Matthew Blaisdel
Telly Talk Star
Last edited:
they accepted Gary, Kristin and Digger as other actors. It would have been fine. Same goes for replacing Pam. I still stand by that as the superior and only move really.Would they? Did they accept Parmalee? Donna Reed, if she was now playing Jock instead of Ellie?
Again, recasting core characters in primetime shows almost never works.
they accepted Gary, Kristin and Digger as other actors. It would have been fine. Same goes for replacing Pam. I still stand by that as the superior and only move really.
Gary. Kristin and Digger had only been bit parts, characters the audience barely knew and had barely seen. You can stand by your opinion all you want to, but if you think recasting major roles like Jock and Pam "would have been fine" then why did everybody go cringe-y over Donna Reed?
DALLAS wasn't a daytime soap, quite unlike DYNASTY (which desperately wanted to be).

Could you even picture Donna Reed's Miss Ellie telling Ray to "go get the shotgun out of the closet?"
In an alternate universe...Oh, sure. If she followed it with "dear."
No no and no. Too gentle, not gruff enough. And way too tall.I think it depends on the character. Donna Reed's Miss Ellie was practically a different character. She went from the matriarch of a ranch family to a socialite. Could you even picture Donna Reed's Miss Ellie telling Ray to "go get the shotgun out of the closet?" I sure couldn't.
A character like JR couldn't be replaced because he had an over the top personality. It would be like trying to recast the Fonz on Happy Days. Jock was a supporting character and if they recasted him with the right actor, it could have worked. I still think Buddy Ebsen could have been recast as Jock. He was about the same age as Jim Davis and had his stature.
View attachment 55023
View attachment 55024
I had no issues with Reed, but then I didn't like BBG, she never felt like a native Texan. Margret Michaels as Pam would have worked just fine. The alternative was never going to work and didn't.Gary. Kristin and Digger had only been bit parts, characters the audience barely knew and had barely seen. You can stand by your opinion all you want to, but if you think recasting major roles like Jock and Pam "would have been fine" then why did everybody go cringe-y over Donna Reed?
DALLAS wasn't a daytime soap, quite unlike DYNASTY (which desperately wanted to be).
I had no issues with Reed, but then I didn't like BBG, she never felt like a native Texan. Margret Michaels as Pam would have worked just fine. The alternative was never going to work and didn't.
Ebsen was too nice, but Jock should have stayed on. The character was bigger than the actor. Same for Pam; would not have worked for Duffy, although they never considered a recast. Dynasty didnt take any care when recast. NO ONE believed Samms was PSM's Fallon, even though she was given a literal blank slate to start over. Amanda's replaceent didnt even have a goddamn English accent! lol. I dont understand it either, everyone has a doppleganger, especially in Hollywood.I think it depends on the character. Donna Reed's Miss Ellie was practically a different character. She went from the matriarch of a ranch family to a socialite. Could you even picture Donna Reed's Miss Ellie telling Ray to "go get the shotgun out of the closet?" I sure couldn't.
A character like JR couldn't be replaced because he had an over the top personality. It would be like trying to recast the Fonz on Happy Days. Jock was a supporting character and if they recasted him with the right actor, it could have worked. I still think Buddy Ebsen could have been recast as Jock. He was about the same age as Jim Davis and had his stature.
View attachment 55023
View attachment 55024
I love both Kristen and Katherine - they both sort of filled the same spot. But the issue with that sort of character is that once they become so openly villainous and criminal it's hard to justify why people are even talking to them without looking like idiots. So I can see why both were written out, though I wouldn't have minded both as recurring villains.They underestimated Katherine's potential.
Good point, its just Katherine wasn't used correctly and BOTH were gone too soon. Kristin should have returned with a baby, is it or is it not JR and her blackmailing him every chance she got or else she will reveal him as the Daddy. Both, too soon.I love both Kristen and Katherine - they both sort of filled the same spot. But the issue with that sort of character is that once they become so openly villainous and criminal it's hard to justify why people are even talking to them without looking like idiots. So I can see why both were written out, though I wouldn't have minded both as recurring villains.
The one I missed the most was Mickey. He and Lucy had real chemistry as a couple. Why couldn’t they have gotten rid of Mitch instead? He was such a stick in the mud.