Who Was More Profoundly Damaged - Kristin Or Katherine?

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Which one do you think was more psychologically damaged and why?

It's tough to choose one because they're both so damaged. They both tried to commit cold blooded murder. They were both willing to frame a sibling. They both tried to take their sisters' husbands from them.

This is close but I'm gonna choose Katherine. One reason is because of how elaborate a scheme she was willing to use on Pam to try to make sure she and Bobby divorced. Sue Ellen knew Kristin didn't like her and Kristin didn't do a whole lot to pretend she loved her sister. Katherine tried so hard to convince Pam she loved her and was looking out for her best interests. Sue Ellen at least knew who she was dealing with but Katherine made it look like she really wanted the best for Pam, while plotting against her.

Katherine didn't ever learn from her mistakes and I don't think she even considered them mistakes. She shot Bobby and then when that didn't work she tried to poison him in the hospital. Then she decided to try to kill Pam (although she ended up hitting Bobby when he pushed Pam out of the way) because she was so deranged she thought that at least one of the two had to die. Katherine just relentlessly tries to commit murder even if she dies in the process.

All that was done because she could not stand that she couldn't force Bobby to love her. He explained to her time and time again he would never feel that way about her but she couldn't accept it. Kristin actually was led on because JR told her he would marry her. No that it justifies shooting JR, but it gives her a legitimate reason to be mad at him.

Katherine believed she should be able to make Bobby love her, just as long as she loved him, and if he wouldn't love her, then he deserved to die either for not loving her or because if she couldn't have him then nobody could.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I would agree with Katherine, although marginally so. In Kristin's case you could also argue that her mother played a part in her downfall, always making it seem she was competing with Sue Ellen in life.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I would agree with Katherine, although marginally so. In Kristin's case you could also argue that her mother played a part in her downfall, always making it seem she was competing with Sue Ellen in life.

Swami

That's a good point. One of the scary things is both of them were usually capable of acting like reasonably well adjusted people.

Even Naldo, as bad as he was, was disgusted with how evil Katherine was. She told him he wasn't good man and Naldo said "At least I know what I am."
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
I would go with Katherine. In addition to what has already been stated, she also paid someone to kill Naldo and frame Jenna.
If she didn't do so many violent, evil things she would be just pathetic. She has all the money and opportunity in the world and she's spends her life pining away after one man.
Kristin was damaged by her mother's influence, but she always came across to me as slightly more plain evil than just damaged. Katherine came off as completely deranged.
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I'd say Kristin, purely because she was damaged from day one. I'm inclined to believe that, if Katherine had never crossed paths with J.R., Bobby and Pam etc., she probably would have lived a perfectly normal life. Kristin, on the other hand, was raised with trauma (Patricia was her mother - case closed) and her life likely would have turned out poorly (perhaps not so spectacularly, but still), despite what Conundrum would have you believe. I have the same theory that Sue Ellen would have been an alcoholic with or without J.R., too.
 

thomaswak

Telly Talk Dream Maker
All I know is from now, I will be very, very careful if any of my friends has a sister with a name starting with a "K" :D
 

Toni

Maximum Member
I think both girls were total nutjobs and in real life they would have become lovers, a lesbian version of "Bonnie & Clyde" but more sophisticated.

Now seriously, I´m completely sure that Kristin would´ve done the same things Kathy did if she had had money but not J.R. It´s the "bad seed" they had inside their pretty brains, and the opposite with Katherine. It´s quite common that people who are rejected may have a "strange" behavior, which is the soap equivalent to be heartbroken. And... who hasn´t been heartbroken...?

I don´t know about your countries, but in Spain there is a quite high number of abusive relationships and husbands who kill (or try to) their wives. Also, sometimes the opposite. It´s what usually opened most news broadcasts before this corona nightmare. I´m not mentioning this to talk about J.R. and Sue Ellen, but about the fact that these soap ladies did get agressive when their lovers dumped her.

Can you imagine Kristin or Katherine being depressed in the show, and how boring that would have turned out? They were reacters, things were done to them, and when they couldn´t stand it, they took things on their pretty hands. J.R. was the one who did start the affair with Kristin and used her in a lot of ways (some of them censorable here!).

And what did she get? A lousy second-hand condo, having to entertain drooling worms like Vaughn and the Cartel, and false promises. I´m not kidding, I´m just putting myself in her place. Then she was used to make people think Sue was drinking again, and J.R. had her thrown away from town accused of prostitution (the poor girl!). Would you have run away, or have done something to get revenge, or at least the deed of Lousy Condo? And please, don´t blame Mama for this!

Katherine was more surrounded by mystery, but also was her Mama. I love to believe that Rebecca was as good mother to her as Joan Crawford to little Christina (if not worse!). She was raised in a big lavish mansion, and went to college to be a journalist. Suddenly, she discovers that her mother is a bigamist, a liar, and abandoned two babies. I think I´d get traumatized for that only...

Besides, his father died right away and she found out that her half-sister was a suicidal wacko committed in a sanitarium, and his half-brother is a cocky lawyer in disgrace...who also tries suicide not long after that. Rebecca´s will is the last straw. She must take justice on her own hands. In real life she would probably had overturned Mama´s will. But that would have been repetitive that season. Oh and she´s seen how gorgeous Bobby looks!

To be continued.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I think that Katherine is so over the top crazy that she is fun to watch!

And I wish she was around a few years ago. Buick had this obnoxious advertisement where people were instructed to say, in the most annoying way possible, "That's not a Buick!"

And since I'm in a pickup truck all day, with the radio in the background, I heard that insipid "That's not a Buick" ad about 500 times a day.

I was just hoping that the next time somebody said, "That's not a Buick" then Katherine would take her 1984 Buick Century and say, "I'll show you a Buick!" and do this:

i296612.jpg


Oh, wait! She did!
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I think both girls were total nutjobs and in real life they would have become lovers, a lesbian version of "Bonnie & Clyde" but more sophisticated.

Now seriously, I´m completely sure that Kristin would´ve done the same things Kathy did if she had had money but not J.R. It´s the "bad seed" they had inside their pretty brains, and the opposite with Katherine. It´s quite common that people who are rejected may have a "strange" behavior, which is the soap equivalent to be heartbroken. And... who hasn´t been heartbroken...?

I don´t know about your countries, but in Spain there is a quite high number of abusive relationships and husbands who kill (or try to) their wives. Also, sometimes the opposite. It´s what usually opened most news broadcasts before this corona nightmare. I´m not mentioning this to talk about J.R. and Sue Ellen, but about the fact that these soap ladies did get agressive when their lovers dumped her.

Can you imagine Kristin or Katherine being depressed in the show, and how boring that would have turned out? They were reacters, things were done to them, and when they couldn´t stand it, they took things on their pretty hands. J.R. was the one who did start the affair with Kristin and used her in a lot of ways (some of them censorable here!).

And what did she get? A lousy second-hand condo, having to entertain drooling worms like Vaughn and the Cartel, and false promises. I´m not kidding, I´m just putting myself in her place. Then she was used to make people think Sue was drinking again, and J.R. had her thrown away from town accused of prostitution (the poor girl!). Would you have run away, or have done something to get revenge, or at least the deed of Lousy Condo? And please, don´t blame Mama for this!

Katherine was more surrounded by mystery, but also was her Mama. I love to believe that Rebecca was as good mother to her as Joan Crawford to little Christina (if not worse!). She was raised in a big lavish mansion, and went to college to be a journalist. Suddenly, she discovers that her mother is a bigamist, a liar, and abandoned two babies. I think I´d get traumatized for that only...

Besides, his father died right away and she found out that her half-sister was a suicidal wacko committed in a sanitarium, and his half-brother is a cocky lawyer in disgrace...who also tries suicide not long after that. Rebecca´s will is the last straw. She must take justice on her own hands. In real life she would probably had overturned Mama´s will. But that would have been repetitive that season. Oh and she´s seen how gorgeous Bobby looks!

To be continued.

A losy second hand condo? How many college age girls live in a condo that nice, or can even live in a condo at all? They live in dorms with a roommate. Kristen threw herself at JR; she started the relationship. She was doing exactly what she wanted to and was free at any time to go back to college where she was supposed to be anyway. She's what we call a gold digger. She didn't want to go to college, earn her degree and make her own money because that would have taken work. She was looking for a shortcut by trying to marry a man with money instead of making her own way in life because that's the kind of woman she was. She didn't even care JR was her sister's husband. Kristin was a thoroughly contemptible woman who got what she asked for.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Do any of you remember how Kristin turned out during the final episode of Dallas? (Conundrum).

I'll put it under spoiler tags if you don't remember, because it's pretty funny to watch, and a very Kristin thing to do!

Kristin is in a very expensive fur coat, and goes to the room of an upscale hotel. The man who answers the door is pleased at how good looking Kristin is. After some small talk, the man invites her into the bedroom. He offers $500 to Kristin in exchange for her services in the bedroom.

Kristin whips out a badge and announces, "You are under arrest, Mr. Smith. Or should I say Judge Smith. For soliciting a prostitute!" After we are over our shock, she says, "I"m officer Shepard and you just offered me money for sexual favors."

The man panics and says, "Maybe we can work something out here! He grabs a handful of cash. Please! Take this!"

Officer Kristin thinks about it for a minute, and after making the man promise to be good from here on out she accepts the bribe. The man is relieved and promises not to mention this to anybody. So, Kristin eventually becomes a cop?

Nope! Even better!

On the way out, she meets her friend and announces, "He fell for it. They always do, when they see that phony badge. And he was loaded!"

BHWHAHAHAHAHAHA! What a perfect con for Kristin!
 

Srqmom

Telly Talk Member
You’d think Pam would be super messed up considering her dysfunctional upbringing! The two K’s had it much better in comparison. But perhaps that’s what made them crazy.
 

James from London

International Treasure
It's hard to say. We kind of knew why Kristin was the way she was -- her mother's geisha training -- while there was never any real basis given for Katherine's behaviour. When Kristin was a regular character, she didn't seem particularly damaged. The wear and tear on her character only manifested itself once she left the show and moved to California. With Katherine, it's the opposite -- we never knew her before she lost her marbles, if there even was a before, so it's not a level playing field really.
 
Last edited:

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
It does seem that Kristin shot
JR
because he used her, was ready to frame her for prostitution, and then ran her out of town. We've all been there.

But Katherine was eventually revealed to be just kill-happy. Which is probably worse.

OIP.Yaoq5ZrxK_yKqBuZMmtMhQAAAA
th
 
Last edited by a moderator:

EricfromNY

Telly Talk Newbie
They were both messed up but by the end of Katherine’s run on the show she seemed like a literal super-villain type ( I take it that we are still supposed to think she was the one who was behind the killing Naldo and framing Jenna for murder stuff even if the only explanation we got was in the dream season ). Kristin on the other hand often just seemed like a brat. Katherine was offscreen planning international murder and when Kristin was offscreen she was getting into drugs and sleeping with Jeff Faraday for some reason.
 

James from London

International Treasure
by the end of Katherine’s run on the show she seemed like a literal super-villain type

Yes. I think that's to do with soap opera inflation. I mean, in Kristin's era, you couldn't have a super-villain. The series hadn't gotten to that stage yet. But by Katherine's era, it was no longer enough just to be a scheming sister-in-law, you had to have big shoulders, big hair, a big hat, big money and be scheming murderous schemes. So I don't think it's really a question of Katherine being more psychologically damaged than Kristin, it's about her being a more exaggerated character for a more exaggerated time.
 

EricfromNY

Telly Talk Newbie
Yes. I think that's to do with soap opera inflation. I mean, in Kristin's era, you couldn't have a super-villain. The series hadn't gotten to that stage yet. But by Katherine's era, it was no longer enough just to be a scheming sister-in-law, you had to have big shoulders, big hair, a big hat, big money and be scheming murderous schemes. So I don't think it's really a question of Katherine being more psychologically damaged than Kristin, it's about her being a more exaggerated character for a more exaggerated time.


That’s correct. For example, during the tail end of the classic Dallas era, being a villain meant kidnaping someone on their wedding day and dragging her to Europe where you hire a hitman to kill your partner in order to frame the person you kidnapped. In early Dallas being a villain meant throwing someone off a building.
 
Last edited:

James from London

International Treasure
Exaggerating things just because your competition is exaggerating them makes you a trend follower and when the trend's over it looks outdated.

I think DALLAS got away with it with Katherine. She was fun to watch then and she still is.
 
Top