Bobby
Telly Talk Newbie
Looking at each season on a scale of 1-4 stars (not counting TNT version) what does everyone think?
Mini Series - ***1/2
Season 1 - ***1/2
Season 2 - ****
Season 3 - ***
Season 4 - ***1/2
Season 5 - ****
Season 6 - ***1/2
Season 7 - ***1/2
Season 8 - ***
Season 9 - **
Season 10 - ***
Season 11 - **1/2
Season 12 - **1/2
Season 13 - **
Season 14 - *1/2
JR Returns - ***
War of Ewing's - *
Recently rewatching the entire series, a few things really stuck out.
Season 2 is unbelievable from start to finish. Season 5 may have it beat though. Both of these seasons are perfectly scripted. The storylines are real, genuine and exciting.
All the other Early Seasons were strong, although Season 3 had some boring characters such as Alex Ward and Clint which really dragged down the season in some ways. Seasom 8 may have had best episode in the series but the boring Naldo Storyline, Pam's trip to Japan and dealing with Donna Reed all season keep it from being special.
Ranking the Seasons in terms of enjoyment
Season 5
Season 2
Season 4
Season 1
Mini Series
Season 3
Season 10
Season 8
Season 11
Season 12
Season 13
Season 9
Season 14
Mini Series - ***1/2
Season 1 - ***1/2
Season 2 - ****
Season 3 - ***
Season 4 - ***1/2
Season 5 - ****
Season 6 - ***1/2
Season 7 - ***1/2
Season 8 - ***
Season 9 - **
Season 10 - ***
Season 11 - **1/2
Season 12 - **1/2
Season 13 - **
Season 14 - *1/2
JR Returns - ***
War of Ewing's - *
Recently rewatching the entire series, a few things really stuck out.
Season 2 is unbelievable from start to finish. Season 5 may have it beat though. Both of these seasons are perfectly scripted. The storylines are real, genuine and exciting.
All the other Early Seasons were strong, although Season 3 had some boring characters such as Alex Ward and Clint which really dragged down the season in some ways. Seasom 8 may have had best episode in the series but the boring Naldo Storyline, Pam's trip to Japan and dealing with Donna Reed all season keep it from being special.
Ranking the Seasons in terms of enjoyment
Season 5
Season 2
Season 4
Season 1
Mini Series
Season 3
Season 10
Season 8
Season 11
Season 12
Season 13
Season 9
Season 14




