Which Storyline Did You Enjoy The Most?

What Dallas Storyline Did You Enjoy The Most?

  • Gold Canyon 340

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    14
  • Poll closed .

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
But imagine if they had done this:

Wes Passes all of the tests, and some people including Punk Anderson and Ray really do believe he is Jock.

Then Wes suddenly disappears. What happened?

Did J.R. or Clayton hire some roughnecks to take care of Wes?

Was it really Jock, who decided that the only way to be accepted again was to go off on his own and start building up evidence to prove who he really was?

Was it really Jock, or was it not?

It would have been more fun to leave it up in the air like that. And it would have kept fans talking (and arguing) about whether or not he was really Jock.

I like that better than what they did. Having a mystery about whether it was JR or Clayton would have been fun. It might even turn out that they collaborated!

I vividly remember everyone watching it with me thinking the whole idea he might be Jock to be one of the silliest Dallas storylines ever. I don't know that I would have kept watching Dallas if the story turned out that he was Jock. I'm glad they knew better than to do that. I wasn't even thinking about whether or not it would have disrespected Jim Davis; that wasn't the issue. It was that he didn't look anything like Jock. He didn't even have Jock's mannerisms. If they'd found an actor who could convincingly have passed for Jock, the thing to do would have been to have him walk right through the front door and say "I'm home." He would have done something direct like that; it was his personality. He wouldn't have taken a job on his own ranch and intended to hide his identity from his own family.


The problem with the way they dropped the character is that it's Ellie who says he told me he wasn't Jock. Well that's hearsay, why didn't they film that scene & insert it to give the storyline closure.

It's hearsay from a person who had no reason to lie. If Wes was Jock, why would she tell everyone, including Clayton, that he wasn't Jock? She knew Clayton vowed to kill him if he wasn't Jock. She wouldn't have put Jock in that danger. Clayton did go after him to kill him too; he just didn't find him. He was hell-bent on killing the guy. I can't see her putting Jock in danger of being killed because she lied and said he wasn't Jock. She'd be putting Clayton in danger too because if he shot Jock, then Clayton would likely go to prison. Telling a lie that potentially gets Jock killed and Clayton in prison would be a horrible thing to do!
 
Last edited:

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
It's hearsay from a person who had no reason to lie. If Wes was Jock, why would she tell everyone, including Clayton, that he wasn't Jock? She knew Clayton vowed to kill him if he wasn't Jock. She wouldn't have put Jock in that danger. Clayton did go after him to kill him too; he just didn't find him. He was hell-bent on killing the guy. I can't see her putting Jock in danger of being killed because she lied and said he wasn't Jock. She'd be putting Clayton in danger too because if he shot Jock, then Clayton would likely go to prison. Telling a lie that potentially gets Jock killed and Clayton in prison would be a horrible thing to do!

To be honest I don't think Ellie did lie, Wes probably did!

If he really did tell Miss Ellie that he wasn't Jock when in fact he was, it was only to spare the family any more pain.

Miss Ellie wanted it all to be over she didn't want Clayton going after him. If Wes really wasn't Jock why did she feel that way, she should've been gunning for Wes for putting the family through hell yet she doesn't do that. She just wants it over. Why would she protect Wes like that? The answer is simple, Wes was Jock all along. Yes I know he's not Jim Davis, the character was portrayed by Steve Forrest.

Or did Ellie actually tell a little white lie? Everyone is capable of lying even Miss Ellie. Look at the fuss she made when Clayton said he was going to go after him. She wanted to forget the whole thing & avoid anyone getting hurt. It's unfortunate we never got to see Wes with Ellie at Southfork prior to him disappearing. Did he tell her he was Jock but that he was going to leave because his presence was tearing the family apart? Was Miss Ellie torn between Wes & Clayton & reluctantly agreed for Wes to leave? We'll never know for sure but I am firmly convinced that Wes Parmalee really was Jock all along. He realised his presence was upsetting to the family & nobody believed that he was Jock so he reluctantly decided to move on. :(

Rest In Peace to both these legendary actors. Jim Davis & Steve Forrest.

Jock Ewing1.jpg Jock Ewing 2a.jpg
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Rest In Peace to both these legendary actors. Jim Davis & Steve Forrest.
You really said it best right there. Even if you didn't like the Wes Parmalee character, Steve Forrest really did a fine job of transforming Wes from a hired hand to a potential Jock Ewing. Not many actors could pull that off.

Both actors are great to watch.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
No way was Wes Parmalee Jock Ewing. It’s not in Jock’s character to just walk away. Jock would have told all of them “This is my house and I’ll come here anytime I damn well please.” Lol
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
No way was Wes Parmalee Jock Ewing. It’s not in Jock’s character to just walk away. Jock would have told all of them “This is my house and I’ll come here anytime I damn well please.” Lol

Maybe, maybe not. Miss Ellie made a comment about what he'd been through was enough to change a man.

Yes it would've been so unlike Jim Davis's Jock to just walk away. However you have to put this into perspective. If indeed Jock did survive the helicopter crash & was taken to a hospital in the interior where he was treated & tended to with plastic surgery every now & again. He had to learn to walk & talk again. He probably underwent a complete personality change as a result of having total amnesia due to the chopper accident. He was never going to be like he was before the crash.

So it's certainly possible that Wes if he was Jock just couldn't put the family through any more pain & decided to leave. We never see the conversation Wes has with Miss Ellie, it happens off screen. Miss Ellie is just so adamant to let Wes go & not to try to find him. As I've pointed out before if he really was the fraud that Clayton believed him to be Miss Ellie should've been as mad as hell too. Yet she isn't, she just looks kind of wistful & anxious. I've watched that particular episode umpteen times, maybe she's just glad it's over & he's gone but you could also look at it that she's protecting Wes from her family because she doesn't immediately tell them that Wes was at Southfork, it's Donna that comments that she saw him first.

It was certainly a dramatic storyline though. I certainly enjoyed it, season ten is one of my favourites because of Steve Forrest. :)
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Maybe, maybe not. Miss Ellie made a comment about what he'd been through was enough to change a man.

Yes it would've been so unlike Jim Davis's Jock to just walk away. However you have to put this into perspective. If indeed Jock did survive the helicopter crash & was taken to a hospital in the interior where he was treated & tended to with plastic surgery every now & again. He had to learn to walk & talk again. He probably underwent a complete personality change as a result of having total amnesia due to the chopper accident. He was never going to be like he was before the crash.

So it's certainly possible that Wes if he was Jock just couldn't put the family through any more pain & decided to leave. We never see the conversation Wes has with Miss Ellie, it happens off screen. Miss Ellie is just so adamant to let Wes go & not to try to find him. As I've pointed out before if he really was the fraud that Clayton believed him to be Miss Ellie should've been as mad as hell too. Yet she isn't, she just looks kind of wistful & anxious. I've watched that particular episode umpteen times, maybe she's just glad it's over & he's gone but you could also look at it that she's protecting Wes from her family because she doesn't immediately tell them that Wes was at Southfork, it's Donna that comments that she saw him first.

It was certainly a dramatic storyline though. I certainly enjoyed it, season ten is one of my favourites because of Steve Forrest. :)

@Via The Void, even though you and I have disagreed over the Wes Parmalee storyline, I really appreciate your enthusiasm for explaining your point of view. You do a great job explaining why you like it so much and in explaining the reasons why you believe that Wes was Jock.

That idea that having complete amnesia for as long as he did (several months) could have completely changed his personality is an interesting one. One of the reasons I didn't find the storyline convincing is that the way Wes Parmalee spoke was so different than the way Jock spoke. I don't mean the way his voice sounds; I realize he had an injury that affected the way his voice sounded. I'm talking about the mannerisms his speech - his style of speaking. I think Steve Forrest could have made more of an attempt to emulate Jim Davis's mannerisms as Jock. Jim Davis as Jock spoke in a gruff tone and was extremely direct in what he said. His whole demeanor was very different from that of Wes Parmalee. He chose to accept a job on Southfork so he could be near the family and hid his identity until Ellie discovered Jock's belongings in his bunkhouse. I think Jock would have walked right through the from door and said: "I'm home"!
 

Herofan

Telly Talk Active Member
View attachment 21073 [/QUOTE]
I'm probably going to get hung, drawn & quartered for this but I really love the Wes Parmalee Jock Ewing storyline of season ten (DVD count).

It kept me on the edge of my seat when I was a teenager back in 1986, I would've been seventeen years old. I badly wanted Wes to be Jock & I can remember being really disappointed that despite passing the polygraph & having identical X-rays to Jock he just seemed to disappear quite suddenly as the season progressed with Miss Ellie saying that he told her he wasn't Jock! I was confused & stunned.View attachment 21073

I’m right with you. I was 17 at the time too, and I absolutely loved that storyline. I loved how it gradually unfolded. Like you, it kept me on the edge of my seat week to week. I loved it.
 
Last edited:

Herofan

Telly Talk Active Member
I admit, the storyline really doesn’t make sense because they could have asked so many personal questions that only the real Jock would have known, but I liked the Parmalee storyline. IMO, might have been Dallas’ last great storyline, but I’m glad he wasn’t Jock.

I always thought that if he was Jock, he should have just started saying things that only Jock the person he was talking to would know. Make them stunned. The others could have also asked deeper things that only Jock would know.
 

pete lashmar

Telly Talk Addict
When Wes took to the stage at the Oils Baron's Ball, he should have thrown in the "Power you take" line, that would have really shaken both Bobby & Ellie.

My favourite plot was definitely the fight for Ewing Oil - as already stated, it just brought everyone into the plot -it affected everyone and was therefore roled out over 2 seasons. Looking back though I really wish that the final office scene with Bobby winning had been a better one. I really wanted JR down on his ass in that scene, to a point where he was begging Bobby - and when JR's down that's when he gets really nasty (well...before they changed his whole character).

As for the wes story - I absolutely hated it when first broadcast but absolutely love it now - and agree, it was a brilliant idea that was killed off far too quickly, and the way it was resolved was very very poor. But we must remember that Dallas had just brought back Bobby from the dead so 2 resurrected Ewings in 1 season was probably 1 too far.

But the way he left was shocking, they could at least have killed him off and have a whodunnit mystery with no one really knowing whether he was Jock or not.

I feel that the writers had decided he was but then changed track - the same wounds, injuries etc etc - I mean that were the chances of that and knowing who and what everyone was just because an old guy was jibbering with fever!!!???
 
Last edited:

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
When Wes took to the stage at the Oils Baron's Ball, he should have thrown in the "Power you take" line, that would have really shaken both Bobby & Ellie.

My favourite plot was definitely the fight for Ewing Oil - as already stated, it just brought everyone into the plot -it affected everyone and was therefore roled out over 2 seasons. Looking back though I really wish that the final office scene with Bobby winning had been a better one. I really wanted JR down on his ass in that scene, to a point where he was begging Bobby - and when JR's down that's when he gets really nasty (well...before they changed his whole character).

As for the wes story - I absolutely hated it when first broadcast but absolutely love it now - and agree, it was a brilliant idea that was killed off far too quickly, and the way it was resolved was very very poor. But we must remember that Dallas had just brought back Bobby from the dead so 2 resurrected Ewings in 1 season was probably 1 too far.

But the way he left was shocking, they could at least have killed him off and have a whodunnit mystery with no one really knowing whether he was Jock or not.

I feel that the writers had decided he was but then changed track - the same wounds, injuries etc etc - I mean that were the chances of that and knowing who and what everyone was just because an old guy was jibbering with fever!!!???

The Wyatt Haines explanation wasn't very believeable at all. Punk suddenly remembered it years after the event! And the viewers were expected to forget that Wes's X-ray's matched Jocks! Just a shame the Producers chickened out as Steve Forrest had the gravitas to be a great Jock Ewing. :(
 
Top