Forums
New posts
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Awards
Log in
Register
What's new
New posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
When this series was good, it was GREAT
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="stevew" data-source="post: 175638" data-attributes="member: 130"><p>I’m referring to the Cartel itself as illegal collusion. There’s not a problem for The Independent Oilman's Association to exist and support each other, say a united political front, but they went way beyond such, especially when it comes to attempting to fix prices. </p><p></p><p>The issue isn’t JR’s intention short term or long term. Many company’s have applied this practice. Over a century ago a chemical company tried to drive Dow out of business by selling bromine under cost. Dow just bought everything they had and resold it, thus driving the competition to near ruin. Long term it never works. I’m also not saying JR is the good guy here, we all know he’s not. Though, if I’d had been a customer of his, I might have thought so. The point is, this is how business plays out and and the Cartel’s attempts to keep prices high, no matter what their thinking, is not the free market capitalism on which this country was founded - freedom. </p><p></p><p>I mean “says a lot” as negative. Because despite all our national talk about free market capitalism, we’re not interested in such. Again and again we’ve fought for protections to keep prices high and ignored monopolies and collusion. Now not always, there’s a lot of good stories about free markets prevailing, about the fight for equal opportunity and so forth. But when a group of guys colluding to elevate the price of gas at the pump are seen as the “good guys” and the bad guy is selling on the cheap - instead of both being viewed as bad guys, it says a lot to me. </p><p></p><p>I disagree - I don’t think they would have been less angry if Jesus himself were selling cheap gas and thus driving them out of business. </p><p></p><p>There should never be just one company left in an industry - that is illegal (without regulation). The Cartel was in fact attempting to act as one big company and that is the problem. Big can be good as it drives down prices by saving on economies of scale. Your point is valid and the government’s role has been to make sure there isn’t one big company - like breaking up Standard Oil. But, if a smaller business goes out of business because it can’t compete, that’s a good thing for the free markets - people expressing their freedom to buy what they want at the price they want. </p><p></p><p>The American Dream wasn’t killed by Walmart and giant business’s - they’ve been around long before and will be around long after. Amazon is going after Walmart. They stated small and are building. Walmart is by no means a monopoly. Part of the American dream has evolved to buying a lot of stuff - companies like Walmart and Amazon make that possible. There are many opportunities to own your own business in America in all shapes and forms. But, I’m not sure if that was ever the American Dream to own your own business or just a dream of some Americans, certainly not most. I certainly am not one to protect businesses for the shake of the business owner - think of all the buggy businesses we’d be supporting today. Instead the smart guys in buggies, like Durant, switched to cars. </p><p></p><p>The issue with the anti trust laws not working as you see it is: 1) they’re not intended to protect the little business man but the free market so yes Walmart is big and has driven small shops out of business but the free market is still in tact, there are still plenty of options for people. Applying the law to break up Walmart wouldn’t help the free market but protect small businesses - which is not what the laws are there for. 2) the political will has to be there and to often the politicians we elect are puppets of business interests, bought off by people like JR and the Cartel instead of fighting for freedom for the nation they promote the self interests of a few. Again I’m not saying JR was a good guy, but I won’t pretend the Cartel attempting to collude and price fix is either.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="stevew, post: 175638, member: 130"] I’m referring to the Cartel itself as illegal collusion. There’s not a problem for The Independent Oilman's Association to exist and support each other, say a united political front, but they went way beyond such, especially when it comes to attempting to fix prices. The issue isn’t JR’s intention short term or long term. Many company’s have applied this practice. Over a century ago a chemical company tried to drive Dow out of business by selling bromine under cost. Dow just bought everything they had and resold it, thus driving the competition to near ruin. Long term it never works. I’m also not saying JR is the good guy here, we all know he’s not. Though, if I’d had been a customer of his, I might have thought so. The point is, this is how business plays out and and the Cartel’s attempts to keep prices high, no matter what their thinking, is not the free market capitalism on which this country was founded - freedom. I mean “says a lot” as negative. Because despite all our national talk about free market capitalism, we’re not interested in such. Again and again we’ve fought for protections to keep prices high and ignored monopolies and collusion. Now not always, there’s a lot of good stories about free markets prevailing, about the fight for equal opportunity and so forth. But when a group of guys colluding to elevate the price of gas at the pump are seen as the “good guys” and the bad guy is selling on the cheap - instead of both being viewed as bad guys, it says a lot to me. I disagree - I don’t think they would have been less angry if Jesus himself were selling cheap gas and thus driving them out of business. There should never be just one company left in an industry - that is illegal (without regulation). The Cartel was in fact attempting to act as one big company and that is the problem. Big can be good as it drives down prices by saving on economies of scale. Your point is valid and the government’s role has been to make sure there isn’t one big company - like breaking up Standard Oil. But, if a smaller business goes out of business because it can’t compete, that’s a good thing for the free markets - people expressing their freedom to buy what they want at the price they want. The American Dream wasn’t killed by Walmart and giant business’s - they’ve been around long before and will be around long after. Amazon is going after Walmart. They stated small and are building. Walmart is by no means a monopoly. Part of the American dream has evolved to buying a lot of stuff - companies like Walmart and Amazon make that possible. There are many opportunities to own your own business in America in all shapes and forms. But, I’m not sure if that was ever the American Dream to own your own business or just a dream of some Americans, certainly not most. I certainly am not one to protect businesses for the shake of the business owner - think of all the buggy businesses we’d be supporting today. Instead the smart guys in buggies, like Durant, switched to cars. The issue with the anti trust laws not working as you see it is: 1) they’re not intended to protect the little business man but the free market so yes Walmart is big and has driven small shops out of business but the free market is still in tact, there are still plenty of options for people. Applying the law to break up Walmart wouldn’t help the free market but protect small businesses - which is not what the laws are there for. 2) the political will has to be there and to often the politicians we elect are puppets of business interests, bought off by people like JR and the Cartel instead of fighting for freedom for the nation they promote the self interests of a few. Again I’m not saying JR was a good guy, but I won’t pretend the Cartel attempting to collude and price fix is either. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Verification
Who played Sue Ellen in Dallas?
Post reply
Forums
Dallas the TV series
Dallas - The Original Series
When this series was good, it was GREAT
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
Accept
Learn more…
Top