James from London
International Treasure
Yeah, cos JR split up her and Ray and she was really angry about it.HUH?
Yeah, cos JR split up her and Ray and she was really angry about it.HUH?
Weren't these alternate scenes of different characters firing the gun just filmed for the blooper reel? Those weren't consistent with what was seen in "A House Divided". Most of them were standing in front of JR's desk, when really both he and the shooter were in the outer office. Some of them were shouting "Take That!", immediately giving away their identities, and one of thsese scenes was filmed outside in daylight. Unless there really were some proper alternative reveal scenes filmed as well?CBS went to great lengths to keep it a secret. They even filmed the cast taking turns firing the gun. Linda was the only one who knew for sure who shot him because she recorded the voiceover "It was you, Kristin.".
I'm not old enough to remember it. But I agree that keeping things a secret is the right way to go with it.
I think today we have so many spoilers that they sometimes ends up ruining the show. I really hated the way Dallas TNT tried to hype up their ratings with "which Ewing will die" campaign as it just left me wondering the entire episode who would die and when Christopher was blown up it was not a shock. It was more of a "oh no not Christopher". But then again I really didn't want them to kill off any of the Ewings.![]()
That's revisionism. At the time, DALLAS was only two years old, and the "rules" we now take for granted, we didn't then. There was no assumption that Kristen was the shooter. And I was around then.There was never any scenes with Bobby, Pam, or Lucy shooting JR. The producers were never going to have Jock or Ellie do it, and Cliff and Sue Ellen would be too obvious, Kristin obviously did it (and it was obvious she DID do it). I don't know why everyone was so surprised! A five year-old could figure it out!
Since this was the beginning of the '80s nighttime soap tradition, they made no bones about JR being shot -- it was actually advertized in the TV Guide in advance.I am very confused! A House Divided is the episode where JR is shot. I didn’t think this was about who shot JR just that JR is shot. Did people know JR would be shot before a house divided Aired? I think the answer is yes. Everyone knew he would be shot. Would it have been better if no one knew jr was shot? Like no one knew Will was shot to death on good wife?!?
Somehow I had managed to stay spoiler-free on that but when the dream resolution was finally screened here, after the initial shock my first reaction was, what about Knots Landing?RE: the dream, the only thing that was throwing people off was the fact that no one could believe that they would sacrifice the continuity between Dallas and KL!
How could Kristen's guilt be "very obvious" when even the writers didn't know who the culprit was when they first came up with the idea of shooting JR?I disagree - it was very obvious, as was Julia being the killer of Carlo on FC, especially after not seeing her car accident that was set up by her and Mr. Fong.
Or really that DALLAS would do something so self-destructively stupid, which -- aside from Donna Reed's hiring -- it never had before.TJames03 said:RE: the dream, the only thing that was throwing people off was the fact that no one could believe that they would sacrifice the continuity between Dallas and KL!
How could Kristen's guilt be "very obvious" when even the writers didn't know who the culprit was when they first came up with the idea of shooting JR?
Or really that DALLAS would do something so self-destructively stupid, which -- aside from Donna Reed's hiring -- it never had before.
I still disagree. There is no way the producers would write out any of the main characters by having them shoot JR. Never ever. A secondary character would have to be the one to go.
Assuming it would be a supporting character didn't mean it was destined to be Kristen -- not when all that WSJR? stuff was going on in 1980.I still disagree. There is no way the producers would write out any of the main characters by having them shoot JR. Never ever. A secondary character would have to be the one to go.
You seem to forget they did not write the shooter out.
I'm not sure he follows DALLAS that closely.Yes, they did. Mary Crosby left immediately after, then returned for just a handful of episodes then was killed off.
OK, OK -- nobody's disputing that except possibly for Michael Torrance who isn't really a DALLAS guy.MC WAS written out immediately after. Kristin was banished to CA., had a miscarriage, got pregnant again, appeared on KL, came back to Dallas, and drowned.
Even Camille Marchetta stated that when she left, no staff writer knew would be the culprit.
As Snarky said, Kristin was just a logical choice. I believe that Cliff might have been considered too (he was not that important in the early days).
I think there's something lawless about those 60s, 70s and early 80s tv-series.At the time, DALLAS was only two years old, and the "rules" we now take for granted, we didn't then
I thought it was Melissa!it was very obvious, as was Julia being the killer of Carlo on FC
I love good twist-y plots, what I don't like is when they keep twisting the same plot for no other reason than to stretch to story (e.g. Lost, Revenge).Now twist plots are the norm, which I think quickly desensitize the audience (" Scandal" and "How to Get Away with Murder" I am looking at you) and they lose interest in the very gimmicks that draw them in to begin with.
Besides, who says that killers have to be written out?