"Dallas" Politically Incorrect?

What Do You Think Would Ultimately Happen As A Result Of Dallas Debuting Now And Angering PC Groups


  • Total voters
    6
  • Poll closed .

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
It's in the nature of things for us to progress! Yet now, we're more uptight and restrictive than we've been in so long that it seems like a return to a 1950s mentality. It goes against the natural order of things
At least we still got Miley Cyrus!
 

Toni

Maximum Member
I don't know why he would be. It's basic manners. It shows respect. What was the fist name of Dr Danvers, the doctor who made house calls when one of the Ewings wasn't feeling good? I'm not sure we eve heard his first name and they said Doctor too. They didn't just say "Hey Danvers, My son is sick" did they? Who would do that? That's just rude.

I´m sure Jock, Miss Ellie and probably also Donna (I remember her scene with him when he tells her she´s pregnant) did call him Harlan. And Sue Ellen would call him anything whenever he gives him a good shot of something strong!!
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
It's basic manners. It shows respect
It's the difference between Mr. Ewing and Mr. Bobby.
Mr. Ewing is the formal way, in the case of Mr.Jock and Mr. Bobby the joke is on the Ewings.
However
So she doesn't use the term out of subservience, but as a business move that exploits pre-existing notions of subservience.
The fact that she uses the term out of free will or as a business tactic doesn't make it much better.
The wrong message being: a role play to capitalize on historical misfortune and degradation in order to be successful in the modern world.
She cheekily explains why she does it, and that takes the sting out of it, but that doesn't change the fact that she's doing it.
It's similar to women exploiting sexism: show some legs in order to get that extra bit of validation, or the gay man pretending to be straight or overtly effeminate (whatever suits the situation best).

But that's how the world works: we adjust and try to make the best of it.
It doesn't bother me, personally, but I could imagine that this kind of perception would not be welcomed in modern storytelling.
We should never have to pretend, the validation is purely based on our skills. And I think that's a good thing. At the same time I think there's something unsettling about the idea that someone's fiction/creation needs to be altered or censored by modern standards, or any standard for that matter.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
At the same time I think there's something unsettling about the idea that someone's fiction/creation needs to be altered or censored by modern standards, or any standard for that matter.

Nothing has to be censored or altered. People can leave their creations as they imagined them. But those who live by the free market, die by the free market. When advertisers boycott or abandon someone, when the social media or regular media turn against them, and when the viewers or readers abandon them, they have been judged for that creation. If they have been savvy, they have found venues and audiences impervious to such reactions. If not, it was nice knowing them. The media agora is very Darwinian.
 

James from London

International Treasure
The fact that she uses the term out of free will or as a business tactic doesn't make it much better.
The wrong message being: a role play to capitalize on historical misfortune and degradation in order to be successful in the modern world.
She cheekily explains why she does it, and that takes the sting out of it, but that doesn't change the fact that she's doing it.
It's similar to women exploiting sexism: show some legs in order to get that extra bit of validation

So Tilly exploits racism in the same way that Sue Ellen exploits sexism when she starts Valentine Lingerie: "I'm a woman. I know my audience."
 
Last edited:

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Right. Especially if some PC group would succeed in getting the show cancelled (not my idea, it just happens to be the concept of this thread)

But if a show is on a network/venue susceptible to such pressure, that was still a choice . There are nowadays plenty of venues where such pressure would not exist. Even the ratings pressure is not omnipresent.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
So Tilly exploits racism in the same way that Sue Ellen exploits sexism when she starts Valentine Lingerie: "I'm a woman. I know my audience."
I think so, yes. It exploits the idea that all women are sex objects, better still: want to be sex objects.
There are nowadays plenty of venues where such pressure would not exist
Or maybe, not yet.
 
Last edited:

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Or maybe, not yet.

There is quite a big backlash against such pressures; the left and particularly some militant and delusional factions have overplayed their hand many times, most recently in the US in 2016, when they helped elect Donald Trump as president. I think the overall public doesn't go to either extremes of bigotry, sexism, and homophobia nor to painting everyone as a white privileged cracker who needs to be (as per their ungrammatical pet term) "woke."
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
I think the overall public doesn't go to either extremes of bigotry, sexism, and homophobia nor to painting everyone as a white privileged cracker who needs to be (as per their ungrammatical pet term) "woke."
I agree, but who knows what the future will bring?
Just look at the smoking ban issue, it demonstrates how we can lose our sense of proportion.
Ironically, fictional smoking habits have increased significantly in TV entertainment, and it's not the casual style smoking of the 70s and 80s, it's a thing. Peaky Blinders even made artsy sequences out of lighting a cigarette.
I guess that supports you backlash argument?
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Yes, it is in season 10 - the season in which they temporarily lost the right to use the Ewing Oil name and were fined roughly 667 million dollars by the government. Do you think any of that money went to the "little people" as Scotfield put it? I doubt it! It probably filled the corrupt politician's back pockets!

I loved the scene where some government worker tried to entrap JR and secretly film him while he did it. He picked the wrong guy to try to entrap, ha ha!



She said that because she didn't have the education,the knowledge or the experience in running a big business to make an accurate analysis of the situation. That was during the oil crunch that hit the southwest around 1986-1988. That was a real phenomenon we've discussed here before. @Lastkidpicked knows all about that because he lived it. Tons of businesses were going under and not just little ones. Braniff Airlines went under. Oil companies of course went under. Major hotels went out of business. Touring rock and country bands stopped touring in the southwest because the economic situation was so bad that the entertainment dollar was gone!

So, if Ewing Oil said, OK, we'll keep everyone employed, even though they'd be operating at a loss, they'd be putting themselves in financial jeopardy. If Ewing Oil goes under, then it's not just a layoff - those jobs are gone. Permanently. Instead of just some Ewing oil employees being out of work, if Bobby kept everyone on the payroll until the company went bankrupt, then EVERY Ewing Oil employee would lose his job. It was a situation of lay some people off to cut costs and keep the majority of the employees working, or run the company into the ground which means every Ewing Oil employee is then out of work.

I stand corrected. :)
 
Top