Decline of Soap Operas - was OJ Simpson to blame?

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
Nearly lost my eye sight reading the BBC website and the family pop up! Interesting article!

_106087015_dallas_976alamy.jpg


https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-47585335

Soap opera was once the mainstay of television entertainment, and their characters part of everyday conversation. Now there are only four such programmes on air in the US. What happened?

In 1969, there were 18 daytime soap operas on US television. Now there are only four.

The Bold and the Beautiful, Days of Our Lives, General Hospital and The Young and the Restless are the only ones left standing, to the disappointment of soap fans.

"That sense of community and television, I think, has disappeared in this country," said Joan DeJean, a trustee professor at the University of Pennsylvania, who has fond memories of gathering around the TV with friends after lunch when at college.

The genre was first established in the 1930s on radio, sponsored by detergent companies such as Procter and Gamble and Colgate-Palmolive, and they became known for their bad scripts and high drama, hence the name.

They were initially used as a vehicle to advertise household products to women, says Miriam Berg, an assistant professor in residence at Northwestern University in Qatar.

The migration to television happened in the 1950s and eventually to primetime, although these were more likely to be once a week.

One of the most famous moments in soap history came in 1980 when JR Ewing was left a bloody mess on his office floor in the weekly primetime show Dallas.

The armed assailant's identity was kept under wraps for months until the next episode, and the intervening summer was filled with speculation - there were T-shirts and other merchandise asking the question everyone was asking. Who shot JR?

t employed the classic soap opera device - the cliffhanger - to maximum effect.

About 350 million people around the world tuned in to find out the answer - it was Kristin, JR's sister-in-law.

The reason for the growth of soap operas during the 1990s was its continuous narrative format, which meant that these shows would run for decades, leaving viewers hung up at the end of each episode.

"There is no ending prescribed, they can go on for years, decades," says Ms DeJean.

Soaps dealt with controversial social issues in a more developed and thoughtful way than earlier forms of television, says Elana Levine, a professor in the department of journalism, advertising and media studies at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, which included abortion, race relations, sexuality and generational conflicts.

"You really delve into personal relations, emotions, romance," says Ms Berg.

But the end was nigh.

C Lee Harrington, a professor of sociology at Miami University, says the OJ Simpson trial in 1995 was a major factor in the soap opera's decline.

The trial was televised for months, taking daytime soaps off the air, and they never fully recovered, says Ms Harrington.

Added to that, she says, the trial gave viewers a glimpse of a world of entertainment that could more than match a soap - the real lives of the rich and famous.

Today, there are few clearer examples of that than Keeping Up with The Kardashians, which has been going on for just over a decade.

What is ironic is that the lawyer in the OJ Simpson trial was a Kardashian family member.

Ms Harrington says the Kardashians are a current example of an ongoing narrative that audiences are emotionally invested in. She says that people who follow the Kardashians tend to follow them as if they're a fictional family.

"Perhaps some of what shows on [keeping up with the Kardashians] is fictionalised, no doubt, but it's a soap opera," said Ms Harrington.

"The romances, the betrayal, the divorce, the birth, the affairs, we are engaged in many similar ways with celebrity culture that we used to be with fictional narrative in the daytime."

Another reason that reality television took off in the 1990s was that it was much cheaper to produce than a soap opera, says Ms Harrington.

Budget cuts had hit TV soaps hard, due to the significant amount of money that was spent on clothes, remote shooting and the set decoration. After the spending cuts, the quality of programmes declined, and directors and writers began to quit.
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
It is a shame that the soap opera has been reduced to 4. I grew up watching the mini series which is not done anymore. there was the telenovas which I did like as well which did not pick up audiences.

As for the soaps, I could go to them if its well written and has good characters.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Yes. Soap operas never fully recovered from being interrupted for the OJ trial for the better part of a year, which was more compelling than any scripted show.
 

TJames03

Banned
Nighttime soaps died years before Simpson, daytime soaps were dying because of intelligence insulting story lines, etc. Everything has a natural end....
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Everything has a natural end....
But everything old is new again. Let's not forget just over 8 million American viewers tuned into the opening episode of TNT Dallas. The issue - which has been critiqued often enough on this site - is the writers/showrunner/producers tampered with the original Dallas timeline. By the following week half the viewers had left. But just by those opening ratings there was - and still is I believe - a market for the Ewing family saga.

I'll admit it would be very difficult for commercial television to introduce a new series based on the old format like Dallas, Dynasty, Falcon Crest and Knots Landing and this was evident with the recent failure - Blood & Oil. But I'll continue to argue there was still an appetite for the Ewing family. There was/is something unique about this family which still holds the public's fascination. Why is that? Could it be there are still people out there - like me - hankering for a series like Dallas to return? The Ewing family still has a story to tell.

Perhaps a series like Dallas no longer belongs on commercial television but a streaming service. Time and time again many customers, friends and relatives I speak with are no longer watching commercial television because of the wall to wall reality nonsense. I get it's cheaper to produce but don't tell me it's real. Bulldust on that one. That Keeping up with the Dashound family wouldn't exist if not amplifying chaos or friction to keep the viewers glued.

As for daytime soaps? I understand why they're nearly dead in the water. It's the same tired old dribble with fresh and ever younger faces. I'm tired of teenager angst. It's like they have the weight of the world on their shoulders. Hell, when I was that age we lived outdoors and enjoyed everything - and still do - the world has to offer.

Take a close look at how these soaps of today operate and you will begin to truly appreciate how far removed they've become from reality. No teenagers or people I know in their 20's and 30's are spending countless hours talking to each other without attending school, university or work. And when they're not doing these things they are on their smartphones, tablets, or computers. Daytime soaps desperately need a reality check if they are to survive.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Maybe it was the high cost that killed it and maybe some influence from reality tv but I think corp. politics and bad writing killed it - no longer were writers given a task to tell a well written and creative drama pulling from real life stories. From how Dallas brought back Bobby to how Dallas TNT ignored original Dallas. The stories were about family, the c-suites of business and politics. They were classic tragedies with enough light hearted comedy to keep you coming back. They changed to cheese and disrespect.

JR was based on HL Hunt - could have had a second family hidden just as Hunt did. Could have brought in a J. Paul Getty character, Jeremey Wendell, married to Katherine. There’s no end in sight to the story but the foils (like Cliff Barnes) exhaust themselves. Let them go away and if the chance presents itself, let them come back in years to come. Focus on the core - JR and Sue Ellen and John Ross. Yes it started as Bobby and Pam but that didn’t work out - could have given them their own show instead of killing off Bobby. Then when Wendell exhausts himself move onto brothers modeled after the Koch Brothers, Marv and Jeb Anderson. And don’t be afraid to let JR win. Dive into the headlines and the stories which grip us. A crazy President. AIDS. Rich people getting away with murder.

I’m sure the same applies for the other soaps. After all once Angela, the core of Falcon Crest, left, the show was over. Angela, Lance and Richard were Falcon Crest. Foils come and go - sometimes too quickly on Falcon Crest. Chase was just a foil. The show went on without him.

Another flaw I saw was replacing people - totally like Donna Reed’s time on Dallas or Lauren stepping into Maggie’s shoes. Come on. Does anyone need to say don’t do that? Like why did anyone need to say a Dream season was a bad idea?

And another I saw with Dallas was it tried to be more like Dynasty for a bit. Ok bring in Foils like Alexis - Elizabeth Taylor as JR’s first lover - a well polished and scornful bitch who eats caviar and drinks Champaign, Wendell’s first wife and large West Star shareholder. Let her bring JR and Sue Ellen closer not replace Sue Ellen.

Just some ideas.
 

TJames03

Banned
But everything old is new again. Let's not forget just over 8 million American viewers tuned into the opening episode of TNT Dallas. The issue - which has been critiqued often enough on this site - is the writers/showrunner/producers tampered with the original Dallas timeline. By the following week half the viewers had left. But just by those opening ratings there was - and still is I believe - a market for the Ewing family saga.

I'll admit it would be very difficult for commercial television to introduce a new series based on the old format like Dallas, Dynasty, Falcon Crest and Knots Landing and this was evident with the recent failure - Blood & Oil. But I'll continue to argue there was still an appetite for the Ewing family. There was/is something unique about this family which still holds the public's fascination. Why is that? Could it be there are still people out there - like me - hankering for a series like Dallas to return? The Ewing family still has a story to tell.

Perhaps a series like Dallas no longer belongs on commercial television but a streaming service. Time and time again many customers, friends and relatives I speak with are no longer watching commercial television because of the wall to wall reality nonsense. I get it's cheaper to produce but don't tell me it's real. Bulldust on that one. That Keeping up with the Dashound family wouldn't exist if not amplifying chaos or friction to keep the viewers glued.

As for daytime soaps? I understand why they're nearly dead in the water. It's the same tired old dribble with fresh and ever younger faces. I'm tired of teenager angst. It's like they have the weight of the world on their shoulders. Hell, when I was that age we lived outdoors and enjoyed everything - and still do - the world has to offer.

Take a close look at how these soaps of today operate and you will begin to truly appreciate how far removed they've become from reality. No teenagers or people I know in their 20's and 30's are spending countless hours talking to each other without attending school, university or work. And when they're not doing these things they are on their smartphones, tablets, or computers. Daytime soaps desperately need a reality check if they are to survive.

I still say that everything has a natural end. On every soap, there are such stupid and tired tropes. Also, the scenes are too quick. I would reduce all of the soaps to just a half and hour, drop all but the vets, and rebuild.

I do not know about the other soaps that were cancelled, but AMC and OLTL were reduced to absolute garbage and needed to be canceled.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I'm tired of teenager angst. It's like they have the weight of the world on their shoulders. Hell, when I was that age we lived outdoors and enjoyed everything
I agree, but I also don't. My problem with all the "teenager angst" of these series is that it's largely bogus angst as portrayed. You may not have had angst as a teenager, but many do. The problem is that these shows just used teen angst as an excuse to place young naked bodies by the swimming pool 24/7. And, yes, even that gets old really fast.

But then no age is ever portrayed more unrealistically as teenagers.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Daytime soaps had a feeder audience--older generations would teach younger generations to watch them, and that mostly included stay-at-home moms and grandmas. They were also a product of a time when there were usually one or two screens per home. Today every one has at least if not more personal screens, watching all sorts of content. I think the reason these 4 soaps in the US stay on the air is because there is still a critical mass of audience watching them, but no significant new numbers are added. Eventually they will die as well.

I don't think everything must end. Biologists are still trying to figure why humans die, as there is no earthly reason for the cells to do so--they actually have to be switched to stop regenerating. What I think is that everything changes. People used to not be able to binge-watch shows until a few years ago. Now if somebody wants to, they can watch 35 seasons (or thereabouts) of Grey's Anatomy during breaks instead of some daytime soap. As people's lives change, so do their viewing habits.
 

bmasters9

Telly Talk Mega Star

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
As people's lives change, so do their viewing habits.
I can attest to that. Since joining Netflix 12 months ago my viewing habits have changed. I watch little commercial television except my local nightly news, then it's back to Netflix. I've also noted how little I'm visiting my DVD collection. My recent viewing on Netflix was The Umbrella Academy. My nephew was surprised I'd watch a series like it as he knows my tastes in movies and series but streaming services allow me the luxury of absorbing the first episode or two without the jarring commercials interrupting my viewing.

However, returning to the subject matter I suspect the OJ Simpson trial may have affected viewing numbers in America more so than any other country. Though I'm familiar with the case I recall having no interest in it - despite the Australian media's fascination with it and their attempts at drumming up interest. What may grip the public's attention in one country does not necessarily repeat itself in another.

Not all American soaps were available for viewing in Australia. The main players were Days of our Lives and The Young and the Restless. Both are no longer on commercial television here in Oz and have moved to satellite services. When this decision was made I remember some sections of the public were rattled. I'm guessing they signed up to satellite or simply found another interest.

I'd be curious to know if Netflix would ever consider the genre of soap. Not every series should be aiming for a Golden Globe or Emmy. I'd go so far as saying the genre of soap on a streaming service could actually work as the producers/writers wouldn't be hamstrung by the confines of commercial television parental approval ratings and TV Executives overplaying their roles.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
with the Bold and the Beautiful?
I think this is the last remaining of the American soaps on Australian commercial television. It's screened at 4:30 in the afternoon. How it manages to stay on-air is beyond me. Another prime example of youth and dull repetitive scripts over substance. At least in its heyday it would remind the viewer - on occasion - it was about fashion. My understanding is most - if not all - actors playing the parts of the Forrester family have been recast. Could explain why not as many eyeballs are watching this once additive afternoon series.
 

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
O.J. Simpson? I don't even know why that case reached such hysterical proportions. On the surface, it looked like O.J.'s long time volatile relationship/marriage with his ex-wife Nicole had finally gone too far, ending with O.J. murdering his ex-wife, and the prosecution had much blood evidence at the crime scene. It seemed that the prosecution had him. Yet going by what was actually presented in court at his trial, I personally believe that NOT GUILTY was the correct verdict. How can the blood evidence be used in the prosecution case when you have a policeman, Mark Fuhrmann, caught being racist on audio tape and refusing to deny under oath that he had contaminated the crime scene with O.J.'s DNA? On top of that, the gloves didn't fit O.J.'s hands and there was no murder weapon nor blood stained clothes of O.J.'s. And of course, O.J.'s main lawyer, Johnny Cochran, told the perfect and true story of racism in the USA.

As for the subsequent outrage at his acquittal, how come there is never such a huge outrage at how policemen across the USA murder black people and get away with it, to this day? And in 2008, when O.J. Simpson finally ended up in jail, he just happened to be sentenced on the 13th anniversary of his previous acquittal (what a coincidence), and sentenced to a ridiculously long sentence for armed robbery. Wasn't it something like 27 years, with him serving 9 years? It's a circus over there in the US.

As for the Kardashians, I keep hearing that Kim Kardashian's sex tape is the reason that they are famous. In reality, it's O.J. Simpson's long-term friendship with the late Robert Kardashian that made their name, especially in light of O.J.'s murder trial. There's also those long persistent rumours that O.J. is the biological father of Khloe Kardashian.
 
Last edited:

Mustard

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Marcia Clark?

No, Marcia Clark was the main prosecution lawyer.

One of O.J. Simpson's long-time best friends was Robert Kardashian (father of the famous girls we hear about today like Kim). Robert became one of O.J.'s defence lawyers at the murder trial. Robert was also a close friend of Nicole Simpson. As the murder trial developed, Robert started to doubt his friend's innocence. While happy at O.J's acquittal and satisfied with nearly everything, he could never shake off the one thing that was really bugging him. How did O.J. Simpson's blood end up at the crime scene? Their relationship was never as close again.
 
Last edited:

Karin

Moderator
Staff Member
Personally I've never been into watching daytime soaps. Too slow paced and repeatitive for my liking.
I tried to get into Coronation Street when I was a teenager but it was a snoozefest.
I did get sucked into B & B for a while when I began watching it regularly to see Patrick Duffy guest star as Brooke's dad. He was too young to play her dad but oh well. I did watch that for a couple of months then and I'd say that B & B is the one day time soap opera I have seen the most of since my dad used to watch it when I was growing up. So I saw bits and pieces every here and there.

Anyway I'd gladly take a daytime soap like B & B over most reality garbage that's out there!
I am definitely not into those kinds of shows. I tried to watch an episode of the Kardashians while on an airplane last year but lost interest after five minutes. So I definitely don't get the hype.

So well the only reality shows I've watched are dating shows like "The Bachlor" and "The Bachlorette". I watched when they first came out since the contestants were somewhat older than I was and I found it interesting to watch then. Now most of the contestants are younger than me so I no longer find it interesting.

I also watched "Newlyweds". But over all I am not into these type of shows at all.

So give me a prime time soap opera and I'd rather watch that, even if it's on DVD and I've already seen it once or twice. In my eyes the TV shows was better back in the 1980s and 1990s than most stuff that's on the air today!

Fortunately there are some exceptions, I must say that I really enjoy current shows like "The Crown" and "Victoria" which except for having better cinematography is actually modern soaps that are given more status due to being about actual historical persons, which makes them fit into the historical drama category. But yes those shows are modern soaps IMHO.:gotcha:
 
Top