbilly girl, Cally (Cathy Podewell), less than half his age; a nearby rancher, Carter McKay (George Kennedy) begins sabotaging activities at Southfork, creating something akin to a modern-day range-war --- as a now-single Bobby is drawn to McKay's daughter in another potential Romeo & Juliet scenario (which they should have pursued); and the Ewing brothers go to Europe, then Moscow, to do big (if vague) business. These plots were rather decent, actually, if only the show surrounding them still felt solid, but, regrettably, the cracks were becoming fully visible. Somehow, it all just wasn't holding together... everything felt rushed, out-of-pace... motivations were beginning to seem contrived... Wealthy oil baron J.R. held captive on a chain gang? Miss Ellie suggesting Bobby take in Cliff Barnes at Ewing Oil?? Okay, maybe, as a conciliatory gesture --- but to have the idea come up and be decided on in a 10 second exchange in the Southfork living room without any sense of dramatic pause as to the gravity of such a decision, or to the history involved? Sue Ellen shelves her movie, quite illogically, threatening to release it if J.R. misbehaves or neglects his new bride, Cally, with no explanation as to how the financial backers of her picture might feel about this. But, no fool, Sue Ellen is out the door with no intention of returning. She's getting out just in time. [B]Season 13 & 14:[/B] Beginning in 1989, the final two seasons of Dallas saw the once-giant series slide into the same pattern adopted by most bad soaps: stuff just happens... Plots are clearly from boredom and are barely fleshed-out if not aborted altogether (why did Sue Ellen, after shelving her movie when she left town, never live up to the ultimatum she'd put to J.R. about when and why she might distribute it?? Just think about the dramatic potential [I]there[/I]!). Other stories appear with little or no [I]raison d'etre[/I] and then dissolve much the same; extraneous bit characters abide giving the impression that the producers might possibly have an idea in mind for them -- but to no avail; relationships seem forced (one never bought Bobby and April as a couple, let alone their doomed wedding in Paris), and the atmosphere of the Ewings residing at Southfork Ranch is no longer believable at all --- and the show doesn't even seem to be trying [I]to convince[/I] us anymore! Just as telling, the show has a "new" theme design beginning with the Fall of '89 --- only it utilizes the same shots of the city skyline as the previous design, yet now those shots are re-arranged and clumsily interspersed with head-shots of the cast matching every drum beat like something some kid might put on Youtube years later. But these opening titles now include the young, minor players, presumably in a transparent attempt to trick the fans (or satisfy the network) into thinking the series was still fresh or hip... It wasn't successful. In fairness, the 1989-90 season started out with promise, the oil tanker spill (in the immediate wake of the factual Exxon Valdez disaster) almost coming off. Then, J.R. meets the grown son he never knew he had, James (Sasha Mitchell); Pam's look-alike (Margaret Michaels) haunts Bobby who thinks she may really be his ex-wife; and Cliff Barnes, now estranged from Ewing Oil, legally pursues J.R. for the latter's involvement in that huge oil-spill... Once again, these were good ideas, but somehow it all seemed for naught.. Perhaps the biggest bungle of the '89-90 season was the serial-killer storyline in which a menagerie of the Clayton's business associates are snuffed-out in a repetition of stupidly bizarre death scenes. The murderess? None other than Lady Jessica Montfort, Clayton's psycho sister fresh from the mental hospital! Jessica had been a terrific character and it was good to see the scenery-chewing Miss Smith reprise her creepy role (and it was quite appropriate that DALLAS turn macabre in its closing era, just as David Paulsen had done with DYNASTY when he tried to save [I]that[/I] messed-up show in its final season) but, missing the tanker entirely, these DALLAS killings are played more for laughs and less for horror, the skeletons-from-the-closets possibilities completely lost; the Ewing Family Story, amazingly, is not furthered or in any way enhanced. The final year, the 1990-91 season, was, to be frank, a bit pathetic -- the stories, the stunt casting (Susan Lucci, Barbara "I Dream of Jeannie" Eden)... Susan Lucci kills April, Michelle kills Susan Lucci. And who cares? By the time Joel Grey guest-starred as J.R.'s guardian devil in the show's May 1991 finale, one found oneself asking: "is this what the present bosses wanted to control DALLAS for --- these last few seasons ??" The epic serial had become merely epically silly... only nobody was laughing (or, going by the ratings, watching anymore). The brass believed that Bobby and J.R. were the only two characters that mattered to the show, the show's antipathy for strong women became far more pointed in its later years. They proved it by letting Miss Principal get away far-too easily in 1987, firing Susan Howard the same year, firing Linda Gray in 1989 (the P.R. statement was that she quit), firing Barbara Bel Geddes and firing Charlene Tilton [I]twice[/I]!! Apparently, the only 'strong' females allowed anymore were pistol-totin' babes. Eventually, even the other guys weren't safe: Steven Kanaly, fired in 1989... Perhaps the show kept Ken Kercheval and Howard Keel around just so J.R. could occasionally snarl at somebody who was (or had been) [I]sort of[/I] an in-law--- especially since brother Bobby, by series' end, was just about the only remaining true Ewing relation... Of course, slipping ratings means decreasing profits which, in turn, means less money with which to produce the show, especially with Larry Hagman's salary still soaring; the more established supporting actors -- or those with biggish salaries yet deemed "disposable" by executives -- were being released. That is, as they say, show business. Budgets change. But allowing the show to turn into an overt sitcom, as Katzman fully believed DALLAS should be a cartoon, meant that the series had now become a parody of something that was already a parody. Yes, a show like DALLAS can and must offer humor and satire, but, as DALLAS creator David Jacobs once observed, that humor has to be kept on the down-low, with the project played absolutely straight on the surface. Obviously, Katzman didn't agree. And crashing ratings didn't seem to faze him. In fact, years after the series' dismal 1991 conclusion, Lenny Katzman stated that his 'biggest mistake ever' in DALLAS was killing off April, a secondary character who'd died in the final season when no one was even watching the show anymore. In its concluding seasons, DALLAS should have turned dusty and dark (similar to the tone of the 2012 reboot, despite the new show's continuity issues), showing the Ewing empire, through scandal and corruption, crumble --- [I]really[/I] crumble, thus allowing the saga to somehow come full-circle; instead, they let the show [I]itself [/I]crumble, grasping apathetically in order to churn-out yet another episode, yet another season, yet another 19-year-old for the old-guys to sleep with for no particular reason. The later reunion movies, J.R. RETURNS (1996) and the even lesser WAR OF THE EWINGS (1998) seemed much too much like the very last days of the weekly series, only even weaker. Everything was played overtly for laughs at the expense of anything else. The brass, it would seem, were unrepentant. True, DALLAS always had humor even in its peak years, but that was a wry, intelligent humor, the show cynical and wise.... and at a level far from the quasi-titillating, campy fate that would befall it at its sunset, the show having slipped into the state of perpetual and deliberate self-parody Katzman preferred even if the audience didn't. Simply put, the Fat Lady dun sung --- but it seems nobody was listenin'... Of course, who really listens when you're singing in the shower? And, for millions of fans around the world, that's just where DALLAS remains, even today: frozen in time, locked in 1986, forever awaiting a better explanation as to why Bobby is all lathered-up in his ex-wife's bathroom. [IMG]http://media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/25/c7/a0/25c7a0f23aebacaff6682bee9e41c6db.jpg[/IMG] [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
6 + 4 =
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
Dallas Season Reviews
What went wrong -- and right -- with DALLAS?
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top