This isn't a film I noticed at the time it was released. The only context it's come on to my radar has been in the last decade, when I discovered the soundtrack featured a song by one of my favourite singers that can't be found anywhere else (I still haven't bagged a copy). Even then, I hadn't really thought about the film, and even when I watched last night I'd forgotten about the association until the end credits when said song played.
From the poster, I wasn't sure about the tone of the film. I really wasn't up for a Nineties high school broad comedy, so I first read the "Reception" section on the film's Wikipedia page (helpful to get an idea of what to expect, usually spoiler-free) and it looked more promising as a political satire (it also mentions that this is said to be Barack Obama's favourite political film).
I confess to being concerned at seeing it was an MTV Production, fearing a busy, noisy, overly colourful film that played out like an extended late-Nineties music video. I needn't have worried. It is very stylised, but the techniques used create visual interest without overdoing it. In terms of soundtrack, the score is a tad on the quirky side which works for the film, even though it isn't one I would care to play at home or in the car. The songs in the film are a curious mix of very Nineties alternative and more traditional, older songs from the likes of Donovan. There's that elusive Mandy Barnett song I mentioned, and Mandy's
With My Eyes Wide Open plays in the background of a diner scene (this made me laugh out loud since McAllister's eye had been stung by a bee, swelling the lid shut during this scene. It was a nice, subtle touch).
Matthew Broderick is great here. It's probably the best performance I've seen of his (not that I've that much to compare it against), and Reese Witherspoon essentially plays Lisa Simpson. With a touch of the Tracy Corkhills since she'd had a fling with a teacher, leaving her with a reputation in certain quarters (Broderick's character resents Witherspoon's character because his friend lost his job and family once his gross misconduct came to light).
Performances are good all round. There are lots of familiar faces spanning several eras. Of the younger cast, the most familiar face was Larry, the young kid who initially counts the ballots correctly. I was pleased when I finally placed him as the lead from
Final Destination 5 as it briefly distracted me. There are soapy connections with the adults. Matthew Broderick's wife is young Miss Ellie from
Dallas: The Early Years (formerly known as Meredith, PWC's researcher from
Knots). And Reese Witherspoon's mother is Colleen Camp who almost shot JR. It's a relatively small role, but her character makes sense of her overachieving daughter. In effect, Camp is playing Patricia Shepard here rather than Kristin.
Even though it's all held together by the thread of one key storyline there's a lot going on. There are also some nice surprises, like the jock character being the nicest and most sensitive of them all. It's a very entertaining film, and I'd be up for watching it again as I'm sure there will be details I will notice or appreciate more on a rewatch.