What if, no JR Ewing after 1991?

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
It's interesting when people say JR/Larry was Dallas yet the last few seasons with him very firmly in the driving seat prove it really isn't just about that character it was about the ensemble.
Although one might argue that the character in the last couple of seasons was not really the true JR.
 

bmasters9

Telly Talk Mega Star
Although one might argue that the character in the last couple of seasons was not really the true JR.

The O-R CBS J.R., you mean?
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Yeah, the buffoon loser JR of 1990-91.

That has to be the worst decision Leonard Katzman ever made. It almost made Dallas into a sit com, & a not very good one I might add.

JR's character should've been beefed up, not diluted.

Katzman maybe thought mellowing the character was the right way to go. Well it certainly wasn't! He lost his ability to manipulate people & that was a serious detriment to the show. JR was at his best when he was setting people against each other & manipulating them for his own ends. Katzman didn't do the character or the show itself any favours. :(
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
This is a good thread! It's an interesting question.

I can't remember if this was ever discussed but what if Larry Hagman wasn't saved by his liver transplant in 1995 and the Dallas franchise never had JR Ewing (at least portrayed by Mr. Hagman) after the end of the CBS series run in 1991? How would the Dallas franchise develop from what we know now if Mr. Hagman wasn't a part of it, if at all?

joel-dallas_2.jpg

Surely Dallas: JR Returns and Dallas: War of the Ewings wouldn't have been made. With the popularity of the Dallas DVD released from 2004-'11, would that have driven a revival of the series? Would the 2012-'14 TNT Dallas ever existed? Would a reboot be more likely or would the series remain dead?

Story-wise, how would it be explained if JR had committed suicide in Conundrum?

The Dallas section has been slow so I thought I'd throw this idea out there. I was always very thankful that Mr. Hagman lived for an additional seventeen years and appeared in the CBS Dallas movies and the TNT Dallas.

I agree with @Michelle Stevens; the movies JR Returns and War Of The Ewings wouldn't have been made. How could you call it "Dallas" without JR? TNT couldn't have had their Dallas without Larry Hagman in it. He died in their second season and guess what? That next year, their third year, bombed. They stopped resembling Dallas even a little and their network cancelled them.

No disrespect to Patrick Duffy, Linda Gray, and Ken Kercheval. Their presence and the rest of the original cast were vital and the combined ensemble made Dallas what it was. I just don't think the Dallas fanbase would accept a show named Dallas without JR. Without Larry Hagman there is no JR. None of these actors and the roles they played are interchangeable. Think about how Donna Reed was received when she played Miss Ellie for a season.

It is an ensemble but think of how much of Dallas revolved around stories that revolved around JR. Had he died earlier, they could have made a spin-off. I can picture Ray and Donna having their spin-off series. Pam and Bobby, or either one of them could have had a spin-off series. Just not something named "Dallas."

They might have even tried a spin-off with Patrick Duffy anyway, when he didn't become the movie star he'd left Dallas to become. Had they said no to the idea of bringing him back, had they said "No Patrick, Bobby died. We can't kill the credibility of the show to bring you back" they might have gone on that direction. But they didn't.

TNT got a lot of criticism for not being authentic, for not feeling enough like Dallas. And it didn't feel or look very much like Dallas but the name Dallas brought a lot of people to their TV sets, even in 2011. Somewhere around 7 million people watched the first episode and they wouldn't have been there without Larry Hagman being part of it. TNT Dallas lasted as long as it did because even though they lost three and a half million viewers after the first episode, they still had another three and a half million left. They managed to lose them as quickly as they could too, but even with CC's ineptness, it took a little while.
 
Last edited:

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I'll be the first in line and argue how dreadful Dallas became but I've always believed the rot had set in much earlier. The return series after Bobby was shot by Katherine is a turning point in my book when Dallas began to lose its way. Everytime I begin to watch "Killer At Large" something is off - both on-screen and off. If I recall Miss Ellie is not even mentioned in the return episode, despite the fact her son has been rushed to hospital after being shot. Afton is quickly disposed of only for Cliff to instantly fall into the arms of Mandy...wait...what?

Then there is the swift confession from Katherine only to exit stage left. I won't even mention that character from the far north waltzing onto Southfork flashing her teeth.

yeah, I've been watching the beginning of that season recently, and... right after a few really really strong seasons, all of a sudden things just seem 'cheaper' (even though the outfits were fancier). I remember someone posting the clip where Katherine gets arrested in the hospital a while back and, not having seen anything that far along in the series in years, thinking it seemed like something straight out of a cheapo daytime soap - completely lacking gravitas and not believable at all, and not really all that entertaining as camp either. It wasn't quite as jarring when I watched it in context following the previous season this time, but it still seemed really lightweight and silly.
 
Last edited:

Michelle Stevens

'The Lovely Michelle'
This is a good thread! It's an interesting question.



I agree with @Michelle Stevens; the movies JR Returns and War Of The Ewings wouldn't have been made. How could you call it "Dallas" without JR? TNT couldn't have had their Dallas without Larry Hagman in it. He died in their second season and guess what? The show dead the next year. That next year, their third year, bombed. Their network cancelled them.

TNT got a lot of criticism for not being authentic, for not feeling enough like Dallas. And it didn't feel or look very much like Dallas but the name Dallas brought a lot of people to their TV sets, even in 2011. Somewhere around 7 million people watched the first episode and they wouldn't have been there without Larry Hagman being part of it. TNT Dallas lasted as long as it did because even though they lost three and a half million viewers after the first episode, they still had another three and a half million left. They managed to lose them as quickly as they could too, but even with CC's ineptness, it took a little while.

I get the impression that if Mr. Hagman had died in 1995 that there would have been pressure at some point to do some newer version even if it were a reboot. I remember how 1980's nostalgia was at it's peak during the time we got the season by season releases from '04-'11. A Dallas without JR would be interesting if written well. A franchise with the earning potential at that time would be hard for a studio to resist if a good script came about. It's just thinking of all of the what if's in the Dallas universe with no JR. :think:

If TNT Dallas successes was hinged on an eighty-plus year-old man then it was doomed from the start. With all this talk it just makes us thankful Mr. Hagman lived another seventeen years and gave us more memories.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
yeah, I've been watching the beginning of that season recently, and... all of a sudden things just seem 'cheaper' (even though the outfits were fancier). I remember someone posting the clip where Katherine gets arrested in the hospital a while back and, not having seen anything that far along in the series in years, thinking it seemed like something straight out of a cheapo daytime soap - completely lacking gravitas and not believable at all. It wasn't quite as jarring when I watched it on context following the previous season this time, but it still seemed really lightweight and silly.

I've never noticed that about season 8. I'll look for that the next time I watch an episode from it and see if I notice it too.

I was wondering if the show was in trouble in season 8 and maybe they didn't have the money to make it look as fancy as before since TV is run by ratings and the higher a rating you have, the more you can charge for advertising. Here's what I found:

1 5 April 2, 1978 April 30, 1978 #44 N/A
2 24 September 23, 1978 March 30, 1979 #15 16.8
3
25 September 21, 1979 March 21, 1980 #6 19.1
4
23 November 7, 1980 May 1, 1981 #1 27.6
5
26 October 9, 1981 April 9, 1982 #1 23.2
6
28 October 1, 1982 May 6, 1983 #2 20.5
7
30 September 30, 1983 May 18, 1984 #1 21.5
8
30 September 28, 1984 May 17, 1985 #2 20.97
9
31 September 27, 1985 May 16, 1986 #6 18.8
10
29 September 26, 1986 May 15, 1987 #11 18.6
11
30 September 25, 1987 May 13, 1988 #21 15.2
12
26 October 28, 1988 May 19, 1989 #30 13.9
13
27 September 22, 1989 May 11, 1990 #43 N/A
14 23 November 2, 1990 May 3, 1991 #61 N/A

It looks to me like the 2 biggest things that hurt the show were Patrick Duffy leaving, a 2.17 drop then, and Victoria Principal, Susan Howard, and Deborah Shelton leaving (a 3.4 drop). I thought the announcement "Last season was all a dream" would have hurt more than a .2 drop. It tells me that losing the actors fans liked playing the characters they liked hurt more than any single storyline being "questionable" at best.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
If TNT Dallas successes was hinged on an eighty-plus year-old man then it was doomed from the start. With all this talk it just makes us thankful Mr. Hagman lived another seventeen years and gave us more memories.

I'm thankful too.

I didn't mean to imply TNT's show needed to revolve around JR, just that he needed to be part of it for people to accept a show named "Dallas." How do you have "Dallas" without JR? It would be like The Rolling Stones without Mick Jagger. When John Bonham died, Led Zeppelin broke up. Some people you can't replace. Not that the rest of the people in those bands couldn't still be successful in other bands. They could. Robert Plant still tours and he even does some Zeppelin songs in his set but he doesn't try to call the band Led Zeppelin.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I've never noticed that about season 8. I'll look for that the next time I watch an episode from it and see if I notice it too.

I was wondering if the show was in trouble in season 8 and maybe they didn't have the money to make it look as fancy as before since TV is run by ratings and the higher a rating you have, the more you can charge for advertising. Here's what I found:

1 5 April 2, 1978 April 30, 1978 #44 N/A
2 24 September 23, 1978 March 30, 1979 #15 16.8
3
25 September 21, 1979 March 21, 1980 #6 19.1
4
23 November 7, 1980 May 1, 1981 #1 27.6
5
26 October 9, 1981 April 9, 1982 #1 23.2
6
28 October 1, 1982 May 6, 1983 #2 20.5
7
30 September 30, 1983 May 18, 1984 #1 21.5
8
30 September 28, 1984 May 17, 1985 #2 20.97
9
31 September 27, 1985 May 16, 1986 #6 18.8
10
29 September 26, 1986 May 15, 1987 #11 18.6
11
30 September 25, 1987 May 13, 1988 #21 15.2
12
26 October 28, 1988 May 19, 1989 #30 13.9
13
27 September 22, 1989 May 11, 1990 #43 N/A
14 23 November 2, 1990 May 3, 1991 #61 N/A

It looks to me like the 2 biggest things that hurt the show were Patrick Duffy leaving, a 2.17 drop then, and Victoria Principal, Susan Howard, and Deborah Shelton leaving (a 3.4 drop). I thought the announcement "Last season was all a dream" would have hurt more than a .2 drop. It tells me that losing the actors fans liked playing the characters they liked hurt more than any single storyline being "questionable" at best.

I don’t necessarily mean “less expensive production values, but just, I don’t know, kind of “mailing it in” a bit? Not trying as hard? I don’t know... I thought the Edgar Randolph trying to shoot JR scene was pretty corny, too.

Of course, the action/police sequences were always pretty hit and miss in the earlier seasons as well - I’m thinking of Bobby punching out the drug dealer in a warehouse at the end of that one season as the cops swooped in to make the arrest - laughable!
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
That has to be the worst decision Leonard Katzman ever made. It almost made Dallas into a sit com, & a not very good one I might add.

JR's character should've been beefed up, not diluted.

Katzman maybe thought mellowing the character was the right way to go. Well it certainly wasn't! He lost his ability to manipulate people & that was a serious detriment to the show. JR was at his best when he was setting people against each other & manipulating them for his own ends. Katzman didn't do the character or the show itself any favours. :(

I agree. I agree that something had to change. He was getting older and so much with him had already been done. But not weaken him - stronger, wealthier, more powerful to step into Jock’s role. I thought the idea of James was a good one (though his mother should have been more Alexis and less the “love of JR’s life”). I am do thought James should be jealous of John Ross, not the other way around. Miss Ellie should have given SF to John Ross in trust with Bobby - not given it to Bobby and weakened JR. Instead of Cain and Abel it would the story of David and his sons, John Ross being Soleman. Then Wendell returns. IMO.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
As always, it comes back to the writing. Dallas needn't be "the JR show".

I never thought it was "the JR show", but JR was one of the fundamental components that made Dallas what it was. Take JR out and you have something entirely different. It might be good, it might be bad, but it ain't Dallas.
 
Top