It's Become Obvious Why Dallas Went Downhill

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
we didn't say it was just him, because as it's been said the show became less and less the show it once was and i think he cared more about money than he cared about quality. i think all he saw was the color green.

Maybe he did think too much about money but still he was smart enough to realize that better quality leads to earning more money. A show that loses quality loses viewers which loses revenue for the entire show. That makes it hard for them to keep paying the same salaries and pay raises become impossible. Ultimately the loss in quality was, at most, indirectly caused by Larry Hagman not insisting on better quality stories, especially better quality for the storylines which revolved primarily around JR. He may have been enjoying the money he was earning too much to keep vigilant about the direction of the show, particularly the direction in which they were taking his character. The direct cause of lower quality was the fault of the creative team - the writers. After all, even when JR's character got watered down and the storylines in which he was a major player got more outlandish or even dumb, it was never the fault of Larry Hagman's acting. I never got the feeling that he wasn't putting all his effort into doing the most he could with the storylines which he was given. Haleyville, for example was a storyline which no actor in JR's place could have done any more with than Larry did. One of the worst storylines was JR having himself committed to a sanitarium, but even then, he did as much with it as any actor could have when presented with such low quality material.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
with most of the cast of Dallas it was prolly like that but with Hagman it wasn't about the love of the show it was about the love of money

Oh, I think Larry Hagman loved the show as much or more than any of the cast. He certainly loved it more than Victoria Principal or Patrick Duffy did. After all, Patrick left and then only came back when he couldn't find work and Victoria did leave for good. If he hadn't loved Dallas so much he wouldn't have participated in the made for TV movies about Dallas after the show ended and he certainly wouldn't have kept working on the New Dallas while he was literally dying. Few actors would have kept working and turning in such good acting performances while that sick with terminal cancer!
 

Tatianna

Telly Talk Fan
Oh, I think Larry Hagman loved the show as much or more than any of the cast. He certainly loved it more than Victoria Principal or Patrick Duffy did. After all, Patrick left and then only came back when he couldn't find work and Victoria did leave for good. If he hadn't loved Dallas so much he wouldn't have participated in the made for TV movies about Dallas after the show ended and he certainly wouldn't have kept working on the New Dallas while he was literally dying. Few actors would have kept working and turning in such good acting performances while that sick with terminal cancer!


Very valid points. Also, I believe Larry needed the money. Even though Larry had struck the big times and big bucks back in the day with DALLAS, I've heard he and his wife had lost most of their money by investing with Bernie Madoff. That's heartbreaking to think about and especially since they were both getting on in age and had health issues.

I really do believe even if his finances had not been a factor he still would have had an active role with anything relating to DALLAS/J.R.
He was a natural and in as much as I dislike the TNT version, I'm glad Larry got to bring J.R. on the screen again..
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Very valid points. Also, I believe Larry needed the money. Even though Larry had struck the big times and big bucks back in the day with DALLAS, I've heard he and his wife had lost most of their money by investing with Bernie Madoff. That's heartbreaking to think about and especially since they were both getting on in age and had health issues.

I really do believe even if his finances had not been a factor he still would have had an active role with anything relating to DALLAS/J.R.
He was a natural and in as much as I dislike the TNT version, I'm glad Larry got to bring J.R. on the screen again..

I also strongly dislike the New Dallas but one of the few things I did like about it, in fact my absolute favorite thing about it was seeing Larry Hagman playing JR again and turning in such good quality acting performances despite that he was dying from cancer!
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Oh, I think Larry Hagman loved the show as much or more than any of the cast. He certainly loved it more than Victoria Principal or Patrick Duffy did. After all, Patrick left and then only came back when he couldn't find work and Victoria did leave for good. If he hadn't loved Dallas so much he wouldn't have participated in the made for TV movies about Dallas after the show ended and he certainly wouldn't have kept working on the New Dallas while he was literally dying. Few actors would have kept working and turning in such good acting performances while that sick with terminal cancer!

I take your point about Larry Hagman. But have you considered the possibility that Victoria Principal left Dallas and never came back because she cared about the show a lot, in terms of her character and storylines? Pam was killed off in the Season 10 (DVD) finale as far as Victoria was concerned, despite producers reversing it later. Surely that shows more concern for Dallas on Victoria's part than just being in Dallas and doing whatever poor storylines that came in the late Dallas seasons and TNT Dallas?

What is loving the show more?

1. Having respect for the storylines
2. Just appearing in Dallas, whatever the storylines

Larry wins if number 2. Victoria wins if number 1.
 

bmasters9

Telly Talk Mega Star
I respect all opinions, but I think that Sue Ellen´s last season was stupid beyond belief regarding her storylines. She as a character sort of "died" (or got to the climax, to make it sound "sexier") when she and Kimberly voted J.R. out of WestStar and Jeremy back in. All that happened from that moment on, was total lameness (is that a word?):

Lameness is a word-- I looked it up in the dictionary.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Oh, I think Larry Hagman loved the show as much or more than any of the cast.

I don't believe the majority of posters here dispute Larry's fondness for Dallas. I certainly don't but I do believe he had enormous influence on the producers/writers. The character of J.R., became the standout - that's obvious. However, J.R. could only remain relevant if characters like Miss Ellie, Clayton, Sue Ellen, Bobby, Pam, Jenna, Ray, Donna etc had stayed. Once these characters began to depart Dallas became more about other characters rather than the Ewing family and if this sounds familiar it does - Dallas TNT anyone?
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I don't believe the majority of posters here dispute Larry's fondness for Dallas. I certainly don't but I do believe he had enormous influence on the producers/writers. The character of J.R., became the standout - that's obvious. However, J.R. could only remain relevant if characters like Miss Ellie, Clayton, Sue Ellen, Bobby, Pam, Jenna, Ray, Donna etc had stayed. Once these characters began to depart Dallas became more about other characters rather than the Ewing family and if this sounds familiar it does - Dallas TNT anyone?

That's exactly the point Kenny. Like the TNT Dallas the focus of the show changed. Whereas TNT Dallas took the focus off the remaining Ewings, the Lorimar Dallas took the focus off it's ensemble cast & made it the Pat Duffy & Larry Hagman show.

Big Mistake.

And making JR into a buffoon only made matters worse. His menacing, manipulative character got diluted down & the comedic elements seemed to take over. Just like Dallas TNT this was all down to the writing & the direction the showrunner & Executive Producer Leonard Katzman took it in. :(
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Just like Dallas TNT this was all down to the writing & the direction the showrunner & Executive Producer Leonard Katzman took it in.

According to Wikipedia Leonard Katzman only became Executive Producer of Dallas from Season 10 to 14, with assistance from Larry Hagman during Season 12, 13 and 14. This is interesting in itself because I find those 4 seasons painful to watch. Leonard was only a producer from Season 1 to 8. Philip Capice was Executive Producer from Season 1 - 9 which most die-hard Dallas fans find to be its best years. I don't believe Phil receives enough credit sometimes.

When Patrick decided to leave Dallas my impression is Philip wanted to strengthen the character of Pam. Early indications (after Bobby's funeral) eluded to this especially after the reading of his Will. By this stage viewers were enraptured by Alexis Carrington's shenanigans on Dynasty - even men were tuning in. Nothing like getting men's pulse racing than watching two women attempt to scratch each others eyes out, ripping off each others clothes etc. There was a shift in viewers from Dallas to Dynasty - ratings prove it.

Giving Pam control of Christopher's stake in Ewing Oil was just the start. Witness J.R.'s sense of dread after Harv's announcement that a Barnes is going to be positioned in the Ewing Oil building. After several seasons of J.R.'s meddling in Pamela's personal life I was ready for a fight between these two giant characters. Other posters will argue that J.R. would have easily out maneuvered Pam. I personally believe it would have been interesting to watch his reactions to go up against a woman who was hell-bent on protecting her sons interest. All the other characters would have drawn into this scenario especially Miss Ellie. She knew better than anyone how ruthless J.R. could be.

After Bobby's death I wanted to see a darker shade of J.R., a place not even Miss Ellie thought he would go. Larry certainly had the ability to take J.R. there as evident in those early seasons of Dallas. I personally loved it when he displayed cruelness. Look at his reaction to Sue Ellen when she arrives home to Southfork, not knowing of Bobby's death. That was drama!
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Philip Capice seemed to get the best out of Leonard Katzman's talents, while keeping Katzman's worst side away. Unfortunately, after Season 8, it seems that the relationship between Capice and Katzman had deteriorated to the point where they could no longer work together as Executive Producer and Producer. It seems the cast and crew took sides, with Larry Hagman on Katzman's side, and Capice copped flak for Dallas' fall in the ratings in Season 9. Capice then left, and Katzman not only came back to the production team but was promoted to Executive Producer. The irony is that ratings fell much further and faster with Katzman (and Hagman) as Executive Producer(s).

Don't forget that Lee Rich was also Executive Producer with Philip Capice in Seasons 1-3, up to where J.R. was shot.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Capice copped flak for Dallas' fall in the ratings in Season 9

Which tells me Dynasty was having more of an influence on Dallas than the other way round. We could see that influence with the introduction of Angelica Nero and her outlandish outfits. Dallas had suffered with the loss of Patrick Duffy but I thought it could have survived Bobby's death if only the producers/writers had confidence in the characters that we truly cared about since inception. Strange how the writers handled Jock's (Jim Davis) illness and eventual death far better than Patrick's announcement of his intention to leave the series.
 

Karin

Moderator
Staff Member
Well I think the problem with first Patrick's leaving the show and later on VP leaving, was that without them the classic lovestory that was the set up for the original Dallas didn't work. I mean imagine if Juliet would outlive Romeo. Who would want to watch Juliet move on to a new love just weeks after losing the love of her life?
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Dallas had lots of potential after Bobby's death. That potential had to be seized once the mourning of Bobby started fading away, but it seems some people backstage were clinging to the past like grim death, even to the extent of bringing Bobby back from the dead and resetting a year's worth of storylines.

I personally like the dream season, but a criticism I do have is that Pam didn't fight for Christopher's share of Ewing Oil. I do feel an opportunity was lost there to have Pam enter the snake pit of Ewing Oil in the interests of her son and be faced with the vicious J.R., with neither of them really over Bobby's death. It was an opportunity to have a certain bonding between them and to intensify the hate. There's plenty of potential conflict there that could have lasted a few seasons easily.

The J.R. vs. Bobby stuff was great in the past, but it was the past. Why go through that again, when it had already been done? The Romeo and Juliet analogy with Bobby and Pam works in the sense that Bobby's death has tragically cut the story short, just as they were engaged again.

Which tells me Dynasty was having more of an influence on Dallas than the other way round. We could see that influence with the introduction of Angelica Nero and her outlandish outfits. Dallas had suffered with the loss of Patrick Duffy but I thought it could have survived Bobby's death if only the producers/writers had confidence in the characters that we truly cared about since inception. Strange how the writers handled Jock's (Jim Davis) illness and eventual death far better than Patrick's announcement of his intention to leave the series.

To be fair, they took a while to get to grips with Jim Davis' terminal illness and how that would impact the storylines. After the "Who Shot J.R." reveal, things did calm down for a while and the intensity dropped a bit. Once they figured out Jock's death, decided to intensify the J.R. vs. Cliff feud and then the whole thing of Jock's Will and the Battle for Ewing Oil, Dallas had an amazing period.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Dallas had lots of potential after Bobby's death. That potential had to be seized once the mourning of Bobby started fading away
Exactly. It's rare for an actor to leave a series at the height of its popularity. I can still recall how Bobby's death affected me personally, it was like he had become a member of the family. Patrick had obviously told the producers his wish to leave. I applaud them for having the strength to kill off such a popular character rather than going down that path of replacing Patrick with another actor. They must have learned their mistake replacing Barbara with Donna Reed.

During the off season this was the opportunity for the writers to really develop a strong story evolving around J.R. Ewing and Pamela. The ramifications of Bobby's Will had been set in motion. Dare I say it but maybe when Patrick had announced his intentions of leaving the producers could have gathered the cast, looked at this and said right, "We'll give this two more seasons." The last two series need to be high octane, really pushed the envelope of drama between Pam and J.R. squaring off over Ewing Oil. The other characters would have been caught in the cross-hairs. Let's send Dallas off in a blaze of glory.
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Exactly. It's rare for an actor to leave a series at the height of its popularity. I can still recall how Bobby's death affected me personally, it was like he had become a member of the family. Patrick had obviously told the producers his wish to leave. I applaud them for having the strength to kill off such a popular character rather than going down that path of replacing Patrick with another actor. They must have learned their mistake replacing Barbara with Donna Reed.

During the off season this was the opportunity for the writers to really develop a strong story evolving around J.R. Ewing and Pamela. The ramifications of Bobby's Will had been set in motion. Dare I say it but maybe when Patrick had announced his intentions of leaving the producers could have gathered the cast, looked at this and said right, "We'll give this two more seasons." The last two series need to be high octane, really pushed the envelope of drama between Pam and J.R. squaring off over Ewing Oil. The other characters would have been caught in the cross-hairs. Let's send Dallas off in a blaze of glory.

Agreed. Dallas would be even better remembered today had Dallas had 2 more seasons after Bobby's death and gone out in a blaze of glory regarding Pam and J.R. at Ewing Oil. It would have ended with a bang, instead of a whimper. There wouldn't have been many negatives in Dallas' history had that happened.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
There wouldn't have been many negatives in Dallas' history had that happened.

My thoughts exactly. If Dallas had left our screens on such a high our appetite for re-visiting the Ewing family (after 1991) would have remained. CBS could easily have developed one off seasons (25 episodes) possibly every 5 years. This way we remained in contact with the Ewing's and not tire of them. It would have been interesting to watch John Ross and Christopher develop from teenagers to young men. Instead when Dallas TNT was introduced I felt like John Ross and Christopher were carrying on as if they were still teenagers instead of smart, articulate young men. I envisioned John Ross being married, perhaps with young children himself. It would have been great to see J.R. sitting in the Southfork living room with said grandson or granddaughter telling stories about Jock and Miss Ellie. It's what Dallas TNT sincerely lacked, a sense of family, tradition.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I personally like the dream season, but a criticism I do have is that Pam didn't fight for Christopher's share of Ewing Oil. I do feel an opportunity was lost there to have Pam enter the snake pit of Ewing Oil in the interests of her son and be faced with the vicious J.R., with neither of them really over Bobby's death. It was an opportunity to have a certain bonding between them and to intensify the hate. There's plenty of potential conflict there that could have lasted a few seasons easily.

I don't see any conflict of interests there. Christopher's interests were in having the most competent person running Ewing Oil to maximize the value of his shares in the company. By what basis could Pam be considered even close to as competent at running Ewing Oil, or any oil company as JR? He spent his entire life learning the business. She never even liked the business. As much as Pam didn't like JR she had no reason JR would ever do anything to hurt Christopher's interest since that would harm his daddy's company and JR lived to make his father proud of him.
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I don't see any conflict of interests there. Christopher's interests were in having the most competent person running Ewing Oil to maximize the value of his shares in the company. By what basis could Pam be considered even close to as competent at running Ewing Oil, or any oil company as JR? He spent his entire life learning the business. She never even liked the business. As much as Pam didn't like JR she had no reason JR would ever do anything to hurt Christopher's interest since that would harm his daddy's company and JR lived to make his father proud of him.

You think J.R. could be trusted not to hurt Christopher's interest at Ewing Oil? I don't. J.R. was basically saying that Bobby made a mistake or didn't realize the implications of leaving his share to Christopher. He wanted Pam to sell to him and made her feel totally unwelcome at Ewing Oil. The potential is there to make them both dig their heels in.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You think J.R. could be trusted not to hurt Christopher's interest at Ewing Oil? I don't. J.R. was basically saying that Bobby made a mistake or didn't realize the implications of leaving his share to Christopher. He wanted Pam to sell to him and made her feel totally unwelcome at Ewing Oil. The potential is there to make them both dig their heels in.

Christopher's share of the company is directly tied to the value of JR's share of Ewing Oil. What would JR's motivation be to harm both Christopher's and JR's own interests in the company? Having the most experienced, most competent person running the company was Christopher's best chance to do well, and choosing Pam to do half of the running of Ewing Oil has neither competence or experience in Christopher's favor. Pam didn't go to college, never worked in the oil business aside from loaning Cliff some money a few times, and she never even was interested in working in the oil business. Her experience was in department stores selling clothing and running an aerobics studio, which was given her because it was the best one in Dallas according to Bobby, and yet in a year the aerobics studio was gone. She wanted a job, wanted one where she could bring Christopher to work, ad the aerobics studio provided both. Pam had the enthusiasm to begin it but lacked the discipline to stick with it for more than a year, much like her job at The Store. She had a history of quitting every job she started, even her job as Cliff's financier. In her words when speaking to Mark: "It's frightening how much more about the oil business JR knows than I do." Mark responded by saying JR spent his life interested in and working in the oil business. Pam did not.
 
Top