Why It Wouldn't Have Worked If More Of The Ewings Besides JR Were Devious

James from London

International Treasure
It makes it so much better when you know who you like, because then it matters a lot more what happens to whom.

I don't think it's a question of liking or not liking. I think I like most everyone on Dallas, except for Dream Season Donna and latter years April. I don't think I have to pick a side beforehand in order to be fully impacted by what happens on screen. I'm happy for the story to pull me one way then another. In fact, that's what I hope for.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
With the character of JR I think there was more to tell. For as long as Dallas has aired there are two characters I believe we still know little about: Jock and JR. Others like Miss Ellie, Bobby, Pam and Sue Ellen had real depth to them. While Jock was gruff in personality JR would often come across as just cold...not evil. JR had two weak spots; Ewing Oil and John Ross. But Ewing Oil was JR's Achilles heel. Despite all his wheeling and dealing JR would inevitably come undone, much like Cliff and his constant vendetta against the Ewing family.

I believe the writers missed a golden opportunity to explore the character of JR after Bobby's death. There are two paths the character could have taken; full on revenge against those responsible for his brothers death or witnessing JR collapse into a foetal position, burned and worn out by his own excessive need to have it all. Hell, I would have thrown everything at JR. Crippled by his own guilt at being partially responsible for Bobby's death I would have taken that smirk off JR's face and have the character tortured by his own greed.

I think we know quite a bit about Jock and JR. I also think JR’s weak spots were Ewing Oil and Jock. For a middle aged man, he was a little too infatuated with his daddy.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
^
I agree, and "to like" and "to love" are not things that you need to know or decide, it happens when it happens.
There's no cure for stupid
I think the problem with Cliff was that he tried to play JR's game, he also became ruthless but it was a different kind of ruthlessness.
A very good example in season 2, when Cliff asks Pam for a $10000 loan, supposedly to help out Digger
That's what he did to his family in the second season.
Fast forward 30+ years, and you see how he still doesn't know how to play the game. "Do it! Bomb it!" A man so desperate to win and to defeat, I think that's Cliff Barnes in a nutshell.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I've seen opinions that maybe JR shouldn't have been the only Ewing who was willing to be devious and do things that as a lot of people put it "made you love to hate him."

One thing that is easy to forget is that originally, J.R. was a sympathetic character. Think back to the original few episodes. Bobby was the playboy, running around handing out "The Three B's". Poor J.R. was stuck in the office, doing the dirty work that nobody else wanted to do. And doing this under the thumb of his father, who was never satisfied with the job J.R. was doing.

And to add to his misery, people such as Lucy gladly accepted the privileges of wealth, while criticizing the way that J.R. kept that money coming in.

Oh, yes. In the early episodes J.R. was a sympathetic character.

But then Larry Hagman took the character in a different direction. He played J.R. as a person who relished the dirty tricks, and enjoyed getting down in the mud. He took such delight in destroying his enemies that we just had to watch.

I still remember the announcer every Friday night:

"Next, on Dallas. Tune in to watch J.R. Ewing-- the man you love to hate."
 
Top