I'm also giving serious thought to replacing my DVDs with the Blu-ray set.
Well, my copy arrived a week or so ago. Despite the packaging being quite poor, I'm happy to say that mine arrived with the slipcase mostly undamaged, apart from a couple of small dings to the corners.
Some pictures of the Blu-ray set alongside the outgoing DVD set:
And here are some packaging comparisons in more detail (DVDs on the left; Blu-rays on the right):
Overall I'm happy with the new packaging.
The gatefold seasons inside the DVD set look nice and have lots of extra great artwork, plus episode information beyond just the titles, but they are prone to creasing and digipaks are never ideal with the risks to the discs themselves when taking out and putting back in. Looking at these pictures the edges of the DVD slipcase and the individual digipaks inside look very worn considering it's only been watched a couple of times (this set replaced a different DVD box-set with full-sized individual season sets inside) and I'm very careful with how I treat and store these.
I actually prefer the back of the Blu-ray set. Because of the lack of BBFC information, plus the smaller print being on the sleeve of the Amaray case rather than the slipcase, it looks more attractive and they've been able to make the text larger even though the surface area is smaller. Plus I far prefer the images from episodes rather than the thumbnails of covers from the three seasons. My main gripe relates to the booklet, which is just four sides and printed on poor quality paper stock. It doesn't feel it will last well at all. A decent booklet with more information about and images from the series would have made this feel more special and definitive.
I'm curious how it will compare with the DVD to my eyes.
Reviews suggest it's not perfect (a bit oversaturated here, a bit soft-looking there) but overall an improvement and probably as good as the series is going to look.
Well, it's good news here. Yes, the colours are extremely vibrant, especially compared directly with the DVDs. It's now far more vivid than how the series has ever looked and I would definitely have preferred this taken down to a less artificial-looking level. I assume someone just got the memo that this was taken from a comic and went full on pop art with the colours.
That's about the only complaint regarding the picture, though. The quality of the image itself is absolutely stunning. I've only skipped through and haven't yet watched an entire episode, but it looks rich and detailed without looking overly sharp. There's still a little grain and it largely looks era-appropriate.
More disappointing is the sound, which is mono. While it's probably no worse than the DVD audio, with the picture in high definition, it really jumps out that the sound...
isn't. I can't imagine it would have been a huge undertaking to create a lossless audio for the soundtrack without compromising the authenticity of the era. I'm sure it's fine, once the ears adjust, but frankly it could have been much better in this regard.
On the subject of audio, one strange thing happened when I first tried the discs a week ago: the WB logo played fine on each disc as it loaded, but no matter which episode or disc I watched, there was a horrible screeching sound and the audio was inaudible. This then continued on a DVD I was watching and the only thing that eventually seemed to fix it was taking out the HDMi cable and re-attaching it. All the same, it took a week to work up the courage to try the
WW Blu-rays in the player again. Very peculiar timing, but all seems well now and I hope it was just an anomaly.
Incidentally, I've noticed the running times are different:
- DVD - 2855 mins
- Blu-ray - 2950 mins
I assume the difference of 105 minutes is due to PAL speedup rather than any edits to the DVD episodes. Who'd have thought it would add up to two whole episodes' worth of time.
It appears that on the initial pressing of the BDs, Stella Stevens's credit was missing from The New, Original Wonder Woman.
I've checked the codes on the inner rings, and am pleased that Discs 1, 5, 7 and 8 are all the re-pressed versions which contain fixes to glitches found on earlier pressings of those discs. This makes my set as perfect as it's possible to get.
And of course the first thing I checked was that Stella's credit was present and correct.