Which Dallas Character Endured The Most Hardship?

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Which one of the original main cast of Dallas characters do you think endured the most hardship during the course of the series? They all went through a lot, but I think Ray might have gone through the most hardship of any of the main cast because he was just so consistently hit with loss after loss.

When Amos Krebbs visited, we saw why Ray felt the way he did about Amos

He found out Jock was his father. That was great for Ray, and Jock handed it so well. Then Jock dies the next year.

Then two years later Ray goes through the ordeal with Mickey Trotter trying to help Sue Ellen and getting paralyzed as a result. Then he goes into a coma. Mickey comes out of the coma but then goes back into one. The doctors say he will remain in a coma. Mickey's mother convinces Ray to pull the plug. Loses his cousin and almost goes to prison.

Bobby dies at the end of season 8. Bobby was the only brother Ray was close with, and was Ray's best friend.

Donna gets pregnant with a baby that has Downs Syndrome. Then Donna miscarries.

Then Bobby returns because season 9 was a dream, but Ray then loses his wife!

Donna not only leaves Ray, but she takes their daughter over a thousand miles away, knowing that means Ray can hardly ever see his daughter.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Let's compare that to Bobby: 1. His first wife falls from the hayloft and has a miscarriage. She can no longer have children.
2. Pam has a breakdown and ends up in a mental institution.
3. He becomes disgusted by Jock and JR's business practices, decides to leave SF, but remains because his brother is shot.
4. His daddy dies.
5.His wife believes baby Christopher is a child Bobby brought home for her, yet it's really JR's(or so he believes at the time).
6.The stress of the fight for Ewing Oil
7. Returns home one night to find his home on fire and has to rush in and rescue everyone.
7. His beloved wife leaves him, taking his son.
8.He is shot by his sister-in-law.
9.His new fiance is framed for murder and goes through a long trial.
10. He finds out his ex-fiance is pregnant on his wedding day to his ex-wife.
11.His mother is kidnapped by her sister in law.
12. Because of JR, his family is threatened by a terrorist.
13.His wife is horrifically burned in a car accident, vanishes without a trace.
14. Loses Ewing Oil, his daddy's company because of JR's shenanigans.
15. Sees his second wife gunned down right before his eyes.
16. Has to be the "stable one" in his dysfunctional family which means Sue Ellen turns to him for support repeatedly, and he can't grieve his daddy's death because he has to pull JR out of his depression. He also is the family hero which means he always does things such as rescue Lucy from something or dive into the river to look for Jock's body.
17. Constantly having to look over his shoulder because JR is either trying to undermine him at work or destroy his marriage.
18. His ex-fiance leaves for Europe with his son, who he apparently never saw again.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Oddly enough I reckon JR was subjected to considerable hardship when Vanessa "Granny" Beaumont decided to put in an appearance, so between putting up with her and the dire James, JR didn't have his sorrows to seek.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Let's compare that to Bobby: 1. His first wife falls from the hayloft and has a miscarriage. She can no longer have children.
2. Pam has a breakdown and ends up in a mental institution.
3. He becomes disgusted by Jock and JR's business practices, decides to leave SF, but remains because his brother is shot.
4. His daddy dies.
5.His wife believes baby Christopher is a child Bobby brought home for her, yet it's really JR's(or so he believes at the time).
6.The stress of the fight for Ewing Oil
7. Returns home one night to find his home on fire and has to rush in and rescue everyone.
7. His beloved wife leaves him, taking his son.
8.He is shot by his sister-in-law.
9.His new fiance is framed for murder and goes through a long trial.
10. He finds out his ex-fiance is pregnant on his wedding day to his ex-wife.
11.His mother is kidnapped by her sister in law.
12. Because of JR, his family is threatened by a terrorist.
13.His wife is horrifically burned in a car accident, vanishes without a trace.
14. Loses Ewing Oil, his daddy's company because of JR's shenanigans.
15. Sees his second wife gunned down right before his eyes.
16. Has to be the "stable one" in his dysfunctional family which means Sue Ellen turns to him for support repeatedly, and he can't grieve his daddy's death because he has to pull JR out of his depression. He also is the family hero which means he always does things such as rescue Lucy from something or dive into the river to look for Jock's body.
17. Constantly having to look over his shoulder because JR is either trying to undermine him at work or destroy his marriage.
18. His ex-fiance leaves for Europe with his son, who he apparently never saw again.

Good job, @Jimmy Todd! That's an impressive list. I think #13 and #15 are particularly awful. Seeing his wife Pam in that much pain, and injured that badly was devastating. Then Pam vanishes. Then he sees his second wife April shot to death before his eyes. I had been thinking Ray's place in the whole Mickey Trotter storyline - that he felt responsible for Mickey's life being cut short, seeing him paralyzed, then in a second coma and then having to be the one to pull the plug was the hardest thing anyone on the show went through, and that overall, Ray might have gone through the most, but those and some of the other things you listed makes me think Bobby is the one who went through the most hardship. Bobby takes adversity so well, that it made me forget just how much he went through!

It's interesting, Bobby blows up over relatively small things, but when real tragedy strikes, or he's confronted with a situation that calls for him to act heroically, he shows tremendous poise.
 
Last edited:

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Good job, @Jimmy Todd! That's an impressive list. I think #13 and #15 are particularly awful. Seeing his wife Pam in that much pain, and injured tbat
at badly was devastating. Then Pam vanishes. Then he sees his second wife April shot to death before his eyes. I had been thinking Ray's place in the whole Mickey Trotter storyline - that he felt responsible for Mickey's life being cut short, seeing him paralyzed, then in a second coma and then having to be the one to pull the plug was the hardest thing anyone on the show went through, and that overall, Ray might have gone through the most, but those and some of the other things you listed makes me think Bobby is the one who went through the most hardship. Bobby takes adversity so well, that it made me forget just how much he went through!

It's interesting, Bobby blows up over relatively small things, but when real tragedy strikes, or he's confronted with a situation that calls for him to act heroically, he shows tremendous poise.

Bobby is as many people in life seem to be. The ones with the most problems carry on stoically, the ones with relatively few are drama queens.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Walt Driscoll.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Bobby is as many people in life seem to be. The ones with the most problems carry on stoically, the ones with relatively few are drama queens.

Are you saying he's a combination of the two - that he responds stoically in the face of real adversity, but acts like a drama queen over relatively small problems?
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Are you saying he's a combination of the two - that he responds stoically in the face of real adversity, but acts like a drama queen over relatively small problems?

I hadn't thought of that actually. I was thinking of Bobby and other characters such as SE. However, maybe with Bobby it's a sense of family responsibility that kicks in for him. In major crises he takes on the responsibility of holding everything together and being strong for the family.
 
Last edited:

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Bobby had a petulant streak that was often irritating. By the time of the TNT incarnation it was weathered, leavened by an extra layer of pomposity - but it was still there.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer

DALLAS' greatest love story that could have been, ruined by that conniving Shepard woman.

It's so hard!
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Which one of the original main cast of Dallas characters do you think endured the most hardship during the course of the series? They all went through a lot, but I think Ray might have gone through the most hardship of any of the main cast because he was just so consistently hit with loss after loss.

I really enjoy it when we can disagree because it makes for a fun conversation.

While I do agree that Ray was hit with a lot of hardships, I believe he was one of the happier people overall. Especially when he was a ranch foreman and before he found out he was Jock's son. Look at the relationship they had:
317f9e1f2d30406c98768e97cfbc2c98.jpg


And in Conundrum, the alternate ending where it was never discovered that Ray was a Ewing, he was a hired hand who never made much money. But when his sons (one was named Jock) gave him a pair of gloves and a pocketknife for his birthday, he said, "I think I'm the luckiest man alive."
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Walt Driscoll.
BHWHAHAHAHA! Didn't see @Snarky's Ghost sneaking in with that one, but it's right on the money!

Bobby is as many people in life seem to be. The ones with the most problems carry on stoically, the ones with relatively few are drama queens.
This is such a true statement. And now I'm thinking about all the people in real life where this is especially true.

Bobby had a petulant streak that was often irritating. By the time of the TNT incarnation it was weathered, leavened by an extra layer of pomposity - but it was still there.
We see that sometimes when it comes to Bobby and Pam.

DALLAS' greatest love story that could have been, ruined by that conniving Shepard woman.
She is even better during a re-watch. Because you know how deliciously evil she will turn out to be.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
The ones with the most problems carry on stoically, the ones with relatively few are drama queens.
Well said Jimmy. I have to work with them everyday. If only I could print this out in banner size and place it on the wall in our tearoom. But then the poor insulted dears would go screaming to HR (Human Resources).
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
If there is one character I believe endured the most hardship I'd say John Ross. Only days old and he is kidnapped. When he is finally returned to the bosom of Southfork he is rejected by his mother. As the tug-of-war began between his parents John Ross was often caught in the middle. Growing up his father tried to mold him into something he struggled against. Sue Ellen desperately tried to keep him on the straight and narrow.

Years later (TNT Dallas) the struggle continues with John Ross. Is he bad, good or indifferent? The legacy of JR Ewing can weigh heavily on an only son.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I suspect Julie Grey had a rough time of it.

And this is just the thing-- We think of the main characters, but often forget the minor characters like Walt Driscoll and Julie Grey. They do have some great plots that happen around them.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Years later (TNT Dallas) the struggle continues with John Ross. Is he bad, good or indifferent? The legacy of JR Ewing can weigh heavily on an only sonl

This was one of my favorite parts of TNT Dallas: The complicated relationship between J.R. and an adult John Ross.
jr-john-ross.jpg
 
Last edited:
Top