Dallas Killed Off Way Too Many Good Characters.

Matthew Blaisdel

Telly Talk Star
Donna Reed, if she was now playing Jock instead of Ellie?
9bgu19.jpg9
9bgu19.jpg
 
Last edited:

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Would they? Did they accept Parmalee? Donna Reed, if she was now playing Jock instead of Ellie?

Again, recasting core characters in primetime shows almost never works.
they accepted Gary, Kristin and Digger as other actors. It would have been fine. Same goes for replacing Pam. I still stand by that as the superior and only move really.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
they accepted Gary, Kristin and Digger as other actors. It would have been fine. Same goes for replacing Pam. I still stand by that as the superior and only move really.

Gary. Kristin and Digger had only been bit parts, characters the audience barely knew and had barely seen. You can stand by your opinion all you want to, but if you think recasting major roles like Jock and Pam "would have been fine" then why did everybody go cringe-y over Donna Reed?

DALLAS wasn't a daytime soap, quite unlike DYNASTY (which desperately wanted to be).
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Gary. Kristin and Digger had only been bit parts, characters the audience barely knew and had barely seen. You can stand by your opinion all you want to, but if you think recasting major roles like Jock and Pam "would have been fine" then why did everybody go cringe-y over Donna Reed?

DALLAS wasn't a daytime soap, quite unlike DYNASTY (which desperately wanted to be).

I think it depends on the character. Donna Reed's Miss Ellie was practically a different character. She went from the matriarch of a ranch family to a socialite. Could you even picture Donna Reed's Miss Ellie telling Ray to "go get the shotgun out of the closet?" I sure couldn't.

A character like JR couldn't be replaced because he had an over the top personality. It would be like trying to recast the Fonz on Happy Days. Jock was a supporting character and if they recasted him with the right actor, it could have worked. I still think Buddy Ebsen could have been recast as Jock. He was about the same age as Jim Davis and had his stature.

BDC0CA11-A17D-490F-A3C9-737362428181.jpeg

A1686856-6C7F-4422-886B-6F96E71F373E.jpeg
 
Last edited:

Toni

Maximum Member

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I think it depends on the character. Donna Reed's Miss Ellie was practically a different character. She went from the matriarch of a ranch family to a socialite. Could you even picture Donna Reed's Miss Ellie telling Ray to "go get the shotgun out of the closet?" I sure couldn't.

A character like JR couldn't be replaced because he had an over the top personality. It would be like trying to recast the Fonz on Happy Days. Jock was a supporting character and if they recasted him with the right actor, it could have worked. I still think Buddy Ebsen could have been recast as Jock. He was about the same age as Jim Davis and had his stature.

View attachment 55023

View attachment 55024
No no and no. Too gentle, not gruff enough. And way too tall.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Gary. Kristin and Digger had only been bit parts, characters the audience barely knew and had barely seen. You can stand by your opinion all you want to, but if you think recasting major roles like Jock and Pam "would have been fine" then why did everybody go cringe-y over Donna Reed?

DALLAS wasn't a daytime soap, quite unlike DYNASTY (which desperately wanted to be).
I had no issues with Reed, but then I didn't like BBG, she never felt like a native Texan. Margret Michaels as Pam would have worked just fine. The alternative was never going to work and didn't.
 

Jock Og

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Of them all I wouldn't have killed off Digger. 1980 was too early for him to go. The other side of the dime was that the poor guy was killing himself; anyhow, with the amount of alcohol he consumed. I wanted to see a showdown between him and Rebecca, after many years estranged.

20-david-wayne1.jpg


David Wayne as the original Willard 'Digger' Barnes.


23-keenan-wynn1.jpg


Digger returns a relatively new man, after 'a finding oil' project. Keenan Wynn is the portrayer now.


Pamela and Cliff go looking for Digger, to break the news of his daughter’s recent marriage. Cliff finds him in one of his usual bars, surrounded by people and talking about when he and Jock struck oil; (a scene from the 1st episode, the mini-series, DVD-1, 1978):

Bar patron (slurred speech): “Pour my old buddy another drink here.”

Digger: “Thank you….thank you sir! That’s mighty nice of ya, now 1930 was my year. My partner and I walked out right here in Texas and I just followed my nose and I said here and he went back to register the claim and I stayed there and I drilled, until I thought we had enough. We owned 10 times more than we could ever spend. I said that’s a plenty and he looked at me and laughed in my face and said that I owned nothing, nothing at all. I even owed him some money. Well I tried to kill…I tried to kill Jock Ewing, once or twice but I bundled it. You see I can drill but I can’t kill.”

Cliff: “There you have it Pammy, the product of Jock Ewing’s ethics.”

They decide to interrupt Digger’s craic.

Cliff: “Excuse me…excuse me!”

Bar patron (slurred speech): “Listen don’t take him away. We’re having a good time here. What’s going on?”

Digger opens his arms to greet Pam and says, “Pammy.”

Pamela: “Hi daddy! You ok?”

Digger: “Sure…..sure.”

Pamela: “Daddy I came…….”

Digger: “Uh?”

Pamela: “I came to tell you……”

Digger looks at her drunkenly.

Pamela: “Daddy I came to tell you that I got married.”

Digger smiles and replies (slurred speech): "Well now what do ya think of that?”

Pamela: “Daddy please don’t be mad or hurt. I love my husband daddy.”

Digger smiles and says (slurred speech): "Sure you do!”

Pamela: “…..But he’s Bobby Ewing.”

Digger replies, while not registering who it is: "A ha!”

Cliff looks at Pam.

Pamela: “Daddy the boy I married is a Ewing.”

Digger nods.

Cliff: “Jock Ewing’s boy.”

Cliff then looks down at the table.

Digger then just stares at Pamela and gives her a look that says it all. Pamela then gets emotional.

She leaves the bar. Digger still has the shock stare, with Cliff beside him.
 
Last edited:

LB-Colby

Telly Talk Member
They killed off some of the best characters (Julie, Kristin, Rebecca, Mickey).
And they didn't kill off some boring characters who stayed too long (Ray, Donna, Jenna).

So many mistakes!
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
They underestimated Katherine's potential. She should have stayed on with Pointer, and they, too, begin their hate for the Ewings, but Katherine does it with an agenda of winning back her company and kicking Barnes out! She could have been the Wentworth/Barnes version of JR, instead of crazy, jealous harpie.
Lucy should have left after Mickey. if she was going to return eventually, give her a career.
I too, thought Julie Gray was gone too soon and yes, jealous and feeling betrayed, should have shot JR in the guts.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I think it depends on the character. Donna Reed's Miss Ellie was practically a different character. She went from the matriarch of a ranch family to a socialite. Could you even picture Donna Reed's Miss Ellie telling Ray to "go get the shotgun out of the closet?" I sure couldn't.

A character like JR couldn't be replaced because he had an over the top personality. It would be like trying to recast the Fonz on Happy Days. Jock was a supporting character and if they recasted him with the right actor, it could have worked. I still think Buddy Ebsen could have been recast as Jock. He was about the same age as Jim Davis and had his stature.

View attachment 55023

View attachment 55024
Ebsen was too nice, but Jock should have stayed on. The character was bigger than the actor. Same for Pam; would not have worked for Duffy, although they never considered a recast. Dynasty didnt take any care when recast. NO ONE believed Samms was PSM's Fallon, even though she was given a literal blank slate to start over. Amanda's replaceent didnt even have a goddamn English accent! lol. I dont understand it either, everyone has a doppleganger, especially in Hollywood.
It's funny how many will balk at that, yet our favorite soap operas have actors who were not the original portrayers. Julie from DAYS OF OUR LIVES was the second actor. Josh Taylor as Roman Brady is the second actor and the longest tenure. From a long way back of ANOTHER WORLD, Rachel was the 3rd actress, and the most famous. I guess Daytime is different, but I have no issues with replacement if it means keeping the character---- Pam Ewing, I'm still looking at you.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
They underestimated Katherine's potential.
I love both Kristen and Katherine - they both sort of filled the same spot. But the issue with that sort of character is that once they become so openly villainous and criminal it's hard to justify why people are even talking to them without looking like idiots. So I can see why both were written out, though I wouldn't have minded both as recurring villains.
 

Jock's Ghost

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I love both Kristen and Katherine - they both sort of filled the same spot. But the issue with that sort of character is that once they become so openly villainous and criminal it's hard to justify why people are even talking to them without looking like idiots. So I can see why both were written out, though I wouldn't have minded both as recurring villains.
Good point, its just Katherine wasn't used correctly and BOTH were gone too soon. Kristin should have returned with a baby, is it or is it not JR and her blackmailing him every chance she got or else she will reveal him as the Daddy. Both, too soon.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
The one I missed the most was Mickey. He and Lucy had real chemistry as a couple. Why couldn’t they have gotten rid of Mitch instead? He was such a stick in the mud.

In order for the audience to care about the death toll over Jock's will, they had to kill characters we actually liked.

I mean, what's the point of killing Mitch when he's only going to complain about the mahogany and satin lining and polished brass handles on his coffin as he's being lowered into the ground??
 
Top