If You Had Been In Charge Of Deciding Whether To Rehire Patrick Duffy

What Would You Have Said To Patrick Duffy When He Asked To Return For Season 10?


  • Total voters
    19
  • Poll closed .

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
What started out as a drama turned into a soap opera.

That's a good way of describing it.

If you hold this against the background of what was going on at the time, it does make sense. Dallas was competing against Mimi Vice and that show not only had wealth in terms of money, but it also had exotic locations, fast cars and beautiful women.

Yeah, and that worked well for Miami Vice to put a lot of focus on the exotic locations but for Dallas, it just made it seem less like Dallas and more like a different type of show. Instead of the exotic locations, the more they stayed in local areas, or at least in that mid-south, or southwest region, the more authentic it was. Dove Hunt was supposed to be in Louisiana, I think, just over the Texas border and that fit. Going to the Caribbean didn't.

In fact, one Dallas episode showed Mandy Winger acting in a scene for Miami Vice. The Miami Vice shot was over the top, a sly reference to the fact that if you wanted unrealistic stories and unrealistic characters you could switch over to Miami Vice but if you wanted good storylines you should stay tuned to Dallas.

I remember that scene. I didn't consider that they may have been referring to that, specifically, but it makes a lot of sense.

I think Don Johnson may have been jealous of the success Dallas had, because without Dallas as competition, they would have done even better. I didn't find out about that until he was in that show named Blood and Oil, or something similar. Some interviewer asked him if his character was similar to JR Ewing and he seemed agitated that they brought up the name. Don Johnson said: "Is he still around"?
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
I love your storyline ideas. I would add that JR and Sue Ellen should have had a daughter after John Ross who would later years be a confidant to John Ross and like John Ross have personality aspects of JR and Sue Ellen.

I liked the dream season. It had some good parts to it like Jack not being a carbon copy of Bobby and Ellie not wanting JR to leave Southfork which was a rare instance of her caring about JR's feelings.

A daughter would be a good idea. I’d have her pregnant from the start - Bobby’s dead and a baby’s on the way. As a girl I’d gave name her Eleanor and called her Ellie. I like your forward thinking. I’d set up John Ross to be the voice of reason and the heir apparent and Chris to be the carbon copy of JR with his devotion to Sue Ellen as his mother the only time he’s stand against JR. And yes Ellie would stand beside her brother more capable than anyone since Jock Ewing.

I liked some of the dream season too. Shame they wiped it all out.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
My season finally for what became the Dream season:

JR and Sue Ellen host dinner at Southfork. This includes John Ross, Christopher and Ellie (an infant) along with Jack, Jenna (married) and Lucas (Bobby’s son, an infant as well). Start with cocktails. Talk about Jack buying the Wade Ranch and remodeling the house. A scene establishing JR’s ideal family set up.

Jeremy Wendell shakes Jordan Lee’s hand, welcoming him to his home in the middle of a grand party. He introduces him to his new wife, Katherine. He talks about his new job as Chairman and CEO of the Trident Corporation (based on Chevron). He wants to acquire Lee Oil and bring Jordan on the board. They talk about JR’s Ewing Industries and its acquisition of West Star, along with owning Ewing Oil, Wentworth Tool and Die, Cattleman’s Bank, etc. They talk about how Jack is JR’s Achilles heal, owning 10% of Ewing Industries. They meet up with Donna, who as former assistant secretary of energy, he’s placing her on Trident’s board and she’s moving back from D.C. Jordan asks about Ray and their son Tony. Introduce another board member with a grudge against JR, David Sanchez. This sets JR’s enemies on one team.

Ray begins an affair with Pamela, both struggling with depression.

Miss Ellie and Cliff have a heart to heart, putting an end to the Ewing Barnes feud. Cliff and Afton have a baby girl.

David Sanchez is filled in on JR’s secret family, a wife and two children in their early twenties (think HL Hunt).

Jeremy confronts Jack with evidence he murdered his father in Alaska. Jenna rushes to the hospital with baby Lucas.

Baby Lucas stops breathing.

A West Star - Ewing Industries Subsidiary - refinery explodes in the dark of night.

JR enjoys an evening at Southfork with his wife and kids, ending with a joyful laugh.

Credits.

JR walks down a hospital hallway, into a room where Bobby lies in a comma. He tells him how he still can’t let him go. Bobby, eyes still closed, takes JR’s hand.

The End.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Apart from the mortgage story (and that was something of a Pyrrhic victory for JR) I’m at a loss to think of ANY major business storyline where his schemes ended up being profitable for Ewing Oil. Even as a kid I was perplexed about the mismatch between the mythologising of JR’s business acumen and the serial failure of his money making ventures.

I didn't find it perplexing. The way you know whether JR's good at being an oilman, is to listen to how his peers and competitors talk about him. How much do they talk about him? A lot? How much they worry about him and how much they talk about him compared to how much he talks about them shows you where he ranks and where they rank on the food chain of the Texas oil industry.

Why did so many of JR's ventures go badly? I'm pretty sure they did it for the purpose of creating drama. It's exciting for the fans when Ewing Oil is often on the brink of being ruined. It's not how you'd handle a business in real life, but it's TV - it's gotta be more exciting than real life so they make it larger than life and manufacture one crisis after another. That's basically what the soap opera genre does, isn't it? If they portray JR as being a more sensible oilman who doesn't like to take unnecessary risks, he might appear even more successful, but then they don't end up with one crisis after another. It's done for entertainment value.

I was just watching an episode from season 7 and Bobby is talking to Clayton about the possibility of Clayton joining Bobby and JR in investing in an offshore oil lease. Bobby says: "No matter what you think about JR, and believe me, there are a lot of negatives, he is one of the best oilmen in Texas." Here is Bobby who has had huge differences of opinion with JR regarding business ethics, and as much as he dislikes some of the things about him, Bobby can't deny JR is one of the top oilmen in the state.

How many scenes are there where several people are talking about JR and what they are going to do about him? People who don't fear someone aren't gonna spend so much of their free time talking about "how are we going to stop him." Why would they spend so much of their free time talking about somebody they don't like and don't see as a threat? They feared JR's capability to do what he wants to do. That's why never shut up about him. Even Ray and Donna, who weren't even in the oil business, seemed to spend as much or more time talking about JR than they did talking about people or things they actually enjoyed talking about! It must have really tickled JR to know that they and his competitors, especially Cliff, spent so much of their time worrying about him and talking about him.

Cliff talked about JR incessantly. Even when he was trying to romance a woman, even when he was out on a date, Cliff talked about JR. That didn't exactly endear Cliff to his girlfriends, which is one of the reasons he could never keep a woman. He lost Mandy when he told her "I need you now more than ever" and then proceeded to tell her it was so he could use her to pretend to like JR and date him so that she could collect information about what he was doing. The funny thing is, by deliberately having Mandy have spend time with JR, Cliff engineered the whole scenario that ultimately resulted in his hated rival taking his woman from him.

In contrast, JR spent very little of his free time talking about people he didn't like, and worring abut how he was going to "stop" them. People did that regarding JR but JR didn't because you don't do that when you rank at the top of the food chain. While they were constantly worried and upset, JR was smiling and loving life. That's a big part of what made JR Ewing such a pop culture phenomenon. People liked JR despite his underhanded tactics because it's hard to not like somebody who is always smiling and is so good at what they do. People love a winner. When you're the one who is making everyone talk about you, that pretty well establishes who is on top, and who are the people who aren't on top but wished they could be.
 
Last edited:

ArchieLucasCarringtonEwing1989

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Would I rehire Duffy?

Honestly no, bringing PD back destroyed what credibility Dallas had, the audience had spent an entire year getting used to a Bobby free Dallas.

Not only that but it was partly this reason why Pam had such a botched and haphazard exit from the series, the writers were needlessly paranoid that VP would want to return like PD did.

I toyed with the idea that the dream is Bobby’s coma dream but this still treats the audience like dirt so no, PD stays out of Dallas for the sake of credibility.
 

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I didn't find it perplexing. The way you know whether JR's good at being an oilman, is to listen to how his peers and competitors talk about him. How much do they talk about him? A lot? How much they worry about him and how much they talk about him compared to how much he talks about them shows you where he ranks and where they rank on the food chain of the Texas oil industry.

Why did so many of JR's ventures go badly? I'm pretty sure they did it for the purpose of creating drama. It's exciting for the fans when Ewing Oil is often on the brink of being ruined. It's not how you'd handle a business in real life, but it's TV - it's gotta be more exciting than real life so they make it larger than life and manufacture one crisis after another. That's basically what the soap opera genre does, isn't it? If they portray JR as being a more sensible oilman who doesn't like to take unnecessary risks, he might appear even more successful, but then they don't end up with one crisis after another. It's done for entertainment value.

I was just watching an episode from season 7 and Bobby is talking to Clayton about the possibility of Clayton joining Bobby and JR in investing in an offshore oil lease. Bobby says: "No matter what you think about JR, and believe me, there are a lot of negatives, he is one of the best oilmen in Texas." Here is Bobby who has had huge differences of opinion with JR regarding business ethics, and as much as he dislikes some of the things about him, Bobby can't deny JR is one of the top oilmen in the state.

How many scenes are there where several people are talking about JR and what they are going to do about him? People who don't fear someone aren't gonna spend so much of their free time talking about "how are we going to stop him." Why would they spend so much of their free time talking about somebody they don't like and don't see as a threat? They feared JR's capability to do what he wants to do. That's why never shut up about him. Even Ray and Donna, who weren't even in the oil business, seemed to spend as much or more time talking about JR than they did talking about people or things they actually enjoyed talking about! It must have really tickled JR to know that they and his competitors, especially Cliff, spent so much of their time worrying about him and talking about him.

Cliff talked about JR incessantly. Even when he was trying to romance a woman, even when he was out on a date, Cliff talked about JR. That didn't exactly endear Cliff to his girlfriends, which is one of the reasons he could never keep a woman. He lost Mandy when he told her "I need you now more than ever" and then proceeded to tell her it was so he could use her to pretend to like JR and date him so that she could collect information about what he was doing. The funny thing is, by deliberately having Mandy have spend time with JR, Cliff engineered the whole scenario that ultimately resulted in his hated rival taking his woman from him.

In contrast, JR spent very little of his free time talking about people he didn't like, and worring abut how he was going to "stop" them. People did that regarding JR but JR didn't because you don't do that when you rank at the top of the food chain. While they were constantly worried and upset, JR was smiling and loving life. That's a big part of what made JR Ewing such a pop culture phenomenon. People liked JR despite his underhanded tactics because it's hard to not like somebody who is always smiling and is so good at what they do. People love a winner. When you're the one who is making everyone talk about you, that pretty well establishes who is on top, and who are the people who aren't on top but wished they could be.

An interesting perspective, but one that reinforces my perplexity rather than resolving it. I once worked with a leader in an organisation who generated a lot of talk - and anxiety - about their methods. This wasn’t because the leader in question was ‘at the top of the food chain’ in terms of the ecology of company success but because they were venal, reckless and received emotional gratification through sowing conflict and discord (they smiled a lot too).

You also suggest that JR’s serial business failures were a soapy contrivance that didn’t accurately reflect his reputation for winning. Yet there is no meta-Dallas that could adjudicate this. We have only what’s on the screen. It’s a bit like saying Cliff’s neurotic obsessions belied his reputation as a brilliant lawyer or that Sue Ellen’s drink fuelled social climbing was a contrivance that obscured her dynamic philanthropic role in Daugters of the Alamo. Of course there’s Bobby’s tribute to his brother, but this is hyperbole since we saw very little evidence of JR’s business successes.

He was an inveterate - and often brilliant - schemer. And he generated notoriety, indisputably. Yet this is not the same thing as being the best at what he does if that means generating profits and success for his company.

My own equally notorious former colleague was sacked for bringing the company into disrepute and was eventually jailed for malfeasance.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
An interesting perspective, but one that reinforces my perplexity rather than resolving it. I once worked with a leader in an organisation who generated a lot of talk - and anxiety - about their methods. This wasn’t because the leader in question was ‘at the top of the food chain’ in terms of the ecology of company success but because they were venal, reckless and received emotional gratification through sowing conflict and discord (they smiled a lot too).

You also suggest that JR’s serial business failures were a soapy contrivance that didn’t accurately reflect his reputation for winning. Yet there is no meta-Dallas that could adjudicate this. We have only what’s on the screen. It’s a bit like saying Cliff’s neurotic obsessions belied his reputation as a brilliant lawyer or that Sue Ellen’s drink fuelled social climbing was a contrivance that obscured her dynamic philanthropic role in Daugters of the Alamo. Of course there’s Bobby’s tribute to his brother, but this is hyperbole since we saw very little evidence of JR’s business successes.

He was an inveterate - and often brilliant - schemer. And he generated notoriety, indisputably. Yet this is not the same thing as being the best at what he does if that means generating profits and success for his company.

My own equally notorious former colleague was sacked for bringing the company into disrepute and was eventually jailed for malfeasance.

I see what you're getting at but the difference is, in the comparison you made it doesn't sound like the leader of that organization had people who would have been the real life equivalent of a Jeremy Wendell or a Bobby Ewing praising his or her abilities.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I believe Don Johnson will be rather annoyed J.R. Ewing will spoken about for all eternity unlike Harlan "Hap" Briggs.

Here's the big reason for his grudge (From Wikipedia-Miami Vice): For its third season in 1986–87 after the cancellation of Knight Rider, the show moved from its traditional time slot of 10PM on Friday nights to 9PM, which now put it up against perennial Top 10 show Dallas. This began the show's decline, and in March, 1987, TV Guide ran a cover story entitled, "Dallas Drubs the Cops: Why Miami Vice Seems to be Slipping."[73] Miami Vice's season ratings slipped from #9 in Season 2 down to #27 by the end of Season 3.[74]

Don Johnson did popularize the stubble beard though.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I wouldn't have brought him back but if I had I wouldn't have used the dream explanation for his return.

I would have had him in a coma in a private ward in Dallas Memorial.

I would've kept Ben Stivers & have him be revealed as Jock after all. Steve Forrest was far too good an actor to let go. :)

Jock Ewing 2a.jpg
 
Last edited:
Top