Could Deborah Shelton and Jennilee Harrison scuppered the dream?

Grangehill1

Telly Talk Fan
At the end of season 9 (the dream), Mandy is dumped by JR and Jamie is blown to smithereens.

Of course next episode they’re alive and well again as it was all a dream.

BUT...

If Deborah and Jennilee’s contracts had finished at the end of season 9 and they thought that was the end, obviously there had to be some form of contract negotiation to bring them back for continuity for season 10 and to Swansong. But what if they’d refused? Mandy and JR were very close in Swansong. Jamie has just married cliff. If both actresses or even one had refused to return, would the dream scenario have been ditched? And a more creative solution developed for Bobby’s return?

I’ve never thought about this before but this could have had a huge impact on what ended up happening.

I am surprised Jennilee returned given the appalling material she was given in season 10 and then killed off again. Deborah had a bit more to do but they were both simply brought back to be written out again in a different way.

What do you think?
 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I can only imagine that the dream solution at least put those two actresses in a much better negotation situation when it came to pay - I can imagine that at least Jenilee got a significant pay bump to sign on again after being killed off. With Deborah, she was always recurring during her years on the show so I'm not sure if it effected it all that much. I can imagine it being easier to write an off-screen explanation for her character (although not ideal). Honestly, I don't think them not doing season 10 would've affected them going with the dream solution - they were obviously hell-bent on doing so.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Had they refused to come back they would have found a way of writing them out off screen.

However, I imagine their agents realised they were in a strong negotiating position because the return of those 2 characters was an important factor in making the ridiculous decision to wipe out an entire year of storylines a little more believable and got them enough money to persuade them to come back.
 

James from London

International Treasure
I am surprised Jennilee returned given the appalling material she was given in season 10 and then killed off again.

I very much doubt she's have been privy to any scripts prior to her agreeing to return. And she was only killed off after she'd already left the series.

I actually really preferred both characters post-dream than during it. Jamie and Cliff were really funny together and Mandy's story was just great. Her final scenes with Sue Ellen and JR (before she left for Hollywood the first time) were very poignant.

I can only imagine that the dream solution at least put those two actresses in a much better negotation situation when it came to pay

Yes, very much so.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I was happy to see both of them return. I know there are those who perhaps aren't their biggest fans, although in some ways that is a case of the lines blurring between the characters and the actresses themselves.

Let's face it, they were streets ahead of the newbies who came in towards the end.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I was happy to see both of them return. I know there are those who perhaps aren't their biggest fans, although in some ways that is a case of the lines blurring between the characters and the actresses themselves.

Let's face it, they were streets ahead of the newbies who came in towards the end.

Swami

Absolutely. That Cally would be the ideal wife for JR or to think that anyone wanted to see Sasha Mitchell playing the role of JR's bastard son or Kimberly Foster playing the woman running Ewing Oil is just..another mindset. .

Deborah Shelton had just starred in a major movie directed by Brian DePalma just the year before she came to Dallas. I can't say I'm surprised that the later additions to the cast never accomplished anything of that stature.

Showing the fans ten years of a marriage going through the same problems over and over while the people in it refuse to learn from their mistakes is probably fun in a way, but I don't know what way. The man repeatedly begs his wife to give him a divorce and she actually asks why. Why would he possibly want a divorce? What could be better than that special kind of relationship they had? It was: I'll stay and be miserable to ensure you will also be miserable. I guess if self-annihilation is your thing, that could be a real turn-on.

The best way Jenilee and Deborah could have approached it is to get together and have one agent negotiate big salaries for each one. I don't think either one by herself could have held them up for big money, but the two of them together would have had some negotiating power. If their agent says they each want this much or they're not coming back, then pretty much any demand within reason would be met, sine Katzman's ego was too big to let season nine stand.
 
Last edited:

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
Neither of those characters were important enough to scuttle the dream season plot line. If one or both had refused to return, it could have been dealt this off screen. Think about it... Mandy could have been killed in an accident or something and we would have been treated to the nice storyline of having JR have to deal with her death. Jamie and Cliff could have had a fight off screen and she could have just left town. Fans had already said goodbye to those characters in season 9 so no one would have been "startled" if they were missing from season 10. Neither was getting "star" money to return. Their characters just weren't that important.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Neither of those characters were important enough to scuttle the dream season plot line. If one or both had refused to return, it could have been dealt this off screen. Think about it... Mandy could have been killed in an accident or something and we would have been treated to the nice storyline of having JR have to deal with her death. Jamie and Cliff could have had a fight off screen and she could have just left town. Fans had already said goodbye to those characters in season 9 so no one would have been "startled" if they were missing from season 10. Neither was getting "star" money to return. Their characters just weren't that important.

Ultimately more effort should have been made in keeping the regulars on board.

Swami
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
Ultimately more effort should have been made in keeping the regulars on board.

Swami

Agree..The show certainly could survive without Mandy or Jamie, but when you lose Pam, then Donna, then Ray & Jenna, Eliie, and finally Sue Ellen? Wasn't even the same show anymore.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
Showing the fans ten years of a marriage going through the same problems over and over while the people in it refuse to learn from their mistakes is probably fun in a way, but I don't know what way. The man repeatedly begs his wife to give him a divorce and she actually asks why. Why would he possibly want a divorce? What could be better than that special kind of relationship they had? It was: I'll stay and be miserable to ensure you will also be miserable. I guess if self-annihilation is your thing, that could be a real turn-on.

.

There was a lot more to the JR/SE marriage than what you describe. The "fun" part of it was watching these two deeply damaged people find some sort of comfort in one another and yeah, it was fun to watch them go at one another, mostly because, as a fan, you knew JR wouldn't tolerate her behavior from any other person in the world.

Yes, they had the same problems for ten years, but they also had some good times too. And that was fun to watch just because LH and LG had such incredible chemistry together

I don't think JR could have been successfully paired with any other character for any length of time. JR and SE worked because they were similar in nature. SE understood JR in a way no one else ever did, not even his parents. Say what you will, but when JR was hurt or scared, it was always SE he sought out for comfort, even when they were at each other's throats.

It was a horribly complicated relationship. But yes, it was fun to watch. And I hate how the writers destroyed BOTH those characters in season eleven and twelve.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
There was a lot more to the JR/SE marriage than what you describe. The "fun" part of it was watching these two deeply damaged people find some sort of comfort in one another and yeah, it was fun to watch them go at one another, mostly because, as a fan, you knew JR wouldn't tolerate her behavior from any other person in the world.

Yes, they had the same problems for ten years, but they also had some good times too. And that was fun to watch just because LH and LG had such incredible chemistry together

I don't think JR could have been successfully paired with any other character for any length of time. JR and SE worked because they were similar in nature. SE understood JR in a way no one else ever did, not even his parents. Say what you will, but when JR was hurt or scared, it was always SE he sought out for comfort, even when they were at each other's throats.

It was a horribly complicated relationship. But yes, it was fun to watch. And I hate how the writers destroyed BOTH those characters in season eleven and twelve.

There was more to it because I was mainly describing the last three years of it since that was the time when JR would ask Sue Ellen for divorce but she wanted to stay, even though they weren't even sharing a bedroom anymore. Their marriage certainly served its purpose for the show in the first 6, maybe 7 seasons and then, in my opinion, it was just beyond repair at that point. They did work well together as actors and I found their story interesting somewhere up to the Peter and Sue Ellen relationship which I didn't care for at all or if not that then the Holly Harwood and JR situation should have done it. They had nowhere left to take the marriage by then - it was doomed.

Having them find a way to fix their marriage at or before season 6 or 7 would have worked for me, or having them go their separate ways. I felt like I had seen everything their relationship was going to be and past that point it got very repetitive. It was the constant misery they inflicted on each other in the last few years that to me, was in bad taste. Seeing a marriage where two people are just trying to hurt each other isn't something I get any enjoyment from.
 

CeeCee72

Telly Talk Star
There was more to it because I was mainly describing the last three years of it since that was the time when JR would ask Sue Ellen for divorce but she wanted to stay, even though they weren't even sharing a bedroom anymore. Their marriage certainly served its purpose for the show in the first 6, maybe 7 seasons and then, in my opinion, it was just beyond repair at that point. They did work well together as actors and I found their story interesting somewhere up to the Peter and Sue Ellen relationship which I didn't care for at all or if not that then the Holly Harwood and JR situation should have done it. They had nowhere left to take the marriage by then - it was doomed.

Having them find a way to fix their marriage at or before season 6 or 7 would have worked for me, or having them go their separate ways. I felt like I had seen everything their relationship was going to be and past that point it got very repetitive. It was the constant misery they inflicted on each other in the last few years that to me, was in bad taste. Seeing a marriage where two people are just trying to hurt each other isn't something I get any enjoyment from.

Oh, I agree the way they treated each other in those last few seasons was in bad taste. It actually made me dislike BOTH characters.

It's a shame they threw away all the growth (by both characters and in their marriage) that we saw in the dream season. But, the relationship could have been salvaged with the way they brought them back together in season 10 (not as much growth, but enough to make their reconciliation believable). But then the whole thing just went off the rails. The characters regressed and they were so mean and petty, neither of them showing any concern for how they were affecting their son with their horrible behavior...

I didn't care for it either. I thought it was bad and lazy writing, a re-tread of what we'd already seen. That's why I don't blame LG for wanting out. The writers took a blow torch to SE and to the JR/SE relationship. It was hard to watch.
 
Top