How John Ross Jr. Became J.R. Ewing

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Did you notice how JR was always trying to get his parents' approval, especially Jock's approval? Nothing he did ever seemed to be enough to get it. You could tell it was something he wanted badly. I don't know how many episodes had a scene where JR would say something to his parents such as: "I was hoping just this once you'd proud of me."

He was their firstborn child and then they had Gary and Bobby. Gary became Miss Ellie's favorite and then Bobby became Jock's favorite. Imagine the resentment that would create. When JR was their only child he had all their attention and love and then both of his brothers surpassed him in gaining the love of his parents. That's not supposed to happen. Having a new brother or sister isn't supposed to diminish the amount you get loved.

Favoritism puts a child in an impossible position. "What do I do to get them to love me as much as they used to? Is there anything I can do to get them do love me just as much as my brothers"?

The parents - the one source that is supposed to provide equal, unconditional love - undercut the child's self-esteem. It's a betrayal from the two people that the child should never have had to fear betrayal from.

As adults we have a hard enough time trying to figure out how to gain someone's love but for a child, it's completely overwhelming. How is a child supposed to figure out why Mama loves Gary the most and Daddy loves Bobby the most?

At some point JR decides: "If I'm ever going to gain Daddy's love, I'm going to have to do what he does and be even better at it then he is"!

At that point JR decides whatever will get him ahead in the oil business, whatever will give him the competitive edge on his competition, is what he will do. Ethics become irrelevant because as long as the outcome is that he becomes more successful than Jock ever became in the oil business, then he there is no way he can be ignored or neglected ever again. His worth will be undeniable.

JR becomes the man he needs to become at work. He learns how to manipulate people's emotions. He masters the art of gaining every competitive edge there is to be gained.

Somewhere along the way, he can no longer separate who he is at work and who he is in his private life. He's become so convincing at becoming whatever his business requires him to be that he can't remember how to turn it off when he goes home. He's convinced everyone, and now himself, that he is who he pretends to be. Honesty, vulnerability and a conscience are liabilities....aren't they?

The two personas merge into one as his business persona devours all that is left of the man he used to be, the one they didn't like anyway. There is no separation anymore between the two - they have become one and the same.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Maybe he’s the one who needed to go see Dr Elby. Lol I know favoritism can definitely affect you, even as an adult, but that don’t explain everything. JR, on too many occasions, went out of his way to ruin peoples lives. Was he trying to impress Jock by treating his wife like dirt? And he wasn’t even trying to hide it, according to Miss Ellie. Pam was completely out of his life and he couldn’t resist sending her on a wild goose chase around the world looking for Mark. Who was he trying to impress? Jock was long gone.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Maybe he’s the one who needed to go see Dr Elby. Lol I know favoritism can definitely affect you, even as an adult, but that don’t explain everything. JR, on too many occasions, went out of his way to ruin peoples lives. Was he trying to impress Jock by treating his wife like dirt? And he wasn’t even trying to hide it, according to Miss Ellie. Pam was completely out of his life and he couldn’t resist sending her on a wild goose chase around the world looking for Mark. Who was he trying to impress? Jock was long gone.

That's the idea I was explaining at the end:

Somewhere along the way, he can no longer separate who he is at work and who he is in his private life. He's become so convincing at becoming whatever his business requires him to be that he can't remember how to turn it off when he goes home. He's convinced everyone, and now himself, that he is who he pretends to be. Honesty, vulnerability and a conscience are liabilities....aren't they?

The two personas merge into one as his business persona devours all that is left of the man he used to be, the one they didn't like anyway. There is no separation anymore between the two - they have become one and the same.
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
It's the same mantra of "evil isn't born, it's created" - it's so much easier to be bad, to do horrible things when it's what people expect from you. A prime example early on is the scene in Barbecue when Sue Ellen asks J.R. if he pushed Pam; he had never been physically violent with her (at that point) but his own wife believed he was capable of that? It becomes so much harder to turn those behaviours around, as you said, so you only fall deeper into that persona.

Jock definitely introduced his concept of masculinity to J.R., then softened in his later years and very rarely defended J.R.'s actions when he likely would have done the same and that must have been very infuriating for J.R..
 
Top