What if, no JR Ewing after 1991?

Michelle Stevens

'The Lovely Michelle'
I can't remember if this was ever discussed but what if Larry Hagman wasn't saved by his liver transplant in 1995 and the Dallas franchise never had JR Ewing (at least portrayed by Mr. Hagman) after the end of the CBS series run in 1991? How would the Dallas franchise develop from what we know now if Mr. Hagman wasn't a part of it, if at all?

joel-dallas_2.jpg

Surely Dallas: JR Returns and Dallas: War of the Ewings wouldn't have been made. With the popularity of the Dallas DVD released from 2004-'11, would that have driven a revival of the series? Would the 2012-'14 TNT Dallas ever existed? Would a reboot be more likely or would the series remain dead?

Story-wise, how would it be explained if JR had committed suicide in Conundrum?

The Dallas section has been slow so I thought I'd throw this idea out there. I was always very thankful that Mr. Hagman lived for an additional seventeen years and appeared in the CBS Dallas movies and the TNT Dallas.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I don't think the show would have continued if we had lost Larry back in 1995.

Thank goodness we didn't. Larry Hagman is Dallas & no revival series or any films would've gone ahead without him, that's for sure! :)
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
With the benefit of hindsight JR Returns would have been a fitting climax, given that Leonard Katzman died after it was filmed.

Swami
 

Matthew Blaisdel

Telly Talk Star
And so did "Dallas" for me.
"J.R. returns" was the last decent "Dallas" thing filmed.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
And so did "Dallas" for me.
"J.R. returns" was the last decent "Dallas" thing filmed.

War Of The Ewings wasn't too bad but the main fault with it was having established the great things in JR Returns with the younger members of the cast, they cast them aside along with Cliff Barnes as well.

Swami
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Don't underestimate the power of dead soap characters. JR's masterpiece (and everything else connected to post-JR) is one of the best Dallas stories I've ever seen.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
If Larry had passed in the mid 90's I don't believe for a moment those television types would have ventured forth with Dallas, in any format. And that would have been befitting to both Larry and JR that the show could not survive without them.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
If Larry had passed in the mid 90's I don't believe for a moment those television types would have ventured forth with Dallas, in any format. And that would have been befitting to both Larry and JR that the show could not survive without them.

You are forgetting that they at one point wanted to do a big screen movie reboot without Larry and the rest of the original cast (except minor cameos I guess).

The Dallas IP was at one point too valuable not to do anything with it, like it or not. I think we would've gotten a Dynasty-esque reboot at least if Larry had passed.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
You are forgetting that they at one point wanted to do a big screen movie
Tommie I had not forgotten the potential Dallas Movie. In all serious there was never a chance this would get off the ground despite the constant chatter. When rumours began to swirl John Travolta was destined to play JR I laughed out loud. Only one man could/can/ever play that role and it was Larry. He played it so magnificently other actors will pale in comparison...and rightly so.
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
Tommie I had not forgotten the potential Dallas Movie. In all serious there was never a chance this would get off the ground despite the constant chatter. When rumours began to swirl John Travolta was destined to play JR I laughed out loud. Only one man could/can/ever play that role and it was Larry. He played it so magnificently other actors will pale in comparison...and rightly so.

My point is that the idea was there to do it without Larry. No one thought anyone but Joan Collins would play Alexis, and well, here we are.

Dallas is too much of a valuable IP to just let it sit on the shelf forever - it was, after all, one of the most successful tv series ever. And not just in the US, but worldwide. TNTDallas might have cooled interest for another two decades or so, but I fully expect there to be another attempt to do it (even if it's after I'm long gone).
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
With the benefit of hindsight JR Returns would have been a fitting climax, given that Leonard Katzman died after it was filmed.

Swami

Yeah that was sad too.

I can still remember the dedication to him just after the show finishes, just before the closing credits come up. :(
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Tommie I had not forgotten the potential Dallas Movie. In all serious there was never a chance this would get off the ground despite the constant chatter. When rumours began to swirl John Travolta was destined to play JR I laughed out loud. Only one man could/can/ever play that role and it was Larry. He played it so magnificently other actors will pale in comparison...and rightly so.

So did I mate! John Travolta as JR, what a laugh!

No other actor could ever play JR Ewing other than Larry Hagman.

Dallas as either a series or a movie would only ever happen if Larry Hagman was involved in it.

Larry was Dallas & even when he passed away having Linda Gray & Patrick Duffy involved wasn't enough to guarantee the longevity of the TNT Cyntax Dallas. No wonder it bit the dust. Mind you it was mainly to do with the crap storylines in the third season which killed that show. A shame, if the focus of the writing had remained on the Ewings it might've continued. I didn't mourn it once it was axed. :(
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Only one man could/can/ever play that role and it was Larry. He played it so magnificently other actors will pale in comparison...and rightly so.
Rove, next time you are bopping around online, youtube the video "Dallas Opening Theme J.R. Tribute".

It will confirm your position that nobody else could play J.R.

P.S. It's dusty here in Texas. So when I watch that tribute, my eyes get a little watery and my throught gets tight.

Must be that Texas dust. . .
 

bmasters9

Telly Talk Mega Star
For me to mourn I really need to feel connected. TNT Dallas just didn't have it. I was just thankful it was put out of its misery by the head honcho at TNT's Sports Department.

How did TNT Sports kill TNT Dallas?
 

Clubsoda

Telly Talk Active Member
It's interesting when people say JR/Larry was Dallas yet the last few seasons with him very firmly in the driving seat prove it really isn't just about that character it was about the ensemble.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
It's interesting when people say JR/Larry was Dallas yet the last few seasons with him very firmly in the driving seat prove it really isn't just about that character it was about the ensemble.
I'll be the first in line and argue how dreadful Dallas became but I've always believed the rot had set in much earlier. The return series after Bobby was shot by Katherine is a turning point in my book when Dallas began to lose its way. Everytime I begin to watch "Killer At Large" something is off - both on-screen and off. If I recall Miss Ellie is not even mentioned in the return episode, despite the fact her son has been rushed to hospital after being shot. Afton is quickly disposed of only for Cliff to instantly fall into the arms of Mandy...wait...what?

Then there is the swift confession from Katherine only to exit stage left. I won't even mention that character from the far north waltzing onto Southfork flashing her teeth.
 
Last edited:
Top