Which Storyline Did You Enjoy The Most?

What Dallas Storyline Did You Enjoy The Most?

  • Gold Canyon 340

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    14
  • Poll closed .

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The "Who Shot JR" storyline is the most famous one in Dallas history and it's the one that set records for viewership, but I didn't see the whole thing take place when it originally aired. The first Dallas episode I ever saw was the episode right before the episode that revealed Kristin as the shooter. So for me it was only a week of suspense and I didn't know about all the things that had led up to him being shot. I didn't know there were so many people who had a motive for trying to kill JR or what their motives were.

I think the first time I ever saw the entire "Who Shot" JR storyline was when TNN - The Nashville Network, aired Dallas for the first time. If I remember correctly they began in 1996 and showed one episode daily, Monday through Friday, airing it once in the morning and once at night. The NashvilleNetwork didn't have a lot of variety in their programming and for all I know, Dallas and The Dukes Of Hazzard may have been the only two popular series from major networks they aired at that time. What other series did they need? They had the CBS Friday night of TV I remembered liking so much and I finally had a chance to see it again.

Watching the "Who Shot JR" storyline in its entirety for the first time, I could understand why people liked it so much, but since I already knew who did it, that killed the suspense. I don't know what it was like to see the whole thing when it originally aired. That may be the reason that while I like it, it's not my favorite Dallas storyline.

The Dallas storyline I enjoyed the most was the contest for Ewing Oil. That storyline had most of the elements that make up a great storyline. They had the whole cast involved in it to some degree and the best thing about it was watching how the contest affected different characters since they all seemed to be affected by it, either financially, emotionally or both. None of the main characters liked that JR was doing what our whole economic system was designed to do: to give the customer the lowest price possible for any given product. The public loved it but the other characters were too upset that JR might win the contest to be able to appreciate that everyone but them loved the low gasoline prices.

At some point Bobby realizes he's got to start becoming a more aggressive businessman and when he tells the cartel that he wants to either open the Wellington field or sell it to them for the amount they agreed to in the contract, one of them replied: "You mean you'll cut our throats"? How awful. Imagine a businessman trying to outdo his competitors!

Pamela couldn't take being married to this more competitive, hard-edged, aggressive version of Bobby and I could only wonder whom she had thought she married. As Bobby explained it, he grew up in a very competitive family. He had always expected himself to do his absolute best. Whether he was in football, whether he was the road man for Ewing Oil, or whether he was running Ewing Oil, Bobby demanded the absolute best from himself. It was what his father expected of him and it was what he expected of himself. The Ewing family creed may very well have been: "Be The Best"!

It was actually Pam who talked Bobby into discontinuing being a road man for Ewing Oil and getting into actually running the company! If you're lucky enough to get what you wanted, why complain? Her problem was she had a brother who could never mind his own business. Cliff literally made a career out of sticking his nose into Ewing family business. He actually found a way to get paid to do it.

It only made matters worse when her mother decided to resume actually acting somewhat like a mother, after what was apparently about a 25 year hiatus. We found out from whom Cliff inherited his unique characteristic of immersing himself in matters that were none of his business. From that point on, Rebecca discussed the Ewings as much and sometimes more than her own two kids. From a Barnes standpoint, where it somehow must seem natural to want to make an entire career out of reacting to what one other family does, Rebecca couldn't resist the temptation to get involved in the contest for Ewing Oil just as much as was humanly possible for her to do so, once again at the expense of her own daughter.

When Cliff yet again reacted poorly to stress and got so drunk that he forgot to take the plane flight he had planned on taking - of course with the purpose of getting involved yet further in Ewing business - Rebecca took it for him! Her goal was to interfere in one of JR's deals, so that he would have to stop selling gasoline to the public at such a low price, or at the least wouldn't be able to sell as much of it as he had planned. This was a woman wealthy enough to be able to afford to buy her own jet airplane and this was how she chose to use it, rather than using it for something that might actually be productive or at least enjoyable. When the pilot of her plane and the pilot of another plane managed the not inconsiderable feat of actually colliding with each other in mid-air, I suppose it should have been predictable that somehow Pamela would end up blaming Bobby for the whole thing. I didn't predict it though, and then the contest for Ewing Oil had become not only the best business related storyline I'd ever seen on a TV show, but one that also ended up with the two best liked characters of the whole show divorcing each other. I didn't want to see Bobby and Pam divorce, but it did keep the story very exciting, because as Bobby explained to Sue Ellen, now that he'd lost his wife, why shouldn't he do everything he possibly could to ensure he didn't also lose Ewing Oil?

The contest for Ewing Oil was a storyline that did a truly remarkable job of combining business and personal affairs into the same storyline in a way where the implications for both the future of Ewing Oil and the Ewing family were such that literally everything seemed to be at stake. It's my favorite Dallas storyline.
 
Last edited:

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
The contest for Ewing Oil. There really wasn’t any bad episodes that season. JR with his cheap gas. The other oil men challenging JR to a fight at the Ewing BBQ. Bobby getting down in the mud. Miss Ellie trying to break the will. Jessica Wentworth’s death. Something I just noticed while watching this storyline, Miss Ellie is indirectly responsible for Bobby and Pam’s marriage falling apart by introducing us to Mark Grayson. Lol

As good as the “Who shot JR” storyline was, and it’s by far the most famous storyline, the fight for Ewing Oil was the best.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Interesting points Kenny!
As good as the “Who shot JR” storyline was, and it’s by far the most famous storyline, the fight for Ewing Oil was the best.

Well, said, Billy.

When many people think of Dallas they immediately think of the who shot JR storyline. And that was a fun summer of everybody guessing who shot JR. The lead up to JR getting shot was well written. They did a good job of building up all the different people who would have a motive to shoot JR. And of course this buildup is what started JR as the villain we love to hate.

So while the buildup is fun, the truth is that the several episodes right after that are kind of slow paced and not that exciting.

The battle for Ewing Oil was a much more interesting and exciting storyline. we did a rewatch of the series last summer and definitely enjoyed the battle for Ewing Oil the most. Even though we had seen the series several times, we couldn't wait to see the next episode to watch what would happen next.

To put a finer point on it, If we had friends we were trying to get to start watching Dallas we would show them the first few episodes of the battle for Ewing Oil to get them hooked.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
All the above choices were excellent, personally I went for "Who Shot JR?".

It should be said that during Dallas' peak series virtually all the storylines were superb, the only real exception was the Leslie Stewart tarradiddle.

I think we all know where season 9 fell - with the Angelica Nero Eurovision Song Contest clishmaclaver, so totally not Dallas.

Season 10 was very good, much more like Dallas, but thereafter the storylines never were as strong and this was exacerbated by bringing in newcomers who knew as much about acting as my backside knows about snipe-shooting!

In fairness, given the length of time that Dallas (and its rivals) had been on the air, it was inevitable that difficulties would crop up in coming up with fresh storylines.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Interesting points Kenny!

Thanks @Lastkidpicked! It had some ideas in it that I'd sort of had for a thread but never gotten around to using like: The Ewing family creed may very well have been: "Be The Best"!


All the above choices were excellent, personally I went for "Who Shot JR?".

It should be said that during Dallas' peak series virtually all the storylines were superb, the only real exception was the Leslie Stewart tarradiddle.

That's a good one too. Does it surprise you that the Who Shot JR storyline got so much more publicity and attracted so many more people than the storyline that so far, is ahead in the poll by a considerable margin?

Leslie Stewart marred what otherwise was an amazing season.

In fairness, given the length of time that Dallas (and its rivals) had been on the air, it was inevitable that difficulties would crop up in coming up with fresh storylines.

Dallas has 357 episodes. So yes, to be fair, it's amazing for any show to be as good as Dallas was for around 200 episodes!
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Thanks @Lastkidpicked! It had some ideas in it that I'd sort of had for a thread but never gotten around to using like: The Ewing family creed may very well have been: "Be The Best"!




That's a good one too. Does it surprise you that the Who Shot JR storyline got so much more publicity and attracted so many more people than the storyline that so far, is ahead in the poll by a considerable margin?

Leslie Stewart marred what otherwise was an amazing season.



Dallas has 357 episodes. So yes, to be fair, it's amazing for any show to be as good as Dallas was for around 200 episodes!

I am surprised that the contest for Ewing Oil has got more votes, as you say it never attracted the same levels of publicity.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I am surprised that the contest for Ewing Oil has got more votes, as you say it never attracted the same levels of publicity.

Swami

It could be that the huge number of viewers they had for the episode where we found out who shot JR was something that was fueled by the media, with Dallas being a completely new type of show for that time, and then through that and word of mouth, the show just exploded in popularity to a level that no storyline could have gotten them again; it wasn't a new type of show anymore - there were other shows like Dynasty and the others - and a lot of the people who made up that 90 million audience were just watching out of curiosity because everyone was talking about Dallas!

A lot of those 90 million probably didn't watch for much longer after the identity of the shooter was revealed; it was probably a novelty for a lot of them. I think it must have been because it was more than double the normal audience even in the peak years of the show! There were some great storylines after that but there wasn't going to be 90 million people watching again because it wasn't a novelty anymore and they didn't have all the media talking about things like "the contest for Ewing Oil" or giving any other storyline the publicity that "who shot JR" got.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The battle for Ewing Oil was a much more interesting and exciting storyline. we did a rewatch of the series last summer and definitely enjoyed the battle for Ewing Oil the most. Even though we had seen the series several times, we couldn't wait to see the next episode to watch what would happen next.

To put a finer point on it, If we had friends we were trying to get to start watching Dallas we would show them the first few episodes of the battle for Ewing Oil to get them hooked.

I think the contest was the most consistently fun storyline to watch. I still remember when I was watching it for the first time, my reaction to the scene where they finally revealed the reason why JR got the variance and why he was pumping so much oil. They did a good job of letting that be a mystery, week after week, and then there was that scene where we saw what it was: JR Ewing gas stations. I vividly remember watching that scene when it originally aired and how I thought it was such a brilliant idea. I didn't see that coming at all; I really didn't know what the reason was for all the oil he'd been pumping.

The discount gas stations made perfect sense; it was a great strategy for trying to win the contest because the sheer volume of business he was doing would make his total profits for the year huge and would have if the variance hadn't been rescinded. Bobby made that happen - he got Donna to help him with her trying to convince the committee to rescind the variance and then blackmailing Hicks to vote against the variance. I don't think Pam should have criticized him for that, because Hicks was being bribed by JR to vote for the variance. Bob just got Hicks to vote the way he normally would have if he hadn't been bribed by JR.

I see it as: Bobby blackmailing Hicks cancelled out the effect of JR's bribery and set things back to how they normally were. That's quite different than blackmailing someone to help you get away with doing something illegal, for example. Bobby didn't blackmail anyone to get an unfair advantage, he blackmailed Hicks to take away JR's unfair advantage -the variance he never would have gotten from Walt Driscoll if Driscoll's wife hadn't been framed for a hit and run. I would have thought Pam was smart enough to see those are two distinctly different things and that what Bobby did was the former - setting things back to normal as opposed to obtaining an illegal, unfair advantage.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Remember JR saying: "I see an army mobilizing against me"? He was talking about all the people who didn't want him to win and were going to help Bobby win the contest.

Bobby didn't have the experience and expertise JR did but what he did have in his favor was he acted in a way that made people want to help him. He had a reputation for being honest, which led to the Canadians offering him to be part of their deal - the one that won Bobby the contest when he finally got paid on the last day of the contest. That was the one big thing JR always underestimated in business: It's good to have a reputation that makes people want to do business with you and want to help you.
 
Last edited:

Bobby Southworth

Telly Talk Fan
Top Poster Of Month
How about the whole Jock's trial scenario that revealed Pam wasn't really Digger's daughter. I'm not saying it beats out Who Shot JR or the contest for the company, but it's episodes that I used to show friends when trying to get them into Dallas. In hindsight, the flashback scenes to Digger, Rebecca(VP), and Hutch have become a bit corny over the years, but I think it's a shocking storyline that stands out.
 
Last edited:

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
How about the whole Jock's trial scenario that revealed Pam wasn't really Digger's daughter. I'm not saying it beats out Who Shot JR or the contest for the company, but it's episodes that I used to show friends when trying to get them into Dallas. In hindsight, the flashback scenes to Digger, Rebecca(VP), and Hutch have become a bit corny over the years, but I think it's a shocking storyline that stands out.

Very interesting point, Bobby. Some of the storylines seem a little corny watching them today, but some of the storylines are even more compelling when you re-watch them today. We did a re-watch last summer and were amazed at how well some of the storylines held up.

I believe that @Swami did a re-watch last year as well.

The reason I think that is if you read the "Who Said What and Post Your Line" of Dallas thread, The Swam's posts would tell where he was in the rewatch.

Am I right, Swam?
 

Toni

Maximum Member
1- Fight for Ewing Oil
2- Who Shot J.R.
3- Bobby and Pam apart
4- Miss Ellie stronger after Jock´s death
5- The Jessica Montford mystery
6- Lucy´s career as a model Noo, just kidding! :p:danc:
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
I understand why, for Dallas fans, many of the storylines mentioned were important. But as a TV viewer in general, I can find no plot more compelling than Sue Ellen and Cliff having an affair and Sue Ellen getting pregnant during that time. Suddenly it was impossible to fit the arc into weekly segments that had a neat resolution at the end credits. The arc blew up the format of prime time TV as we knew it, and transformed Dallas into a bona fide prime time soap opera. But more importantly, it changed TV forever: serialization became the standard mode of storytelling, so that even when sitcoms would premiere decades later, like "Friends," there were in-built arcs that would gradually unravel, like Rachel and Ross. Before Dallas and even in the 80s, stand alone shows were the standard. They are now the exception. And all because that loser Cliff Barnes dared look at a former Miss Texas...
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I'm probably going to get hung, drawn & quartered for this but I really love the Wes Parmalee Jock Ewing storyline of season ten (DVD count).

It kept me on the edge of my seat when I was a teenager back in 1986, I would've been seventeen years old. I badly wanted Wes to be Jock & I can remember being really disappointed that despite passing the polygraph & having identical X-rays to Jock he just seemed to disappear quite suddenly as the season progressed with Miss Ellie saying that he told her he wasn't Jock! I was confused & stunned.

Of course decades later I've since found out why. A backlash from the fans who disliked the storyline made their feelings vocally known to CBS & Lorimar not to have Steve Forrest be Jock as they believed it was disrespectful to Jim Davis who originated the role. I certainly don't think it was disrespectful at all. It was more of a tribute to him. The storyline was well thought out & believable for me that Jock could've survived the crash but had total amnesia & was burnt in the crash.

I've always thought that copping out & kowtowing to some of the fans negative reaction was a bad idea with hindsight. The notion that someone else was also on the chopper was pretty lame. Why did Punk Anderson just suddenly remember that years later? It didn't make any sense really the way they wrote Wes off. I don't believe he was some guy called Wyatt Haines. The X-rays for me proved conclusively who he was. He was Jock Ewing. No two different men can ever have identical bone breakage scarring! So despite the ambiguous ending, I firmly believe that if Wes did tell Miss Ellie he wasn't Jock he was actually lying because he didn't want to put the family through any more pain.

I really think that it was detrimental to the show at this point to drop this storyline the way they did with hindsight. Jock's return could've re-invigorated the show. Instead they made the fatal mistake of bringing Bobby back from the dead instead which sadly had a knock on effect on this storyline. Two Ewing resurrections from the dead was probably seen as a bit too much!

I know I've said all this before & you're all probably fed up of reading it again! I just wish that they'd followed through & had kept Steve Forrest as Jock. The show might have had a much longer run if he had stayed on. :(

Jock Ewing 2b.jpg
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Very interesting point, Bobby. Some of the storylines seem a little corny watching them today, but some of the storylines are even more compelling when you re-watch them today. We did a re-watch last summer and were amazed at how well some of the storylines held up.

I believe that @Swami did a re-watch last year as well.

The reason I think that is if you read the "Who Said What and Post Your Line" of Dallas thread, The Swam's posts would tell where he was in the rewatch.

Am I right, Swam?


Indeed you are! Again that was a superb storyline, especially since it was originally planned as the season finale.

Swami
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
It kept me on the edge of my seat when I was a teenager back in 1986, I would've been seventeen years old. I badly wanted Wes to be Jock & I can remember being really disappointed that despite passing the polygraph & having identical X-rays to Jock he just seemed to disappear quite suddenly as the season progressed with Miss Ellie saying that he told her he wasn't Jock! I was confused & stunned.

Here is where they missed a great opportunity. Once they decided not to keep Wes Parmalee around, they just said that he was a fraud and that was the end of the storyline.

But imagine if they had done this:

Wes Passes all of the tests, and some people including Punk Anderson and Ray really do believe he is Jock.

Then Wes suddenly disappears. What happened?

Did J.R. or Clayton hire some roughnecks to take care of Wes?

Was it really Jock, who decided that the only way to be accepted again was to go off on his own and start building up evidence to prove who he really was?

Was it really Jock, or was it not?

It would have been more fun to leave it up in the air like that. And it would have kept fans talking (and arguing) about whether or not he was really Jock.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I agree it was perhaps left a bit open-ended. Perhaps it would have been better earlier on to have had an on-screen funeral for Jock, removing all doubt.

Swami
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I admit, the storyline really doesn’t make sense because they could have asked so many personal questions that only the real Jock would have known, but I liked the Parmalee storyline. IMO, might have been Dallas’ last great storyline, but I’m glad he wasn’t Jock.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
Here is where they missed a great opportunity. Once they decided not to keep Wes Parmalee around, they just said that he was a fraud and that was the end of the storyline.

But imagine if they had done this:

Wes Passes all of the tests, and some people including Punk Anderson and Ray really do believe he is Jock.

Then Wes suddenly disappears. What happened?

Did J.R. or Clayton hire some roughnecks to take care of Wes?

Was it really Jock, who decided that the only way to be accepted again was to go off on his own and start building up evidence to prove who he really was?

Was it really Jock, or was it not?

It would have been more fun to leave it up in the air like that. And it would have kept fans talking (and arguing) about whether or not he was really Jock.

But that's more or less what happens on screen anyway. Ray was starting to believe he was Jock. Even Ellie sensed that there was something about him too. Despite Bobby saying he didn't believe him you could see the doubt on his face.

The problem with the way they dropped the character is that it's Ellie who says he told me he wasn't Jock. Well that's hearsay, why didn't they film that scene & insert it to give the storyline closure. Bobby's so-called proof was just hearsay too! Apparently there was a scene filmed at Southfork where Wes proved to Ellie that he was Jock but it was cut because of the backlash from the show's fans. I just wish they hadn't left his departure so ambiguous because despite the negativity to this storyline from the fans the possibility still exists even today that he really was Jock. Oh well. :)
 
Top