Mustard
Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Money was also a factor in her departure in 1990, IIRC
They offered Barbara the same contract for Season 14 DVD that Howard Keel was offered, for 4 episodes only. Howard accepted the offer, Barbara turned it down and retired from acting.
I do think the producers were shortsighted in letting her walk away in 1984. Surely there was room for some compromise, but I also think the producers wanted to make an example of her, to show the others that they could be replaced if they wanted too much money.
It was Philip Capice, who remembered what Larry Hagman did in 1980 with his successful contract renegotiation. What Capice did in 1984 backfired, and he admitted so by asking Barbara back.
Frankly, I blame Hagman as much as any of them. Lorimar’s mission was to run a profitable business. To keep paying Larry his exorbitant salary, they started cutting away core cast members in the later years. They acted, financially, as if Dallas was “The Larry Hagman Show”. From a creative standpoint, it certainly wasn’t.
Larry isn't to blame for what happened to Barbara in 1984. He didn't know about it until it was too late, although he did try to get his real-life mother Mary Martin to take over before Donna Reed was confirmed in the role. Larry Hagman and Philip Capice were rivals almost as much as Capice and Leonard Katzman by this point.