Your Impressions Of Dallas Now vs. During Its Original Run

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It's been a long time since Dallas first made its debut. Just over 41 years! I know most of us still enjoy watching Dallas from time to time even all these years later and we still enjoy talking about it. So what I'm wondering is: In what ways, if any, do you see Dallas differently now compared to when you watched it for the first time?

1. Overall, do you think Dallas still holds up pretty well, or do you enjoy it now mostly for nostalgia?

2. How well written and well acted do you find the storylines now compared to when you were first watching it?

3. Has your opinion changed about the characters? Are there any particular characters who you view in a much different way now than you first viewed them? Have who your favorite characters are changed from then to now?

4. Finally, at what point in the original run did you start watching Dallas every week? Did you start right at the beginning? If not, how far into the original run did you start watching it? For people who discovered Dallas after it's original run was over, around what year did you start watching Dallas?
 
Last edited:

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I find it difficult to disentangle Dallas from a particular time. A time when I was young, naive and when the world that I imagined lay before me with all the sprawling grandeur of those sun scorched Southfork plains. As the term nostalgia itself suggests, there’s pain when I watch it now, but it’s strangely commingled with longing.

Despite all that, a lot of it is still so bloody good.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
1. Overall, do you think Dallas still holds up pretty well, or do you enjoy it now mostly for nostalgia?

I think Dallas holds up remarkably well. Dallas is timeless in the sense that it's a great story and great story can be appreciated in any time, regardless of the time period on which the story is set and/or was originally told. I enjoy it primarily for how good it is, but there is nostalgic value as well because it brings back some good memories of the 80s for me.

As the term nostalgia itself suggests, there’s pain when I watch it now, but it’s strangely commingled with longing.

Despite all that, a lot of it is still so bloody good.

Very nicely worded @Laurie Marr!
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
2. How well written and well acted do you find the storylines now compared to when you were first watching it?

Just as good when I watch some Dallas now as when I saw it the first time. Of course it was a lot more exciting the first time because I didn't know what would happen.

3. Has your opinion changed about the characters? Are there any particular characters who you view in a much different way now than you first viewed them? Have who your favorite characters are changed from then to now?

My opinion of some characters is exactly the same and for others it has changed.

Cliff: I hated him then and hate him now. He was a bitter, jealous little termite who treated his sister like crap though she treated him like gold. He's necessary though because his continuous attacks on the Ewings get most of the best storylines going. Cliff hates the Ewings but he doesn't realize he needs them. Cliff has no meaning to his life without the Ewings. Pretty much everything Cliff ever does is in some way related to the Ewings. Almost everything he does is either an action against them or a reaction to them. Ken Kercheval did a tremendous job of portraying Cliff.

JR: I thought he was great then and he's great now when I watch again. It's counterintuitive that you'd like a guy who commits so many unsavory acts, but face it, if you watched Dallas, you liked JR Ewing. He was the most central character of the ensemble. He got the most TV time of anyone and was involved in more of the big storylines than anyone else. You certainly weren't watching for the satisfaction of seeing him get his comeuppance because that hardly ever happened! Even getting shot only slowed him down for a few episodes. He kept winning and winning and when later in the series they changed things and had him start losing most of the time, a huge percentage of the audience simply stopped watching.

Sue Ellen: I preferred watching her in the times when she and JR were getting along to the times when they weren't. When things deteriorated to where they were by season 7 or 8, it didn't make any sense that JR would have put up with her poor attitude, her repeated returns to alcoholic drinking and living in another bedroom, or why she would have put up with his constant cheating on her. They would have divorced. They should have! What a nightmare of a marriage that turned into. I guess the argument would be that they kept the marriage together for the sake of their son. No. You don't want your son growing up learning that's what love is supposed to look like. I saw it that way then and see it the same way now, just even better now.

Pam: I liked her then and I like her now. I see her the same way I always did. Pam was a vital character who'd I'd rank right up there with Bobby in importance to the show. I didn't like that she left Bobby because he didn't deserve that, especially after how he'd always treated her so well. He never told her: You're not the Pamela I married! Even when she was acting nothing like the woman he married. She came back though, so obviously she wisened up. When she and Bobby were getting along, which was most of the time, they were a great couple. I especially enjoyed her in her poolside scenes.

Bobby: When I first watched I thought he was a very good guy who never did anything bad. Well, watch season 4 and you'll see him do some things even JR never did. Basically a good guy though and a vital part of the story because his competition with JR, and the way he'd try to reign JR in so that Ewing Oil would stand for something was crucial. Nobody else could have done that because Bobby was the only brother JR had who he loved. They could be rivals and at the same time either would have risked his life to save the life of the other.

Miss Ellie: I liked her then and now. The only time that was an exception to that was season 4 where I don't like her. Barbara Bel Geddes did a great job portraying Miss Ellie. I guess I can understand why it bothered some people so much when they had to bring in the other actress in for a season. I'd been watching Entertainment Tonight so I knew that BBG had been having health problems and they were just bringing in Donna Reed temporarily so I never thought much of it. I figured they were just doing what they had to do. But it certainly was a lot better when we got to see Barbara Bel Geddes play Miss Ellie!

Donna: I found her very obnoxious and overbearing and still do. She always had to get her way and would throw a fit on the rare occasion she didn't. She thought she knew everything but she didn't.

Ray: I thought he was OK when I first watched, but didn't think that much about him one way or the other. Now I appreciate him more. Great character! In a show filled with incredibly wealthy people who ran huge companies, he was just a regular guy that we could identify with. A man who took pride in hard work and valued having a family of his own. That's all he needed to be happy; he didn't need to be rich and didn't want to be famous. Ray is the kind of guy you'd want to have as a next door neighbor. That was very smart of them to create a character the regular person could relate to.

Jock: Big difference between then and now. I started watching in season 4, so he was only around one season the first time I watched and then he died. Now when I watch I fully appreciate what an amazing man Jock was and with such great entertainment value. "Real Power" was as good as Dallas ever got. What a performance by Jim Davis! Jock knew when to play hardball and when not to. Jock set the standard none of his sons could ever quite manage to live up to, but they sure did try!

4. Finally, at what point in the original run did you start watching Dallas every week? Did you start right at the beginning? If not, how far into the original run did you start watching it? For people who discovered Dallas after it's original run was over, around what year did you start watching Dallas?

I remember the exact episode I first watched because it started off with a woman screaming. Of course I had no idea who she was. It was episode 3 of season 4. I was just in 7th grade then and my family and I would watch Dallas together every week. When I went out on a Friday they'd tape Dallas for me on our Betamax, and I'd do the same for them so we never missed an episode.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Another thing I see differently about it now than during the first run is how they decide to resolve storylines. Whether it's "who will get custody of John Ross in early season 5", or "who will win the contest for Ewing Oil in early season 7" they went with whatever would keep all the characters the most relevant to the story. If JR wins custody of John Ross, then Sue Ellen isn't a very relevant character anymore because she's not part of the family or even raising John Ross anymore. They had to give her something to do that kept her in the big picture, so she wins custody.

If JR wins sole control of Ewing Oil, then Bobby doesn't have a part in the big Ewing Oil storylines anymore. They resolve all the storylines so that all their main cast is still in the big picture and has as much as possible to do with the central theme of the show. If you know that, you can usually predict how the storylines will resolve in any serial style show.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
1. Overall, do you think Dallas still holds up pretty well, or do you enjoy it now mostly for nostalgia?

Good question! I think that some of the story lines hold up well. Especially the fight for Ewing Oil in Season 7, and also some of the traditions, such as the BBQs and the Oil Barron's Ball.

2. How well written and well acted do you find the storylines now compared to when you were first watching it?
I think the storylines are even more compelling the second or third time around. Watching Lucy fall in love with Mickey Trotter has deeper meaning when we know what will happen to him.

3. Has your opinion changed about the characters? Are there any particular characters who you view in a much different way now than you first viewed them? Have who your favorite characters are changed from then to now?
I have more empathy for Lucy on re-watch. It seems the writers never quite knew what to do with her character, and the analogy is that Lucy never quite knew where in life she fit in.
To put a finer point on it: Lucy seemed to have it all. She had money and she was quite attractive. But Lucy could never find happiness. So she is the character who I view differently on rewatch.

4. Finally, at what point in the original run did you start watching Dallas every week? Did you start right at the beginning? If not, how far into the original run did you start watching it? For people who discovered Dallas after it's original run was over, around what year did you start watching Dallas?
During the original run, I started watching after the summer of Who Shot J.R.? That's not the best time to start watching because the show kind of plods along for several episodes after that. Fortunately, I stayed with it and I'm glad I did.

If I want to get my friends hooked, I ask them to start watching at the beginning of the contest for Ewing Oil. These are the episodes where you can't wait to see what happens next.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
During the original run, I started watching after the summer of Who Shot J.R.? That's not the best time to start watching because the show kind of plods along for several episodes after that. Fortunately, I stayed with it and I'm glad I did.

If I want to get my friends hooked, I ask them to start watching at the beginning of the contest for Ewing Oil. These are the episodes where you can't wait to see what happens next.

So are you saying you started watching right at the beginning of season 4, just a few episodes before we found out who shot JR? Because if that's the case, we started watching at the same time! Did you start at the very beginning of the season? I started on the 3rd episode, which was only one episode before we found out Kristin did it. The only reason I remember for sure that was it, is because I distinctly remember Sue Ellen screaming in the first scene.

You thought it plods along at that time? I love the first half or so of season 4 - anything before Leslie Stewart arrives. But them it gets good again with the revolution in East Asia and the trial where it looks like JR will be found guilty. And it has "I am Takapa"! That's a good storyline. Season 4 has one of my favorite episodes of any season- the one with Jock's "real power" speech. I also found it exciting when Dallas said that he'd get his job back from Bobby "If I have to destroy Ewing Oil to do it"! Fortunately he didn't.

I think the best time to start, besides the beginning of course, is the start of season 3 - because that's the season that builds up to what was the overall most famous cliffhanger ending - JR getting shot and the whole world talking about it.

One other thing about watching Dallas then compared to now is back then I took for granted how great it was to have seasons lasting from fall to spring. Now some shows only have 10 or 12 episodes a season. We called that a miniseries! If Dallas had only had 14 episodes to a season it would have aired for 25 years!
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
You are you saying you started watching right at the beginning of season 4, just a few episodes before we found out who shot JR? Because if that's the case, we started watching at the same time! Did you start at the very beginning of the season?

I remember that summer well. Instead of starting a conversation with, "Pretty hot today." Or, "It looks like we'll have a good ball team this year" Every conversation started with, "Who do you think did it?"

So that fall, we all watched from the first episode of the year, including me.

To be honest, I almost gave up after those first few episodes. Nothing really happens.
But then, as you point out, the action really picks up and the series gets better and better.
One other thing about watching Dallas then compared to now is back then I took for granted how great it was to have seasons lasting from fall to spring.
I agree, and the other thing that was great about the original run is that there was no TiVo, no Youtube, no DailyMotion. You had to watch it on Friday night or you missed it. That meant all of us were watching together, and maybe that was the best part of all.
 
Last edited:

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
It's still a cracking good series. :)
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I wasn’t allowed to stay up watch it until maybe the pre-dream season, so... I find it more (literally) accessible now!

(although I pretty distinctly remember having a rather lax cousin as a babysitter once watching the show and not sending my sister and me to bed and seeing a woman fall to her death, which was scary - it would have been Julie Grey and I would have been all of 3 years old, about to turn 4!)
 
Last edited:
Top